Do You Like This Story?

Alison and her daughter 380x514 I dont feel guilty that Im working

 

 

 

 

A recently published study, highlighted in the Sydney Morning Herald last week, has found that one third of working mothers are employed by organisations that could not be classed as “family friendly”, leaving them subject to psychological distress. How dreadful. How dreadful that all the article’s readers could do was to blame the woman.

Instead of focussing on how we can help women balance the challenges inherent in working for a living, and living for our children, the comments on the article (all hiding behind the parapet of pseudonyms, of course), targeted women who return to work after having children with vitriol and hatred.

In this day and age, why is it that we are still trying to control women and the choices that they make, through public, degrading and simplistic commentary? As if there is not enough pressure on women already (you must breastfeed, you must lose your baby weight, you must only give your child organic food, don’t smack or yell, don’t let your child watch TV), here is another thing that we are supposed to feel guilty about.

Well guess what, I don’t feel guilty. Like any mother, I adore my daughter beyond measure – she is a smart, funny delight. I would do anything to make her life happy and safe. Now, prepare to be shocked. I also like to work. Cue devil’s horns and wicked laughter. I thrive on the social and intellectual stimulation that work provides. I am a happier and more interesting person because I work.

I also believe that being a working mother makes me a good role model. It teaches my daughter the importance of being financially independent as a woman, of making a contribution to society, of being a responsible citizen. It teaches her that she too can do anything she wants.

Do I think she suffers because she’s not at home with me, 24-7? Absolutely not. When I drop her at day care, she squeals with excitement. Every day I marvel at what she learns from her educators and her peers. I too was a day care baby, and I am a confident, independent and happy woman. I’m great at my job, and I’m a great mother, wife and friend. I don’t harbour any closet psychological problems. Really – when you think of your friends and colleagues, can you work out which of them were cared for at home and which were in day care? Of course not.

For many women, including myself, returning to work is also not a choice. The majority of us are contributing 30% of household income or more to mortgage repayments. Rent takes a similar toll. Simply to keep a roof over her child’s head, many a woman has to be in paid employment. For others, it enables them to make financial decisions that allow the family to build up its asset base, positioning children well for the future, or to allow small luxuries that widen a child’s learning experiences.

From a socio-economic perspective, having women return to work after having children is vital for the economy. At a macro level it increases discretionary spend which sustains growth, and at an organisational level, it creates a diverse and balanced workforce, which has been shown to improve profit results.

The nasty, nasty comments directed at women, and mothers in particular, have to stop. Now. No wonder postnatal depression is on the rise, and working mothers report psychological distress. When we blame the victim, when we stop caring for each other and start attacking, we create social and emotional isolation that is far more damaging than putting a child in care.

Alison Wines is a communications specialist and writer. Find her on twitter here.

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)
*

322 Comments so far

  1. Mommalyze

    I am on the computer tonight looking up topics around Mommy guilt. I have 3 children ages 8,6 and 3. In 8 years I have been off 3 years on mat leave. I have also worked only part time 20-30 hours for the past almost 3 years. I have just now taken a job full-time and I am so afraid that I will feel even more mommy guilt than usual. I want to do what is best for my kids – but that would mean only working 9am-3pm daily. I would love to take them to school and pick them up daily. What a dream that would be. Anyway, I hope I am not making a bad decision. I think the challenge for me whether I am working or not is making the time QUALITY time. I am not the best at that. Maybe this is where the guilt really comes from.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. keziah3103

    And we’ll be talking about whether or not fathers should return to work when?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Julie

    Isnt it sad that as mums we get judged no matter what we do. This is why I didn’t join a mothers group (friends had similar experiences to you). Sadly it doesn’t get any better, you’ll find the same types have their little ‘clicks’ at school too. Not that some working mums are any better mind you, some of the rubbish I hear at work makes me sick.

    The best advice I can give you is (where possible) surround yourself with positive people with children of all ages, the guidance you get from parents of kids your own age is invaluable and parents of older children usually have hilarious stories to tell :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Jane

    Oh how I wish I could have responded with comments that are in this article when at my mothers group. I was the only one who had decided to return to work and the comment I received was “No, I choose to enjoy watching my child grown up”. I think other mums can be very harsh and judgemental, probably to try to justify their own decisions. I would never judge them like that. The decision should be respected and is individual for each situation.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Sarah

    Sigh. I am due to go back to work after no.2 on Monday…I am looking forward to it and have missed the intellectual stimulation work provides me. It could just be my current residence but I received more criticism on returning to work this time than when I did for my first. Who am I copping the criticism from? It is surprisingly stay at home mothers and new mothers.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. Danielle

    I’m returning to the workforce in 6 weeks, having had my first baby in December. I love my job & the company I work for. We need for me to work so we can pay our mortgage but it will enable us to take our son on holidays, both overseas & interstate, we will be able to give him a good education & help set him up financially, possibly even buy an investment property that will be his. Yet I still feel guilty that I’ll be sending him to child care! It frustrates me that our society cannot support working women when the decisions we make are purely for the benefit of societies’ next generation.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Leanne

    Great article.. I was just forced to quit my job at one of the big 4 chartered accounting firms due to the bullying and discrimination I was subjected to for being a part time working mum. I’d been there for 8 years.. Very sad that this still occurs.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Kimerley

    We damage ourselves by choosing to be affected by others comments. Be confident in the choices you make for yourself and family. Each to their own. RIP this debate.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. MKAY

    I went back to work full time when my son started school, it was a juggling act but as a sole parent I knew at the time it was the right decision for us, as working enabled me to provide for my son finacially. I was not getting any child support from my ex husband and a life on a sole parent payments was not someting that I was willing to accept. Like many others, I spent many years of my working life building a career in the corporate world. I worked very hard over the past 12 years and was fortunate enough to achieved great success in my field. But, it did not come without a price. I worked long hours, with tight deadlines, office politics, and a lot of stress – all of which impacted my family life. Whilst I beleive that some employers are trying to improve the workplace for working mums, I still feel that there is a great deal of inequality between genders in the workplace. As a working mum to be taken seriously in the corporate world, I had to make so many sacrifices most of which impacted on my family life. I thought about working from home for a long time. I reached the point where I knew that I had to make a change in my life but didn’t know where to start. Then one day, I finally found the courage to do something about it. I now run a successful home business and am living the life of my dreams! I have the best of both worlds. I still get all the stimulation and satisfaction of dealing with professionals everyday, but I do it on my terms, at my pace and around the needs of my family. I admire women who have the abilty to juggle both a professional and family life. I will always beleive the the role of MUM is the most challenging, important and rewarding role any women can undertake. I also love that women are starting to find a stronger voice and are taking control of their lives on their terms and are no longer accepting being a slave to the office! There are so many work from home opportunities out there these days, it’s great! And I love what I do, I wish I had done it earlier!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Rebecca

    This is a great topic!! Why should working women have to stress more and feel guilty when they are stuck at work and are unable to leave in time to collect their child from care? Mothers are already under enough pressure at home, why do they have to feel these unnecessary pressures from the workplace only because they now have a family to care for. On the flip side why should you feel guilty for making the decision that you want to stay at home with your child so you you can and enjoy the most memorable moments, making a difference to being apart of your child’s growth and development.

    I often here these concerns over and over again, why can’t we live in a world where there is enough balance and leniency so that there is enough time where we can be intellectually stimulated and still enjoy the wonderful stages and development of our own child.

    There is one option around these spiraling questions, a Nanny. An Experienced and Professional Nanny who has the ability to provide you with relief so that you are able to enjoy a social, intellectual and stimulating experience. A Nanny who is also able to provide with you a peace of mind, as you know that your child is receiving 1:1 care with an experienced certified professional, in the comfort of their own environment and not placed in a busy room with a bundle of other children. A Nanny that is able to provide you with a detailed summary of your child’s day with the use of visual technologies, demonstrating the educational benefits they were able to incorporate into your child’s day so that you feel just as much a part of it as they did.

    Providing your child to this option, even if its only 1 to 2 days a week will expand and facilitate their learning and growth to a whole new level. The best thing about it is that YOU make the ‘rules’ and make the final decisions – http://www.preciouspeeps.com.au

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. Pingback: MUMMY WARS | HerCanberra

  12. SAHM

    “I also believe that being a working mother makes me a good role model. It teaches my daughter the importance of being financially independent as a woman, of making a contribution to society, of being a responsible citizen. It teaches her that she too can do anything she wants.”

    So are you saying being a SAHM means my daughter doesn’t have a good role model?

    How come in this day and age of so called CHOICE we never see any articles on how great SAHM’s and thier children’s lives are? I’m totally for choice for women to raise their kids however they want, but I find it’s sad that being a SAHM is somehow a dirty word these days even amongst smart modern women like those who frequent this site. Being a feminist doesn’t mean you somehow need to lose your maternal focus. I feel somehow being a SAHM society has decided I don’t contribute, as Alison is quoted as saying above. Isn’t the most important job I can have in life be bringing up well adjusted people who are respectful, kind and compassionate with the values and behaviours I want them to have not some day care worker?
    This discussion of child care always seems to revolve around how it benefits the women. I just want women to be honest and admit that for the child being with their parent is the best thing for them. Going back to work is best for the women and the family finances not the kids. It doesn’t make you a bad person just accept the reality and stop making out day care the best thing ever and as a result putting down SAHM’s choices.

    The truth of the matter is the moment banks started taking two incomes for mortgages women lost more choice than they could ever imagine. House prices skyrocketted and staying at home was no longer a choice anymore. In the 70′s the bank took the higher income, man or woman, so that if something happened to the main earner there was security of a potential second income to help out and mortgage stress was no where near what it is today even with 18% interest rates.

    Mamma Mia please represent all women in you articles no just those who swing left.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Jules

      What a load of rubbish.

      Just because one person’s choices mean they’re a good role model for her child doesn’t automatically mean different choices aren’t! It’s not all black and white, good and evil… your comment says a lot more about you and your insecurities than anything else.

      As for the mortgages… I have a mortgage that I pay off on my own. I chose not to go halves with my partner for that very reason. People can choose to have a smaller mortgage you know, we’re not sheep.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  13. Anonymous

    i was a department manager for woolies and never had a problem till i had a baby. after my child was born was a different story. if your a full time staff member they bend over backwards to accommodate the family, but if your on salary the way your treated is completely different. there’s very little flexibility at one stage i was paying $120+ a week in late pick up fees at kindy because my boss wouldn’t let me start or finish 15mins earlier so i would get to kindy before it closed. so after 12yrs working for the company and 10 of them as a manager i left the company for life as a SAHM

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. G

    I chose to work part time since my youngest child was about 2. They are in school now and I still work part time. I often feel a little guilty (they do 2 afternoons in after school care) but I like the choices that we have made in life and my working is part of that. I also enjoy the (non child or husband) social part of working.
    I have lots of friends who work part time, full time or are SAHMs we often talk about the pros and cons of our individual choices. I have never felt judged by any of my friends. The only time I feel judged are these types of article online (looking at you Josie). It makes me wonder if I am being judged by SAHMs behind my back.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • jetmum

      From one SAHM to a Working Mum the answer is a resounding No! Definitely no judgements beng made behind your back here :-)

      I’m happy in my choice to be a SAHM, my best friend is happy in her choice to be a work from home mum, & my other best friend is happy in her choice to work a 6-7 day a week schedule running her own business. Between us we have 6 children, all in differing childcare arrangements, and all happy, well adjusted, healthy, beloved children.

      And my friends & I are all equally happy, stressed, exhausted, fulfilled, driven-crazy-by-toddlers, tired, overjoyed, confused & above all swept away by immeasurable love for these tiny humans we have created. After all isn’t that what it’s all about?

      Like you G, the only time I feel judged is when I read these articles pitting SAHM’s against working mums.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • G

        Exactly jetmum, my friends are the same, all feel different at different times, because we all parent in our own ways. It never occurs to me that someone may judge my choices in a negative manner unless I look at these forums. My problem is that when I read about SAHMs judging my choices I start to feel antagonistic towards their choices. When I really don’t feel that way, I’m very happy with my life and don’t care what people think about me. As a result I usually avoid these topics as they make me feel crummy and second guess myself.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  15. Mel

    I grew up in Sweden, where the societal norm is to place your baby in full-time day care at about 10 months old. As an only child it gave me the social skills I needed and had no obvious negative repercussions; I loved it!

    As someone who is soon graduating as a doctor, with an interest in some of the more intense specialties, I know that my field definitely WON’T be family friendly and when I eventually have kids it will be a real balancing act. What I choose to do when the situation arises (most likely keep working long hours) will be my decision, not everyone elses.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. Susie

    It’s disappointing that the individual decisions that families make based upon their own individual circumstances are up for discussion by others. Decisions to work or not work should be up to these individual families and others should show consideration and respect to these choices.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. JulC

    There is nothing like the ‘stay at home mother ‘ vrs ‘working mother’ debate to bring out the guns blazing!! No wonder we will never have peace in the world when even mothers cannot get along and accept each other’s choices or circumstances. I think the only other time I have seen an issue flar up this much was the brazilian debate lol. I wish all woman and their chidlren well – the working and the stay at home…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anon

      I wonder if it would still be an issue if the media didn’t run these articles. I know over the years Mama Mia has got a big reaction to stories like these.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  18. Ali

    I should send this link to the horrible mothers at school last week who felt the urge to make comments of my decision to work.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. Anon

    We should stop having to justify our decisions. Work/ Stay at Home….your decision.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. Vic

    I became a fulltime SAHM when my kids were 4,2,and a newborn. It was hard stressful work caring for them (and I worked at a crisis centre before so was no stranger to stressful situations!). They are now 8,6, and nearly 4. I feel I can devout some more time to my career now and am easing my self back into the workforce. Maybe I did sacrifice my career for my kids but don’t regret doing it. Us women are masters of reinventing ourselves aren’t we?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. Siobhan

    It’s impossible and completely ridiculous to compare your circumstances to anyone else’s. It’s never as simple as a working mother being better than a stay-at-home mother or a stay-at-home mother being better than a working mother. So many factors come into play that influence a woman and family’s choices regarding child rearing and work, and sometimes choice doesn’t even come into it.

    I have been at home with my children since my first son was born three years ago, but I also run my own business from home, and have taken on study commitments over the past couple of years, so I am somewhere between both worlds! I always thought working from home was the ideal situation, but I actually find it almost impossible to get any work done while my children are at home and awake, so most of my work gets done in the late evening, after they’re in bed, dinner’s been cooked etc.. Sometimes I envy my partner for getting to leave the house on his own every day, have adult conversations, lunch breaks and private bathroom visits! But there’s a lot of pressure on him as the main breadwinner too, so I guess it’s all swings and roundabouts.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  22. Anonymous

    Not advocating stay at home or guilt free return to work , but I have notice a lot of the comments from mothers who have previously worked in child care have chosen to stay at home while there children are young , based on their experience of working in early childhood .

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Sharon @ Funken Wagnel

      I’m one of those:)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Another Childcare Worker

        I am another one.
        Based on my experiences across many many wonderful centers, I refuse to put my children in care under the age of 3. They just do not have the staff on hand all day to give every baby the one-to-one attention they need.
        That’s not to say all children in care are neglected, I just know that they cannot take care of my baby the way I want her cared for.
        It comes down to personal choice, the children’s needs, the family’s needs. Just do your homework and get to know the staff well. Spend time there and be aware of your child’s development.
        Kudos to all the mothers that have chosen to raise their own children. You are great rolemodels as nurturers and your child’s first educator.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  23. marie6c

    I find that women who ‘choose’ their decision to return to work or women who ‘choose’ their decision to stay at home are the happiest and feel least guilty.

    From experience the women who only return to work because financial pressures or stay at home mums who want to work but don’t find it because lack of skills or experience tend to be ones who are the least happy and to compensate for their lack of choice by passing judgement on other mothers who they feel are luckier than them.

    I chose to stay at home and I feel blessed to be able to.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. Amoir

    I still can’t believe that working mothers are criticised so much in this day and age. I worked after all my babies, breastfed them all long term, did the attachment parenting things etc and I still copped criticism from some saying I was obviously just being greedy going back to work. Fact was, I had to. Sometimes I hated it, but mostly as the kids got older, I really enjoyed it. Eating lunch uninterupted, drinking a HOT cup of tea, talking to adults about something other than play school and nappies. I am not in any way against stay at home mums and in awe of them as well – lord knows I could not do it for an extended period. We need to be more accepting of each others choices. Thank goodness we can work if we want to, it puts us in a much stronger position in life than if we are totally reliant on a partner for everything. That scares me.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. Anons

    I think the problem is when you love your work more than your kids.

    I have friends that work and have children. I’m sure they don’t love their children any more or less than I love mine. As a stay-at-home-mum I get to go to the sports carnivals and volunteer at school. I do think by spending time at my childrens’ school the teachers and headmaster are looking out for my kids a little more (that’s just me speculating).

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Feline

      OMG. I have no words.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anon

      I know the headmaster is looking out for my kids. You scratch my back, I’ll scratch yours type of thing.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Sophie

      I think it’s the same if you stay late at work. The boss takes notice. The same can be said for the person who always leaves early….unfortunately.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Josie

      I do think by spending time at my childrens’ school the teachers and headmaster are looking out for my kids a little more (that’s just me speculating).

      I believe that too. I am a SAHM and I was spent a lot of time helping at the school while my children were in Primary School. A flow on effect of that was in the eyes on the teachers and staff my children became “Josie’s children” and they got that little bit of extra attention. Also my children knew that if they ever stepped out of line at school that their mum would hear about it for sure.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kelly

        I can’t believe you would state this so openly.

        Also, this is a disgrace if principals and teachers are favouring your child over children who deserve just as much attention as the next regardless of what extra activities the mother/father does for the school.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  26. Jacqui

    Since when is stating an opinion being judgemental? If we all tried not to be judgemental, then we’d all be saying lots of nothing. Loud and proud ladies! What is the point of these forums? Women didn’t get a say in things for a very long time, now we should relish the opportunity for passionate argument with none of this yaaawn pussyfooting that’s going on here. Germaine Greer didn’t achieve what she did by telling people what they want to hear. We are talking about our kids here! Say what you really think and defend your position with gusto and pride. This topic always attracts so much hypocrisy and false sincerity from women who pretend they don’t judge each other.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • ClaireC

      Hear, hear!! The term ‘judgemental’ is often used on here as a criticism if someone makes what is deemed to be a negative comment about a post or comment. But if someone agrees with a post (even though that is actually still a judgement) then that seems to be ok. Unfortunately there is a theme getting the claws out for anyone who dares to not wholeheartedly support and praise other people’s actions, somehow it is seen as a betrayal of the so called ‘sisterhood’ unfortunately.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  27. JL

    I was actually a nanny to a beautiful family and a makeup artist before i had my little man, and when i had him, i was fortunate enough that the timing worked out with the family as their kids were all at school and only needed me for a few hours in the morning and after noon and i was able to have my little man with me. Doing makeup i only took jobs on Saturdays as my husband was home and it worked out very well. By the time my son was 3 i gave up the part time nannying as they really only needed a house helper not a nanny as their mum could get them after school, and it worked out that i could start my own shop! The first year was the hardest as i was in the shop full time almost with a day working from home and my little man at kindy 3 days. But since then we have found a great balance, as my husband gave up his business to come on board and i can now work from home and my son is only in kindy 2 days a week. We have been lucky that things have worked out really well for us, and although we dont have as much money with both of us working the business right now, it means we can be way more flexible with our son and the new baby on the way! I have never felt judged for working! I am not really sure why others judge woman for working or not working…i just feel like woman are doing whats best for their families so i have never thought to question that! I wish everyone could just be happy we live in a world where woman can work and we have options available. I think its lovely if you can spend the first year at home with your little ones, but for some its just not financially viable, and why should they be judged for it! Some woman just love to work, i think thats great as well and shows their kids that they should work hard in life! Lets just be a bit more supportive of new mothers…its hard to get balance and when we find it we should not be judged just because it doesnt compute the same in your head…what works for me may not work for others, but as long as there is love in the home and everyone is well taken care of i think do whats right for your family!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. Jacqui

    Alison your article was all about what you want. What about your daughter, if she could speak for herself? Where are you when she cries or misses you? My 4 and 5 year old girls actually say that they are lucky their Mum has nowhere more important to be than with them. We drive past a creche often and they look in with sympathy, at the kids who are doing the same things with the same people, while mine have been out and about living new experiences every day in the care of someone who loves them. I will go back to work, can’t wait actually, when my children start school. If I couldn’t sacrifice 5 or 6 years of my life for the betterment of my children, what sort of mother would I be? Yes if men pressured their employers more, they would be able to take time off for half the baby years so women wouldn’t have to have such long breaks from work. Children would then always be in the care of someone who loves them, which we all know is best. I would question the motives for having children, if there was not this emotional and financial commitment to being there for them when they are babies. People these days cry poor on one wage yet live in McMansions with all the gadgets. Women claim to be better mothers for having ‘time-out’ without considering that their child is a ‘miss-out’. And just for the record, you can pick the child-care kids from the children of stay-at-home Mums…the latter are the calmer more secure ones who haven’t had to fight for survival while they are still babies. What other animal species abandon their young as babies, to fend for themselves? Creches’ are nothing more than kennels for children. (I apologise to all the women who read this who genuinely have no financial choice.)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Lana

      Jacqui – let’s try to leave the judgement before we comment. Of course we welcome your thoughts but remember that there is no “right” or “wrong” way

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jacqui

        Sorry Lana, my opinion is that babies are best in the care of someone who loves them. If people feel judged by that comment, then that is for their own contemplation. Surely we all know that is the best scenario for them?? I’m a little tired of women going on about what they need and what they want. The baby years are not forever, when did the children get lost in all this? I feel sad for children in child care, especially long-day care.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Josie

          I feel sad for children in child care, especially long-day care.

          I know a woman who after having a baby with IVF went back to work when the baby was 6 weeks old and put her baby into long daycare, five days a week.. Who does that :( goes to all that trouble to actually have a baby and then puts the baby into daycare at 6 weeks of age.

          It broke my heart for the baby

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • lynnd

          Since you seem quite absolute in your opinion, let’s explore them a bit further since Lana is right in saying there is no right or wrong on this debate. Judgement and opinions are not inherently bad things in themselves and we are all entitled to them. This one warrants criticism as it is harmfully perpetuating the myth that one choice is better than the other for all mothers. In addition to that, mothers struggle with enough insidious guilt on their own expectations; they certainly do not need further pressure from others. Whether you intend to or not, judgements such as yours, do add to the enormous cognitive dissonance between what mothers know to be right for themselves and what they’re told is right for their children.

          “babies are best in the care of someone who loves them… surely, we all know that is the best scenario for them”

          Based on what evidence? I can say that evidence supporting day care has benefits such as socialisation and fostering independence. There are also studies demonstrating that a mother’s employment status is largely inconsequential to a child’s well-being in their first year of life and beyond.

          “.. you can pick the child-care kids from the children of stay-at-home Mums…the latter are the calmer more secure ones who haven’t had to fight for survival while they are still babies”

          This is not only ludicrous but an anecdoctal sweeping generalisation. But entirely consistent with your biases, I suppose.

          Of course, the most important consideration is that happier mother equates to happier children & family. And the needs of a mother is just as important as the needs of a child. A family makes decisions based on the best interests of ALL family members. We forget these as mothers and I genuinely feel that that’s why there is a prevalence of guilt. I wish mothers talked MORE about what they want and need without guilt.

          I feel sad for unhappy, depressed, guilt-ridden mums who suffer from stresses on the choices they have made whether it is with regards to SAHM vs working, bottle vs. breast etc. Not to mention these can sometimes be false dichotomies, most women can do a mix of everything at various stages.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • ClaireC

            Sorry but I have to vehemently disagree ith you statement that the needs of the mother are just as important as the needs of the child. I know of mothers who put their children if full time child are just so they can still go out to lunch and keep up their full time schedule of ‘me’ activities such as beauty therapist appointments and the gym. I judge those women as bad mothers and I make no apologies for that.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • lynnd

              To clarify : do you think those are “bad” mothers because they seemingly put their own needs above their child’s? Or that they are attending to their needs at all?

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
    • ClaireC

      I totally agree with you Jacqui although I expect your comment will prompt a barrage of ‘you are so judgmental’ comments. I don’t see you comments as judgmental, they are your opinion to which you are surely entitled.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Feline

      You state about your daughters – ‘We drive past a creche often and they look in with sympathy’. Well, you know what? The only reason they do this is because they have been listening to your self-righteous, holier than thou waffle. And your girls saying they are lucky that their Mum has nowhere more important to be than with them? Also spoon-fed from you. Not sure where you get your bad attitide from, but it seems unlikely that you had any kind of fulfilling career, and now that you’re a Mum you’re feeling a bit important and workin’ it for all its worth. As for telling Alison it was all about her? She outlined several reasons / factors she felt were advantageous for her daughter. Your daughters may have their Mother at home with them all the time, but you do not seem like an inspiring Mother role-model to me. I hope your daughters remain blissfully ignorant of your sense of superiority and judgement of others. They are also going to struggle to keep friends at school once the other Mothers find out what a judgy-pants you are. And I hope you cope when your daughters grow up and find they have somewhere better to be than with you…AND your description of childcare as ‘kennels for children’ is disgusting and shows your complete ignorance of childcare standards and the learning framework. My children spend two days a week in long daycare when I work. They have been cared for by the same staff for years. They do endless amounts of art and craft, they have pet chooks, a vegetable garden, they help cook their lunch, they build things etc etc. When we went on holidays and they realised they wouldn’t be going to daycare and seeing their friends they were most put out! People like you make me shudder. And for the record, I am not criticising stay at home Mums – I think it’s lovely to stay home and look after your children. I’m criticising people who judge others’ lives and choices based upon little more than a tiny snapshot view of those lives.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Josie

        The only reason they do this is because they have been listening to your self-righteous, holier than thou waffle.

        Sorry, but no it’s not.

        The kids are sorry for the little children behind the fence at the creche because unlike those fenced in children cared for by an ever changing staff of random people, they are lucky because they are going out and about with their mummy.

        They are also going to struggle to keep friends at school once the other Mothers find out what a judgy-pants you are.

        I doubt that very much, because for a start they can have play dates after school and have children over to their house to play because they aren’t going straight from school to an after school care centre. Having kids to play after school is what makes friendships.

        When my kids were at primary school the mothers who kids went straight from school to after school care loved it when I offered to take their child home with mine after school to give their child a break from the care centre and have a nice play time with my kid.

        They do endless amounts of art and craft, they have pet chooks, a vegetable garden, they help cook their lunch, they build things etc etc.

        Just think how much better it would have been for your children if they could have done those things one on one with you.

        When we went on holidays and they realised they wouldn’t be going to daycare and seeing their friends they were most put out!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • mummak

          Wow, what a passionate discussion this topic makes.

          I’d like to just add that, as a SAHM (my choice) I can be confident I am doing what is right for MY family. One cannot say or judge what is right for SOMEONE ELSES family.

          I also put my child in day care for one full day a week as he is an only and I want him to have an understandingly of independence and social skills. It was hard the first time putting him in but when he comes home he is so happy and tired and grateful to see me and tell me what he has been doing that day.

          All my friends are working Mums and to be honest, the ‘debate’ has never come up with us. Why? because we care about each other and support each other rather than tearing each other to shreds.

          And you know what, I’m looking forward to being the Mum picking up my son and all his mates for sports practice while their parents work. Many of my friends think its great that there is one of us in the group happy to this while they can’t. Again, its about supporting each other.

          Stop the debate. SAHM or WM, who cares so long as your kids is loved and taken care of.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  29. my 2 cents

    Why do women make it so hard on themselves & for other women?
    Wasn’t the point of feminism to give women a choice? A choice to do what is best for them. Why do we have to make everything into a competition?

    Look at a group of 20/30 year old. Can you tell who was breast feed & who wasn’t? Did that ones mum stay at home or not? Did they do creche or kinder?

    I have 3 kids under 5 & after a bit of trial & error we have found what works best for our family. It might not be what you’d choose & that’s fine. There is no parenting law that says we all have to do it the same way. The benefit of having so many different styles of parenting is that we end up with a mix of great kids who aren’t carbon copy’s of each other.

    Regardless of if you stay at home, work part or full time, study or work from home we are all trying to do the same thing & that is what is best for our families. In the end that’s all that really matters.

    I support your right to choose & all I ask is that my choice be respected too.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. Glad I'm working

    I’ve got 2 children – now 7 and 4 – had about 12 months maternity leave for each and enjoy the intellectual and social side of work.

    But the most important aspect of working has always been about financial security for me and my children. And I have to say that my decision has been vindicated – given my recent marriage breakdown.

    One of the factors helping me deal with this has been knowing I can support us all and we have a solid future … One less thing to worry about. At the end of the day – you really can only rely on yourself despite romantic hopes to the contrary.

    Choice and guilt don’t come in to it – it’s about survival.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  31. Mooner

    I have mainly been an SAHM since my first child was born 4 years ago, but did work 2 days per week for 1 year. I have had to justify the years I have spent at home a LOT more than I had to justify the year I worked part-time I can tell you! I don’t get the ‘working Mum judgment’ thing – it never, ever happened to me. Everyone seemed relieved I had a job that they could ask me about. I got a lot more flak when I resigned from that job to return to being an SAHM.

    I am actually now doing a little bit of work again but I am lucky enough to be able to do it from home. Most people are surprised to hear I work at all or forget that I work because I really do have a good work/life balance at the moment so it’s not even a topic I need to discuss. I know I am incredibly blessed. The sacrifice I guess is time with my husband who works long hours to support our family financially. The money I earn is only an added bonus but goes no way to covering the mortgage. I do feel guilty sometimes about this but as he always says “we are a team”. He contributes in this financial way (although is a fantastic father as well) and I contribute in the primary child care-giver and home-economist way.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  32. Mel b

    Whoa! Make a point fair enough you like to go to work, great for you!!

    but my point to make is how many hous are ‘working mothes’ doing? because if your gone for 40-50 hours plus than you have lost me, I don’t get it! i just love being with them and I DON’T feel guilty about that either!!! 15 hours a week in paid emplyment is plenty for me. Choice! Daycare eats half your wage up anyway, unless your on the big bucks!!! My son goes off to daycare ‘kinder’ there goes half my wage. It’s cheaper to send my older son to a private school ( but that’s a whole different topic)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Dee of Adelaide

      The less hours can be hard to find.

      I’m lucky in that for the first 3 years of RR’s life I worked 60+ hours a week – but for myself at home and she went to childcare 2 days a week. The pay off was I worked til 1am most nights after she’d gone to bed. The GFC made me fearful of security so I tooka public service job. Including drop off/pick up/commute I was gone close to 10 hours a day, but Big Fella was dropping off at 9 and picking up at 4 because he had more flexibility. She spent 3 days in cc and 2 with my sister.

      I’m now going to 4 days with one at home when I return to work when little lad is 8 months old. Is it what I’d ideally like? No, 3 would be perfect but its not an option for my work or financially for us. Its not like 2 and 3 day a week professional jobs are just lying around everywhere waiting for someone to show an interest in them.

      I’m lucky to be in Adelaide and paying only $80 a day for cc (with everything included). After the rebate full time child care makes up 12.5% of my take home salary. I can totally understand it when women clear next to nothing after cc costs.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jessjess

        Such a good point that is lost in this debate…where are the professional 2 or 3 day jobs….they are not advertised much that’s for sure. If you don’t go back to your job and resign after maternity leave like I did….well good luck when job hunting in the professional sphere if you do wish to return to work.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Kitten

          I think this is a very real problem; that is, finding part time work. From the workplace’s perspective however, there is also the issue of contributing meaningful part-time work.

          I work in a relatively family friendly organisation with a huge number of women who are mothers and work part-time. As a non-mother it is really interesting to observe the different attitudes and approaches of the women toward their work (which of course is influenced by more than just their mum status). There are the women who try to squash full-time work into part-time hours, the ones who turn up 1-2 days per week and see it as a social event while the rest of us pick up their slack, and the ones who have worked with their managers to find a way to make a great and meaningful contribution in their part-time capacity. It would be a challenge.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  33. Very happy working

    Being a mother isn’t a job, it’s a relationship.

    A job involves selling your labour for capital. Not a bad transaction, if you also enjoy your labour.

    Raising children isn’t a project. In fact all we need to do is feed, clothe and love them. Look after them when they’re sick. Keep them safe. They’ll raise themselves.

    Hopefully our daughters will learn the value of independence. And they’ll grow up and have fabulous careers.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Vic

      Your response confuses me? I don’t think you can have such a black and white definition of what a job and career is, especially in this day and age. Sounds like you base all your self worth on how good your career is. You don’t have to go to work to model the value of independence to your children- any child pschologist will tell you that!

      I disagree that children can raise themselves and it kind of sounds like you are devalueing women who choose to stay at home. I think parenting is far more complex then meeting their basic needs.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  34. hibiscus

    Felt guilty when I worked + felt guilty when I didn’t = can’t win!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. marie6c

    I thought that I would have a balance when I decided to return to work 3 days a week after my first son turned one. In a teaching workplace that supposedly advocates work practices that support family life my experiences were the direct opposite. Other mothers, who worked full-time would call the days I didn’t go to work as my days “off” and generally make comments obviously meant to make me feel bad. Management would think it was OK to penalize me by not treating me with same favor as other workers. I often felt isolated. I decided to be a full-time, stay at home mum after the birth of my second son and I am happy for it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • EB

      I did the same thing of returning back to work 3 times a week when my son was 18 months old. I went back for intellectual and social stimulation just like a lot of other mums here. I experienced the same thing – full time colleagues who think I get “days off” on days I don’t work. And as I’m the one doing the pick up and drop off at child care too, I have to rush off on the dot at 5pm to go pick up my son on time. Because of this, some colleagues think I’m not as committed and have a more crusiy role than them! I used to work in a professional services firm and the culture is you need to do long hours to be seen as committed and an achiever. What they don’t realise is, I ended up working at home in the evenings or on days that aren’t my working days. Eventually, I realise that I was really unhappy by being back at work. My boss was very hard to work with at times and I always ended up feeling so miserable after I come home from work. One night before bed, my husband pointed out to me that I seemed very upset by work. And that was a wake up call for me. I then realised I was so affected by work and stressed at times that it kept me awake at night. I made the choice of going back to work thinking that it will make me happier but at the end it was so different to what I’ve imagined! I decided to quit! It was a bit sad at first as I’ve been with the firm for 7 years. But since I left, I have to say I don’t miss work at all and quitting is the best decision I’ve made for me, my husband and my son. I am now a stay-at-home mum again. Very happy with this role most of the time but I must admit there are times I yearned for more intellectual and social stimulation. I’m working on that though, hoping to find them somewhere else other than at work! Will I go back to a professional job one day? Absolutely! But just not at this stage. Finally, I just want to point out that a stay-at-home mum is a “working mum” too! Don’t underestimate what a stay-at-home mum has to do all day. It is a tougher job than you think! I think society should give more recognition and credits to stay-at-home mums as we too are the “working mums”! Love to all mums (stay-at-home or not) out there!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  36. nicolemadiganeverest

    I absolutely despise mother judgement, lecturing, comparisons etc.
    I do note though – it seems to be rather PC – almost a feminist cry – for working mums to openly talk about the benefits their children gain by them working, but if a SAHM talks about the benefits of her choice, she seems to be accused of making others feel guilty.
    NB: I work from home so don’t sit in either camp :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Dee of Adelaide

      That is a pretty fair point Nicole.

      I don’t lord the benefits of child care. I think its a good care option, as are all other options. There are pros and cons to all options and all aren’t great for all kids. Red Rocket has loved being in child care, she is super super social and always has been. No idea if it will be a great option for Little Lad.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Lily

      A very good observation, actually. And I am a working Mum. Just turning the tables now in my mind and imagining if a SAHM had written it, talking up her choices? BLOODBATH.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  37. Emma Grey

    Great article, Alison – thank you. It’s inevitable that there are lots of passionate responses.

    Here’s something I wrote about the ‘mummy wars’ last year, after watching some similarly passionate comments unfold after a news report:

    A report released this year on the impact on children of having a working mum, tipped fresh fuel over the smouldering ‘Mummy Wars’ debate.

    Working mums have ‘higher maternal sensitivity’ than their stay-at-home counterparts, according to the University of Columbia’s report: First-Year Maternal Employment and Child Development in the First Seven Years. They ‘seek higher-quality childcare and can return to work within a year of giving birth without harming their babies’ development’.

    ‘Queue all the screaming and bitter stay-at-home mums!’ one online poster commented in response to the story. ‘You breed them, you feed them!’ retorted another. Another described a ‘generation of disconnected kids with mental problems’ (presumably the children of mums who work), amidst a barrage of ‘it takes a village to raise a child’ proponents.

    Breakfast television, drive-time radio and online media were inundated with impassioned talk-back from parents who have chosen one path but feel compelled to stomp and trample on the other – not unlike the behaviour of tantruming two-year-olds (something you see, incidentally, in both private homes and childcare centres across the country).

    I can’t help wondering who was looking after the children while the grown-ups slogged it out on the front line, ripping apart each other’s choices and grasping at snippets of scholarly data and anecdotal evidence that might be used for the dual purpose of piling more guilt on the other side, while building a protective fortress around their own decisions. As with the Breast versus Bottle debate that plagues new mums, it was all about Doing The Right Thing, as if a black-and-white solution exists.

    I’ve been a parent for nearly twelve years and, as far as work goes, I’ve tried it all. I’ve stayed at home full time. I’ve worked full time. I’ve worked part time. I’ve job-shared. I’ve worked from home.

    If my kids are ‘happy and well-adjusted’ (the Holy Grail over which Mummy-War armies fight unnecessarily, not realising that there’s plenty of this to go around), it will have little to do with my work and parenting patterns and everything to do with a much bigger picture. Parenting is not about clocking on. It’s about switching on. And then holding on for dear life.

    We all have days when we’re ‘in the zone’ as parents, just as we have days that we fervently wish we could re-wind and start over. The key is to work out what puts us ‘in the zone’ as switched-on mums most often (we’ll never get it right all the time).

    For some women, this means staying at home full time, without the distraction of paid employment. Others find they’re more effective as parents if they combine parenting with a career. Some stay at home and make a hash of it. Others work and make a hash of that. Good parenting is not as simple as which room you’re in.

    The parents who seem to do it well are the ones who are most ‘present’ for their children when they’re together – the most ‘switched on’, engaged and focussed (which is not to be confused with smothering and spoiling). They spend time together with their kids and time apart. They hold out a hand when it’s needed and they know when to hang back and let their children work it out for themselves. They’ve nailed ‘tough love’, yet they sit in the dark, holding back tears during the school play.

    They’re often fulfilled by more than just their parenting, and this fulfilment is not necessarily derived from paid work, though it can be. They value themselves. Their children have the same sense of ‘wholeness’, opportunity and possibility. They’re flexible, resilient and able to cope well with change.

    Or maybe they’re not. Sometimes parents do everything ‘right’ and their kids go off the rails regardless. Parenting is about what we do, what we don’t do, our triumphs, the mistakes we make and how we learn from them. A large part of it is about who we are parenting, the choices they make – and the luck of the draw.

    How we reach that Holy Grail – happy and well-adjusted kids – is not important. How the parent-next-door gets there is not important either. All we can do is have our hearts in the right place, our heads on our shoulders, take a deep breath, plunge in and learn to swim.

    And if a parent in the next lane appears to be swimming a different stroke – we can resist the temptation to push them under. Our kids are watching us, after all.

    http://www.worklifebliss.com.au

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Michelle

      Alison, Great article
      Emma – great comment!
      Ive done both, and right now I work a min of 30 hours week. Im on call evey 2nd weekend and I am a single mum. I have no choice but to work right now, to give my kids the life I set out to.
      BUT (and thats a big but!) even if I didnt *have* to work, I would. I dont want to end up like my mum (and I love her to bits, dont get me wrong) but she was out of the fulltime work force for 29 years before her youngest finished highschool. Now she cant get a full time job, she cant get a job using the cert that she got while the younger ones were at school, shes just too old.
      I dont want to define myself by my kids. What happens when they (inevitably) grow up and dont need me anymore. I want a career, I want a life that is mine. So when my eldest is 18 and I am 40 and I have at least 25 years left of working I enjoy every moment of it….
      My 3 yr old does 3 days a week in care, my 7 yr old goes to OSHC after school twice a week. Their dad and his family take care of 2 days a week and they have a great balance.
      But, even if I was at home, they would have a great balance and be happy well adjusted kids, because as you say, its not about which camp of the SAHM/WOHM debate you are in, its about the big picture of your parenting, and (today at least) I think I am doing a pretty good job

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  38. Dizzy Bee

    Amen!
    An actually I feel like I could have written myself although not as eloquently. Thank you Alison

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. Kate

    As always, the default response to any motherhood post on Mamamia should be – “Just do what works for you and your family and screw what anyone else thinks”.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  40. T and Ks Mum

    Stop and ask ourselves if the blokes go through this angst. No? Maybe it’s time to turn some of these questions onto the dads.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Dee of Adelaide

      Couldn’t agree more.

      There is lots that would need to change before Dad’s will ask these questions though. Overall (not anyone in particular, but sociologically) they would need to be more involved from the beginning, workplaces would need to change, women would need a higher earning capacity. Socially there would have to be giant changes to how people view fatherhood as inferior to motherhood.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Mel b

      Absolutely! My husbaoffices off to work for over 12 hour days, then not interested much at all what the kids had to say. But we had a wonderful discussion that it’s quality over quantity ( And no one wants a tired, cranky dad around). I’m a really hands on mum ( that’s just me) but they love their dad, love being with him just need him to see that. The third is a complete daddy’s boys and it’s made him change. So he getting out a bit earlier, he’s more involved when he gets home for tea time, reading and bedtime. And the kids get their dose of daddy. Plus weekends he has all three following him around doing jobs and playing.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  41. Motherofa3yrold

    Why aren’t we being supportive of whatever choice a family makes? I was in a family friendly workplace, but was so unhappy being away from my boy (Despite loving my job) I had to make the choice to quit work and live on the single mothers’ pension (not easy when you are used to full time income). Happy parents make for happy children, whichever you are doing SAHM, working full time or part-time I think as long as it was your CHOICE then you will have the happier family for it!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  42. JACS

    I am a working mother. I went to back to work when my daughter was 5 months old. The decision was made for me before she was born that I would always have to work. My husband simply doesn’t earn enough to support us on his wage alone. I went back to work and it was traumatic. I had so much judgment from other women it was awful. I left work some days crying. Not one man was rude and judgmental to me.

    Here is a sample of remarks:

    Who is looking after your baby ?
    Why isn’t your Mum looking after her ?
    You will miss out of so much
    Do you think you missed out on her growing up ?
    Does she pickup bad habits from day care ?
    You will never see her
    Your husband should get a FIFO job in the mines ?

    What astonishes me is that none of these people know or understand my circumstances. I still can’t understand why they even think it is appropriate questions for a work colleague.

    I went back to work because I had to. We needed the money. I don’t know what I would do if I had a real choice. I am doing what is right for my family and I am tired of feeling that I have to defend my actions.

    No one blinks an eye when men go back to work after a baby. No one asks my husband who is looking after the baby.

    As far as I am concerned we all just need to work out what is right for our families and stop judging others.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  43. Moomoo

    I copped a lot of nasty comments when I went back to work after 3 months even though my hubby gave up work to be at home full time. I coped by reminding myself that those who commented had no idea about our situation and were very smalll minded. I also resented comments that hubby eas babysitting so I could work. No he wasnt babysitting he was parenting! Now pregnant with #2 am already getting lots of snide comments about when I will return to work. And this is from women! I dont question your choice to be a sahm so dont question me!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  44. mrssavage

    I find this whole SAHM versus Working Mother debate so ridiculous in that it is never that cut and dried. There are a multitude of parents out there that have had their choices forced upon them. When we start discussing what sort of a role model we are and what psychological affect we are having on our children we are moving away from the writer’s original point which was family friendly workplaces and nasty comments directed at mothers.

    I wish we could step away from the parenting books and think about the ways in which we can place pressure on our government and businesses to change the current attitudes. Then we might actually be provided with more choices and perhaps stop concerning ourselves with comments from people that may or may not have underlying judgment.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  45. aliarlix

    thank-you for your lovely article – i am in the same boat – i love work (3 days/week) & think it makes me a better Mum as I come home happy from social & intellectual stimulation & some time out from tantrums, preparing baby food & changing nappies! I also play hockey twice a week & have my husband looking after the boys at this time. i think my 2 boys (aged 9 months & 27mths) are also more social, happy & adaptive to new environments from being in care & not with me 24/7. I am in awe of anyone who works as a SAHM – I think that is the toughest job ever. The irony of the situation is that the majority of Mums who go back to work, actually do so to give their children a better lifestyle – whether to fund private schools in the future, nice holidays, enable them to do swimming lessons or other fun classes, be able to socialise, buy a treat every so often or a bigger home for them…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  46. suki

    I’ve had a bit of a read through the thread and by and large most comments seem to support the idea that it’s different strokes for different folks. There’s a mix of working mum’s and SAH mum”s in my peer group and it is just not an issue of discussion. Everyone respects everyone else.

    So who do the nasty comments that we saw in the SMH comments section come from prescribing how mothers must parent? That’s what I would like to know.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Staying at home for now

      Yes, yes, yes! I am so lucky that the mothers in my playgroup could not give a damn whether I worked or not, nor do I care what they do. I just haven’t experienced the bitchiness and judgment that people talk about- it’s a very supportive environment.

      That said, I have experienced it from people without kids, as I mentioned in my post below. This is what I find quite puzzling, as I just don’t get why it would be of any concern to them whatsoever!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • alyssakt

      we’re lucky to not have too many nasty people here on this site
      that, and the moderators are very good also :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  47. kateb

    Last week i overheard my son explaining to his daughter (13) that the best thing in his life was that his mum worked. He explained that we had a better standard of living, and the bit that made me laugh, and he was lucky i came home happy and great to be around.

    He explained that if his mum had stayed home she would have been a crazy person and difficult to live with. The Children would have been forced to leave home early.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  48. Staying at home for now

    I am so glad that I’m not the only SAHM who feels awkward about saying, “Well, I actually don’t plan on going back to work any time soon…”. Even before my baby was born, I was constantly asked when I’d be back at work, almost always by childless people. It made me feel as though my child was this temporary little thing I was doing on the side while my real life was put on pause. It frustrated me to no end.

    I grew up with a mother who worked full-time from when I was aged 4 months. My mother is everything to me and we are unbelievably close- not a day goes by where I don’t talk to her for at least 30 minutes on the phone. I admire her so much for everything that she has achieved, both personally and professionally. She made every minute with me count and I always felt like I was the most important person in the world to her. The point is: I know for a fact that mothers who work full-time can be equally as devoted, attentive and loving as mothers who stay at home, and I get angry at anyone suggesting otherwise.

    That said, I have made the (perhaps interesting) decision to stay at home full-time until I’m done having kids (I hope to have at least 3 in fairly quick succession) and then going back to work when my youngest is in pre-school. I will then be able to focus on my career without taking multiple breaks from it. Financially, I am in a position where I don’t need to work. Being in my 20s allows me to take some time off work and come back to it when I’m still fairly young.

    What I find quite confronting is when (childless) people (women, in particular) assume that I’m missing out on something just because I’m staying at home. If I hear one more person say, “I don’t know how you do it… I’d be so bored at home with a child. I really need the intellectual stimulation”, I will scream! Comments like this are really quite disparaging to mums like me, despite ostensibly conveying nothing more than someone’s personal opinion, and I find it hilarious that more often than not, I hear it from people in fields of work far less intellectually rigorous than my own. It is only when I mention that, actually, while raising my child, I am doing quite challenging postgraduate study – which, when finished, will be my 3rd university degree, along with one graduate diploma – that I get an, “Oh wow…” reaction. I really shouldn’t need to mention that, but I so often feel that I need to justify my decision to stay at home and enjoy motherhood for a while.

    I’m aware that I might have difficulty getting back into my profession, particularly since I wasn’t well-established when I left (“Don’t waste your education. Every day that you’re at home, your skills become less and less relevant” is what my boss not-so-subtly informed me). But you know what? I’ll cross that bridge when and if I get to it. However, I am absolutely in no way concerned that I would not be able to find a job if I needed to due to a change in circumstances… maybe not my dream job, but I sure as hell would find SOMETHING given my qualifications. That patronising “What would you do if your husband left you?” argument is frankly utterly ignorant of the fact that many women who stay at home are competent in other areas apart from pureeing baby food.

    I really do feel sorry for mums who get criticised for going back to work. However, if we are going to keep seeing articles on this topic (which I’m not sure I approve of, as I think it fuels defensiveness – my comment being the perfect example), I think we need to stop focussing solely on the plight of the working mother, but also discuss why society has gotten to this ridiculous point where being a SAHM is also frowned upon.

    People just need to mind their own bloody business, I say!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • suki

      No, you shouldn’t have to tell them about your degree. I guess some people say stupid things on all sorts of topics and EVERYONE loves sharing their opinion on this issue. But yes, totally infuriating!

      I agree- can we just move on?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Motherofa3yrold

      I made the choice to stay at home after trying to return to work – twice. I got so depressed being away from my baby, I wanted to be there with him, after all this is my first and probably only child, I didn’t want to miss out!! Now he is 3 I am thinking about part time work again. I feel guilty that I am living off the single mother’s pension, at 35 shouldn’t I be supporting my own family? I always jokingly thank my working friends for paying their taxes so I can stay home. I will return to work once O is at school, and until then, I will upskill and try part time work next year…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • rainbow

        gosh don’t feel guilty living off a single mother’s pension. that is what it is there for. seriously.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Kerryn

      “many women who stay at home are competent in other areas apart from pureeing baby food” – genius!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  49. Tetra

    Therein lies the problem~parenting and motherhood seem to have become some sort of competition, to see whose the better person for doing this or that. I know not all mums are like that but as a mum of two and pregnant with my third I have found this to be the case.
    Breast V Bottle, Public V Private, working mums/SAHMS, organic homemade food for bubs V bought commercial variety, sleeps through the night/doesn’t sleep through, natural V caesarean and I could go on. Why oh why does it have to be this way and can’t we stop competing and start supporting? An example of this is my choice to have an elective c sec with this third baby having had 2 natural births previously. The abuse I copped from so called friends stating I was selfish and taking the easy way out was amazing. Now I just don’t talk about it anymore. Sad really.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  50. MDW

    You know, as a SAHM for over 8 years, I have to say, I completely agree. I believe that you as a Mother know what is exactly right for your own life, and your own child. No one else. For various reasons, it suited our family for me to stay home for that amount of time. Did we get criticism for our choices? Constantly. Did I feel bad about it? Never. How I could I feel bad about something that made everyone in our family, including me, happy. My youngest child is nearly 4. Last year I put her in care for 2 days a week because she needed it. She is a much different kid to my other two and it surprised me that all the stuff I did with her at home, that kept my other two completely happy, did not seem to make her happy. it occurred to me that she was miserable when her older sister and brother was at school and she perceived that she was’being stuck at home with Mum. We are so lucky to have a wonderful kinder/long day centre within our school campus and I decided to try her out. It started with a half day and we kept upping it til we found she was happiest at 2 days a week. After a year I am now about to put her in 3 days a week because every single day she says “is it a kinder day?” and is disappointed when it’s not. I have gone back to work, and once again, we are all happy. It is not a blanket right or wrong. It is what suits you individually, your child individually and what suits now might not in the future. Seems pretty simple to me, and why I would not dream of judging another woman’s choices.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions