Do You Like This Story?
Youre Invited Not  When every kid is invited to the party except yours. Ooooph.

You’re invited. Not.

 

 

 

 

By ANONYMOUS

The rage I felt was instant. My daughter Emily, 7, had just bowled through the front door, full of the happy exhaustion that a little girl should have after her first grown-up sleepover (read: no sleep, tons of sugar).

Dawn, her friend’s mum dropped her off and came in to see me. She was confused. Why were all the other kids piled into her car invited to Amy’s birthday party, and not my kid? Surely, she says, Emily has it wrong and just misplaced the invitation?

But she wasn’t invited. This is the first I’d heard of Amy’s birthday party. Amy, who, as far as I was aware was one of my daughter’s best friends. The same Amy who’d been to every one of my daughter’s birthday parties, as well as many other assorted little gatherings, like trips to the cinema and the bowling alley. She’d invited every other kid in their little gang, except mine.

So I was quietly fuming with Amy’s mum for singling my child out in this way, but also angry with myself for being so angry. “Get over it,” I scolded myself.  But then Dawn followed up with a concerned phonecall. The very fact she did made me think maybe I wasn’t so mental after all. And for once, my husband agreed with me – this was rude.

The kids in the car said that Amy’s mum had told her to choose between my daughter and another little girl for the last coveted spot at the party. Who DOES that? I wracked my brain. In ‘these difficult times’, maybe it was a purely economic decision.  But these are well earning middle class parents. When they’ve already hired the local hall and the kids’ entertainer, pointedly cutting out one little girl saves the cost of a few sausage rolls and a party bag.

So is my kid ‘that kid’, the annoying, badly behaved one who no other parent wants to deal with?  But there’s no way we’d have got several years into schooling without me having an inkling of this. Maybe the girls had simply fallen out or drifted apart. But they’d been running around the playground happily together just a couple of days earlier.

Schoolyard gossip 380x255 When every kid is invited to the party except yours. Ooooph.

“That feeling of walking into the school gates and finding that the girls who were nice to you yesterday have frozen you out today.”

I’ll never know because a huge part of me knows I’m being a bit nuts, so I won’t raise it.  And yet, still the indignity gnaws at me.

I’m sure many of you will be reading this and sniggering ‘first world problems’.  But it’s not really about the party. What’s hit me is the realization that these sorts of events pick over all my own, nearly 30-year-old schoolyard scabs.

That feeling of walking into the school gates and finding that the girls who were nice to you yesterday have frozen you out today. That horrible silence that descends on a group of giggling, chatting girls when you enter the room. That sinking feeling  when you’ve been ridiculed and rejected for wearing the wrong kind of trainers, or having what’s been deemed the day’s ugliest hairstyle/face/body/delete as applicable.

I’d managed to put it all behind me. But this little incident has me wondering if  I’m set to live it all again? Only through my child, which will be even more painful.

Thankfully, so far it seems Emily’s made of tougher stuff than me. She reported this snub in the same tone she might use to tell me she’s just popping to the loo. No biggie. And at least I’ll be able to show her that despite my traumatic teenage years, I got through it. I’m (within acceptable parameters of) normal and all that stuff probably helped me grow the thick skin sometimes needed in my chosen career. But right now, it seems any minor cruelty she experiences is destined to make a little bit of me die inside, every time.

The author is a Mamamia reader who has chosen to remain anonymous.

Have your childhood experiences crept up on you again through your kids?  How have you reacted?

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

210 Comments so far

  1. ELLEON

    I certainly got the surprise of my life this evening. My son finished his baseball game and my husband and I decided to go to dinner right in town. So we walked into the restaurant and got seated and we hear a whole bunch of boys laughing & chatting. We walk into the seating area, and we see some parents of kids we recognize, so we immediately say hello. Then the mother of the birthday boy, walks over to me and says “I wanted to have a little party for my son since it was his birthday today, so I kinda just threw a small dinner of his friends together. I will have my son ask your son to join all of them now.”
    I am actually glad we chose that same place to have dinner at this evening because I could see the word. “awkward” written all over her face.
    First of all her son invited 12 boys out for his birthday dinner. My son just had his birthday a week ago, and we invited her son to come for his birthday but mind you, the mom responded the day of my son’s birthday party–she was rude for not responding to my 3 communications & for not RSVP’ing on time. I let that go, but to think she selectively forgot to invite my son, after he came to my son’s birthday party the week before & I hosted her son over for play dates at my home 3x in the last few months. How can this Mom be so rude and not understanding? You would think she would at least of offered to pay for my son’s dinner since she had her son take him to his birthday table. Instead, my husband & I paid for our dinners & our sons meal.
    I truly believe what comes around goes around and I hope karma comes around to visit her very soon. I also believe God put us there tonight at the same restaurant she decided to have her son’s birthday dinner there, to show me what type of person she really is. She needs a kick up her ass from the Nine West shoe company that she works for…lol! I would appreciate any advice on this situation.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. Maria T

    The saying “Do unto others as you would want to be treated” rings loud and clear here. Adults know better than that, they should never exclude a child unless there is a real issue why that certain child or children should not be invited to a party.
    We are all one, people should respect one another and not practice “selective prosecution” especially when it comes to a child. Always remember, what comes around, goes around.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. tanja

    My son is only 4 and yet, I have the same fears. I never liked elementary school. I was always the shy kid. I have a twin sister, so having her made things better for me. But, we were forced to separate in school. We were both bullied and very shy. We were the shy, quiet, nice kids from a very poor area. My son has a lot more than I ever did and we do not live in a low income area and I get to stay at home with my kids, because my husband and I do well financially, but the poverty I still feel and growing up in that area still gnaws at me. At the same time, I don’t want my son getting things just handed to him. I want him to understand where I came from and how lucky he is. Yet, a lot of the kids around here are mean or feel a sense of entitlement, that my son does not feel, because he does not get that much as other kids in this neighbourhood. I want him to value a dollar. But other parents just give their kids everything and create spoiled and whinny kids. My son is not like that, I can give him grass and he will find a way to play with it. But, I am still haunted by my past and I was often singled out because my sister and I were the only twins in school, but we had each other. My son has not gone to a birthday party all year in school. It is his first year of school. I don’t know any of the kids in his class or the parents. His birthday is in the summer, and I won’t invite any kids in his class because he doesn’t talk about them and I don’t know them and the kids that live in this area all go to private schools or french immersion schools or catholic schools. He goes to a public school but for grade 1 we will switch him to the french immersion school. In any case, I wonder if kids have had parties and he was not invited. Other friends I have and their kids go to other schools have been to a few birthdays of kids in their class, but not mine. So, I don’t know how much I should worry about that.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Robert

    This aint just at school. Everyone in my work place (only four of us) is invited to a colleague’s wedding – except me. Tomorrow, there’s a morning tea for her. I’ve exhausted my sick days so I’ll just have to smile sweetly and congratulate her when really I’m hurt that the other 3 are going, but not me.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Kat

    In year 5 I had to pick the ’5 friends’ for my party. Mum agreed to take us to Sydney Aquatic Centre – the absolute top choice for any 11 year olds birthday- and our van only fit 5 friends, me, and mum.

    I had to make the sacrifice and chose my 5, leaving one girl out. The Monday after the party I received a homemade present from the girl I left out and a birthday card.

    I felt so much guilt. I thought she didn’t know about the party but gossip had spread. I remember to this day that pang of guilt as I said “I could only invite 5 people”. She replied: “I know, it’s okay. I still wanted to give you a present.”

    Picking ’5′ is a tough choice. For parents, and the kids. If you feel your kid has missed out for an unfair reason, providing a card or small gift to the other child is a positive step to teach children that its not a big worry and that the birthday list its not the be-all and end-all to friendships. (It will also subtly let the other parent know you don’t miss a beat!)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. faith

    and I have invited her to all my parties

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. faith

    I am 15 and I am not a talkative person but I have the same problem my friend had told me I wasn’t Invited to her birthday party because I wouldn’t talk to everyone and I came home in tears my mum was trying to comfort I know how your daughter feels

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Krystal

    I remember one year I attended my friend Stacey’s annual slumber party. At the end of the party Stacey and another girl were laughing, lying on the backs and lifting their hips up and down. I didn’t know what the connotations were, all I saw was my friends laughing and wriggling on the ground, so I joined them. As I lay down, the other two girls paused to instruct me on my technique, i was working of my thrust when a couple of mothers walked in. I’ll never forget one of them screeching at me to stop, and that I was a ‘disgusting’ child, everyone paused to stare at me, and the confusion and humiliation I felt was indescribable. It wasn’t until I was a few years older that I realised what it must have looked like.

    The next year, I wasn’t invited to the party. Stacey told me her mother thought I was ‘too rude.’ I’ll never forget the devastation and rejection I felt at being the one girl in the class who wasn’t invited. Stacey must have realised because the next day she ran up to me with an invitation, which I accepted, but remained quiet and well behaved at the party lest her mother consider me rude, and to be honest our friendship was never the same again as I always felt uncomfortable around her mother.

    That experience remained with me for years, and if a similar thing happened to my daughter it would bring it all rushing back. Hopefully if it does happen it doesn’t bother her like it did me…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. guest

    Even with inviting whole class parties you need to exclude some kids, you know the kids who you just dont want around, they break things, fist the birthday cake, have tantrums when they dont win the games, push & shove the other kids. They just ruin the party for everyone and every class has one or two or three.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Yep.

    I really dislike the “choose 5 friends only” type parties. Usually there will be a 6th or 7th friend that misses out. I understand that there may be economical restraints, but the instances that I have known, that’s not it at all. It’s more like what mummy can handle in order to put on a “Women’s Weekly” style themed party.

    My daughter was one of the left out ones & I thought that she and this kid were good friends. But alas, no, she was probably 6th or 7th on the parent’s list. This mum would put on “amazing parties”, but then would get her child to choose “A & B list” kids. She was telling us about it once (not that bluntly, but that’s what it was basically). But I did have a chuckle when her own child missed out on an invite at his school and how upset she was for him and how rude it was of those parents. I’m like, “well, come on???”, having been on the left out list of their apparently awesome exclusive (Women’s Weekly glammed up parties) invite parties. Hypocrite much?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. distracted

    I have a dilemma of this type at the moment … advice much appreciated!

    One girl my daughter has become really good friends with this year has just started being mean to her – telling her to meet her in the play ground and never showing up, telling her to go away, etc. She’s pretty much been her only good friend for a lot of the year. My daughter’s birthday party is coming up in a couple of weeks … do we invite the girl or not? What do I say to her Mum if she isn’t invited? Her Mum is very nice – I think the girl’s been influenced by another little horror in the class.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • chillax

      Invite the girl who is her friend but not the horror.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Sue

      I agree invite the girl. It’s best to think long term, this may or may not all blow over soon, but the hurt of not being invited to your daughters party will always be there and may prevent the friendship from blossoming again.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • distracted

        Thanks guys! Was leaning towards this … great to have your points of view too. <3

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  12. BC

    Happened to my son this year, but in a strange twist the party he didn’t get invited to was on the same day as my son’s little birthday get together at the park. I only received 3 RSVPs out of 7, two of which were genuine cases of couldn’t make it (ie weren’t going to the other party) and one yes. That one yes was the only kid who showed up and I had no idea about the other party til that child’s mum mentioned it to me while our kids were playing – her son had been invited but was given a choice which to attend by his mum. I was devastated at the time but later learned that most of the “other” mums were already friends through their older children whereas my four year old is my oldest so I didn’t know any of the mums. I still think though the other parents could have let me know their kids weren’t coming, I was so sad for my little bloke that only one friend came. He on the other hand was delighted and the two of them are very close, and his mate’s mum is lovely!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • chillax

      If your son is happy thats all that matters.
      Though people not RSVPing is so rude and so common these days.
      I had a clash with one of my children last year. A child at school who is not friends with my child had a party on the same day as mine. We didnt invite her, she didnt invite my child so no biggie. However the parties overlapped by about an hour. So kids who were invited to both were leaving her party early to come to my daughters. But I only found out about this when kids arrived at my childs party already clutching lolly bags from the previous party! I was really embarressed for the other family, who I found out, thought that we had hijacked their party.
      I’m still annoyed none of the families whose kids had been invited to both didnt mention it to me so I could have pushed the time back so it didnt impact upon the other childs party. The mum still gives me dirty looks too.
      Sometimes its just an honest clash, but people really should let you know when it does clash.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  13. Essen

    No, I entirely agree. It’s bad manners not to return the invite.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Tracey Groombridge

      I’m finding people don’t do it any more it’s so frustrating especially when you cater.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  14. Mother of Three

    It’s a brithday party – get over it! Children need to learn they dont get invited to anything! Your daughter handled it beautifully- so should you.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Tracey Groombridge

      Thats ok if it’s one birthday party but when it’s continual it’s heart breaking.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • chillax

        Yeah, but if its continual maybe the child is behaving in a way that the other kids find off putting. Its not always someone elses fault.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  15. BoysRock

    So glad I have boys. Girls seem to endure so much more of this type of thing.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Lisa

      I’m so glad I’m not in your situation. My situation rocks. Oh, I feel so sad for your situation but whatever.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  16. Annie

    My little sister (who is 12 years my junior) a few years ago had her 5th birthday. She told my Mum and I that she only wanted 4 particular girls invited to her “maccas” party. We both exclaimed that you couldn’t do that and that all 8 girls in her class would get invites (small school). We asked her if she got along with them and she said “yes, I get along with them but they get really silly and ruin things”. But we didn’t listen. It was bloody mayhem to say the least. One kid literally jumped up on the table when the birthday cake came out and jumped on half of it! Another kid squawked like a baby hawk through the birthday song. They were rude and hit the clown. And finally one pinned my sister in the corner when we were busy paying attention to other kids and kicked her in her “rudy spot” making her bleed! HECTIC! Mum and I vowed to always listen to her after that…
    Nevertheless, I am totally on the writer’s side in this article. It was clear they were friends and you can’t leave ONE kid out. That is ridiculous and in my mind, totally malicious by the other mother. I think she is jealous of your daughter if I have a guess…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. Anonymous

    My little sister who is 12 years my junior a few years ago had her 5th birthday. She told my Mum and I that she only wanted 4 particular girls invited to her “maccas” party. We both exclaimed that you couldn’t do that and that all 8 girls in her class would get invites (small school). We asked her if she got along with them and she said “yes, I get along with them but they get really silly and ruin things”. But we didn’t listen. It was bloody mayhem to say the least. One kid literally jumped up on the table when the birthday cake came out and jumped on half of it! ANother kid squawked like a baby hawk through the birthday song. They were rude and hit the clown. And finally one pinned my sister in the corner when we were busy paying attention to other kids and kicked her in her rudy spot making her bleed! HECTIC! Mum and I vowed to always listen to her after that…
    Nevertheless, I am totally on the writer’s side in this article. It was clear they were friends and you can’t leave ONE kid out. That is ridiculous and in my mind, totally malicious by the other mother. I think she is jealous of your daughter if I have a guess…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  18. Kelly

    It’s only a birthday party. Fast forward to being an adult do you get invited every time a colleague has a gathering, to weddings of people you know get married or to drinks with friends when they only catch up with some?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. Struth

    My son is reserved and quirky and has some social struggles. He is completely harmless and couldn’t bully a flea but flies under the radar. Last year he only socialised with girls. He doesn’t get invited to any birthday parties – the girls don’t invite him and nor do the boys as he doesn’t play with them. Initially I would come home and have a little private weep when people would say ‘see you at such and such’s party’ or invitations were handed out under our nose to all and sundry or we would see everyone heading off to the park. Now I have decided that we both need to be proud of who we are and not be concerned about our value based on birthday party invitations. There are many and varied reasons why he is not invited and it is part of learning about life for BOTH of us! I have to admit that it has been more of a learning experience for me than for him, particularly as I was always invited to parties when I was at school and now I am the Mum never attending! Initially I found it very hard to accept that he would discretely invite one or two friends from school to his party as he liked them very small and these friends would not return the invitation. Now when other Mums mention parties we are not invited to or say they will see us there, I do my very best to be dignified and casual and just say ‘oh we weren’t invited to that party but no hard feelings’. And now my feelings have followed my words and I have hardened up a bit. It is of no benefit to stew over the party politics and the benefits are not needing to devote hours of our weekend to parties and buying expensive presents!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nomes

      Good for you Struth.Your son is more special than all of them.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  20. Danica

    I have a soon-to-be toddler so I have never thought of this before!! Yikes! Maybe the best policy is if you have a boy, invite all the boys in the class. If you have a girl, invite all the girls in the class. Invite the opposite gender only if your child and that child are actually friends. I would think that the children who are not actually friends with your child may not attend????

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. michelle

    Help! this post has me worried now….
    I’m planning my daughter’s 6th birthday party. I had wanted it to be kind of a small party, nothing too crazy. But soon, one by one the list started getting bigger. Cousins of course are invited, and the two close friends with whom she has regular play dates outside of school. But then there’s her class. There are 24 kids in that class, and I know she’s not besties with all of them. I thought of maybe just inviting the girls but there is a brother and a sister in the class and you can’t invite one and not the other (and also there’s a boy cousin). So OK now it’s girls and boys. But several of the parents know each other really well and while I’m not best buds with them, we are friendly and I do like their company, so I can’t leave out one or two out without looking mean. So the numbers are creeping up and up and it is now approaching half the class. . In truth, the kids will probably never know there was a party as school will have already ended. But what if they do? I’d hate for anyone to feel left out, but I don’t think I have the emotional skills to deal with a party of nearly 30 children, plus parents (plus inevitable siblings), plus extended family… not to mention the cost of all that. My eye is twitching just thinking about it. My husband doesn’t see a problem with inviting 12 of the 24 kids in the class. Is he right? Am I overthinking this?? Do you have to invite all your kid’s schoolmates or nothing? This quagmire of trying not to offend is really stressful…wishing I’d stuck to the ditch-the-party-go-to-dreamworld plan… but it’s too late now.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • chillax

      Your husband is right, just invite the girls. A brother wouldnt expect to be invited to a girls party, nor want to be invited unless he plays with the girls at school anyway.
      You are overthinking it. Just invite the girls and dont invite parents/siblings to stay, thats just crazy!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • B

      I think it’s fine to invite half the class. The problem in this article was that her daughter was the ONLY one not invited (and that’s crap).

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anne

      I think you invite the ones your daughter is friends with. You definitely don’t have to invite all the class, and I don’t believe you need to invite all the girls! The ones your daughter plays with and wants there are enough :)

      My son recently had his 6th birthday. We invited 14 friends, 11 of who were school friends – 9 boys and 2 girls. They were all kids that he asked for, plus we invited the new kid at my suggestion. There’s 40 kids in his grade at school and there’s been plenty of parties my son hasn’t been invited to, and plenty he has. It all works out in the end!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  22. JRuth

    I don’t agree with the exclusion of certain children, if a large group or most of the class is invited. As my daughter is in a fairly small class at school, and tends to have lots of friends rather than close BFFS, I have encouraged her to invite all the girls in her class to her party each year for that reason. However, I totally respect other parents decision to hold small parties for only a handful of friends.

    Having said that though, what I do find lightly irritating though, are those parents who throw a party for their daughter each year, and don’t invite my daughter – even though she has invited their daughter to all her parties and their daughter has come along every year! My mother always taught me that if someone else invites you to their party (and you go) that you should invite them to yours. Do others agree, or is this old fashioned now?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Lottie

    I was accosted in the car-park last year by the Mum of a girl not invited to my daughter’s party. There were many children in her class that were not invited – we simply don’t have the room. I was also trying to teach my daughter that you can’t always have your everything you want ie invite 30 children to your party, just the same as I teach her you are not always invited to every party. My daughter understands this. Although it came slightly unstuck when this other Mum demanded an invite. Who does that? I just don’t get it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • chillax

      Some people think the world revolves around their child. Parents like this are setting their kids up for major disappointment when mum and dad cant control things to cater to their happiness. Thats their problem not yours. Ignore her, she’s mad.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  24. Elsie

    Have been through all this with my first child who was excluded from one particular child’s birthday parties due to jealousy, and the need of the mother to ensure that her child was the focus of all attention. My child wasn’t dominating the friendship group, but was very good friends with one of the other kids which balanced the numbers in the friendship group… Not what the Mother wanted! I grinned & insisted that my child invite the other to their next birthday party… Rise above it, and all that! We are not going to behave badly!!

    Fast forward to my next child. I’ve never been a parent who manipulates friendship groups – have always given my kids room to make their own friends and luckily they have good taste, and even better these kids have great parents! I became aware of a child who was having a hard time at school (as was the Mum) and ensured that said child (and Mum) was invited to gatherings of the friendship group – play dates, outings to the movies, etc – amongst my friends I am known for wanting to be as inclusive as possible as I can’t stand the thought of anybody feeling excluded and upset. Imagine my shock (like somebody had punched me in the stomach!!) when said child had a party and invited all the new friends from this group, but not mine!!! I discovered this when a friend asked to car-pool to said party and I had my idea what she was talking about. I was absolutely gutted! I did consider whether our kids had a problem with each other, but the Mum had been very happy to accept my babysitting services over school holidays etc for the duration.

    That was it for me – never made an effort since and certainly didn’t invite that child to next birthday party and have not made an effort with the Mum since. Call me spiteful, but I tried to rise above it first time around, but not going to waste my time with a parent who uses & abuses my good nature. I’m polite & friendly, but that is it for me.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. chillax

    Without the mum delving into the fine workings of the social group and her childs behaviour at school, it does appear to be mean. But perhaps her daughter has been mean to the birthday girl at school recently and she just didnt want to go there.
    Sometimes there are reasons that children are excluded and without taking our blinkers off and considering that our child isnt the gorgeous thing we see them to be the answer isnt going to be obvious.
    Often the parents of the child who has been causing all the trouble, are the loudest to complain when their child is finally on the receiving end of it themselves.
    We know a child who has been a mean little bully for several years. The kids at school finally all became sick of it and wouldnt play with her. So she ended up having no friends and changed schools last term. And now mum is telling people the reason for leaving was that her child was bullied!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. anonymous

    it does happened to my daughter in many times, it is not in our control so we learned to not to get upset or make a deal of it, what i do on her birthday is i bring cake, lolly bags, balloons and few treats to school, for everyone to share and enjoy the party with teacher’s help, what i m thinking is this is the best way to do for primary school kids. do it at home as a family party but please just because it is a special day for your child do not give the other kids sense of rejection, i deeply know my child getting hurt but she knows that i m 2x getting hurt thats why we kind of ignore this rudeness.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. husband and father of 4

    we let our kids choose who they want to invite, we allow them to invite the whole class and friends from other classes if they wish but they dont, they are all different, for example one invites the whole class plus a couple that they were in prep classes with and/or plays with but does not want them to bring presents (dont ask me why) about half usually show up. Another usually only invites about ten, who all show up!.

    However, they all seem to have kids they love to play with at school but that they dont want to come to our house for a party – puzzled i have asked and the replies boil down to child “X/Y/Z” is full on and fun for half an hour at lunchtime, but two or three hours and they’d be a bit too much to take. Having had one child get a bit too eager in “rough and tumble” a couple of parties back, I’ll trust my kids judgement on who they want over.

    On the same token if our kids dont get invited to a party they rationalise that maybe that parent has a small house or can only afford a few kids, or doesn’t have enough adult helpers going along. We’ve not had any of them sulk at missing out. (i seem to take it much harder than they do).

    When i was a t school parties were expensive and precious, most kids only got to invite half a dozen friends, so they were a rare event. I went to more after parties being a part of the theater group in high school, than actual birthday parties during all my school years.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. Anon

    It happened to my daughter this year. A girl in her little group of friends didn’t invite my daughter but invited the rest of the group some other girls who hadn’t been good friends of the birthday girl up to that point.

    I told my daughter that yes, it was upsetting, but not to let it get to her or affect the way she was around the girl. Reasons for a non-invite can be really random sometimes – it may be that the other non-close girls were invited because they had invited the birthday girl to their parties. Or the parents might be really good friends and there were issues with numbers etc. I

    Anyway, she took my advice and all has been well – she is still really good friends with the birthday girl and they all get along just fine.

    On a different note, when I was in high school there was a girl that was really mean to me. She’d try to trip me over when I walked past her etc. I never knew why she hated me so much, but never let it get to me – whenever she tried to trip me over, I’d dodge it and smile sweetly and say in a cheery voice “Nice try. Better luck next time!”.

    Years later I was talking to another classmate who told me why that girl hated me so much – apparently it was because I had bigger boobs than her. Kids are random sometimes.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. MHP

    One of my son’s good friends in Year 2 invited all of the boys in the class to his birthday party but not my son – this was quite baffling as they play together every lunch time.

    I have since found out that the mother actually has a problem with me (her problem, not mine!) and obviously thought it appropriate to involve an innocent child!

    A few months later my son had his birthday party and I made very sure that an invitation was especially given to this little boy. On the day of the party, I was very amused to see that the woman’s husband turned up with the boy and everyone had an awesome time!

    btw – this was a few years ago now and she still has not spoken to me!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. ac

    oh that is mean – and very odd to single out one child – sorry it had to be your girl.
    It also happened to my son a couple of times and makes me wonder why?? and i worry too…but I realise there are many things we cant control and people do things we dont agree with but hey thats life! What can you do but let them know they are wanted and loved and that there will be loads more parties in the years to come!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  31. JD

    I think you handled it well by not getting involved.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Gabby

      I also think you handled it extremely well but it still doesn’t stop your heart breaking in two for your child.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  32. chillax

    If my child was the only one not invited, instead of turning on the other family, I would be having a long hard HONEST look at my own child.
    I’m not saying that this is the case here, but it could be. Often the parents of the mean child are the last ones to see it or admit it. If a child had been making my child upset there is no way I would invite that child to my childs birthday. And if my child was the mean child I would expect my child to be excluded too. Its not easy to tell someone their kid is the class meany, so reading the signs can be really helpful to everyone.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • chillax

      Excluding the mean kid from their party can often be the only power weaker children have over them. It is ironic that by doing this, it can have the mean kids parents labelling them the bully!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  33. lozzie

    Birthday parties are a minefield.

    When my kids were younger, I went by the rule of the age of the child + 1 was the number of guests allowed. This worked really well. I personally never wanted the expense or the stress of inviting the whole class and certainly my kids were never friends with everyone in the class so I didnt see the point anyway.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. michelle

    When my daughter was in primary school, I had an absurd conversation with another mother in the school playground. Her daughter had handed out birthday invites the day before in class. The mother wanted to make clear to us mothers whose daughters hadn’t been invited that a) not to be upset because its not really a birthday party but an “afternoon tea” and b) there would be second round offers – “if any of other the other girls couldnt make it then our daughters would be sure to be invited”

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Sorry…my daughter would be busy that day… Washing her hair!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  35. Rosa

    I agree with you Chillax. I don’t want my children expecting crazy huge parties filled with gifts. My children are given a set number of invites and they can choose who goes on that list. I don’t tell them who to invite. Their playground friends seem to constantly change from one week to the next, so I’m not in a position to tell them who they want to spend their party with. In my experience with 3 children under 10, they don’t mean to be vindictive if they don’t invite someone, it’s really just about who they played with on that day.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. A-nonny-nonny

    Reminds me of Shankari’s very lovely personal story on the very same topic last year:
    http://www.mamamia.com.au/parenting/childrens-birthday-parties-invitations-presents-and-being-left-out/

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anon

      In fact, it even had the same graphic as used for this article!!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  37. Em

    Oh gawwwd! I’m not looking forward to this stuff!!!. I do remember when I was 10 I had a big party and due to some pretty hopeless invitation management where girls were invited in a steady stream so that somehow, accidently, I’d invited all girls bar one. For example, invitations were arriving for me for other parties so I had to invite that girl. It was completely accidental and I don’t even think mum was aware of the situation. When her birthday came around she invited everybody but me and I just though, oh fair enough.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  38. Anonymous

    The school my children attend has the rule that if you aren’t handing out invitations to everyone, they mustn’t be handed out at school. Both our kids loved addressing the invites and posting them so not a bad thing.
    Personally I cant stand childrens birthday parties, always seems like a huge present grab. I attended one with my then 5 year old daughter and overheard the birthday childs mother comment to her mother that she would be able to put half the presents away for xmas there were that many.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. Lucinda

    The fact that Emily brushed it off like it was no big deal being the only one not invited suggests to me the she and Amy have had a fight about something. Still poor form on the mother’s part, but I think the choosing between one girl or the other was an excuse. I’d be fishing the truth out of your daughter if i were you.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  40. clare

    I was on the other end of this a few years ago when my husband received an angry phone call from a parent whose child had not been invited to my son’s party. We had decided that the number of kids he could invite was 6 (due to space in our home mainly) and so obviously he couldn’t invite everyone. This parent abused my husband and demanded to know why his son had not been invited. I was livid and felt that this man had no right to question who we choose to invite into our home. After much deliberation we invited this boy, mainly so it wouldn’t be awkward at school for either of the boys, but they chose not to send him, and they changed schools soon after so I’m not sure what happened. I think kids need to learn that life isn’t always fair and teaching them to cope with disappointment and to develop resiliance is more beneficial to them than fighting these sort of battles for them.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  41. Suki

    My daughter invited the whole class!
    We have a park over the road from our house. Mr suki mowed a big square in the grass and put up a badminton net he bought from Big W. we sent over a picnic and the kids played a tournament and ran around the park.
    Best day ever!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • distracted

      Great idea! I do love whole-class parties, they’re so inclusive. We always seem to do something which is impractical for the whole class to be invited to … must change next year!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  42. anon

    my mum told me that when I was 6 a girl in my class invited every girl in the class to her birthday except me, and she never spoke to that girls mother again. She was angry but I was blissfully ignorant, please dont stress!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  43. Ness

    I’d be on the phone immediately to find out why and make the parent explain herself. That’ just not on from a so-called ‘adult’.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • chillax

      I think you should only do that if you are prepared to hear the absolute truth. And it might not paint your child is a positive light.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Michelle

        Chillax – I don’t think that is such a bad thing! Would perhaps give answers to this whole article then! Sometimes hearing their version of the truth can be helpful,

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • chillax

          Michelle – I agree! However, from experience, the mother asking those questions usually doesnt like the answer and chooses not to believe it!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  44. K

    I think that is one of the hardest aspects of being a parent- different parenting values. I have taught my kids kindness, compassion, empathy and to treat others as you would like to be treated. There are many parents out there that have no interest whatsoever in teaching their kids those qualities. Being the most popular, having the best of everything, and being the best are their priorities. The “as long as my kid is Ok, who cares about yours?’ mentality is an attitude I have seen over and over again. I have seen some pretty poor parents (my opinion) including some who I played netball with- their kids bullied my son mercilessly (emotional and physical) just to amuse themselves. When I spoke to the parents about it, one of them said “Get your son baby-sat while we play if our kids don’t like him” (!!!! he’s just an ordinary, average kid- they just bonded as a group by picking on him). So -you are telling me I can’t bring my child to a public park? None of the kids were made to apologise for their horrendous behaviour. People like this still leave me speechless (and can I tell you- the way these kids spoke to their parents- as though they were something that crawled out from under a rock- left me speechless too). Different morals and values are a fact of life and no-one can control the way others behave. All you can do is teach your children the values and morals that are important to you and use bad experiences as life lessons -” yes, it’s not nice and that is why you’d never behave that way” :-)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Sue

      Thank you K. Your comment reflects what’s been going around in my head all afternoon. In the schoolyard I’ve come across some very mean and thoughtless parents, who were probably mean co-workers and mean friends etc before they become parents and will never change and unfortunately will pass these behaviors onto their own children. Parents who hold and teach their children the values kindness, compassion and empathy for others are giving their children the greatest gift of life.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • ansa

      I know exactly what you mean about “my kid’s ok, who cares about yours”. I agree wholeheartedly. Other parents are happy as long as it’s not their child being bullied. I met a mother from school who admitted her boy was having a tough time making friends and being included. He’s a nice boy, just quiet. So I arranged a play date with about 5 boys from school so he could interact and form a bond with the others. We met once a week for about a month, and now he is part of “the gang”. Kids need to feel welcomed and included. You cant expect 6yr olds to know about it, but you should expect it from adults. if you know someone is having a tough time, try to help.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  45. Another reject

    My 5 yr old was the only boy not invited to a prep party. I didn’t even know there was a party until the birthday boy’s mum came up to me and said “I heard your son was crying because he wasn’t invited to the party. I had to chose who to invite and decided to only invite the boys going to the private school next year” Which was every boy but mine! And then she snapped “but if it’s really a big issue I suppose he can come” – yeah no thanks. What a ridiculous reason to exclude a single little person. I was upset for him, but i suppose he has to learn that life’s not fair. He’s a lovely little kid and when he finally was invited to a party he was on cloud nine. For some reason I felt the rejection too. Maybe a throw back to my own childhood rejection!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Caro

      There’s at least one word I can think of to describe that woman but I doubt it would get past the moderator. How horribly callous!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • ac

      what a ridiculous reason not to invite a child…??

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  46. Tracey Groombridge

    Thanks so much for writing this my son was often left out of the clicky catholic mum’s group also being a working mum i realise my child has missed opportunities because I haven’t been around to participate in groups and clichés.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Bec

      I presume that you meant ‘cliques’ instead of ‘cliches’ but it still works so well in that context!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Tracey Groombridge

        I wish I was that clever.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  47. Zara

    I recently went to a six year old birthday party. I was very surprised to hear the parent of the child talking about how she invited everyone but a little boy who she considered a bully. I know this little boy and due to language delays he often will get a little bit rough when trying to communicate. Felt so sorry for the little boy who wasn’t invited and couldn’t believe that adults could be so cruel.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kylie2

      When my son was little he begged me not to have to invite a bully in his class to his party. It’s not always just the parent who decides who to invite. A six year old who’s “a little bit rough” can be scary to other kids.

      In the end we cut the list so that this boy was not the only one excluded but I wasn’t going to force my son to invite a child who might ruin the party for him.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  48. Bionda

    Birthday parties are a minefield of anger and frustration. My daughter was invited to a party at the movies. We bought a gift. I dropped her off. Before going in she was asked to pay for the movie! She had no money (why would she?!) so the girl’s mother paid for her. She was so embarrassed. I thought it was the height of rudeness! The invitation should have said ‘no gifts’ or ‘please pay for yourself’

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  49. Julie Cornwell

    An all too familiar story. I’d be interested to hear from a parent who has actually been the one do this. Why and what was your motive excluding one person? Have you not experienced this kind of exclusion with your own child as yet? I don’t get it!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kylie2

      I’ve come close. When my son was little he begged me not to have to invite a bully in his class to his party. It’s not always just the parent who decides who to invite.

      It was a small school and he wanted to invite all of the other boys but we cut the list so that this boy was not the only one excluded. I would rather have invited them all but I wasn’t going to force my son to invite a child who might ruin the party for him.

      Some parents are oblivious to the fact that their child is mean or violent (I’m not saying this is the case in this story)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • dewberry

      You should read some of the comments from the article Shankari wrote on this subject last year. (A-nonny-nonny has a link to the post in the comments above). The article was before comment moderation was started and there are plenty of mums expressing a harden up, why should we invite people we don’t want attitude.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • chillax

      Yes, I have done so. My daughter simply didnt want the child invited. This child was one of those hot and cold children, who was her best friend one day. Wouldnt talk to her the next. She also regularly did mean things to all the kids in the class. And mum thought she was sweet and perfection which didnt help. When it came time to write the invitations my daughter simply refused and said she was sick of her mean behaviour and didnt want her party ruined by her. And yes mum did ring and ask why and I told her that our children didnt get on. I dont think she liked that answer but I’m glad I told her instead of making up a silly excuse. I’m not doing her any favours by pretending it was a numbers game or we were on a budget. Her child isnt the sweet petal she thinks she is. I know mine isnt either.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • tastebud

      Julie, there is another scenario I’m not sure anyone has mentioned.

      I had my first ever birthday party when I turned 10. I was so excited. We were going to go ice skating and then McDonalds and then of course…..cake!

      Mum was given the invite list and at the last minute I realised I’d forgotten someone. She reluctantly agreed to one.more.person. No more!! I spent most of my childhood terrifed of my mother so I did not doubt her one bit.

      Turns out I was wrong – I had forgotten another very good friend. From the same circle. Someone who 30 years later to this day I still know and someone who had a pool party every year to which I was ALWAYS invited :(

      I was too scared to ask my mother for one more! My friend has never really told me about the impact it had on her. We do have a little chuckle as she knows how scary mum is. But I still feel awful about it to this day.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  50. mummamoo

    Have just finished writing the invitations for my son’s 6th Birthday party. He is born on Christmas Eve, so he NEVER gets a friends-based party on his actual birthday. This year, I actually asked him what HE wanted. His response “I want all the kids from my class, and can we go to the park and have cake and then can we have lolly bags when its time to go home??”
    So that is what he is getting! 22 kids, Angry Birds theme, Musical Bobs if I remember the iPod dock, cake and lolly bags. Sorted!
    And he probably won’t get another one for at least 3 years!
    So my logic – ask your kids what THEY want, and see how happy it makes them!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions