Do You Like This Story?
Amanda Kendle profile pic 380x329 Why Im happy with my only child.

Amanda

by AMANDA KENDLE

I never set out to have just one child. Some people do, I know that but I was more average and imagined two or possibly three.

When I met my husband in my late twenties, one of the reasons we got together was because we were both keen to start a family. We got married quite quickly, and waited until he got a job before we started trying to have a baby.

I thought it would be reasonably easy. My mother conceived her first child – me – easily at 34 and another at 36. I was only 30, and I was healthy, fit, had never smoked, drank rarely and had a regular menstrual cycle. It was not so simple, however, and we ended up doing torturous rounds of fertility treatment and were eventually told that my ovaries were acting as though they were much older and I was headed for early menopause.

The doctor had just one final plan for a last chance IVF cycle, full of even nastier and longer doses of hormones and other drugs. We had already been counselled on other possibilities – my husband, by this stage, was labelled as “too old” for us to try the adoption process; we had reached the compromise that flying to Spain or Ukraine for donor eggs was likely to be the best chance we had.

And then, in the midst of a crazy regime of life-dominating medication and suddenly chaotic menstrual cycles, we conceived our little boy, naturally. Unless you have been in that position, you have no idea of the relief and joy we felt. And continue to feel, to this day.

This was not quite yet happily ever after. For no apparent reason, I was plagued with every pregnancy difficulty under the sun. I had to quit my job as a teacher four months in advance of the birth, and spent those months just passing time and surviving, constantly in pain and only gaining joy from the kicks I’d feel from that precious baby inside.

one Why Im happy with my only child.

“This was not quite yet happily ever after.”

Yet then the most gorgeous boy ever to be born came into the world. He is still, at two, the most incredible young man I could ever ask for and there is no question I would go through all of it again to have him. It took my body a year to begin to function normally again, though, with a lot of physiotherapy sessions and exercises, and I still have serious issues and regular bouts of severe pain.

And now that my son is two, everybody wants to know about our plans for a second child. It was early on when my husband decided he probably didn’t want any another one, that it was too hard and we should be happy with what we have.

At first I was devastated, still thinking that of course we would try for a second one, that perhaps the miracle could recur, and we could deal with the side-effects somehow. But over time, I have come round to his way of thinking. I think our son will be an only child.

For a decision that is really nothing to do with anyone else at all, you’d be surprised how many people have a strong opinion, or at least give me odd looks when I try to explain that I’m thinking of stopping at one. There are so many reasons I rattle off, worrying that all of them make me sound selfish.

For a start, I don’t really want to go through several years more of pain and suffering in pregnancy – since I’m told the problems I had in pregnancy will recur. I also don’t want to go through the agony and mental torture of trying to conceive again, of wondering every month if this is the time, of being bitterly disappointed. You can tell me all the tales you like of easy second-time conceptions but since I’m on a fast downward slide to menopause my situation’s probably different to your neighbour’s cousin’s best friend.

Screen shot 2012 08 14 at 8.57.10 PM Why Im happy with my only child.

WARNING.

Maybe I am just happy enough with our perfect little boy and I don’t feel the need to share my love any further. It has taken half a decade of my life to have him and now I’d like to enjoy him. And, to be honest, do some things for me again, the things I couldn’t do during the lost years of infertility and pregnancy problems. I didn’t have my child at 30 as planned – I was 34, and my husband was 42, and we were getting ready to move on to other things.

So, everybody, you can go on and on until you’re bright blue in the face about all the reasons I should have another child. You can give me all the odd looks you like. Sadly, few of you will actually understand that for some people in some circumstances, maybe one is really enough.

Amanda Kendle is a blogger, social media consultant and a mother of one. You can find her travel blog atnotaballerina.com or stalk her on Twitter @amandakendle

How many children do you have or do you hope to have? Were you an only child or did you have siblings? How do you think that influenced your childhood?

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

167 Comments so far

  1. Anon

    Great article and comments, which have been very interesting and useful to read.
    I guess it’s easy to assume that siblings are a positive thing. When I reflect on my experience having a sister, despite the intense positives, I would have preferred to grow up alone than with her. My sister is incapable of making the right decisions for herself and is regularly suicidal, and as my parents age, I will be looking after them as well as her. It’s not always true that having two children means that the burden of caring for aging parents will be shared between them.
    My partner has a brother who was raised separately to him, and with whom he wasn’t able to form a close bond during childhood. There was no advantage for him, either, in having a brother.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. Ellen

    I have one son who is three and i really wish i was having another baby but i know its not the right thing to do. Ive been single since my son was a tiny baby, and being a single mum doing everything myself I haven’t met anyone else. In a way I’m quite jealous of people with two little kids and also jealous of other single mums who find a new partner so quickly. Ive thought about having a baby by a sperm doner but i dont think it would be fair. Maybe if I was older, but at this point Im going to try to find someone before I go down that road. This year Im going to try going out more, or maybe internet dating. It just breaks my heart when my three year old says “me give my baby toys to mine baby buva”. It also doesnt help when people ask when Ill have another baby. I dont know how they think it would happen.
    On the other side of the coin, people need to think about how many people are already on this planet and how we are going to find the resources to look after them all. It just doesnt seem fair that western people think they can keep consuming and having children when there will be a food crisis, a serious increase in demand for electricity and the planet is already showing the terrible effects of global warming due to too much carbon. And per capita Australia is a terrible contributer to this. Maybe people should only have one child, because i dont know how this world is going to cope.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. tmax

    I conceived via IVF at 41 and now have a gorgeous 2 yr old. The pregnancy was a 9 month bubble of blissful gestation. But my post natal health suffered and like Amanda my body took a good year (plus) to recover. Every now and then I think it would be nice for our son to have a little brother & sister. But I’ve decided to count my blessings and be content with one child. I’m from a family of 7 but never wanted to have a large family of my own. I can focus on pouring all my love into my one child. That feels right as a child who had to share my mother’s time and affection with 6 others. There was never enough love to go around. I feel for Amanda as I do believe you need to grieve for the children you will never have. A life of unconscious expectation takes time to come to terms with. Be gentle with yourself. Your son is so fortunate to have all your love.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Julie of Perth

    Hi,
    I agree with you. The decision to have a child is a very personal choice and no one else’s business.
    If there were more people like you and your husband, who think before trying to become pregnant, we would have many more children emotionally equipped to deal with life.
    I have never decided that I would like children. I am the youngest in the family and have been looking after nieces and nephews since primary school.
    I have also seen every women in my family being violently sick throughout the whole pregnancy. My sister was hospitalised at about seven months pregnant because she couldn’t hold any food or drink down . Her hair went grey, her teeth were loose and she weighed about 71/2 stone and was 5 foot six at seven months!!
    My sister in law had a 23hour labour of excruciating pain and was torn and traumatised. She also suffered debilitating vomiting throughout the pregnancy.
    All this was happening when I was about 15 years old.
    I think I had a good idea of what parenting involved and decided that it was not for me. I love my sleep and peace and quiet at home.
    I also have had to have surgery on on ovarian cyst that was filled with so much fluid , it was enough to fill a a Coke can. Which also meant that I would not conceive very easily.. I can also state that in my life time, I have never regretted my decision.
    Although people sometimes are very rude and think I am strange because I am not a mother. I have even had people say how would I know how to deal with baby issues because of this!! although as a early teenager/ twenties I was involved with my nieces and nephews.
    I have a stock standard answer to people’s comments and say I was never blessed with one. It makes things easier fork me.
    Although, I suppose, I shouldn’t need to justify my stance.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Nicole

    My mum had me when she was 24 and had an incredibly difficult birth. She decided she did not want to go through that again, so I was it…im 27 now and my parents are awesome, we’re very close. As far as im aware i think i turned out ok! Im running my own succesful business and loving life. Theres no such thing as an only child curse and i can vouch for that first hand :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. Tallulah

    …I didn’t know there was such a thing against only children…not nasty, but I didn’t know it was such a horrible, distressing thing, the idea of not giving your kid a sibling.

    Um, I turned out okay?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Anon for this

    My partner is adamant that he only wants one child. He says before he met me, he didn’t want any children, so this is a development I’m happy with.
    My theory is that having one with someone I adore, rather than three with someone I settled for, is a nice way of thinking about it.
    And you never know, he might enjoy fatherhood so much that he might cave in and say “oh alright then!!” I don’t keep anything crossed for that – I have just accepted that one is all we will have.
    We do need to get onto it though, I’m 31 and he’s 44! Argh!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Anita Ruth

    Hi Amanda, thank you for sharing your story. I have a good friend who is an only child because her mother was unable to concieve after the first baby, I always found it amazing that she felt she needed to explain this to people! No one has the right to judge you or anyone else about the decision on how many children people should have. All the best Amanda and enjoy the blessing of having a lovely, healthy child in in your lives. Cheers

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. KarenDT

    At 43, I became a first-time mum, and a single mum at that. Having never thought I would have children, and approaching the whole thing half-convinced I would be so hopeless at it that I couldn’t manage motherhood, my little girl is truly the love of my life.

    My heart breaks a little that she will grow up an only child, but I thank God every day that I am blessed to have more than none.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Tallulah

      I, um… -shuffles- what’s wrong with being an only child?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  10. only child

    Hi, I have found all the comments and different points of view very interesting.
    This is a topic I am quite passionate about, as I am an only child. I would never presume to tell another parent how to plan their family, nor judge their choices. I can, however, comment on my own experiences.
    I am 40 years old. My mother used a Dalcon Shield after she had me, and never fell pregnant again. Mum and Dad were ok with that. I had a great childhood, with lots of friends and family around. I don’t think I was spoilt. Many of my friends had more freedom and material possessions than me. I always felt loved and valued, and encouraged to follow my dreams.
    It wasn’t until I had my first baby at age 28 that I really missed having a sibling. It hit me that for good or bad, I would never know what that relationship was like. I felt this lack so strongly that my husband (who is one of 3) and I decided that if we had troubles having another baby we would adopt from overseas so our daughter would not be an only child. We now have 2 children.
    Some things that make me sad – I will never enjoy that special bond of an aunty with a niece or nephew. My children do not have cousins or aunties and uncles on my side. I have no-one I can share the experience of growing up with. Now my parents are getting older, the full responsibility for their care rests with me.
    I feel I grew up loved and encouraged, and had lots of cousins and friends around. My parents have always encouraged me to be independent, to the point of encouraging me to move 2000km away because they felt it was best for my family. The demanding early years of parenting, while sometimes being extremely challenging, are only for a few short years. The decision to have only one child has repercussions that last into the next generation.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Priscilla

      do you think you’d feel differently if your mother was unable to have more children as opposed to have choosing not to have had more children?
      i ask as i am unable to have anymore children, my daughter was a true miracle too and i wonder if she’ll feel this way in years to come. because medically i am unable to provide her with a sibling…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  11. Toni Seton

    I to had problems conceiving at 35 and was just about to start IVF at 38 when I fell naturally!! My husband and I have decided that our beautiful daughter will be our only child…….we do not want to damage our relationship with each other or with our daughter trying for another child that could end with more miscarriages and pain. We are a wonderfully happy little family!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. Nicole

    Ahoj Amanda! I am an only child and I’ve certainly never felt that my parents were ‘selfish’ for not having more children. That’s a terrible thing to say to a parent. It’s nobody else’s business how you choose to create your family. Happy and healthy is more important than numbers.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. guest

    Amanda, I have two children who are fairly close in age. Most days I wish I had stopped at one. I really enjoy being a parent of one, but most of the time don’t enjoy being a parent of two. I think the benefits of siblings are overrated. Having said that though, I think in the future they will appreciate it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Mmm

      Hi guest, I really appreciate your honesty. I have a two year old daughter and whilst I love her to bits, I have found it all so hard that I am definitely stopping at one! If you don’t mind me asking, how old are your two kids?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • guest

        My kids are 18 months apart. My son is 4 and my daughter is 2.5. Most days are still a struggle for my husband and I. My kids are good kids and pretty well behaved when they are out. At home we find them the most challenging. The fighting and squabbles get very tiring. It probably doesn’t help that I’m 38 and my husband is 42 – I think I could have handled them better when I was younger and had more energy…

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  14. Anonymous

    I have one beautiful, clever and handsome 11 year old son. What more could I ask for? After suffering severe post natal depression, the thought of having another bout of that was so frightening that I COULD not have another, as much as I would’ve liked to. I sometimes feel bad for my son, but he has many friends and is the light of my life.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Linda

    In September 1980 our beautiful only child came into our lives – Our little ray of sunshine. Even before she was born I was constantly asked how many children we would have. Unlike many women of my era I only wanted one child and my husband supported this decision. Very soon after our daughter was born I was asked by my father in law when would I have another – after all she was a girl and who would carry on the family name (he had two other sons). I asked the question “who would carry on my family name?” My brother had girls. Then as our daughter grew we constantly heard the “only child, you must be spoil” comment. I dont believe our daughter was treated any differently to that of our family or friends children. Another comment we would receive is “isnt she lonely” – far from it! I was a ballet teacher for a number of years and more often than not we had a house full of children or were visiting another child’s home. Sometimes children would be dropped at our house because our daughter must be lonely. When our daughter was about 9 years old I fell pregnant and all our family members were so excited. My mum was madly knitting booties. Unfortunately it was ectopic. My husband and I began to wonder if we had made the right choice with an only child and decided we would try for another child. Another ectopic followed. In a hospital bed and dazed the Doctor told us he would refer us to the IVF clinic and we agreed. I give full credit to women who go through many rounds of IVF. After one go of dealing with all that IVF entails I was phoned at work and told “It didnt work, better luck next time”. Devastated and emotionally exhausted my husband and I agreed it was not meant to be. We had made the decision many years before that one child was all we wanted and we had been so caught up in the hype we lost sight of that. There were many times when my daughter was growing up we would discuss the awful comments she had to endure as an only child. There was one time when I wondered whether we had consider her in our decision when she said to me “mummy I am scared that when you and dad die I will be alone”. There was also the times when she told me “I going to have lots of children!” Next month our only child will be 30. She is well adjusted, smart, kind, loving and respectful of others. We are very proud of her. I dont believe she will ever be alone – she has many aunts, uncles and cousins. One day she may have a child or children of her own. Whatever choice she makes will be what is right for her and her partner. I can highly recommend the book ‘The Only Child’. Best wishes to you Amanada

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. rivkah

    I’m really struggling with this at the moment. I had my first child this year. I have always wanted to have two, but for a variety of reasons, that may now not happen and it’s a thought I find really painful. I would like a second child less for myself, and more for my son. I personally feel uncomfortable – at this stage at least – with the idea of him being an only child. My reasons for this are complicated and I don’t really want to outline them here. I realise I am very blessed to have one child, however, so I am trying not to dwell too much on the issue.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. sarahinadelaide

    We have a beautiful, intelligent and healthy 4 year old and yes he will be an only child. We have fantastic neighbours ( gate open between houses on back yard) and from birth he has had 3 boys he calls his brothers and who they think of as the 4th. He has many friends and we live in a street that has an old fashioned community feel with kids who play with each other. I have been subjected to many rude and nasty comments, that we are selfish etc. How intrusive some people are without knowing someone’s real story, my good friend would love another child but medically is unable, this has been very difficult for her and I wince at people’s blatant rude comments. Do not judge until you know a persons full story or walked in their shoes. We have a wonderful life and a happy bonded family and that is all that matters to us.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  18. Sweets

    You know what? It’s no one else’s business how many children you decide to have.

    We all make decisions on what is the best way to live our lives given our particular circumstances.

    I am 38 with no plans to have kids ( for a few reasons but mostly mental health reasons ) so I have to endure the ‘selfish’ person judgements that come with that.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. Shannon @ Relentless

    Well said Amanda. It is nobody’s business but your own if you want one, three, six, none or eleven children. Whether you adopt, single parent, blend families, foster, conceive naturally or with help, are old, young, teenaged, or in your 40s.

    What is important is that you love your children and never take them for granted.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. Carly Findlay

    I am an only child. My parents chose not to have any more children when they 
    learned of the chances of having another child with the same condition as me, plus I took up a lot of their time being in hospital and needing home care.

    There has often been an assumption (from other kids as I grew up, mostly) that I was spoilt or received a lot of pocket money. Neither were true. Yes I had the full attention of my parents – which was often needed given what an unwell child I was – but I received $5 per week pocket money until I was 15, and my parents were strict on me (still are!). 

    A lot of adults have questioned why I don’t have siblings, even saying that if I had a sibling with the same condition as me, it would be easier to support each other. But it’s not that easy.

    I think that I grew up with a lot of adult interaction and conversation, and the time my parents spent with me allowed me to develop my love of English and the written word. My parents and I have a very close relationship. 

    I dont think it is fair to judge parents or children on the only child status. You never know the reasons for an only child. 

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. Carly Findlay

    I am an only child. My parents chose not to have any more children when they 
    learned of the chances of having another child with the same condition as me, plus I took up a lot of their time being in hospital and needing home care.

    There has often been an assumption (from other kids as I grew up, mostly) that I was spoilt or received a lot of pocket money. Neither were true. Yes I had the full attention of my parents – which was often needed given what an unwell child I was – but I received $5 per week pocket money until I was 15, and my parents were strict on me (still are!). 

    I think that I grew up with a lot of adult interaction and conversation, and the time my parents spent with me allowed me to develop my love of English and the written word – when in hospital or at bath time they would read and we’d make up stories. My parents and I have a very close relationship now too.

    I dont think it is fair to judge parents or children on the only child status. You never know the reasons for an only child. 

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  22. Carly Findlay

    I am an only child. My parents chose not to have any more children when they
    learned of the chances of having another child with the same condition as me, plus I took up a lot of their time being in hospital amd needing home care.

    There has often been an assumption (from other kids as I grew up, mostly) that I was spoilt or received a lot of pocket money. Neither were true. Yes I had the full attention of my parents – which was often needed given what an unwell child I was – but I received $5 per week pocket money until I was 15, and my parents were strict on me (still are!).

    I think that I grew up with a lot of adult interaction and conversation, and the time my parents spent with me allowed me to develop my love of English and the written word. My parents and I have a very close relationship.

    I dont think it is fair to judge parents or children on the only child status. You never know the reasons for an only child.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Jane

    Thanks for sharing your story Amanda. I had my son when I was quite young; I fell pregnant accidentally and decided to raise him alone. I always got judgments made about him being lonely and spoilt and I should have another child for those reasons but siblings don’t make a child not be spoilt, parenting does, siblings don’t make a child not be lonely, there is no guarantee that siblings will get along and be the best of friends! I could not understand their logic to have a child for a child rather than for myself. I invited my son’s mates around regularly for sleep-over’s and to hang out, he went to a neighborhood school so lots of children lived nearby and if they didn’t we got in the car and drove, he plays lots of sports so being lonely has never been an issue. Just because he was on his own didn’t mean I had to spoil him, I could still raise him to share and be considerate, have manners and respect people and only give him what I felt was appropriate at the time. He never had a game console till he was 10, he wasn’t allowed to watch MA movies until he was 15, he had rules that he had to follow at home and jobs he had to do. I have an amazing relationship with my son, I was able to spend the time with him and give him the attention he deserved to hopefully raise a wonderful, confident human being who will contribute positively to society and find his own way. He is now 16 and he is just gorgeous in every way, gosh I love him! I finally met the right man to marry and have another child with when he was 7, it took time for us to fall pregnant and it was an emotional journey and it wasn’t until my son was 13 that we had a daughter. Now she will be raised the same way as my son but now I get the judgments of leaving such a huge gap between my children! But you know what? Stuff them! I have amazing children who will get the time and attention paid to them that they deserve for me choosing to bring them into this world. Life just happens and that’s they way the cards fell, embrace what you have as life is too short. My mum once said to me I was destined to have 2 children born years apart who both adore me…I kinda like that. All the best Amanda.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Vegas

      Hey Jane, same age gap between my stepson, who is now 16, and my little girl, who is 3. He lives with us full time so is always with her. I was 40 when I had her and won’t be having any more of my own. In some ways she’s an only child, because it’s like he’s another adult, but they have a really amazing relationship, and I think it’s going to be a very special relationship for both of them throughout their lives. It’s just the way it worked out for us, but it works really well.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  24. Anonymous

    Thanks for sharing your story Amanda. I had my son when I was quite young; I fell pregnant accidentally and decided to do it alone. I always got judgments made about him being lonely and spoilt and I should have another child for those reasons but siblings don’t make a child not be spoilt, parenting does, siblings don’t make a child not be lonely, there is no guarantee that siblings will get along and be the best of friends! I could not understand their logic to have a child for a child rather than for myself. I invite my son’s mates around regularly for sleep-over’s and to hang out, he went to a neighborhood school so lots of children lived nearby and if they didn’t we got in the car and drove, he plays lots of sports so being lonely has never been an issue. Just because he was on his own didn’t mean I had to spoil him, I could still raise him to share and be considerate, have manners and respect people and only give him what I felt was appropriate at the time. He never had a game console till he was 10, he wasn’t allowed to watch MA movies until he was 15, he had rules that he had to follow at home and jobs he had to do. I have an amazing relationship with my son, I was able to spend the time with him and give him the attention he deserved to hopefully raise a wonderful, confident human being who will contribute positively to society and find his own way. He is now 16 and he is just gorgeous in every way, gosh I love him! I finally met the right man to marry and have another child with when he was 7, it took time for us to fall pregnant and it was an emotional journey and it wasn’t until my son was 13 that we had a daughter. Now she will be raised the same way as my son, like a single child but now I get the judgments of leaving such a huge gap between my children! But you know what? Stuff them! I have amazing children who will get the time and attention paid to them that they deserve for me choosing to bring them into this world. Life just happens and that’s they way the cards fell, embrace what you have as life is too short. My mum once said to me I was destined to have 2 children born years apart who both adore me…I kinda like that. All the best Amanda.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. Mel - Guest

    I am an only child and have lived with people’s judgement and stereotypes my entire life, as I’m sure most only children do. The first thing to come out of their mouths is usually “ah, you must be so spoilt!”. This is the most frustrating of comments! It couldn’t be further from the truth. Being spoilt has nothing to do with being an only child, it’s about how your parents raise you. I know plenty of children with siblings who are spoilt rotten, way more than myself!

    I’m about to turn 30 and I didn’t meet another only child until university! I think it is becoming far more common for people to only have one child, for a variety of reasons. So Amanda, rest assured that your child will not be in the minority and due to it becoming more popular, maybe (hopefully) people will start to be more understanding and it won’t seem so strange to them.

    I had an extremely happy childhood and wouldn’t have asked for anything different. I am very fortunate that I have cousins around my age, did sport, played with next door neighbours etc. so I was never ‘alone’. I have an amazing best friend who I consider a sister even though we are not blood. There’s a lovely quote I have always remembered that says “friends are the brothers and sisters that the universe (or god, whatever your belief systems is) forgot to give us”. There are no truer words for me.

    I’ve heard the hurtful comments, and no doubt they will continue. A close friend once told me that I’d never be a ‘real’ aunty because I didn’t have a blood sister or brother. Unbelievable! But I have learnt over the years to brush it off. We are all products of our own experience.

    For those interested, there has been ample research done on only children and there are really no ill-effects from being an only. On the contrary, only children often have advanced language and higher IQ’s as a result of spending more time with adults. You may also be interested to know that only children CAN in fact have siblings! For instance, if you are 15 and your mum has another child, that child is considered an only because of the age gap between the two children.

    Amanda, and anyone else interested, there is a fabulous book called Only Child by a lady called Miriam. It’s a great read for all only children and their parents.

    All the best, Mel :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. meow

    make sure your second baby is a different gender to the first!! i have two beautiful boys and people want to know when i am having my girl. want to wring their necks!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. Anonymous

    I have an interesting observation… I have two kids and everyone is more than comfortable in asking me (constantly) if we will have another. It doesn’t bother me, as I know they are just curious.

    And I have one fairly close friend who has one child who is 5 years old. And no-one, not even me, ever asks her if she is going to have another baby.

    Why?
    Is it because she is over 40 and from the outside it might look like the child they already have was a much-wanted baby after a long time of trying? (but no-one really knows this is the case, but we are too scared to ask for fear of upsetting her)
    Is it because her child is already 5 years old and a large majority of people have their babies within a closer age gap?
    Is it because, people like myself who have more than one, are perhaps open to more questioning from others about more babies coming?

    In any case, I think as long as people are asking questions just out of friendly curiosity, with no pitiful looks or interrogation-style questions, it would be nice if we all felt comfortable to ask each about babies.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. Anonymous

    I apparently didn’t act like a first time mum in hospital (whatever that is – who knows) so the comments started then…”you’re a natural…we’ll see you in a year with your next” said the midwives. Ah no you won’t!

    Like others posted here I was blessed to conceive within 5 minutes of trying and have a beautiful daughter. My husband has 2 pre-teen children from his first marriage and agreed to have one more child. I agreed (pre marriage and pre birth). Right now I am completely content with one child. I grew up in a huge family with lots of noise but due to the large age difference between myself and my other siblings they all moved out of the family home by the time I was 13. And of course, I didn’t see a whole lot of them between the ages of 13-18 years. Yes, I was resentful towards them as a teenager and very much felt like an only child but 20 years later we are a very close family and I have a tonne of nieces and nephews. So I’m hoping that my daughter will also experience the “big extended family” just like I did.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. Anonymous

    I’m having my first bub at 40 – was definitey not the plan for it to be this late. While there is an outside chance I could still have a second, it’s probably not likely so bub may end up being an only child. Certainly not my choice, and not anybody else’s business.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. j197

    Amanda, I loved your article, I think you’re amazing! I have a beautiful 18 month old boy. Due to health issues, I was hospitalized for my entire pregnancy in severe pain and with constant vomiting. It has taken me these 18 months to fully recover after the pregnancy. I know there is know way I could go through that again or put my family through it again- even though I would love another baby. However, strangers still question me that they cannot believe I wouldn’t try and have another one. I don’t think people quite understand that a difficult pregnancy isn’t just the odd bit of morning sickness! But like you, I am just so grateful for the baby I do have and one is definitely enough for me.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anon

      My first pregnancy wasn’t as bad as yours but I do understand the vomiting side. And I understand the feeling of when people say they had horrible morning sickness but then go on to say they could work up to 36 weeks. I stopped work at 6 weeks and my doctor advised not going back.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  31. peterhau

    I am an only child. I have had 3 kids with my (now ex) wife. we were aiming for 2 kids, but IVF gave us 3. (2nd time around twins) The main reason was that I wanted my kids to have someone to talk to and be a form of support to each other when their parents aren’t around anymore. I can survive on my own, alone, but not lonely, but I dearly wished for a sibling. When my mum remarried, I found that I just didn’t get the whole step sibling thing, how to act, what to say, etc. My sibling in laws were just as bad – I just didn’t get the big family thing.

    It is a bit of a social issue, I have no really close friends, I have no support network, I mean, I could be dead on the floor for a month before my parents would come to check on me. (they would probably knock on the door and go)

    The thing is that my mum chose to have me and that was all. If IVF hadn’t worked, I would have my daughter only. It is down to the individual. if you want lots of kids, great. if you don’t, also great. It is your choice what you do with your body, and whether you have many or one child.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  32. Mon

    Good on you but isn’t it stupid how we feel the need to justify our decisions to others and quite often strangers.
    We have one gorgeous little girl & my husbands had the snip we’ve decided financially we will stop at one. We want to be able to provide well for her and become wealthy ourselves. Selfish? No. Why make life harder than it needs to be?
    Why have more just because it’s the thing to do? There are plenty of people out there that have way more kids than they can provide for financially, emotionally and time wise. I see them in the malls and they look so defeated.
    That is not something I ever want to be!
    It’s your life you are the one whose job it is to love and provide for the child not the governments not your parents but you and only you can make that call. All the best x

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  33. Thea

    I’m an only child and have several friends are also. We are all in agreement. Other than at times such as Christmas and birthdays, where you get more spent on you ( being there only one of you to buy for) being an only child bloody sucks. Growing up I was so envious of my friends with a brother or sister, even more so of those with several. I found it funny that they envied me. Ok I may have got a bigger haul at Xmas, but their houses were always full of the sound of kids messing around, they never got lonely on family holidays. When my Mum died when I was 15 I felt the loneliness of being an only child more than ever and I swore when I had kids, I would never just have one, no matter what. I’m now 30 and have 2 girls, ages 3.5 and 2. I’d love one more soon. I don’t want to be an older parent due to complications I’ve learnt of that my own Mother went through having me at 36.
    The amount of criticism you receive as an adult for being an only child is phenomenal. Stupid really considering it is could not be further from being your fault if it tried. ‘ only children are spoilt’ is a common one. Well, I’d gladly trade all that spoiling to have a sibling.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. OnTheFence

    This article really touched me. I have suffered several miscarriages both before and after the birth of our beautiful daughter, now 3.5. Whilst all previous (6) pregnancies were natural, after the last miscarriage we went to a fertility clinic to investigate what could be causing all the losses. They identified several possible causes (endo, age – I’m now 37, raised antinuclear antibodies) and suggested IVF so that we could fall quickly and then carefully monitor the next pregnancy. But after three failed IVF transfers it took its toll emotionally and we took a six month break. We’re now thinking of trying IVF again but I’m so undecided about it. I had always wanted two children and never thought that our daughter would be an only child, but IVF is so emotionally draining, I’m dreading starting it all again. Do I try for this much longed-for second child or stop trying and continue to cherish the miracle daughter that we have? I wish I was certain one way or the other but I’m scared I’ll have regrets no matter which choice we make. At least if we give IVF another go I know I’ll have tried my best. even if we aren’t successful.
    It does give me comfort, though, to read the comments of people who were an only child and had happy childhoods. I guess our definition of “family” often goes back to our own family and growing up with a sister I always assumed I would also have two children. It’s so hard when the decision is taken out if your hands.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. Louise

    I am selfish. There it is. I am selfish. I didn’t have any of the heartache of having to go through IVF, I fell pregnant on the first try (my partner thinks it was what he calls “his boys”) and we have the most wonderful little girl imaginable. Parenting her is easy, yes I actually said that, EASY! It’s an absolute joy having her in our lives, even on Sunday night when she covered me in vomit and I got only 2 hours sleep, it was absolutely fine because I love her and I’m her mother and thats what happens sometimes. I know that I am a bloody brilliant mother. But my partner (who is a fabulous Dad) and I don’t want any more kids. We are just so happy with her and us and we don’t want that to change anytime soon. If I could adopt a little girl from China, India, etc I would in a heartbeat but my partner is adopted and he has issues with adoption so it just isn’t an option. My family, his family, friends, aquaintances and strangers all make it very clear that i am a selfish cow when I tell them this. Initially when people asked why I would try to explain. Now I just agree with them that yes I am selfish. But it is our choice, and we are happy with it for now. That may change in the future but right now I’m happy being selfish with my wonderful, little family.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. Isabelle

    I think we worry more when they are little. My son is 11 and it now seems perfectly ok for him to be and for me to have an only child – among friends, family, and his school and sport friends. There are lots of only children out there. It isn’t strange. It’s life!! Families come all shapes and sizes, numbers and forms. No one worries when they are older.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. Jane

    Amanda, I love you for writing this. I (finally) had a beautiful boy when I was 38. I will not be having any more babies despite always wanting 4 children. I feel soooo lucky and soooo blessed to have this gorgeous, perfect healthy child, but he will be an only child. I get so sick of having to give reasons or justify why he’ll be an only child, being made to feel guilty by friends and strangers alike for deciding to only have the one child. THANK YOU for writing this and expressing so well exactly how I feel. I really do just want to tell people sometimes to f*** off and mind their own business, that they have no idea of what I’ve been through to have this one child! Why can’t people just be happy for me – there are so many others out there who don’t even get the one child, and I was oh so close to being in that club.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Amanda Kendle

      Jane, so glad you could relate. Exactly, we are so, so, so lucky to have one – I really don’t know how I would have coped being in that other club. xx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  38. Anon

    I am an only child and plan to only have one child myself.

    My mother had an unplanned pregnancy when I was in primary school, but miscarried early on. Her pregnancy with me was difficult so I think they were happy to stop at one.

    I have always enjoyed being an only child. My parents were able to give me a life they probably wouldn’t have been able to if I had siblings. They could afford things like private education and travel that would have been financially out of reach with more children. I wasn’t spoilt but also never wanted for much. And I had and continue to have amazing relationships with my parents because of the amount of one on one time we spent together.

    I have close friends I’ve known since primary school who have often felt like sisters I got to choose so I don’t feel I’ve missed out. I am also often told I don’t “seem like an only child”. I think most people have misconceptions of what an only child will turn out like.

    My parents are both from big families, but both have siblings they no longer speak to so I think they knew that having brothers or sisters doesn’t mean you will end up being close to them.

    As an adult I now have step siblings. But they also are not particularly close so I’ve never envied their relationships.

    As a result of all of this and more, I intend only ever to have one child as I think being an only child can actually be pretty great!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. anni

    There is such a stigma attached to only-children isn’t there? That the parents are selfish, not giving their child someone to play with, that they will be socially awkward/weird/spoilt. I know quite a few only children and yes some are weird and socially awkward, some are spoilt rotten, but you can get that with any child regardless of how many siblings they have. I also know only children who love not having a brother or sister to compete for attention/share things with. But I also know a couple of them who yearned for a sibling.
    It’s such a personal choice to make, but however things turn out, as long as the child is loved and happy that’s all that matters, it shouldn’t be anyone else’s business.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  40. Anonymous

    After a very difficult birth, almost resulting in me not being around & then being diagnosed with cancer 3 months later my Husband was not keen at all about even thinking about a second baby, although I was. However, 3 years later I’ve decided I feel the same way. If it ain’t broke don’t fix it!! I love my little girl to bits, I’m not jeopardizing my health/life for another baby, better outcome for my one baby to have her mummy around! I make a conscious effort to build relationships with her cousins, so she has that ‘family’. But I must admit I find it difficult when people ask about baby number 2, can never just answer ‘no’ – always comes with the full explanation.
    I wonder how many people actually evaluate if they want more than one, or do the have more because that’s the norm?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  41. Tim Tam

    This is such a personal choice and I wish people would think twice before judging others. I have always wanted 2 children – but after having my first this year and realising how much hard work being a mum is, I have had to start thinking seriously about whether or not I could cope with another one. I am still deciding – sometimes I think I will have another one in a couple of years…then sometimes I think I might not …but at the end of the day, it’s my choice. I just hope people can just accept that and move on with their own lives. Everyone has their story. Live and let live.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Amanda Kendle

      I wish that too! And exactly. It’s your choice. Do what feels right for you and (try to) ignore what everyone else says.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  42. Karen

    The need to judge and comment constantly on other peoples’ (read womens) lives just completely baffles me.

    It starts when you meet someone, “when are you getting engaged?” and then “when are you getting married” and then “are you changing your name?” and then “when are you having a baby?” and then “when are you having another one?”

    And they’re not always the innocent questions from friends and family who are genuinely (and naturally) interested in your life. The toxic comments that follow the answers are proof of that!

    And the worst thing is….it’s ALWAYS women judging women. Wasn’t womens’ lib really about giving women the right to make the decisions that are right for themselves and their own families? We’re not all made from the same giant cookie-cutter…what’s right for one woman isn’t necessarily right for another.

    Let’s please try to accept each other as we are – including the choices that we make.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  43. Kimmm

    I completely understand!

    We get that too, all of the time. It can be irritating, especially when the same people continue to hound you with the same question.

    I’ve started responding with “What makes you ask?” or “Why do you ask?” as it puts the onus back on them to explain themselves first, rather than you explaining yourself.

    If they continue to hound you for an answer/reason/explanation I just explain, quite directly by this stage, that they don’t need to concern themselves with our reasons ;)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nat

      I like your reply. I’ll use that one myself, next time I am asked which won’t be long I’m sure!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  44. Kimmm

    I understand and agree completely!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kimmm

      Oops, pressed enter too early!

      We get that too, all of the time. It can be irritating, especially when the same people continue to hound you with the same question.

      I’ve started responding with “What makes you ask?” or “Why do you ask?” as it puts the onus back on them to explain themselves first, rather than you explaining yourself.

      If they continue to hound you for an answer/reason/explanation I just explain, quite directly by this stage, that they don’t need to concern themselves with our reasons ;)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  45. Simone

    Your body. Your lifestyle. Tell everyone to butt out.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  46. Anna

    I’m 40 and an only child – for the record I love it, and yes I don’t know any differently – just as all you people with siblings don’t know any different.

    Only children have to fit into their parents world a lot more than multi kids in my experience, but it’s such a great world.

    Yes I was spoilt but I knew I was and didn’t laud it – in fact I usually didn’t say what I had to most friends but I also didn’t get everything I wanted when I wanted.

    I have a great bunch of friends – yes I do worry about my parents getting older and living interstate that I’m going to carry the burden of looking after them but it will all work itself out.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  47. hahamama

    Great post, Amanda. I can’t believe how insensitive some people can be. After having heard your reasons, I can completely understand you wanting to stop at one. However, if I met someone whose reason was, “Because I only want one” and it was as simple as that, then I’d say, “Fair enough!” What is so wrong with it, after all? I’m currently pregnant with my second child, I also have a 2-year-old son. I always knew I’d want at least one more, but I’ve also learnt since becoming a parent that you don’t judge other parents’ choices and methods. Period.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Gengen

      If the like button worked I would like, like, like this post!!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  48. hahamama

    Great post, Amanda. I can’t believe how insensitive people can be. After having heard your reasons, I can completely understand you wanting to stop at one. However, if I met someone whose reason was, “Because I only want one” and it was as simple as that, then I’d say, “Fair enough!” What is so wrong with it, after all? I’m currently pregnant with my second child, I also have a 2-year-old son. I always knew I’d want at least one more, but I’ve also learnt since becoming a parent that you don’t judge other parents’ choices and methods. Period.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  49. Guest

    I don’t want kids but if I did have them I would only have one. I see nothing wrong with it. Let’s be blunt, it is a bit financially appealing. Maybe as a childree person I am seeing it too coldly, but I bet the financial aspect of one child is something that does cross the mind. As a lifestyle person I think one child could be a good lifestyle – for child and parent. Feel free to flame me.

    That said, I love having a brother. That extra hand to help out when you need it, and to help in return. And someone to share the load and bitch with when parents get tough. My mother is high needs and I couldn’t cope with her without my brother.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Amanda Kendle

      I agree on the lifestyle bit – I love to travel (I’m a travel blogger, after all) and that’s much easier with one. Unfortunately in our case the many, many thousands of dollars spent on fertility treatment didn’t make our son a bargain! But worth every cent and more.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  50. Jeneane

    It really bothers me that people seem to think they have a right to judge your physical pain and heartbreak. We have quite a few friends with one child and each has their own story as to why. But you know what – that’s their business as much as why we stopped at 2 or had more than 1 is ours. Great article – I hope it makes people think twice before they offer up some uninformed opinion or re-tell the tale of their second cousin twice removed.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Amanda Kendle

      Thanks Jeneane. That’s my hope for it too. xx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions