The Gay Talk is the new Sex Talk. At some point, everyone with kids in their lives will have to sit down and explain what these words mean while trying not to giggle, squirm or look awkward. Except you probably won’t be sitting down when either subject comes up. You’ll be standing in a supermarket queue surrounded by people straining to hear your answer to the question: “What does gay mean?” while unpacking your pasta sauce onto the conveyor belt.
Good luck with that.
The fact that The Gay Talk is a relatively new thing is wonderful because it means same-sex relationships are no longer underground – unlike my own childhood when I didn’t know any gay people. In hindsight, of course I did. In fact, I was surrounded by them but in the seventies and eighties, the closet was much bigger and more oppressive so they were invisible to me, even as a teenager.
There were no openly gay celebrities (remember the shock when it was eventually revealed Rock Hudson died from AIDS and had been homosexual? Even Liberace never confirmed it), no gay characters in TV shows or movies and no gay people in public life. It’s only decades later that I realised my most beloved primary school teacher was a lesbian, an older cousin was gay and one of my favourite aunts was a lesbian although she hadn’t told anyone yet, especially not her husband and kids.
My very limited understanding of homosexuality came from the occasional drag queen and a couple of glimpses of The Freak on Prisoner who I recall had some lesbian leanings. So The Gay Talk never came up for me although I very clearly remember having The Sex Talk with my Mum when I was about seven years old. She took a pre-emptive strike approach, talking me through the whole shebang from conception through to birth in the hope that I’d have all the relevant information way before I needed it.

Neil Patrick Harris and David Burtka join David Furnish and Elton John to take their kids on a playdate.
This is a philosophy I’ve continued with my own kids. Well, I’ve continued it with my daughter who – like her mother – has an insatiable appetite for information (my sons have always wandered off when I tried to explain sex to them).
At the moment, she is stuck on the pain part of the giving birth story and is currently leaning towards adoption. At a recent family dinner, she politely enquired if she could adopt one of her pregnant aunt’s twins. “I want a baby but I don’t want anything to hurt,” she said. Quite an apt metaphor for parenting, really.
Which brings me back to The Gay Talk. I’ve been reading a bit about it lately and when I decided to write this column, I immediately felt smug about my excellent sources.
My son’s best friend has two dads. My daughter’s classmate has two mums and two dads. My 4 year old’s preschool teacher is gay. So one after another, I bowled up to them and asked for their brilliant insights into The Gay Talk. One after another, they cocked their heads and blinked at me, puzzled. “Um…..oh…..well….you know….”
“I’ve never had to have that conversation,” all the parents said eventually, as if I’d asked them to explain how to breathe. My son’s pre-school teacher was more direct, “It’s a mistake to talk to kids about things when they’re not actually interested. At pre-school, it never comes up. We have the rainbow flag pinned up on the noticeboard next to the indigenous flag to signify that we embrace everyone and that’s enough.”
Right. Ok. Point taken. To many kids, including my own, having gay parents is as unremarkable as being adopted or being an only child. Gay people are embedded into their world to the point where The Gay Talk is kind of redundant (I am slightly sad about this to be honest because I adore a Learning Opportunity).
But not every child has that kind of immersive experience. What if they DO ask questions?
Here at Mamamia, Adventures of a Gay Superdad blogger, Jerry Mahony, recently wrote a funny, helpful post about how to explain The Gay to The Kids. “I’m not a child psychologist” he admits, “just a gay dad who’s thought a lot about the issue and who has a big stake in it. After all, I don’t want your kids coming up to my kids one day and telling them they’re weird for not having a mommy.”
Among his tips Jerry suggests:
Jerry Mahoney
1. Use the word “gay”.
2. You don’t have to pretend half the world is gay (having two dads or two mums is less common than having one of each- just avoid words with value judgements attached like “abnormal” or “strange”)
3. Get your mind out of the gutter (no need to talk about sex, like being straight, being gay is not just who you sleep with, it’s who you love)
4. If your kid does ask you to speculate, you can tell them they’ll “probably” be straight (statistically that’s true).
[You can read the whole post here and it's great. Check out Jerry's blog here and follow him on Twitter here]
And there’s nothing remotely awkward about that.
Have you had ‘the Gay Talk’ either as a kid or a parent?








Comments
37 Comments so far
So the talk inour house went like this: “you know you’re starting kindy soon, well you are going to see lots of families, some will be like ours and others they’ll have a mum and a dad. Its not strange just different and those parents love their kids just like mum and I love you and your sisters”. Easy – that was three years ago, we’ve had the puberty talk now just the sex talk to go (we talk about how our babies were made not, no questions yet about how others make their babies, although we live on a farm….).
Seriously though, more people need to have the gay talk (I call myself a lesbian though) because even if you don’t agree from a religious or cultural perspective making your child feel less like a pariah particularly as a teenager has got to be a good thing. When you grow up and there’s no discussion about gay and lesbian issues its another thing that can break the balance of a teenager. The risk and reality of (particularly male) gay teen suicide is much higher than people who identify as hetrosexual. For that reason alone the gay talk is important, even if you don’t agree with it, keeping your child alive and safe through the teenage years by supporting their choices should be driver to have these conversations little and often.
loading...
For chrissakes, you just tell your child that some men love other men, some women love other women, and that’s just fine. Then you tell them that some people judge the love of others, and that’s not fine at all, no one has a right to do that. Keep the emphasis on the love part, and the human rights part, children understand that.
loading...
While I applaud you Mia, for broaching this subject, I had a couple of comments. Not one of my lesbian friends likes to be referred to as ‘gay’- they term themselves as lesbians. The term ‘gay’ tends to evoke an umbrella concept, when my lesbian friends have experienced different types of prejudice. Just as the average woman receives a different type of prejudice different from men. It’s currently ‘cool’ on popular mainstream American sitcoms or shows to have a male gay character or couple, especially who are parenting but I struggle to think of mainstream lesbians parenting on like shows. My second concern is the final point that you quoted from Jerry Mahony’s site re ‘everyone ends up with the right parents for them’. That is a lovely comment for a functional family, regardless of the sexuality of the parents, but stings for people who have experienced backgrounds of abuse. Given my many years working with traumatised young people who have sometimes survived their parents abuse and sometimes haven’t, I’m loathe to encourage a view that the young people ended up with the ‘right’ parents. I know the young people I have worked with would read that comment and feel their background was their fault.
loading...
Yep – fair points both.
x
loading...
Actually, I’m ‘lesbian’ but prefer to be called ‘gay’ if anyone is going to label me. Moreso, I’d much prefer to be called by my name – I really hate any labels, but (for whatever reason) I really detest the word ‘lesbian’. Maybe I’ve just heard it muttered in such detest from bigots over the years that I don’t like the tone of it anymore. Who knows. Each to their own.
You are right concerning the different sets of prejudice that gay women face, however, I’d like to think that these aren’t the fault of the gay community, and don’t feel the need to separate myself even further by branding myself with a name to distinguish me from my gay brothers.
loading...
I will be offering my daughter two options to make up her own mind about as she grows up and when she asks me about being gay. On the one hand my belief that being in a homosexual sexual relationship is not okay with God. On the other, that some people don’t agree with this and believe it is okay to be gay.
loading...
Will she have the opportunity to choose her own god (or none at all) as well?
loading...
Yes. Most definitely. I have two older children and I have always believed that I do not own any of them, that they are all God’s children and are on loan to me until they are old enough to look after themselves and be free to live according to their own lights.
loading...
Totally, I would argue that there are lots of options and beliefs to choose from! What about humans seeing other humans as okay, whatever they believe?
loading...
Life is a smorgasboard, Z, you can choose whatever you like.
loading...
I love kids – they see life for what it is, not what they’re told to (by parents/religion/media).
My niece (who is three) calls my partner ‘aunty’. No-one told her to, she just did – she intuitively recognised our relationship just like any other relationship between aunts and uncles, and has never questioned, nor judged. I’m proud that she grows up in a very liberal and open minded family as mine, and my sister has done a brilliant job of keeping that tradition alive in our family. It makes my gay life so much easier, I can’t tell you.
I don’t want a label, just use my name.
loading...
I’ve had the talk with both my kids over the years, from when they were old enough to ask what the word/s meant. I kept it really simple at the beginning: People fall in love and may want to live together or get married. Like me and your dad (together 20 years, not married). Two women can fall in love too, or two men, like our friends Max and David. That was it.
Later, we went on to why this was so hidden, why gay people couldn’t get married, what marriage meant, why my partner and I didn’t want to marry, and a lot of it boiled down to ALL of us wondering why anyone cared who loved who, lived with who, had sex with who, married or didn’t marry. We’ve looked at the political and social pressures and impacts, at how gay people are portrayed in film / TV / etc.
My kids don’t think being gay or straight is any more noteworthy than being Chinese or Irish. Which I think is just the way it should be.
loading...
I don’t get the angst over this topic.
When my kids started asking about the birds and the bees I just added and some boys like boys and some girls like girls. One kid nodded and the other (thanks to his homo-phobe father) did the ewww shudder so I just added and that’s ok, that’s how they’re made. Done.
More detail is given as follow up questions arrive.
loading...
To have this conversation you don’t need to mention sex. G rated children’s shows still have families in them! And kids do encounter people with two mummies, two daddies, or have aunts and uncles who are gay. Explaining it to them in an age appropriate way if they ask is hardly abuse.
loading...
My 4 year old son came home from Kinder the other day and announced “mum, do you know what? Alice from Kinder has 2 mummies”. My response was “well she’s a lucky girl”.
He wasn’t asking why, he was just telling me something he found interesting.
So I left it at that, for now.
loading...
Sorry, it wasn’t “me” it was “Guest” that my comment was aimed at. 1:30am.
Brain. No. Work. Good.
loading...
I took my kids to visit lesbian friends for a weekend who at the time had one son together. My kids were 6 and 4 at the time. I told them that Andre has two mums and that sometimes two women can fall in love and two men can fall in love. That’s all. They didn’t ask any questions but occasionally still mention that it’s ok for two women or two men to fall in love. That was my gay talk. It seemed to work!
loading...
when i asked my mom what gay meant (mind you we are talking india in the 80s), her face went red and froze and the she said “when a man loves a man” and changed the subject. simple. to the point. gotta love her. ps: she denies she ever said that.
loading...
Actually I thought I was about to have it the other day with my 8yo daughter, but it didn’t quite happen like that. Maybe I should’ve used the moment as a teaching opportunity, but hey, I’ll put it off till another day….
We were in the car (of course!) and she said: “Mum, what’s gay?” So I took a deep breath & started on the: “Well, it can mean plenty of things. When your Nanny was a girl it just meant happy, but nowdays (deep breath)”, and then she interrupted me: Because Cameron said “That’s so gay”. Me: “Oh! Well (change tack)…he means stupid”.
Ah, the English language. Gotta love it!
loading...
maybe you should not have equated ‘gay’ and ‘moron’…it is one of those microaggressions we should stop
loading...
Unfortunately, you just missed a very important lesson to teach here…. That saying gay to connote stupidity is NOT OK, and very offensive to myself and others.
Maybe you need to reopen that talk.
loading...
Completely agree with you Oceans. Calling someone gay is just as inappropriate as calling someone a “retard” – NOT COOL.
To quote Macklemore “Gay is synonymous with the lesser” and we need to fix that.
loading...
I had this discussion recently with my 12 year old son – but from a different perspective. My husband and I split up several years ago – but he only recently came out of the closet. He lives in England and wasn’t comfortable having the conversation, so it came down to me. I started by asking my son if he knew what gay meant – and it told me that yes he did and that one of his friends at school was gay! So it turned out to be a much simpler conversation than I was expecting. After explaining to him that his dad was gay, he said he felt a bit weird because it was something he didn’t know, but that it didn’t change anything because he was still his dad and he still loved him. So, life goes on! : )
loading...
I had to have the ‘gay talk’ when I realised that married heterosexual life was not for me. It was when I met my partner that I realised that I was in fact ‘gay’. I have two biological children and so does she! Five years on and our children know this as normal! The school is aware, the other parents either work it out or we tell them and our kids still get to spend time with their dads too.
I have found that it is more acceptable now, our children have not really had to deal with any bullying (thankfully) and we are all blissfully happy. It really is reassuring to know that people can look past ‘sexual preference’ to see who we really are as people and parents.
loading...
I think the best way to approach any subject like this is honestly, unemotionally and age appropriately- not always easy as it so often happens on the spot but I think the trick is to not make a big deal out of it. Also, I’m not sure about 5- ‘Everyone ends up with the right parents for them’ because quite frankly it’s not true and I’d feel uncomfortable saying that. What about those children who are victims of parental abuse or neglect?
loading...
Had a “gay talk” with my 5 year old yesterday. He said that someone from school said that boys couldn’t marry boys but he thought they could. I told him that he was right. I said that boys usually marry girls but sometimes boys fell in love with boys and girls fall in love with girls – and that’s okay. Apart from the technicality that Australian law doesn’t yet recognise gay marriage, I thought I did a good job of answering his question truthfully and age appropriately.
loading...
I just said gay means happy because it does.
loading...
According to the dictionary anyway. Being gay or even straight or bi doesn’t mean you actually are happy
loading...
Being adopted isn’t unremarkable.
It’s been one of the main issues throughout my life and has it’s own issues that I deal with. Not every day, but they’re always there waiting to pop up at unexpected moments. It’s a pretty bloody remarkable for some. (As Mamamia has shown in several articles).
loading...
The gay talk with my kids was a non-event for me, and I have to say, I don’t understand why anyone would think it’s difficult or a big deal.
I didn’t find it difficult at all. I just said that most of the time boys love girls and vice versa, but sometimes boys love boys and girls love girls, and that it’s fine either way.
loading...
I didn’t find this conversation awkward at all with my 8 year old. I was matter of fact and said that some men love other men and some women love other women. I think the more we present it as nothing to get worked up about the more kids will just accept it as just one of the many types of ways to live your life. I think kids are really perceptive and if we approach it as something to be anxious or a little embarrassed or awkward about it they will pick up on that. One of my proudest moments was when during that conversation I explained that at the moment men aren’t allowed to marry men and women not allowed to marry women and my daughter’s immediate response was “Well we have to change the laws then, that is so unfair!”
loading...
The answer to the question regarding the meaning of “gay” is: lively, merry, light-hearted, joyousness.
The word has nothing to do with homosexuality but it is a word that has been hijacked by them possibly to illustrate their lifestyle. So when telling children about the word “gay” then use the proper definition not the hijacked version i common use!
loading...
Ewan, language is not a static thing. It evolves. New words come into the vernacular and old words sometimes change meaning or disappear. You may want gay to retain the meaning it had when you were a child but it hasn’t. It has evolved and that’s OK.
My 6yo heard the word gay in conversation last week and asked me what it means and so I told her, giving her only as much information as is age appropriate. To tell her it means lively or merry would not be helpful for her as she moves through the world because that simply isn’t what it means any more.
loading...
Hi Ewan, I think you’ll find that “hijack” means to illegally stop and commandeer a vehicle. Good luck with limiting your conversation – let alone the world’s – to original meanings of words! Seriously, being gay – or GLBTI, or homosexual, if you prefer – is not a “lifestyle”. It’s people’s lives, the lives they were born to.
And yes, the “gay talk” is mostly as easy as everyone says. Life and love is mostly this way, but sometimes that way, with no judgement. And after eleven years of experience bringing up two boys in a home with two mums, I could count the negative experiences we’ve had on the fingers of one hand, and there’s been nothing getting to know us hasn’t fixed.
loading...
I’ve never thought of the ‘gay talk’ conversation as a difficult one. When my seven year old asked why two men were kissing on TV, I explained that a man can love another man, or a woman can love another woman just the same way that I love his Dad. My emphasis in this conversation was on the love shared between these two people kissing.
loading...
My 11 y.o and I had this talk after he came home using ‘gay’ as an insult (playground talk in the ‘burbs. Sigh.) Anyway, after explaining that this was not a word to use as an insult (try moron) we had a chat about love. And who you love. He was most surprised to learn that two of his ‘uncles’ were gay. It had never occurred to him. (Even though one insists on being called Aunty John) And it still doesn’t matter.
loading...
I really wish everyone did end up with the right parents for them. Some kids really don’t
Maybe something about parents who love their children are the best parents, regardless of their orientation, instead of something that gives the impression that children with bad parents must deserve that (because how could a parent who abuses or neglects or abandons a child ever be the right parent for them)?
loading...