My daughter is excited about starting school. She has been counting sleeps, insisting on wearing her school uniform everywhere, and greeting everybody with, “Hello, I’m going to school soon!”
When asked if she is worried or sad at all, she says no. But her behaviour shows otherwise. She throws monster tantrums almost hourly. She clings to me like a limpet: she’s even taken to lying on the bathmat waiting for me while I’m in the shower. And she’s insisting on endless games of big-sister-little-sister, a fun (read: excruciating) game where I have to talk in a baby voice and pretend to know nothing while she smiles patronisingly and puts me straight.
I know what’s wrong with her. She can feel the big wheel turning. And I know that, because it’s also what’s wrong with me. What else could make a grown woman with a PhD get teary when buying a Tinkerbell lunchbox from Coles?
The big wheel turns whether we like it or not, rolling us from one stage of life to another. For my daughter, it’s the transition from the private world to the public world.
Even preschool, that cocoon where the teachers only have first names and little beds are laid out in the afternoon, is a private place. Starting school is their first step into the public world. They are no longer considered so little that they require shelter and gentle handling. We stop using words like “care” and “love” quite so much when kids go to school. “Numeracy” and “literacy” become more important terms.
For me, it’s the transition between being the mother of a baby and what comes next (I don’t know what comes next, but I guess I find out this year). I didn’t feel the wheel turn when my son started school four years ago, because I had a one-year-old to occupy me.
I’ve known a few women who, faced with this transition, have another baby just so they can hold the wheel back a little longer. And that’s fine. But for me, this is the end of my childbearing years. No more babies for me. No more toddlers to vex and delight me. No more tiny sticky hands up my nose or new shiny teeth popping up in gums; no more lying down with a warm little body for a daytime nap while the public world—full of postmen and trucks and telephones—goes on outside.
This is it. Life has resumed. It has been nearly ten years since I first fell pregnant and I’m now outside the age where I have reliable eggs or, frankly, any energy left for babies. Like my daughter, I’m excited about where this turn of the wheel will take me.
My career, which I’ve kept bubbling with part-time work and carefully spaced contracts, may blossom. Perhaps I’ll finally learn to meditate and achieve spiritual peace. But, like my daughter, I’m also full of unvoiced fears. Maybe I’ll fall into despondence, feeling the sting of the end of my biological usefulness. I really don’t know. On good days, I’m cautiously optimistic. On bad days, I want to drink gin until menopause is over.
So when my daughter chucks one of her wobblies, I try to go gently with her. When she clings, I hug her harder. And I’ll continue to play the part of little sister with gusto, as long as she needs me to. We all go into the unknown with hope in our hearts and doubts in our minds. Right now I understand her better than anyone.
Kim Wilkins has published over 20 novels. She is a former bogan who now has a PhD and teaches writing and literature at University of Queensland. She has two young children and lives in Brisbane. You can read more about her here.
Do you remember the feeling when your kids started school? Do you remember your first day of school?



Comments
94 Comments so far
Stepping foot into the big wide playground of life.
I hope your little girl has kind and understandiing teachers to help her along.
loading...
All I can add is when the time came my children were fortunate enough to transmission from a Montessori child care centre Montessori International College (Buderim). They were in classes of less than 20 and each teacher had a full time assistant. They had the same teacher for three years. Needless to say the bonds of mutual respect very very strong. Both my teenages are curious, strong minded, secure individuals who are self motivated learns. There are schools and then there ARE schools. Good luck to you and your daughter as you start this amazing journey
loading...
This is a gorgeous post. I can identify with it all; my daughter starts 4 yr old Kinder next week. I am feeling very emotional about it but at the same time excited at this next stage, with an 8 yr old and a 4 yr old…
loading...
My son will be starting primary school next week and I am more than a little sad
I know that we have had some wonderful times together, and there are days when I WISH he was already in school (!!) but there are more days when I wish we could just sit on the swing-chair in the backyard reading books, bake cupcakes, jump on the trampoline and go for endless walks (the list goes on…).
To all those commenters below re: the “right” age to start your child at school – we all have personal choice, because it’s important. Some kids are ready at 4-turning-5, some aren’t. I know that everyone quotes the Steve Biddulph book (1997) and some Kathy Walker material (similar vintage) but, there is more recent research to consider from the University of Sydney (2009) that actually found that there is no advantage from delaying entry and that it may, in fact, hold kids back.
See this: http://sydney.edu.au/news/84.html?newsstoryid=3197
Also, this from the US:http://www.smh.com.au/news/opinion/miranda-devine/holding-him-back-can-do-just-that/2009/01/30/1232818724394.html
loading...
My youngest boy might be starting kindergarten next year (late March birthday so not sure), which is freaking me out. My little baby and my last born about to embark into the big wide world… Then I suppose I really should think about going back to work more days and being a more ‘active’ member of the workforce (instead of just part-time when no-one takes you seriously). Yikes!
loading...
Beautifully written post and really resonated with me. Thank you.
loading...
“no more lying down with a warm little body for a daytime nap while the public world—full of postmen and trucks and telephones—goes on outside” oh wow, you have summed that feeling up perfectly. My eldest is starting kinder this year and I still have a 16 month old…. But that pull from turning from babies into toddlers is happening…. Makes my heart full and also sad all at the same time. Lovely post Kim.
loading...
I don’t have kids yet… my first is due in 2 weeks! But there’s a song I love that makes me cry every time that kind of describes this feeling. And although I don’t have kids yet, I can totally get what the singer is feeling. Is that weird? Anyway it’s called “In My Arms” and it’s by Plumb.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hf-1rtYPjjE
loading...
My ‘baby’ is starting school this year as well and I thought I was absolutely fine until now the reality of being only days away from school actually starting I find I am teary, clingy, emotional and prone to throwing the odd tantrum myself. I just hope I don’t embarass either her or myself next week.
loading...
This is completely off-topic, but I used to love your Gina Champion books! They were scary (I’m a massive chicken), but they were good so I just kept reading and being scared.
loading...
What a lovely article, Kim, thankyou for this. I particularly love the poignant visual of the “big wheel turning” – it really connected with me. I”m on the verge of a few of those moments myself with my 4 year old just begun kindy and a 5-months- along baby in my belly waiting to challenge and change my life again.
After this article I can look ahead to where you’re at wistfully and know that although that time will be hard for me, it will also be lovely to step into a space where I can concentrate on being me again. For now, I’ll enjoy the sticky fingers and warm cuddles. All the best xx
loading...
after talking to my mum about my neice starting school I thought I’d better look it up as to when son #1is expected to start. turns out in only 12 months time he goes to kindergarten because he will turn 4 before 30/6/12. I’ve been in a daze eversince, I am really struggling with the fact that for 11 hours a week, someone other than family can influence his behaviour, diet and knowledge! plus it means i’ll be left alone with son #2…..yikes!!
loading...
Our eldest, a daughter is 18 months and our son is 4 months old.
My husband and I were discussing our parents music tastes and were discussing The Beatles Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band where one of my mother’s favorite songs is “She’s Leaving Home”.
He can’t even bear to think about the song for the sentiment it contains and he sometimes feel heart wrenched when he drops her off at daycare and she happily runs off to join her friends. How is he going to cope with her going to school in a couple of years?? Bless. One of the reasons I love him so much.
loading...
Pumpernickel starts kindergarten (the first year of “big school” in the ACT) next week. She too tells EVERYONE that she’ll be in kindergarten and is excited beyond words. She has always been a curious and inquisitive child and to her school is this magical place full of wonderous things. My hope is that for her school meets her expectations. And I wish her teacher well in dealing with her curlier questions she wants answers to (and anyone who can tell me where the 10th tree in the world grew I’d appreciate your assistance).
loading...
re- “should they start school before 5 yo or nearly 6″ debate:
The thing no one mentions or seems to think about is, that all other things being equal, it’s good to have an extra year up your sleeve. Three of my friends had health promblems (anorexia, bipolar disorder, mum had cancer) in year a 11 and had to repeat yr 11. Fornutately, they were young for thier year, so it did not matter.
Who knows what slings and arrows life will throw at you…
loading...
I completely agree. So many people talk about their child’s social readiness but they don’t look beyond the first couple of years at school. I have researched this issue extensively and some studies have shown that by middle primary school the “older” children may struggle with the fact that the “younger” children are doing just as well or better than they are. Also, being 18 at the beginning of Year 12 must surely be distracting with all the freedom it brings. I would much prefer my kids to get their “freedom” after their high school studies are complete. The New York Times recently ran an article suggests that children “step up” to what is expected of them and that there is evidence that the younger children often do better because they are more challenged.
loading...
Lani93 your post made me teary. Actually thinking about my now 14 month old going out into the big wide world makes me cry. As a parent you want to protect your kids so fiercely and not to see them hurting but that’s life isn’t it? All we can do is to provide them with the right tools to be able to work through the maze.
loading...
Pingback: Five Alive Friday | Checks and Spots
Next week my last baby starts primary school and my first starts secondary school – I’ve shed many tears these last few days. And while they aren’t babies anymore they’ll always be my babies!
loading...
My experience of childhood and subsequent adolescence was strongly influenced by bring sent to school (QLD) when I had just turned five. I was so keen to go to school and I loved the learning but my social and physical development was a year behind my class mates. At school sports, which was strictly restricted by age, I did OK, but most team sports were played in grade groups and my skills were insufficient to suceed. Academically, I did well but my maturity was not sufficient and mostly I ate lunch alone.
As an adult, I feel compelled to contribute to the debate regarding the age when children are school ready and I believe it differs for each child. My preference is to err on the side of caution and send a child who is older rather than a child who is younger. I want my child to shine at school, I want then to have good friends, know how to apply themselves to learning and navigate the politics of adolescence with happy memories. I would prefer my child to be the most socially skilled in their grade group rather than the least.
loading...
PS mamamia – can you tell us if the photo you used on this icon is a preschooler or a kindy starter?
loading...
My oldest child starts school next week. She will be six in May and is very “ready” for this journey.
We made the decision not to send her to school last year when she would have been one of the youngest in her class. Academically it was not an issue, but emotionally and physically it would have pushed her.
We made the right decision. Her personality is growing and her confidence has blossomed. She has the social skills that provide the foundation to maintain her self-esteem. I have loved cementing our relationship and finding new ways to relate as she has become more independent and engaged in the world around her.
We will miss her being around – for all her cheekiness and boundry testing – and so will her little sister. But as a working mother who runs a business from home, a part of me is relieved at least one of my daughters will not have to be asked to play alone while I spend some time at my computer or join a conference call.
I am fortunate to have enough flexibility to allow me (most of the time) to be part of the school community – to join her class for reading and be there for important events.
She has left the cocoon of our wonderful preschool and its protective, nurturing and caring environment … Oh yes, I cried for the loss of that. Sobbed in fact.
But we are all ready now and can embrace this journey together. It’s time for her to move out into the world and start to find her way. We will be there alongside her to share in the delight, the wonder and the challenges.
We need to put trust in her that she will be capable to begin making decisions herself. This is not high school we are talking about! It’s kindy, with kind, caring and dedicated teachers. More than 30 of her preschool friends are going to the same school and she has met her teacher a number of times.
We have our children for many reasons – one of them is to guide them through life and prepare them for the world – warts and all. My baby starting school is not about me – it’s about her. I say EMBRACE it, be involved and be happy for her as she explores the wonder of learning, the ups and downs of friendship and the rewards of budding independence.
When she hugs me now I hug her tighter than ever.
I say have a glass of bubbles to celebrate. Celebrate your own achievements as a mother in preparing your child for this event. Celebrate your child’s journey through life and celebrate the fact (for yourself and for them) that you feel so much love.
loading...
I do not have any children on my own yet, or maybe ever, but I have vivid memories of my own first day of school.
I started school a month before my 5th birthday, maybe a tad more.
My first two days were all “yeah man, I’m cool with this”
My third day, I SCREAMED. Holy shit did I scream. I do not know how my memories of this day are so vivid, but I do remember them. I remember trying to punch my wonderful mum because she was leaving me.
I remember clinging to my teacher and being sat on her lap during our first leeson because I wouldn’t calm the duck fown.
It must’ve been alright on my 4th day, because I don’t remember that.
I do remember mum being absolutely hysterical every morning for the first 2 weeks of my reception career.
Oh mummy, I started school at the same time you realised I would be your only child. I wish I had known that then, so I could hug you like you needed to be hugged. I love you.
loading...
My daughter started at 5 1/2. didn’t want her starting kindy (nsw first year infants) at 4. She was in daycare full-time but she was academically ready no way socially ready. To many kids starting early. That said you have to do what is right for you and your child and the hell with everyone else.
loading...
Woolies have the sweetest hair band packs in the back to school section with holograms on the lid; I found the perfect one for my daughter Amie, a caterpillar transforming into a colourful butterfly, something from me to her to show her how much I love her and treasure that beautiful hair that I’ve combed and plaited since it was no more than little silky tufts. When the checkout girl scanned the pack and asked if they were for my ‘little’ girl I had to explain, well yes, but she’s not five……she’s twenty five and expecting her first baby in May. She will always, be my baby, and no matter how old she gets, she still relishes those moments that remind her of that
xxxx
loading...
Thanks so much, you made me cry a little!! How beautiful, really and truly.
loading...
Me too! *sniff*
loading...
Oh that is just beautiful Dawn, you brought tears to my eyes! xx
loading...
I think starting school is one of life’s most monumental milestones.it is the first time children are given the opportunity to truely be an independent little person,away from mum and dad.For us mums,it is really easy to see this transition as an end…an end to having your baby,an end to being the centre of their world.i think it is normal to feel what you are feeling and I encourage you to have a little cry if you need to….but after your little cry,get up,dust yourself off,and remember she will always need you…it’s just that what she needs from you will change.New beginnings can only arise from something else ending…embrace it,this is a truely special time!
loading...
Beautiful writing and so very accurate. The big wheel never stops turning. When it does, we are no longer here.
loading...
Anyone else think that’s the cutest picture? Although I do wonder about the longterm effect of such a big backpack being carried by such a small body …
loading...
Why?
loading...
I think its adorable too!
loading...
I still keep in touch with the very first friend I made at school.
Like Kim, my child bearing days are over and although I still have a 2.5yr old at home I am dreading the day when she starts school.
Both my older boys were happy to start school, I’m the one who put on a brave face as I let go of their little hand and helped them put their bag on the bag rack, enter the classroom and sit down. As soon as I turned to walk out the flood gates opened the tears came and I didn’t stop them.
So as long as my daughter asks me to read Goldilocks(several times in a day) and put Thomas the tank on TV when I want to have the Circle on (or trying to work from home) I’ll let her do it because these moments are precious and life changes when they start school.
loading...
I think I’m in the minority but there was not even a tinge of sadness when I sent my boys off to school. I guess it also helped that they excited about starting too.
I knew they would love school as they both have a very strong love of learning, and I was excited about having some regular time to myself for the first time ever.
loading...
Agree agree. They were excited to start and so was I.
loading...
Exactly the same for me WTE. I was so happy that they were heading off to school, because they were so happy and so ready to be going…and a part of me which was selfish yearned for my me time back.
I don’t understand it when mothers get upset about it because I never felt the same emotion. Instead I felt so proud of them, as I am sure others do too, but I just felt like yep off they go, that’s cool…right what can I do today?!!!!
loading...
My eldest starts school on Wed & youngest start one day a week pre-school on Thursday. I am not sad or upset in either case both girls are happy and excited to go and I am looking forward to a coupe of hours a week to myself. I have never understood the ‘feeling sad’ cos they are going to school thing!?!?
loading...
For me, it marks the end of babyhood. They lose their fat little cheeks in that first year. The main thing is though, I miss having them at home with me and I worry about them.
loading...
For me it is because it is the first major milestone in growing up and away. Next they graduate primary school, then high school, then turn 18, then they’re off.
loading...
Is there a hurry that I’m not aware of?
loading...
You might feel different when your youngest starts school.
Three days to go for me…
loading...
A day to yourself is rejuvenating. Wait until the last one starts school, and even though, like my 3rd and youngest who has just started and is loving it and coping very well, for me it is the very final end to a stage. No more kids at home
That is sad, although of course there are many good times to come…
loading...
My (4 and a half year old) daughter started on Monday too, and I have no other babies (nor reliable eggs to make more babies) and I was very sad about it too. I love having my little sticky fingered helper around me. Yes, my career has suffered, but I have loved my brief journey into revisiting childhood with my girl. I think if she was 5 already I might feel marginally better about it, but maybe not. Anyway, she is loving it, so I love that about it – and I did enjoy being able to go to a movie with my husband during the day yesterday – there just might be an upside!
loading...
My middle child started school this week. He went on Monday and Tuesday then school cancelled due to rain yesterday. Hubby and I can’t believe the change in him already. He’s also been my quietest, more sensitive to change and more easily unsettled. He has also generally needed more sleep then his older sister and younger brother. I was so sure he would fall asleep in the car on the way home or be in bed by 6 exhausted. He’s been the complete opposite. Very, very chatty and excited. Hes been getting up super early. Having trouble falling asleep at night because he’s so excited talking about his day and what will be happening the next day. He just seems so conifident. It’s like he’s been there for 2 years not 2 days. We’re waiting for him to crash in an emotional exhausted heap but not yet. I can’t even imagine what it would feel like when my baby gets to school.
loading...
When son number 1 started school I was teary and when son number 2 started( my baby)I really cried.They are now 23 and 20 and I still remember the feelings.
loading...
WHO has been asking her if she feels “sad or worried at all?”
To her, it’s very likely an exciting Big Deal, starting school, but *someone* has been putting negative ideas into her little brain, so she’s Not Sure and maybe she should be worried or sad….? Hence the wobblies.
Adults have a lot to answer for – like putting negative ideas into little girls’ heads instead of making the start of school a fun part of Life.
loading...
My son starts school next week, and I have asked him if there is anything he’s worried about. I don’t see anything wrong with asking that and answering any questions or concerns he might have. School is such a big deal to these little people, and it is built up to be such a big thing that it can be very intimidating. What’s wrong with asking if they are OK?
loading...
I agree, Cherry. Doesn’t hurt to ask & it opens the door of communication if they ARE feeling worried or unsure!
loading...
My five year old son is starting school on Monday, and I’m excited for him, but at the same time, so sad. He’s been my little mate around the house for the past five years! His big sister will love having a sibling finally at school with her, but his little sister will not know what to do with herself, as it’ll be the first time she’ll have extended periods with no siblings to play with.
loading...
You sound similar to me. My oldest is going into grade 1, and my middle child started school and almost 3 year old will be home alone with me for the first time. He will be going to toddler/kindy 2 days a week but I’ve already had a taste of the demands he’s putting on me for a playmate!
loading...
LOL! Yeah, we’re just planning to keep her really busy. That, and trying to spend this next year working out if we send her to school on the early or late side. This’ll determine whether she’s home with us for one more year or two
loading...
I have a little girl who turned 5 on December 27; she is staying home for another year. She has always been a fearful person, and I feel I know just how much to push her so her fears are overcome, without making her close up – like I have seen so many other children do when made to undertake things beyond their current capabilities. But wow, talk about judgement, I have had no end of opinions about the fact she will be in kinder @ 6. Maybe I should have been throwing shade at all those parents who send them off at 4 for 5 days a week. I haven’t- but I tell you what, if you walk to the beat of a different drum be prepared! I am very happy to have another year with my girl, we are going to do some reading and numbers together, she is doing karate and ballet and I will join up with the local homeschooling network for the year , her mates will be too tired after long days at big school for a play so meeting new people is a must. For all those sending off children to big school this year, best wishes – I will be the one blubbering at the gate next year for sure!
loading...
Oh I think you are hindering your child holding her back another year. Their minds are like sponges. They need the stimulation. Why hold her back? Turning 6 in 4 year old kinder. She needs to be at school.
loading...
Wow some people are judgemental! I think listen to others opinions ( just in case those rose colored glasses are on) but YOU know your daughter best and know if she’s ready. My dad is a NSW primary principal and he believes the best age for starting is 5 turning 6, but parents know best!
loading...
That is correct, that is what I am saying . I agree, just like your dad that a child should be at school at 5 turning 6. Not at 4 year old kinder.
loading...
Yep, definitely think there is some nsw/Vic confusion when it comes to kindergarten!
loading...
Well, we don’t know that’s the case until the original poster says so
loading...
My above comment was in answer to anonymous:)
loading...
My son turned 6 in January of the year he started Prep (1st year of school in Vic). It was the best thing I ever did for me, keeping him back that extra year. In fact, all of the kinder teachers I spoke to previous to enrolling him in kinder suggested that the older the child is the better. They might be little sponges, but it is also the social side that you need to think about. I am so glad I did what I did. He thrived in his first year at school and was so ready. If I’d sent him earlier when he’d just turned 5 I don’t think he would have done as well and I am sure I would have been sitting at home worrying and doubting my decision.
loading...
Kinder in some states is the first year of school – in other places it’s called Prep – whatever, it’s the year before 1st Grade and kids in ACT/NSW start Kinder/Prep/first year of school at 5 years of age.
In addition to different names, all the states have different cut-off dates. In the ACT it’s 30 April, in NSW it’s 31 July, which makes a whole year of difference for my May-born child.
loading...
My son will be starting at 6 (turns 6 in January). He was a late talker and walker and is still catching up socially and physically.
He has just turned 4 and is just starting to be able to run and struggles with stairs, holding a pencil etc he can read though ( self taught)
The development paediatrician tolds us she has never met a child whose development was so scattered. She also told us to definitely send him at 6.
Attitudes like yours Anon are really ignorant and simpliistic not to mention inconsiderate of children who are different.
I’ve got enough on my hands with speech, OT appointments and generally trying to help my son catch up to have to worry about judgmental people like you too..
loading...
Mina, as I pointed out, unless their are developmental or social problems I think children should be at school.
loading...
What state are you in? I’m in NSW and my son is starting his first year at big school (called kindergarten) and he’ll be turning 6 in June. Here, you can start them the year they turn 5 or 6, and that’s considered pretty normal.
loading...
I am in Victoria where we have 3 year old and 4 year old kindergarten. 3 years go to 3 year old kinder, and four year olds go to 4 year old kinder. 5 turning 6 year old children attend prep. Having a 5 year old turning 6 complete a 4 year old programme is almost hindering the child. In Victoria unless there is a social or intellectual problem with the child they should be at school.
loading...
See, I’m wondering if this mum is in NSW, because we call the first year of school, ‘kinder’ as she has.
We have preschool for the years prior to that, I chose not to send any of my kids to it.
loading...
I dont know about that because the mother specified that her child is 5 in December. Children can only start prep or first year of school as a four year old if their 5th birthday is before April 30th. This indicates to me that she will be completing a four year old programme this year.
loading...
Thing is though, being a birthday right at the end of the year, it could be a nsw thing or other state. If I were in her shoes and she’s talking about first year of ‘big school’, I’d probably do the same
loading...
Yes I am a nsw mum (i am original poster) my girl goes to pre school 2 days a week this year and will go to big school (kinder) next year when she is just 6.
loading...
I personally don’t see a problem at all. My son who is starting school this year, could’ve gone a year earlier, but he had some shyness and anxiety too whenever I took him to the under 5′s program run by the school. Once he turned five, he became so much more confident and now I know he’s ready.
Sometimes they just need some time. They also can get the stimulation they need at home and at other places besides just school in the meantime
loading...
I used to be a NSW teacher. I think you are doing the right thing. It’s also what I did with my own children.
loading...
I have made he same decision for my son. He will be five late this March and is about to go into pre-school in Canberra – which is a five day fortnight (Mon, Tues and alternate Wed). He qualified for pre-school last year according to his birth date but my husband and I agreed that we didn’t feel right sending our three year old off to preschool last year, even though he was only a few months from turning four.
This has proved to be the most controversial parenting decision we have made, but we now know it was the best. He is so ready for preschool this year – and the extra of time with me has been good for both of us.
All of the parenting and child experts that I respect – Steve Biddulph and Dr John Darcy to name just two – recommend delaying a child’s entry into school if there is any doubt about whether they are ready. Also, EVERY school teacher and principal I have discussed this decision with has told me that they wish more parents would evaluate each individual childs situation and not simply follow the guidelines – which are just that, a guide.
My SIL is a primary school teacher and has been for fifteen years. She held all three of her children back, making sure they were all five before they started the first actual year of school (five days a week, uniforms etc). She says that mentally, emotionally, psychologically and physiologically children are much better able to cope when they are in the 5-6 age group than in the 4-5 age group.
So, in other words, I think you’ve made a good call. Trust that no-one knows your daughter the way you do and that only you have all the information to make this call.
loading...
Not so. I’m a Prep teacher & also work in the Education Faculty of one of Melbourne’s biggest universities. It is *generally* (but not always) the norm to give children another year at kinder if their 5th birthday falls in the early part of the prep year. In my experience Dec/Jan children are often borderline on being ‘ready’; many are sent and many are ‘held back’. It is impossible to make a call on what is right for a child you have never met!!! However I don’t believe there is anything wrong with giving children another year at home/kinder.
loading...
Sorry, this reply was directed at Anon who believes that “in Victoria” this child would certaily be sent to school.
loading...
The main thing is that as you are confident it’s the right decision for your child.
I think it’s a good idea to at least consider the opinions of preschool teachers and close family and friends who know their personality, but my experience from the other end (sending my son at age 4) was that the only people who told me I was doing the wrong thing were those who didn’t actually know his personality.
loading...
I sent my son to prep as a 4 year old turning 5 in the Feb. Being the youngest in the class I was a little concerned but he had an outstanding year, winning a maths award, his has matured beyond my imagination, he reads beautifully and is eager for more. I am thrilled with how he progressed and yes it does depend on the child but deliberately keeping them back when there are no issues with the child I think is unfair. They need the stimulation, their minds are sponges. Keeping my 5 year old in a four year old programme just seemed odd to me, like I was holding him back. I am very happy with my choice.
loading...
My son didn’t turn 5 until May and has thrived at school also, so I’m a big advocate for sending them to school young if they are ready. However I can understand that if you had a really anxious child another year may make a difference.
loading...
I agree, and I think generally parents are really good at determining what’s best for their child, as they know their personalities inside out
loading...
Not necessarily.
How much anxiety is generated by the parent though? My Sister-in-law kept her eldest son back from school because of her own fears, not his. He was more than capable of going. If she was worried about possible lack of maturity, it is because she fusses over him all of the time. He never has a chance to attempt to complete a task himself. It brings to mind Maria Montessori’s famous quote: “Never help a child with a task at which he feels he can succeed.” Always did even the simplest tasks for him and when he would have a go, she would preempt him needing help.
She was the one not ready for him to go to school, he was fine and would have managed quite capably if he had started in his original age group. It would have given him the stimulation and a chance to learn to be more independent. Another year of child care and his behaviour became really bad “I don’t know why he’s acting like this?” she would say as that extra year from school wore on, “Ah, he’s bored being back at child care another year” was my first thought.
The age groupings have changed in Qld schools to accomodate boys by making the class older than it was previously. Even the youngest kids in the class would have been in the older half when kids were sorted in calendar years. It works out that her son is 18 months older than I was when I started grade 1 (due to her keeping him back and the new age groupings).
loading...
Holy cow. Judgement much??
Well get your guns back out again ready to shoot me down because I did the same thing. As another NSW Mum I understood you perfectly when you talked about them having just turned 6 when they started kinder. I think people forget that we have all sorts of names for things around Australia and probably should have checked before they started making assumptions. In NSW the majority of kids would be almost 5 and a half when they start school (some parents send their kids at 4 and a half but they are in the minority. In the kinder intake of one of my kids who is still in infants they had about 58 kids and only 4 weren’t 5 years old when they started).
My child is actually about a week older than yours. I agonised over the decision about when to send my child. I talked to anybody and everybody, I attended the school readiness nights, and I went up to the school to see the principal, and I spoke with all her preschool teachers. My child has had all sorts of things go on over their life including speech disorders etc. Intellectually they are a very clever child who actually tests just outside of gifted (we had to get an IQ test done before starting the school process). Academically my child would have been better than fine. But socially? Nope!!
What essentially decided me was that the teachers etc were clear that you can send a child that is academically ready but if they aren’t socially ready, their academic performance will start to suffer. School is SUCH a social place now. It is not like when we were young and we sat in desks in straight lines which all faced forward where the teacher always stood. We learnt what we were told, very very occasionally worked in groups, and in a lot of ways socially it was much easier. Now you have a system where the teacher teaches from all over the classroom (white board on one side, blackboard somewhere else etc). The kids are constantly doing group work, and they are much more encouraged to lead their own learning. This is not a bad thing, but think how much more difficult it makes it for a child who is not socially ready to be there? They could hide out a bit before until their emotional maturity catches up, but now they have to be switched on from day one. My kinder student had to go in a public speaking competition for goodness sake! That would be unheard of even just a few years back.
You are not in the minority in having your child that little bit older before starting NSW kindergarten. I was amazed to discover that there were three other kids similar in age to my child (one was a couple of days younger than yours, and one was a couple of weeks younger).
I figured that I was sparing my child the possibility of either being always the follower that couldn’t cope in the class, but kept moving up because of academics ability (if they managed to hold it together despite her lack of social ability) or sparing them the possibility of needing to repeat. My child is very successful in the class. Socially there is still an issue but that won’t likely change any time soon. That extra year of preschool gave so many extra tools though and my child started with confidence instead of fear.
loading...
Wow, people have very strong opinions about this! Actually in the majority of countries around the world, children start school at 6 turning 7 or just after their 7th birthday. Australia is in the minority, sending their chidlren to school at just 5 years of age. So I don’t think it’s a big deal to hold your child back if they are not ready, especially seeing as you are the one that knows your child best. Some children are probably more than ready to go to school before they are 5 whilst others are not ready until they are 6 and a half. Gotta consider both social and academic maturity too. Each to their own and no judgement here!
loading...
I think its a big deal delaying children from school. Read up on it. Children need stimulation. Delaying that just disadvantages them. Sending them to prep at 7 is quite sad. I would prefer to have my child at 7 reading novels then learning basic words and reading basic books like they do in prep. A seven year old should be at grade 2 level.
loading...
No one in this post is saying they send their kids at 7.
Who says this child won’t be getting stimulation?
In NSW kindergarten (first year of school), the latest you can send your child is 6. That’s all the original poster was talking about doing.
loading...
I’m sure you don’t really mean to Anonymous, but you are coming across really judgemental and sanctimonious. Not only only that, it seems that you are not even bothering to properly read other replys that indeed clarify their point. The poster you are judging is starting her child at primary school at aged 6, not 7. in Nsw where she is said she is from, “kinder” is the first year of school. So in summary NSW kinder = Victoria prep. Now can you please admit that you stand corrected so that we can just move on from this?
loading...
Read up on it???? I actually laughed out loud when I read that. I honestly could not think of a single collegue, educational consultant or teacher I know that would agree with you. Sending children to school just because of their age is totally inappropriate and often harmful for the child. Trust me…. I’ve had to help parents pick up the pieces on many many occasions. I’ve NEVER met a parent regret holding their child back, but I’ve worked with dozens and dozens of children paying the price for their parents poor choices, while mum and dad lament “ah, if only….” Your child was young and school was a success. That’s great!!! But please don’t judge others and the choices they make for their own children. Your child Is the exception not the rule.
loading...
Parents are holding their children back when they don’t need to. I disagree on you comment that most teachers would suggest you hold a child back. . For some reason there has been a trend to do so. Studies suggest it beneficial for them to start at 5. Why hold them back. Unless of course there is a problem with your child,
loading...
I’m not saying that “most” teachers I know would agree that it’s ok to hold a kid back, I’m saying that ALL teachers I know would!! I would really love to know which studies you are referring to? could I perhaps refer you to the research by Cath Walker? Steve Biddulph?
loading...
If in VIctoria you choose to keep your 5 year old turning 6 in 4 year kinder to complete a four year old programme than that is your choice. But only a child who is behind will be content. Stimulation v’s boredom., I will choose to stimulate my child and have them in school rather than in a programme designed for children 1 to 18 months younger than they are.
loading...
Really ? I have met many parents who wish they had held back and sent their 5 year old to a 4 year old kindergarten. Their child was bored with the programme, their was only 12 hours of kinder a week and by the end of the year their child was 6. So effectively they were BORED with kinder because they should have been in school. What kinder teacher I wonder creates a programme for 3 year old or 4 year olds would encourage children a year or 2 older to be in that kinder group. 3 year old kinder for 3 year olds, 4 year old kinder for 4 year olds. Simple really.
loading...
No it’s not that simple, children develop at different rates. While 5 might be the right age for most children some children have development delays and need longer. Not simple at all!
Anon, perhaps you’ve been lucky enough to have had children who have developed ‘normally’ you shouldn’t judge others who have children who need a little longer.
loading...
Anon, while I admire your commitment to your beliefs I do find your “arguments” rather amusing to be honest. You show a total disregard for the fact that ALL children are different and a total lack of understanding for how education works.
Oh and can I please teach one of your children?? If all you expect of a teacher is to teach one set curriculum for one set age group, then Im in for a pretty cruisy year really!
loading...
Sorry the above comment was from Coffee Snob!
loading...
Wow. you’d really judge me then as I never sent any of my kids to daycare or preschool.
And no, my kids have never been bored, under stimulated or behind.
loading...
UAE kids start formal school (as in uniforms, full day at school) at 3. My friends’ son turns 4 in April and he was a bit late starting!
loading...
My daughter is starting NSW kindergarten next week and she turned 6 in early January. She has been at preschool for the last 2 years and we went with the preschool teachers opinions as well as what my husband and I knew was right for our daughter. She wasnt ready at all last year when she had just turned 5 but she is very ready this year having just turned 6. Each child is so different some are ready younger and some not. As parents I think its our job to evaluate and make these kinds of decisions for our children taking in the advice of pre school teachers etc. We all I am sure try and do the very best for our own children.
loading...