Do You Like This Story?
invited Everyone is invited. Except you.

.

 

 

 

 

Yesterday a seven year old’s birthday party made me cry, and it wasn’t even my seven year old. My daughter Prima tearfully explained to me that every girl in her class, except her, had been invited to the party of a classmate (hereafter referred to as “Birthday Girl”). Apparently, the Birthday Girl had shown Prima the large pile of invitations for all the other little girls, before she handed them out.

I am not a Helicopter Mummy. I don’t hover around my children anxiously trying to protect them from emotional and physical harm. Not me. No, I’m not a Helicopter Mummy. I’m a goddamn Stealth Bomber Mummy meets Special Prosecutor Mummy.

Firstly, I called my mummy friends from Prima’s class to collect evidence. Seven year old girls are unreliable witnesses and whilst their mummies are more credible, the hearsay rule rendered most of their testimony inadmissible.

I needed to know whether or not Prima was the only girl who hadn’t been invited because this would affect my response to her. I knew I had to explain to Prima that she won’t get invited to every party in life but I was hoping that in this instance she was not being deliberately excluded.

So I proceeded with a pre-emptive strike. I called Birthday Girl’s mummy. Yes, I called Birthday Girl’s mummy, and, feigning nonchalance, I told her very politely that I was not calling to ask for an invitation, I was merely inquiring whether Prima was the only girl who was not invited to the party or could it be that the party was smaller and involved only some of the girls?

It was a leading question, I know, but the mother sounded panicky and I hadn’t even morphed into Crazy Mummy yet.  Turns out that all the girls in the class had been invited except Prima.

Later, as I kissed the tears from Prima’s eyelashes, I talked her through my Key Messages Matrix for this situation (I draft KMMs for many difficult situations. They’re not necessarily very good, but they help me manage my stress and remember what I wanted to say (I suffer from temporary amnesia under pressure).  I would really welcome editorial assistance as I am probably going to need this KMM again).

It went as follows:

1. Prima you are a kind and thoughtful girl. This is part of what makes you special

2. I know you feel hurt and sad right now and that is normal

3. To help yourself feel better, remember that you go to parties and play dates with other girls;

4. Also, remember Point1

5. And let me take you to Kmart, so you can choose any Littlest Pet Shop toy your broken heart desires.

Today, Birthday Girl’s mother gave Prima an invitation to the party, claiming that Birthday Girl had lost the original one. I didn’t want to accept it because I don’t want to be the mummy who muscles in on parties. I also want Prima to learn to deal with disappointment. But most of all, I really don’t want her to feel so hurt at such a young age. (Or ever).

But we are accepting the invitation because the look on my daughter’s face when she got it was worth more than my principles.

The whole incident reminded me that

1. there have been many parties I was not invited to that I have forgotten. Prima will forget too, at the time it hurt because being invited meant being included and we all want to be included;

2. children can be mean;

3. when mummies talk to me in the playground and ask me for coffee, I am always relieved and happy to be invited (and I am 37 not 7)

4. as Prima’s world expands, there will be more parties that she won’t be invited to, and greater disappointments, so maybe I should work on that Key Messages Matrix, or at the very least, stock up on Littlest Pet Shop toys for both of us.

Do you remember not being included in games or parties as a child? What about as an adult? How do you react when you aren’t included?

Shankari Chandran is a recent returner after ten years in London. Formerly a social justice lawyer, she now uses her skills to keep the peace between her four children, a husband and a sometimes live-in mother-in-law. Shankari chronicles the day-to-day of her family’s return in her blog.

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

459 Comments so far

  1. Lucy Ormonde

    This story really resonated with me. When I was 10, the ‘cool’ girl at school was having a party at Luna Park. I didn’t get invited, but she told me I was on the emergency list and that I could come to the party if someone else couldn’t make it.
    Turns out I did get to go and I was stoked. But looking back on it now, I wish I could go back in time and tell her to stick it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • katehunter

      The ‘emergency list?’ WTF????

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Lucy Ormonde

        I KNOW! Girls are mean.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Meg

          My sister and I were once invited to a friend’s party because another set of twins couldn’t go (her words). When I asked my mum, she said no because it seemed like we were simply alternatives. Ha! I’m glad she did that.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • MotherR

          Goodness! An emergency list? It’s not so much that the girls are mean but that their parents are not guiding them correctly with regard to good manners, compassion and just simply being a decent human being.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • Ms P

        My husband I I were left off a wedding invite as the happy couple had so many friends. We later found out we were on an “emergency B list”!! Didn’t bother us in the slightest but another couple caused such an almighty stink they were hastily put onto the “in crowd” A list!! Lol

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  2. aprill

    I have been one of those parents helping out in the classroom several times. I know all the kids by name to look at them, but if I were writing out invitations for all the boys (I have sons), I wouldn’t know if I was missing one or not. I would *probably* take the word of my kid (foolish, I know) that that was all there was. I call “oversight” on this case, and the BG’s mother felt slack and didn’t want to fess up.

    My 7yo raced home from school the other day and insisted Birthday Boy was at Mutual Friend’s house having his party and that he had been invited to attend. Lucky I trusted my Spidey sense because I then rang Birthday Boy’s mother and she explained that “no, Mutual Friend is coming to our house to play with Birthday Boy. There’s no party. Isn’t it funny the stuff they come home with?” And then promptly changed the subject. Yes, I had to deal with resultant tears but I’m not muscling in on someone else’s arrangements.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Frankie

    My kids have missed out sometimes and been sad, been invited other times and been thrilled. I would never, ever allow my kids to organise and write their own invitations. They can’t possibly understand the impacts. But this is not the case in many families, so I use it as a ‘what not to do’ life lesson. Even moreso if it’s some other kid left out. It does make me feel really sad at different times, but just as the world can feel like a beautiful place at times, it can also feel really crap and cut throat.

    My kids have a party every second year, it’s party year this year (3 in 3 weeks – give me strength). They go to a very small school so invite their year group rather than their class (around 8 or so kids) and any other special friend from the town or ballet or whatever. I am not a fan of massive party celebrations and ours are the fruit platter, fairy bread go nuts for 2 hours style of party. My son is turning 10 so he might do something a bit different as a rite of passage/double figures occasion, but I don’t know what yet.

    I don’t buy into the kids party competition as I truly and honestly don’t care. My kids have a fantastic time at their parties which have none of the trimmings. no clowns, no ponies, limited expense. They’ve had fun at parties which are like that too, but it’s not the way we run our family.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • bowerbird

      3 in 3 weeks? Have you ever thought of staggering them between the alternate years??

      And I am 100% with you on the style of party. Ours are limited to pass-the-parcel, balloons with lollies inside, maybe some water fun. The kids still have a ball!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Frankie

        I have thought of it, but it seems better to go hard then go home. The ‘off’ year is great. My kids love their parties, I love the idea of their parties, but the actual living through the parties I find a bit hard core.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • bowerbird

          *nods* Fair call :)

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Anonymous

      Good luck Frankie … I have 4 in two weeks and survived party year this August beautifully! Don’t need to see another patty cake or cheezel for a while but I did it! Go hard or go home – love it!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  4. rainbow

    if i could high five you, hug you and ask you out for coffee i would right now.

    i think that is really, really nasty. i have had several parties for my kids, and i either invite all or some. never all minus one. there is a very big difference.

    the thing you have to remember is that says nothing about you and prima, but A LOT about the other mum. how she can encourage her daughter to exclude at such a young age makes her look so bitchy. but you can bet your bottom dollar she was an alpha girl at primary school. shame she has clearly forgotten she has left primary school.

    i know some comments below have been negative, but i think they need to remember that we need to teach our children to treat others well and be kind. if we all grew up with those principles the world would be a better place.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Meg

    My twin sister and I have received so many ‘courtesy invites’ that I’ve lost count.

    We’ve been part of completely different friendship groups our whole lives, yet so many of our friends invited the other because they felt like they had to. It was probably the worst thing they could do. My sister and I recognised that we had different friends and would be invited to different birthdays. So, when we would both turn up at a birthday surrounded by people that only one of us knew well, the other was always going to have that lingering sense that they were intruding on an event where they didn’t fit in.

    As we got older, I told people not to invite my sister (and she did this as well) unless they genuinely wanted to, not because they felt obliged to. It worked for most of the time. Sometimes I guess people just want more guests at their parties.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • wec-chick

      My daughter knows twins and is always invited to their birthday parties. The invitation lists both girls but my daughter is better friends with one of the girls and every year we struggle with the question of whether we buy both girls a present, or just the girl my daughter is better friends with. Was this an issue for you as you grew up, and if so, what did you do about it?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Meg

        Hmm.. when we were younger, our separate friends would usually buy both of us presents, but as we’ve got older (we’ve just turned 21) it’s normal (and preferable) to only get presents from our close friends. I’ve always preferred it that way because I’d rather not get a present from someone who felt like they had to, their presence is enough.

        Having said that, if they’re primary school age, it’s probably safer to get presents for both. Maybe your daughter could get the girl who she’s closer with a slightly better or more personal present?

        Being friends with twins is complicated, isn’t it! :P

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • wec-chick

          Thanks for the thoughts. I especially like the idea of getting a slightly better present for the twin my daughter is closer to. The other twin issue we’ve had it that when my daughter has had birthday parties she’s always wondered whether to invite one or both girls. You are right – twins can be complicated.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • ParisChic

        My (twin) sisters usually got things “to share” if they didn’t both know the guest. Eg just buy a present, write both their names on the card – chances are they will end up sharing it anyway.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  6. mrssavage

    This is why I feel physically ill at the thought of my son starting preschool next year. I am thinking of getting a t-shirt made up for his first day that says, “we don’t do parties”. I’m sure I’ll make lots of friends.

    Do we all want to spend our kid’s entire educational journey ferrying them around to parties every weekend? Between that and the half a dozen extra-curricular activities no wonder kids are battling anxiety disorders!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • katehunter

      Don’t stress about it. If your kid gets an invitation to a party YOU don’t want to go to, for whatever reason, just say thanks, but we’re busy. ‘Doing nothing, just hanging with the family’ is a perfectly valid reason to feign an excuse to get out of a preschool party. It gets trickier as kids get older and form genuine friendships, but time is on your side. Keep your powder dry!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  7. Kate o

    I can empathise completely with the mother and the daughter, school yard politics can be harsh but has anyone thought maybe there was a reason that the birthday girl didn’t want prima invited, perhaps prima had had an altercation with the others. However It is sad and embarrassing for everyone involved that these events occurred. I hope the birthday girls mother doesn’t read this because I know it’d make me feel like I was bullied and vilified! To respond on here doesn’t seem very mature and graceful. I feel for your daughter but I dont think responding in this manner is appropriate

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Jo

      My impression from reading the post was not that the author was necessarily having a go at the birthday girl’s mother but rather was about the very real feelings that occur that can occur as a result of not being invited. Even if a child has caused an alteration of some sorts and has thus been excluded (which I am not saying happened), the feelings of being excluded remain.
      My own feelings are that I would give the birthday girl’s mother the benefit of the doubt – she may have thought everyone was invited. To leave one child out deliberately seems unfair.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kate o

        Yes fair call, I can appreciate that more now. Thanks Jo!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  8. Sailorgal

    Thanks Shankari – your KMMs have gone straight to the pool room [aka notes on iphone - I may even be able to open them up subtially and read them when I have distressing incident with my kids]. Please write some more KMMs.

    What I hate about hosting a whole of class kids party include
    - quite a few of the kids take it for granted
    - its a bloody lot of work – especially at home or in park
    - my kids get given a whole heap of toys that they seem to take for granted because they have so many anyway (just a normal amount comparing to others but way more than I had growing up)- and some of them are just crap – and overall I think the presents are a waste of the other parents money (and time spent buying them – unless you run a presents drawer). Really just chuck $5 in a hat when you come in and my kids can go buy one box of lego of their choice and they would be happy.
    - so end of day – would rather just have a few of their best friends over or to a movie

    Right – that was a bit of a dump. Gearing up for Mr 5′s party and he has such high expectations! Aagh!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. Louie

    Wow, I find this really over the top. I don’t think that it is very nice that your daughter was not invited but that is life. Do you always take her shopping when she suffers some disappointment?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      I agree, as was ringing the birthday girls mum. Too pushy.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • No Use for a Name

      Louie I think that’s rather harsh to sit and pass judgement on Shankari right now. Maybe you should keep your judgements to yourself.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Gabby

      I’d not only take her shopping, I would have taken her out to dinner too. And let her order desert.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Lulu

      Okay, if you don’t approve of shopping, what do *you* do when your small child suffers a disappointment? Say “Life’s tough, princess – stop complaining”?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anonymous

      Sometimes I take my kids shopping to cheer them up. Other times I take them on some sort of excursion, anything from Dreamworld to the local cafe, depending how bad I feel for them. They’ll get enough of ‘real life’ when they’re older.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • alyssakt

        or they mightn’t be able to handle real life when they’re older. Time will tell!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Anonymous

        Or they just grow up not learning about disappointment!!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Anon

          Just because the kid gets taken out for a treat does not mean they don’t still have to deal with the disappointment! Kids aren’t silly. How many of us now will have a stiff drink or eat something we shouldn’t after a bad news day?

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  10. Jennifer

    In 1974 I was having a birthday party…I was 8…I handed out invitations and recieved RSVP’S from everyone saying they were coming…on the day my mother and I cut strawberries, made red jelly cups,decorated the house,wrapped the presents for pass the parcel…I was so excited. We had balloons,cake,prizes…the lot!! NO ONE SHOWED UP. Since that day I have despised my birthday. Looking back now I am older I bet my parents were more up set than me. Bless my mother…she took the party bags to school and handed them out to all the girls…with a big smile.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      I can’t understand why people would say they are coming and then all not show up? Is there some background to the story?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jennifer

        Yes…we I was new at the school and we had just arrived in Sydney fro the U.K and believe it or not in 1974 as a family we were considered “funny” because of our half English half Danish accents. Also it was a small country school and all the girls had been friends for years and all their mother were friendly with each other also.

        I did end up making friends with alot of the girls and we all moved to high school together…but never did I host another party. xx

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Jb

          The same thing happened to me once jennifer,only topped by the party where the two girls who lived next door left in a huff only to return later and ask for their present back! I too hate birthday celebrations now.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Jackie

          OMG some of these stories are terrible – people are quick to call children ‘precious’ but some of the stories people are sharing here only proves how traumatic childhood cruelty can be!

          My mum was a Pommy immigrant and we had it drilled into us constantly: “BE NICE TO THE NEW KID” if we announced someone had started at school, it was always “WELL DID YOU TRY TO BEFRIEND THEM AND SHOW THEM AROUND?”

          Funnily enough, one of my best friends still remembers my kindness from her first day of starting a new school in year 11 – so I guess it pays off!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Sammy

      I feel your pain!! This happened to me twice! I was turning 7 and I had invited 30 kids, those who didnt respond we called the few days before just to confirm only for me to be the only one there… When I turned 13 I invited what I thought was my closest 8 friends, 3 showed up but the rest went to the movies instead next to where my party was held

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Leanne

        This happened often to my youngest. So many RSVP in the affirmative only to not turn up because they got a better offer. It makes me soooo angry!

        I’ve always brought my girls up by the rule that if you say yes, you turn up. Doesn’t matter that someone else asked you to do something you thought might have been more exciting after you’ve said yes, you go where you said you were going first.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Leni

      How awful people can be! I’ve not had this happen but did have a very bad experience on my birthday one year and ever since I’ve hated it just like you. Your mother sounds amazing though.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Cordeline

      Oh that’s awful!

      This is the kind of thing in adulthood that I call ‘function anxiety’. When you are organising a party socially or an event for work and you fret that no-one will show up.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Shannon

      I love that your mum took the lolly bags to school. My mum taught me this too – when I came home crying (in Year 10 no less) because one of my friends had given out Easter Eggs to everyone but me, right in front of me, mum asked what I was going to do. When I said I wasn’t giving any out she suggested that instead I give eggs to everyone just as I had originally planned because its called ‘heaping hot coals’. It’s actually from Proverbs in the Bible, and while I don’t adhere to a vengeful God, it says “If your enemy is hungry, give him food to eat; if he is thirsty, give him water to drink. In doing this, you will heap burning coals on his head.” By doing the right thing by those who have done the wrong thing by us they can see the shame of their own behavior and we can let go of our hurt. I gave everyone an Easter egg with a genuine spirit of generosity and instead of feeling like a victim of hurtful behavior I felt like a strong person who makes decisions independent of others behavior. Thanks Mum.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Loves2bake

        Awesome Shannon. I’m going to remember that, not only for my boys as they get older, but for myself as well :)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Anonymous

        I think what you’re actually doing is rewarding bad behaviour.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Shannon

          The point is that the situation ceased to be about her behavior and became about mine. It taught me that while I can’t control how others act I am in complete control of how I act and I should always be true to my values – one of which is not to publicly exclude someone for any reason.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  11. Melany

    Good on you for standing up for your little girl. It’s totally natural to feel pained at what has happened – it’s definitely a mother’s instinct to protect their children from pain. I think you got the best outcome possible from a bad situation. Children can be so mean sometimes – I think I dislike this Birthday Girl!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. WendyH

    Gosh, even *I* want to cry! My heart breaks for both of you.
    As a mum to a not-yet 2 year old, I already worry about how to protect her from the meanness in the world. To protect her from the kind of hurt that your poor Prima just experienced.
    I hope that I’m up to the task of loving her and encouraging her and equipping her with as much self-confidence as I can so that when something like this happens, which it surely must, it leaves as small a bruise as possible. I constantly tell her, you are smart, you are precious, you are clever, you are important, you are LOVED. Is that enough?
    I think just as important is to teach her not just how to cope with the meanness but perhaps more so, never to BE the meanness. Fill her up with love and praise and also teach her how to do the same for others.
    You’re doing an AWESOME job of being a mum to her and she is lucky to have one like you. Love your KMM!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • bbubbles

      loved that part of “The Help”

      “You is kind. You is smart. You is important.”
      (is it sad that I say this to myself at 40ish?)

      The world can be a mean place. My girl was in the same situation. I wish I had handled it the same way you did Shankari. I just held her and dried her tears. You are a good mum… and you is kind, you is smart, and you is important.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  13. christinedavie

    i want to know what birthday girl’s mum said – it is NOT ON to not invite 1 kid…either invite about half the girls or boys or class but do not leave out 1. that is mean & thoughtless. Poor little Prima and mumma. I am LOL at off to kmart to buy crappy plastic toy to cheer her up – i would do the same thing and be mad at myself too!! Whatever has gone b/w the two kids that mum has done the wrong thing. especially allowing her daughter to flaunt the pile of invites….good on you for calling her on it – awkward as that was…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. Anonymous

    Birthday parties are really hard. A similar thing happened to us two weeks ago, except it was the mother making a big deal to me about why my daughter wasn’t invited to her daughter’s 7th birthday party. Apparently her daughter just doesn’t like my daughter. Nice.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Kelley

    I want to find that mother and hunt her down. What a complete b#$ch and what an awful lesson to her child. How pathetic and revolting must she be. I get the issue of not being able to invite everyone but oh Lord…My almsot 9 yr old is faced with the choice of friends at her party and she has invited her close group of 5 of them (what I call the Zone I group) and a couple of Zone 2s, and I have made her invite one of the girls in her basketball team who is not even a zone 3 friend but is autistic, her mother is lovely, and I know it would mean so much more to her than any of the other “popular’ potential Zone 2s. Just so important to teach kids empathy and to eliminate this awful obsession with looks and popularity.
    Bit incoherent of me, sorry, but I hope it makes sense.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. Cordeline

    Poor Prima! She is very lucky to have you as a mum.

    I can’t see myself ever allowing a whole class of kids to one my daughters’ birthday parties. Still, I am sure I will be presented with the idea at some stage in the future!

    I agree with many people below… you either invite everyone in the class, or just have a small party.

    At my eldest daughter’s kinder last week, it was one of the other girl’s birthday. I wished her a big happy birthday and asked her if she had had a nice day and if she was going to have a party (just as you do with kids). Her mother was standing beside her and kind of just of moved her daughter along to talk to someone else. On the way home, I thought she probably felt like I had put her on the spot wondering about a party of if my daughter would be invited! I was a bit mortified as that had not even crossed my mind. Especially considering I know that my daughter and this particular birthday girl are not friends (not enemies, but they just don’t play together)

    Let’s encourage a trend MM parents out there – why not post the invitations? That way, there is no awkwardness around handing them out at school PLUS kids get a huge kick out of receiving something in the letterbox.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. Leni

    I don’t remember this happening to me as a young child but when I was in Year 10 I didn’t get invited to another girl’s party. Our friendship group was about 50 girls and guys, and I was the only one who wasn’t invited. What made it worse was how she’d talk about it in front of me, and then give me a pitying look. I still remember it and how hurt it made me feel. I look back and wish I had stood up for myself.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  18. Kylie L

    I love point 5. EXACTLY what I would have done (and hidden the evidence from my husband, who would be appalled. Easy to do when my own girl already has eleventy bazillion My Littlest Pet Shops).

    This sort of stuff is a parenting KILLER. Kids can be so cruel- why do little (and maybe big) girls in particular seem to enjoy the exclusion game so much? I make a point of sending my daughter’s invitations out by mail, so as not to upset the kids that aren’t invited. Maybe that’s a bit helicopterish, but we only usually have 3 or 4 guests from a class of 25 and I have been in the room before and watched the kids watching hopefully as invites are distributed- then their shoulders sag when they realise they’re not getting one. I can’t take it!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. bec

    Seriously, what sort of parent allows their child to invite everyone except one child to a party!!!

    When they were younger, my kids had the rule of “invite as many people as your age plus one” and yes, there have been times when I have pointed out that they have nominated everyone but one or two peers and we’ve talked about how they would feel if that was them. My kids have always been happy to err on the side of common decency and invite the extras, but as they get older thankfully they discriminate more and really only want to invite their few closest friends.

    One daughters school actually made a note of asking parents to either ask the whole class (or all the girls in the class if it’s a girls party) or to limit it to a few friends, seems to be working well.

    As for the grand handing out of invites, I remember that well, even up to the point of not being given a 21st birthday invitation when they were handed out at uni (see you’re never too old to feel rejected!). My strategy for this is to talk to my girls about how much everyone loves to receive mail and we post (yep, the old fashioned way) invitations. That spares the awkwardness of having to explain why some people aren’t receiving invitations.

    thanks for the thoughtful post

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Ellie

      Yes, I feel as if this is a little more to blame on the parents (ie. the people writing the invitations and funding the party) than the kid. Even if she did say she didn’t like Prima … the parents would have known she was the only girl not invited with the number of class lists and school photos and performances there are. How mean! Very luckily my primary school class was never more than 20 kids so the whole grade was invited to everyones parties or it was all girls (about 12) or all boys (the rest). High school and beyond is another story … just this month I have been “forgotten” three times. But I have a simple rule, you don’t invite me, I won’t invite you! It gets the message across to older mean girls pretty quick that I can give as good as I get.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  20. Noelle

    Three words: first world problem.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Cordeline

      Our lives are full of FWP’s.

      We are all affected differently by each of our challenges. And consoling your own child when they have been socially excluded is definitely a challenge.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jennifer

        Two Words…well said!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Anonymous

          We live in the first world. Problems are relative.

          All the problems spoken about on here are first world problems. We couldn’t actually talk about second or third world problems with any great meaning, because as far as I see, most readers don’t live in the second or third world, or for the most part, have a truly first-hand understanding of the associated problems.

          That was a pretty superior-sounding comment, really.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • vic

        thefeeling of being excluded is no just a fwp it’s universal

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • JJ

        Well said! The poor child doesn’t know the difference between first world problems or otherwise. She knows nothing but rejection right now.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Elizabeth

      Yes but if we can be the best parents we can be for our kids… they can grow up and help the WHOLE world.

      I realise this comment is silly but so was yours.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anja

      One word: judgemental.

      Do you think nobody has a right to complain or feel unhappy about their life, simply because they live in a developed country? I’m sure you complain about things all the time.
      Sure, we all need perspective but to simply dismiss this mother’s problem because she isn’t a starving mother in Africa is a bit rude.

      The Birthday Girl in this post had the problem of not understanding how her actions make people feel and I think you should take a lesson in that too.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • mamaruns

      If you want to see some real first world problems, go to Whitewhine.com. This is not in the same league. The bigger picture here is about exclusion, which I am not sure is limited to first world school kids.

      This topic seems to resonate with a lot of people, so perhaps the solution is: don’t read it if you feel it is frivolous.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jb

        I am the first to bemoan first world problems but I think that is a very unfair comment to make here; the author did not decree that this was an earth shattering issue of universal relevance but was seeking to relate an experience and share some thoughts on a topic, this is a parenting issue that is very relevant to many obviously and for the individuals concerned would be upsetting. It is clearly important to many reading and your glib rejection of it in a sneering tone denotes a lack of compassion on your part.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • mamaruns

          Um, just so we are clear Jb, my comment was in response to Noelle. I objected to her trivializing it as a first world problem on the basis that the issue of exclusion is not just limited to the first world. We seem to agree.. was your reply supposed to be for my comment? I’m a bit confused if it was, and apologise if my message sounded sneering.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • bowerbird

      My two small children are healthy, well-fed, have plenty of warm clothes and a comfortable house. Does that mean I should shrug my shoulders and casually dismiss anything that causes them hurt or sadness? Or be completely unconcerned about developing in them empathy and concern for other well-fed and housed kids? Thanks Noelle, I’d no idea parenting could be so easy.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anonymous

      You reckon? I bet you there are some kids in second and third world countries with the same problem. Social exclusion hurts regardless of whether you live in a first world country or not.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • MissV

        i read the “first world problem” as someone complaining about something they don’t agree with on the internet, which in turn, is also a first world problem.

        tad hypocritical really.

        xxxmissvxxx.wordpress.com

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  21. Melb40

    I can’t believe you rang the mother. So your daughter wasn’t invited – it’s sad and hurtful but it’s their choice You’re being just as rude to call and ask about the invite, so obviously putting the birthday girls mother on the spot. You’ve stooped to their level.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      @Melb40:
      so you think sophisticated bullying is something we should ignore?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        There’s no background information as to why the girl didn’t invite Prima.

        Who knows what’s happened between the girls? There are many reasons why they might not be friends, and at some point in life we need to understand and accept each others differences, move on and do our own thing.

        I’m not suggesting it easy – as a 21yo in a tiny university course I was excluded from a 21st which everyone else in the course went too – but in hindsight, I understand what went on and why. Hurt at the time though.

        Lessons in life hurt, they’re hard – but they’re called lessons. It’s not bullying to exclude someone from a party.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  22. katehunter

    Whole-class parties for pre-schoolers are nightmarish. Confession time: When my child got an invite to the party of a kid they didn’t know well, and if said invite wasn’t seen, I have been known to politely decline and never tell my kid there was an invitation in the first place.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Clare M

      I have done that many times!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anonymous

      What happens if they go to school and everyones talking about the party? Or the birthday boy/girl asks if their coming/why they weren’t there?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • katehunter

        I’m talking about under 5s. In my experience littlies parties aren’t discussed much by the kids themselves before or after the event. It’s always more of a talking point between parents.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  23. jessie

    When I was about 10, a girl in the other year 6 class invited all of my friends (excluding me) to her birthday party even though she didn’t know any of them very well.

    I held a grudge against her but didn’t show that it bothered me. Instead I told myself that the best revenge is to show you are better than the person. I ended up having a seriously epic party that she was very aware she didn’t get invited to.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. AnthonySherratt

    Oh this broke my heart. I can’t believe another parent had a part in this. How could you? But i loved the line where the look on her daughter’s face was worth more than principle. It’s easy to forget that when emotions are involved. I think Prima has a great Mummy and will grow up wonderfully by the looks of it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. Anon today!

    I hate the culture of inviting the whole class. Its fake and insincere. Birthday child cant possibly like every kid in the class and I think its encouraging dishonesty to pretend they do. I understand how little feelings can be hurt when they are the only one left out, but there may just be a simple personality clash between Prima and Birthday girl and mum thought it would be too stressful to manage while running a party. Kids also can have firm ideas about who they do and dont want, even at 7.
    I have received that phone call myself not long ago, from a mother questioning why her daughter wasnt invited to my daughters party. Apart from being taken aback and shocked I was really upset by it. Her daughter has large indulgent parties every year with up to 30 kids at each one. I dont approve of that, so I was offended by her questioning my parenting choices. This was my daughters first party in 3 years and she had invited 6 children. The mother told me she invites everyone so nobody is left out and upset, like I had obviously just done. I wanted to tell mum that she had created a monster by doing this and her daughter wasnt actually someone whose friendship we were encouraging because each time we have had her in our house she has stolen things. I couldnt say that though because mum is obviously blinkered to her childs faults. So I just had to explain that we had to draw the line at 6 kids and there was no exclusion intended, we just couldnt invite everyone.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Such a sensible comment from Anon today! I agree.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • marmalady

      I hear what you’re saying and I agree. All-inclusive massive parties are not within everyone’s budget or taste. And why, for example, should a child from the class be invited when they have bullied your child or your child just really doesn’t like them? As adults we choose our friends, our kids have preferences too. I wouldn’t agree with an exclusion out of meanness or nastiness, and wouldn’t agree with excluding just the one person. But I see nothing wrong with choosing a few genuine friends out of the class.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anonymous

      I invite the whole class to my kids parties. I’m not ‘fake and insincere’ and neither are my kids. I don’t expect everyone to do the same but if my family want to invite everyone I don’t see why we shouldn’t. And no it’s not a present-grab, we specify ‘no presents’ on the invitations. I don’t think encouraging my kids to be friendly with, or at least polite to, all their classmates is ‘encouraging dishonesty’.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anon today!

        I encourage my kids to be polite and friendly to all their peers too, they just dont have to invite the kids who are mean to them or who they simply dont get on with. My son insisted we didnt invite one boy, who is an alpha type kid, to his party last year. When we pressed him for the reason he told us he was too bossy and didnt want him to take over his party. I thought that was fair enough, afterall its to celebrate my childs birthday, not to keep the bossy kid and his parents happy.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  26. Kb

    My son wanted to invite everyone in his kindy class bar one girl to his party we had at the park. No way said I, that would make her really upset. Invite some or all, you can’t just leave one out. So the invite went out and my son was rewarded by the fact she didn’t come. I didn’t even get a decline from her parents. But I’m glad she was invited

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Jac Qld

      I agree. If there is a large number being invited, one more won’t make a difference. Yes, it may be your child’s party, but I think that it is important to learn from an early age about not unnecessarily hurting peoples feelings.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Dani

      Exactly! It’s not particularly about whether you have small parties or whole-class parties – but leaving just one person out is horrid.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  27. contented

    Firstly, love the memory tricks. Just beautiful.

    What I really want to say is that it baffles me when we all complain about how children can be so mean and nasty and how there is much more bullying etc around nowadays. I understand that some kids can just be like that. But come one. It’s all about the parenting. What parent would do that to one child??? Surely the Mum of the party girl should have said that not inviting Prima was unkind and so not okay. I have a feeling that her house will be a nightmare when her girl is a teenager. I’m sure that won’t be true of Shankari’s house.

    We need to value kindness and courtesy – and out kids never well if we don’t model it and teach it and insist on it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Elizabeth

      So true. How was Birthday Girl going to know that it was unkind to invite all but Prima IF her parents didnt talk her through it. That is why 7 year olds have parents ;-)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  28. Deb H

    i am 37 and still remember not being invited to a party when i was 10, and all the other girls in my circle were invited…i still remember crying about it to my mum

    last year at kindy my daughter did not get invited to a single party. not one, for the whole year. at least the invites were given out discretely and my girl was non the wiser, but i knew……i have mentioned it recently to another mum from the kindy, she was horrified. her son didn’t get invited to every party, but he did get some invites. i do think it was because of her brothers (they have autism), i think the parents just thought if they invited my daughter, then i would show up with the screaming boys as well, and they didn’t want that at their party. so instead of acting like grown-ups and discussing it with me, they decided the best course of action was to exclude my 5 yr old. nice.

    this year Miss 6 had a party. if she wanted boys and girls, there was a limit of 9 people that she could invite (so 10 including her). if she wanted all girls, she could invite all the girls in her class. there are only 11 girls in her class, there was no way (especially based on my childhood experience) i was going to be responsible for 1 little girl feeling excluded.

    good on you for standing up for your daughter!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Deb H

      and i meant to add, at least in my daughters class it can be done discretely….all the kids have folders that go home with notes, etc…..so the mummies sneak into the classroom and put the invites in the folder! or give to the teacher to put in the folder. at least that way there is no “grand handing out of invitations” in front of other kids who are not invited

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • vanessayoung

        I feel for Deb H . People are so ignorant about ASD and about how we are handling things with our kids and their siblings outside of school hours. One thing we have had at kindy and junior primary is the tradition of cupcakes (made with people’s dietary requirements in mind) at the end of the school day.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  29. jennyblume

    Birthday parties are minefields! I’ve found that it’s sometimes the birthday child who decides not to hand out all of the invitations … the mother often has no idea, and just thinks the lack of response is rude. So frustrating on so many levels!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. auscrawl

    What a bitchy act by that family!

    On our street all the kids were invited except my son similar aged one, and the 2 girls next door. What annoyed me was yes the little brats started a game of drawing on their coloured driveway one day and my son didn’t know any better (got bailed up by the dad) but he was usually welcome at their house and the kids across the road who went were awful bullies. He asked to go to their house seeing all these kids out the front. I thought it was after the party so I said ok he could ask to go for a swim. I was mortified to find out the party hadn’t started and put on the spot they had to invite him..eekk. I was so embarrased when I went to collect him so he didn’t stay too long, but with an intellectual disability and only about 6 at the time he was clueless about what had actually happened.

    If you have a child with special needs even a well behaved friendly high functioning one, you are suprised on rare occasions when they get an invite.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anon

      Parties are for competing among parents methinks. It’s parents living vicariously through their children. Frankly it’s pretty repulsive. My nieces had a party in kindergarten and some of the kids weren’t allowed to come because my mother (who was living with them at the time) had Alzheimer’s and would think other kids were her grandkids and parents were offended because she would be affectionate with their children in ‘another language’. She didn’t speak English. My nieces were pretty devastated and none of us ever told them why most of their friends didn’t come.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anon this time

      Yes, my cousin is step mum to a disabled girl who is about 8 who attends a mainstream school. She NEVER gets invited to parties and my cousin and her husband find it very upsetting. Thankfully the girl doesn’t realise what is happening.

      I have a brother with a special needs child and he and his wife (based on the experience of our cousin) and dreading having to face the fact that their son may not be invited to any parties. It’s awful, people can be terrible mean – and that’s the parents I’m talking about, not just the children!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • auscrawl

        At the special needs school the families are often out of town are have income restricted by being registered carers, so not a lot of parties going on.

        I used to send a cake and treats for lunchtime for his class to just skip the whole headache.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  31. Oh, god…the same thing happened to me when I was a kid…!!

    *dials therapist*

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  32. B's Mummy

    I remember one of my birthday parties. I had invited all of my friends and I had thought we were actually friends. We had sleepovers and I had been to their parties. Everyone RSVP’d and only one person showed up and they were an hour late.

    I was always excluded as a child even when it was my own party and it still actually makes me feel sad even today.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Mel

      Oh, that’s awful..

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  33. Langers

    This has happened to me. I was 12 and every single person in the class, boys and girls, was invited except for me. I cried and cried and the following Monday at school I had never felt more alone. I wasn’t a weird kid with no friends, I was well liked, just this young girl was particulary cruel.

    Bad news is your daughter will never forget it, good news is she will learn a fantastic life lesson of treating others how you wish to be treated.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • honey&spice

      I totally agree.. same thing happened to me in primary school some children can be so mean!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  34. Margaret Jolly

    Good on you. I have been in situations where I have MADE my children invite someone to a party so as not to offend or hurt. More recently my 18 year old didn’t really want to invite one of her former school friends to her 18th but I said I would rather spend the money than risk hurting someone’s feelings and so should she. If they were not going to be friends long term it will drift away but that will happen over time not over one night. I’m glad I insisted. They are still friends!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. Leanne

    My kids are long since grown up and I can’t remember if this came up. Knowing me though, I probably just shrugged it off with a ‘well, that’s rude, she’s not very nice is she – here look at this shiny thing’ type of comment.

    Party rules surely have changed.

    I do like your KMMs cause I also have amnesia under pressure. A brilliant idea. I wonder if I can adapt that for work situations??

    :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. blondage

    My mum had the same rules for my sister and I as many other mums…
    Either we could invite 4 friends each OR the whole class.

    If the party was out and about (movies, bowling, maccas, HJ’s, etc) then we were only allowed 4 friends each.

    We choose to have a party at home, we could invite the entire class.

    Most of the time we choose to have a party at home because it meant we could invite LOTS of kids! :)

    I’ll be doing the same with Squiggle when he reaches that age – either have an outting party where he can only invite 4 friends, or a home party where he can invite everyone.

    http://thefridgedoorblog.com

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. Erin

    At 21, I worked in an office with about 8 other women, one of whom was quite snide towards me at times, despite my best efforts to win her over. (I don’t like not being liked!)

    I tried, SO hard to please her, but I realised this was futile when one Christmas our boss took us all out for lunch. The NC (Nasty Cow) from the office presented each and every female staff member with a Christmas card, complete with tacky flashing LED badge….. except me.

    I sobbed my little heart out into the payroll lady’s shoulder! (I was pregnant, so emotional anyway… but so was NC (and she was also a good 10 years older than me, so should’ve known better, really!)

    I’ll never forget the hurt and shame of being left out….. I hope my girls (now 5 & 3) never have to feel this way! (And I ensure we don’t cause this kind of pain either…. although our last birthday party with 70+ children and a jumping castle was somewhat risque!)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nico

      Ugh. I hate that it can continue on from primary school to ‘grown up world’….where you had always assumed, as a child, that this doesn’t happen! What a horrid woman.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  38. MissV

    i think that you handled the situation really well.
    Poor Prima.
    and i do hope that the girl losing the invitation was the truth because if Prima was the only girl not invited, well that just makes me angry thinking about it.

    xxxmissvxxx.wordpress.com

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. monnie

    It’s heart breaking to see your child hurt, especially when they are hurt by others.

    Kids are mean. Part of this is developmental…and not necessarily meant to be vindictive, just part of their developmental journey from a egocentric, instant gratifying little being to, hopefully, a compassionate and inclusive adult. They are trying to find their place in their social worlds and sometimes that means they stomp on others. Not nice, but I sort of get it. Unfortunately, it’s part of the journey…and it is meant to be a temporary phase.

    But…what I don’t get is how a parent can let their child send out invitations to all but one. Wouldn’t you check…if not with your child at least with the teacher…or do a head count when you drop your child off? That just seems nasty…and uncaring. What happened to ‘do unto others as you want others to do to you’…or ‘if you don’t want your child left out, don’t leave other people’s kids out’.

    I’m a therapist who works with kids with social skills difficulties so I see the rejection stuff everyday. In fact, I’m sure it’s my childhood scars of rejection (and thankfully it wasn’t huge), that propelled me into the work that I do today.

    The KMM is lovely…gorgeous. Prima sounds beautiful. I don’t think there is anything more beautiful than a kind hearted, thoughtful person. It is something very special and I hope that Prima can see her treasures.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  40. Peta

    About a month ago I took my daughter to kindy and we were sitting on the mat (parents and children) just before the parents all got up to leave. A little girl walked in with her mum and had a stack of invitations in her hand. The mum proceeded to read the name of every little girl in the class off of the invitations and the little girl walked around and handed them out. This wasn’t done in front of the whole class and if you weren’t sitting close by you may have been oblivious but my daughter and I were sitting RIGHT NEXT TO THEM!

    As all of the names were read out, one by one, my daughter slowly rose off her seat, she leaned over in front of the girl so she couldn’t possibly see that she wasn’t there and by the end she started whispering to me “mummy, where’s my invitation? Why hasn’t she given one to me?”

    I tried to distract her and change the subject and was praying there would be an invitation with her name on it. Finally, the very last invitation in the pile was hers and she was ecstatic. Her face lit up and she was so happy. I was fully preparing myself for devastation (just in case) and I was heart-broken to see how much she wanted it and knowing how upset she would be if she didn’t get one.

    That one worked out fine and it turns out that every girl in the class was invited (and a couple of the boys). Just a note to parents though…….if you’re going to have a party and you are handing out invitations please please please either invite everyone or make it discreet. It may not seem like a big deal but to a 4 year old, missing out on a party invitation when everyone else is going means the world!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Peta

      ….as an aside, I’ve loved every piece you’ve written for Mamamia Shankari. I can relate so much to what you have to say!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  41. Beka

    Wow! Well done mum on the way you handled the situation. :) Your daughter is so lucky to have you.
    Kids do remember stuff like this.. I specifically remember being 7 years old and intentionally left out for a birthday party party. Did exactly the same thing – handed out all the invites in front of me, along with ‘none for you’.. Kids can be so crafty when it comes to cruelty.
    I didn’t take it lying down though! Nope, not even at 7! I confronted the girl’s mother when she dropped her daughter to school and said ‘howcome I didn’t get invited to lauren’s party but everyone else did?’ needless to say, the mother was unaware Lauren hadn’t given me an invite and so I was invited on the spot!! I went to lauren’s party at McDonalds, and boy was she pissed!!!!!!

    All i can say is that those things do stick in your memory (I’m almost 28 now and have daughters myself).
    well done for calling the mum. The girl will probably be a ‘nothing’ in her life, but for her, you are the best mummy warrior And that she will remember!!!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Erin

      Way to go, you ballsy little 7 year old you! :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • MissV

      wow. i’m totally impressed considering you were 7 at the time!! good on you!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Beka

        He he! Forever etched in my memory! I was incessantly teased at the party for asking her mum if I could come.. But you know what? The little girl was just being downright mean to me, so even though there was teasing, all these years later, I’m glad I didn’t let her win :)
        I didn’t tell my mum any of this though – she just thought I was invited.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Nico

      Wow! What a badass seven year old :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • ClaireC

        What rude 7 year old.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  42. MM

    Kids can be so cruel. Teachers always told me that I had a very thin skin and I had to toughen up or else I couldn’t cope. Over the years I have toughened up and have gotten through some horrible lows but I still hate the feeling of being excluded. For some reason that still cuts to the core to feel that someone doesn’t want to share something with you.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  43. twomummies

    Bad form by the mother of the birthday girl I reckon. There comes a point where inviting every kid in the class bar one is just cruel. If you are prepared to allow your child to have 26 kids at a birthday party one more won’t make a difference and as a parent i think it is your responsibility to invite them all.

    In our home the last round of class mate birthdays were selective. Each kid generally only got to invite up to 10 kids so that meant some missed out, but no-one felt singled out and shunned from the whole class.

    Good on you Shankari for calling BS and doing something about it!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  44. katehunter

    Our kids’ parties are either small (you’re 5 – you can have 5 friends) or big (everyone in the class). Personally I prefer the first scenario.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  45. Wasabi

    Blinking back tears as I type. We’ve just invited every girl in Miss Five’s class to her party just so no-one would have to feel this sadness. Thankfully she has never been the only one not invited to a party but that day will come & I’ll try to remember your KMM. Thanks for a lovely post.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  46. Jackie

    That broke my heart. Poor Prima! Birthday Girl sounds like a little turd who has been poorly raised. I hope you don’t spend too much time/effort/money on a present! Xo

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Alysj

      I agree this can’t have been a nice experience for Prima, but let’s remember that Birthday Girl is also only 7 years old. I don’t feel that calling her names is okay.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jackie

        Oops, you’re probably right. I would never condone calling a 7 year old that-to her face anyway :-)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  47. Jess

    My mum had a rule for us when I was younger. If I wanted to have a party, everyone from the class was invited, or I didn’t get to have it. My kids will be abiding by the same rule when they get around to having parties.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions