by ALYSSA ROBINSON
Please take a moment to stifle your gag reflexes, because I’m about to take you down gender normative lane. I’m going to take you back to the 1990s, when I was all cute and tiny, and when buying Christmas presents for little girls and boys wasn’t such a gendered quagmire.
Best Christmas gift I ever received as a child? One in particular comes to mind: I must have been 8 or so, and I was given an adorable plastic princess castle, which served as a convertible teapot and cup. Genius! It was all pink and purple and glittery. I loved it.
A year or two later, my parents surprised my sister and me by directing us to the backyard on Christmas morning, where a brand new trampoline was set up. Holy shit, was that exciting. And then there was the year after our house had been renovated and we’d built an in-ground pool, when my parents again surprised us with a bag full of inflatable toys and water guns and assorted wondrousness. Oh, and another year, one of my aunts gave my sister, my cousin and me purple Spice Girls shirts. It was the ’90s, after all, and I assure you, we looked superb in our Baby Spice-esque pigtails.
Those were the days.
The thing with Christmases is that there are a lot of them. And childhood tends to drag on for a while, too. So your little girl wants a tiara and a sequined puffy skirt this year? Good for her. Buying it for her isn’t going to tell her that females are more princess-like than presidential.
This is one day in a year. I assure you, the ideas you instil in her head over the other 364 days are going to be far more cemented than anything a bit of pink glitter might suggest. And, of course, pink glitter says nothing in its own right. We imbue it with meanings, and what it means to an adult is likely nothing that will ever occur to a 5-year-old. She’s not thinking “my kiddie baking oven is teaching me that women are domestic slaves whose value is measured by the ratio of cupcakes baked to shirts ironed.” She’s probably thinking “this toy is pretty awesome—hey, I want a cupcake.”
Yep, you can have your (cup)cake and eat it too. Hence my teapot castle one year and trampoline the next. I watched Disney movies and fawned over the gown-adorned princesses (team Belle, anyone?) and I played many a game of “mommies and daddies” with my cousins.
Oh, what delightful make-believe nuclear families we had. And never any bills to pay! Despite these cookie-cutter childhood experiences, I grew up to be an open-minded feminist, all for alternative identities, sexualities, and families.
My mother is a compulsive studier, and when I was young, she was going through her Gender Studies phase. When a famous actress appeared in a print ad supposedly selling a car but featuring far more woman than wagon, Mom showed it to me and we discussed it. If you’re worried about your kids getting the wrong ideas from Bratz dolls or violent and sexist video games or whatever craze is going about the playground, talk to them about it. Give them alternate ideas. Encourage them to seek not just answers, but more questions. An inquiring mind is the best gift you could ever give.
And remember, sometimes kids can surprise you. They can be pretty cool. Another case in point from my childhood: I once was invited to a fairies and pirates party. I went as a pirate. Because pirates are badass, and I’ve always liked stripes.
This article originally appeared here on Role/Reboot and has been republished with full permission.
Alyssa Robinson is an international development student, writer and part-time perky salesgirl hailing from Sydney, Australia. She tweets at @thatsironical.








Comments
25 Comments so far
It isn’t just one day in the year during which little girls are inundated with pink and sparkles. If only.
loading...
As I sit here waiting for my 3yo boy to wake up on Christmas morning, I know that despite all the money I spent on gifts for him the one he’s going to be most excited about is a fuschia $10 microwave from Kmart. The thing lights up, has a timer, spinny turntable and makes noises… just like our real one that he’s obsessed with. Strangely though it only came in that one colour. He has wayyyyy too much ‘typical boy’ stuff that cost way more waiting under the tree for him but that microwave is going to be the winner. He also has a lot of crafty stuff waiting too, including feathers and glitter letters because despite my hating all things glue, he loves craft somehow.
I guess the sad thing is though that I did hesitate for a moment when I saw the microwave only came in fuschia and even glanced around at the other shelves for one in a different colour. I also carefully hid the more ‘girlie’ craft things he already has when we were decorating Xmas cards for family so he didn’t use them. I even saw sticker packs yesterday labelled girl and boy when I was buying more treats for his stocking and so I skipped those altogether. But my kid doesn’t know he’s only supposed to like blue, rockets, dirt and dinosaurs. So I think it crosses both genders and I think a lot of these things stem from us as parents. If you love pink and your daughter picks up on that and ends up loving it too, who cares?! I guess it just becomes a problem – when like anything – we become too staunchly militant either way.
loading...
My son is in primary school and loves pink. I;m pretty sure the reason he likes pink is the saturation coverage of Pink Ribbon Day. His nanna passed away from Breast Cancer and was involved heavily involved in “Pink” activities before she passed.
He specifically asked for a Pink grip for his cricket bat and he wanted a pink ribbon charity “bangle” which is proudly wore for months to school.
loading...
I have decided to embrace my 5 year old daughter’s love of all that is pink and sparkly. I see it as an expression of joi de vie rather than a symbol of patriarchal submission. This year she asked Santa for a Doctors Kit and a rainbow skirt. I see no good reason why one can’t heal the sick and wear a rainbow at the same time.
http://mum-abulous.com/2012/07/15/the-pinkification-blues/
loading...
The fact that toys are marketed separately to boys and girls is just silly.. My cousins and I mixed up all our “girl” toys and “boy” toys together to have the most fun, and th boys liked the cooking things and dollhouse just as much as the girls, and same for the girls with the toys cars and building stuff. Though, we ALL though the plastic was stupid, and used it as a boat in the pond instead. It bothered no one that are battleship was pink.
loading...
I so very much agree! Pink is my absolute, all time favourite colour. I have not swayed from my dedication to pink since I was a little girl (you can ask my mother to verify that, even when I went through my weird hardcore phase, I still admitted to loving pink!)
Glitter rules my wardrobe, which rivals that of a drag queens in shiney, sequined, feathered get ups.
Yet some how I’ve ended up a strong feminist who doesn’t back down on her beliefs ever.
That’s what I love about feminism – it’s about equality and choice for all women and men. It lets me be everything I want to be: I can wear cute outfits and enjoy cooking and sewing while still challenging the boys in the brains department. (And yes, based on my academic pursuits, it often shocks people that I sew and cook)
I’m glad my mother let me be who I wanted to be while still instilling in me the right beliefs about being just as smart, strong and good as boys. I hate this idea that you can’t be feminine and feminist – I believe you can and I bloody well will be!
Having said that, I think pink is for everybody who wants it to be for them. I know lots of boys who wear pink or own pink items and I say GO THEM! It’s just a colour.
If a little girl doesn’t like pink or traditionally ‘girly’ things, that’s fine. But I’m glad you wrote this piece, because people can get too caught up in trying to ensure their children don’t become gender stereotypes. I say let them play with what THEY want to play with!
I still dream of being a princess… I don’t think there is anything wrong with that.
loading...
I love my pink. So does my little girl. And nobody’s gonna stop me from buying her all the pink princess, Hello Kitty snd Barbies she wants.
loading...
A damn big goodonya, Anon !
loading...
Thanks Braddles! x
loading...
Ah anon, who’s stopping you? Or are you getting sucked into the article’s intended purpose- to whip up a little anti-feminist vibe?
loading...
I think this is a great article but it may have missed the point a bit on the reason why ‘pink’ and all things gender-norms are currently a point of discussion. There is nothing wrong with pink, femininity, princesses, or any other toy or experience targeted at young girls. The problem is the backlash that can occur when children deviate from what is considered the norm. So it is not the toys themselves that are the problem, but rather that there are very few socially acceptable avenues for children to explore their identities if they don’t fit the Barbie doll or action figure norm.
loading...
Exactly. Not to mention the deliberate marketing of pinky, sparkly things as being ONLY for girls and that girls’ toys are baking, sewing, mini stove type products, whilst cars and science kits are blue/boys stuff.
Google it, there was a blog post somewhere that compared toys marketed to girls and boys.
loading...
Great article – I completely agree! My sisters and I had a plethora of all things barbie and pink was the clothing colour of choice (much to our mum’s distaste), and all three of us are now educated, independent, ‘feminist’ women. I think the message is to let kids be kids, and not to weigh them down with our own concerns about gender constructs.
loading...
I don’t have a problem with pink. I do have a problem with it being the uniform and an indicator of boys and girls stuff. I refuse to dress my little girl in only pink “because she’s a girl”. I’m a girl, and I don’t wear use appliances and tools of any colour exclusively. Why should kids?
loading...
It’s one thing to be against stereotypes, and I am the first to agree that these can be pushed fairly insidiously through things like toys, hobbies that are pushed on girls (and boys, for that matter). But “girly” should never be a bad thing. Just like “being like a girl” should never be a sledge. Being a girl is awesome.
loading...
I’ll try again. There are extremists within feminism that would say that anything “girly” is bad, but that isn’t what feminism is about. The title shouldn’t say “Sorry feminism”. Feminism is about females and the feminine, so why would any true feminist be against that?
loading...
I’d be inclined to agree with you, Kris. Extremists within any movement do more harm than good to their cause. They certainly have, and continue to do harm to the positives that have been achieved.
loading...
Kris….you are a woman. They don’t like you using the word “girl” unless you are referring to a female child. I think that the word might even draw looks of dismay if directed at a female adolescent.
loading...
Yes, well if anyone is good at putting themselves down, it’s me.
Bradley – I heard a song on the radio before and thought of you. It’s a Dropkick Murphys xmas song. I think you will relate.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qTx-sdR6Yzk
loading...
I don’t have a problem with pink. I have pink clothes. I dress my daughter in pink. I just have a problem with ALL pink and how kids are being subliminally told that pink is a girl’s colour. I think you’re missing the point of the pink discussion.
I’m a primary school teacher and in my year one class earlier this year we did a graphing lesson on favourite colours. While the boys all had different favourite colours (red, yellow, green, blue) ALL 13 of the girls had a favourite colour of pink. It was a very interesting looking graph.
The other thing that is annoying is the toys that have two versions. More often these days there is a multi coloured version and a pink version of each toy. For example, I bought my daughter a water play table for her birthday and it came in a red / yellow / green version and a pink version. The colour of it does not affect the function so why is the pink version necessary? I bought the multi coloured version for my daughter.
Go ahead and say that it’s just a colour but when children are constantly bombarded with these messages they’ll grow up with ideas of where they fit in the world. It’s also more pervasive now then when we were young. While I played with barbies and dolls when I was little the pink message certainly wasn’t as strong.
loading...
It worries me that every single girl would choose pink – it definitely suggests that they’ve been somewhat programmed into making that choice. Like you, I have a problem with pink being pushed by marketers as THE colour for girls – my problem with that is as much out of concern for boys, who have just as much right to pink toys! So on a corporate/marketing level, yes, the issue of products for girls is much more complicated. It’s on the level of parenting that I feel we sometimes make a mountain out of a molehill with pink tutus and such.
loading...
What about when she asks for pink, every single day.
loading...
I’m the Mum. I can make the rules. She has a bit of pink, but not tons. I must admit, it is better this year than last with regard to clothes.
Also, you know, if it’s her asking, I can cope with that. What I have trouble with is pink being the only colour for girls, and that’s the way it is. It’s a bunch of crap.
loading...
Agreed, pink is just a colour when it comes down to it. It’s the way you live the rest of your life as their role model and the opportunities you offer kids that matter.
You can still be a powerful confident woman (be it engineer, CEO or SAHM), and still like pink.
loading...
Well said, Faybian. I’ve just done my bedroom in shell pink shades after years of resisting. It’s not very bloke friendly, but I find it calming.
loading...