Child care used to be thought of in pretty basic terms. It was simply a group babysitting service so that parents could go to work. Not anymore. We now know that child care is about so much more than that – that’s why there have been debates, reform and huge new investments in the sector.
So what exactly has changed?
Firstly, a huge body of research now clearly demonstrates that the first five years of a child’s life are the most critical in terms of learning and development. The experiences of a child in these early years will shape their future outcomes.
This is the time when children crave stimulation, are curious about everything and hungry for their knowledge to expand as they grasp the basics of sight, sound, movement and thought. In fact we know that 90 per cent of brain development occurs within the first three years.
I am an absolute believer in the power of education; to ensure that individuals have greater opportunities than those enjoyed by their parents and grandparents, to lift people out of poverty and of course, to ensure we are a smart nation for the future.
All of the evidence shows this power of education is at its height during these early years and we get the best results through giving children access to trained and qualified early childhood staff, who can provide adequate attention and supervision by not having too many kids under their care.
Another thing that has changed is just the sheer size of the early childhood sector.
We now have more children in early childhood care than at any time in Australia’s history. These children are attending care for longer; being enrolled for a far greater number of hours than the generations that have come before them. And we are spending more taxpayer dollars to support their care than at any time before.
All of these facts combine to mean we need to get it right.
Early childhood education and care needs to be of high quality – we know that – and that’s why the Federal Government and every State and Territory Government in the country came together and agreed on National Quality reforms that commenced on the 1st of January.
These reforms will see gradual changes, implemented over a number of years that will improve the quality of care that is provided to kids during those previous early years.
This year, parents who have kids in child care aged between 0 and 2 years will notice there is now one staff member for every four children. This was already the case in a number of states but is now national and I think most would agree that four babies is more than enough for one hard working staff member to manage!
Similar improvements to staff-to-child ratios will come into effect for other age groups over the next few years.
And we’re going to change the qualification requirements so that our amazing, hardworking early childhood staff members are better equipped to lead the activities that help our children learn and develop.
We’re also making sure parents have the information they need to chose the child care centre that works best for their family, with the introduction of a transparent ratings system for child care centres on a number of indicators.
For the first time parents will be able to see a clear assessment of what their centre is doing well at or what requires improvement – a bit like the MySchool website.
Now some have criticised these reforms with arguments that they’ll threaten the affordability of child care.
LET’S JUST BE VERY CLEAR ABOUT THIS!
No Government in the history of this nation has offered more support to Australian families for affordable child care.
The reason our Government increased the child care rebate from 30 to 50 per cent is because we get how important it is that families are supported with child care costs. That’s why we increased the cap on the rebate from the $4354 (as it was under the Federal Liberal Government) to $7500.
We know that families need Government assistance with child care, which is why over the next four years we’re providing over $18 billion of it (almost triple what the Howard Government did in their last four years in office).
Independent expert modelling has confirmed increases in costs will be nothing like the ridiculous figures being touted by some but will in fact be at a national average around $8.67 a week (when you take into account the fact the Government will pick up around half of most parents’ share of any cost increase through the Child Care Rebate) in 2014-15.
There has been a massive 36 per cent increase in the number of approved child care centres since we came to Government just four years ago, including 500 new centres opening in the last year alone. This obviously helps parents’ ability to find care where and when they need it.
There have been huge increases in our Government’s affordability assistance, ensuring the percentage of family income being spent on child care fees has dropped markedly over the last few years.
Surely the quality of care that our kids are receiving is the next piece in the puzzle. Making sure our hard working early childhood staff are supported to do what they do best and have more time for the care and attention they give kids is the next step in our endeavour to offer accessible, affordable, quality child care.
These are important changes.
And you know what? Australian children absolutely deserve them.
Kate Ellis is the Minister for Employment Participation and Minister for Early Childhood and Child Care.
What do you think of the child care changes?
Mamamia is giving you the chance to ask questions specifically of Kate Ellis. She’ll be sitting down next week to answer them – the hard ones and the easy ones – you can either record a short video question which you can email to info@mamamia.com.au (already uploaded to YouTube) or simply leave your question in the comments and Kate will answer them in a dedicated post next week.







Comments
237 Comments so far
I was lucky enough to be able to stay at home for the first 2 1/2 years of my child’s life. Lucky in a way that even though I became a single mum when he was 3 months old, it gave us the time we had together. I started him in daycare part time when he was 1 1/2 years so I could continue with my studies to become a primary school teacher. I visited a number of daycare centers, none of which I liked and which had no places available in the immediate future. One for example, had the half door to the toddlers room right next door to the administration desk. No other door or wall between, so anyone could just walk in as the front desk wasn’t manned. I wasn’t a fan of that. Another one requested I put down a deposit of $100 to be placed on the waiting list, NON REFUNDABLE. I eventually found one when going to the shops one day. We stopped in, he fell in love with the teachers and he’s been there ever since. Ultimately, there are not many daycare centers around. If there are, you have a huge waiting list. The fees for all centers should be capped. I pay $62 per day in Brisbane bayside and for that he gets morning and afternoon tea. He is now in fulltime, 5 days a week, 6.45am – 6.15pm so I can work in the city. Very long days for him, but he loves it there.
I’m happy the rebate is the rate it is, it is hard enough these days to afford to pay daycare as well as everything else. No wonder ppl quit work and go on the dole.
loading...
I have had a battle with one of our centres, and if I had the power, I’d remove us from the waiting list, (I thought it was a lovely centre, just poorly managed above the actual hanging out with the kids staff level – previous director is getting blamed for everything). But they are the ones with the power, because I NEED daycare for my kid, and there are a lot more people who need it than there are positions available. So they have us over barrels, really.
loading...
Won’t let me sign in for some reason.
While I think the reforms are good (I wouldn’t want to either have to deal with 5 babies as a carer), I think there needs to be reform in how childcare is looked at.
Kate, my daughter is a couple of weeks off 1. I applied for uni and started tentatively putting our names down for daycare last year, before she was even 6 months old. The majority of centres (northern suburbs of Wollongong) told me that for that age group, they have waiting lists of 2 years. Minimum. For the 0-2 age group. How does that even work logically? People are putting their names down when they’re just pregnant!
I appreciate that many people consider day care a choice, but for vast numbers of us, it’s a necessity to make our lives better or to be able to pay rent and buy food. I am at uni full time, I have had to drop a subject because the only place I can take her for day care is an Occasional Care place which isn’t open long day care hours. I want to do my studies full time so that I get through them in the quickest time possible and am not relying on the abundance of riches that the single parent payment is for longer than I have to. Obviously I’ll be trying to get work on top of Uni as well, I don’t have a problem with that at all.
Every single one of them has blamed the new ratios for the waiting lists.
I am also using the JET Child Care allowance, which is fantastic, but rather than covering the duration of my course, it’s set at two years assistance. My degree, to become a teacher, is four years. What am I supposed to do for the second two years? Why does it not cover the duration of the course, and make you show results to show that you’re progressing through it in order to get the allowance rather than just approving me for double the care I need for two years? I’m approved for 60 hours a week for 2 years – I could get away with 30 hours a week most of the time and spread it across the four years of my degree – why is there no way I can do that?
Bottom line is that childcare needs to be treated as the necessity it is for many people rather than a luxury that you are lucky to get.
loading...
I am doing the same as you except in the Northern rivers nsw. I don’t qualify for JET and my husband has to work away so we can afford for us to live and get a help create a better life for ourselfs. It is not ideal but we hardly get any gov. assist. Our childcare centre is amazing and the girls are great. Coming from working in Childcare they deserve every penny they gets. Keep up the good work. Just a hint there are apparently excellent distance ed course through new england uni, southern queensland uni and curtin uni. Good luck.
loading...
I like coming to uni, it’s local and we’re in schools early. It’s a highly regarded course.
I guess my problem with the JET thing is that it approves for ridiculous amounts of heavily subsidised care, but for a short amount of time. I don’t understand why it can’t 6000 hours or whatever to be used over the course of your study.
I’m not ungrateful, it’s a great scheme, but I just think it could be administered better.
loading...
‘how does that work logically’
Because the baby room places are often filled by siblings.
I have found for my kids that for the first child for the first year you take what you can get days wise, then from then you are in the club so you are right
loading...
Oh, I’ve figured that out, doesn’t make it any less frustrating, though.
And it doesn’t make it OK for there to be such a crazy situation. I’ve floated the idea before that day care should be attached to schools and funded the same way – like I said, it’s a necessity rather than a nice quiet day for Mum for most of us.
loading...
I am currently pregnant and looking into daycare for when I return to work. Can you explain why there is no requirement that costs be standardised? The local childcare centre charges $106 per day – and that doesn’t include food or milk! That seems extraordinarily high to me. Although the $7500 refund will assist, when paying for full time daycare – well, the cost is clearly still too high.
loading...
That is extremely high and not providing food or milk!! Unbelievable.
loading...
Private centres will charge what the market will allow them to charge. Obviously there are families prepared to pay that much for childcare. Do shop around if you can because I found that the most expensive centre with the beautiful decor and the one that looked the most impressive on paper wasnt actually as good as the cheaper daggier centre nearby.
loading...
Thanks for the feedback. I guess I will have to look into it. It’s the only daycare in my local area. If it’s no good, I will have to look at daycare options in the CBD.
loading...
Private centres will charge what the market will allow them to charge – I am having to pay $125 per day in Melb… It’s not like there are a lot of options as someone mentioned earlier they have us over a barrel !
I had to go on the waiting list whilst I was pregnant and it took 18months afterwards to get a place (i.e. over 2 years)
loading...
I saw one in Brighton VIC charding $120 a day yet advertising jobs paying their staff only $35k a year SHAME SHAME SHAME
loading...
Kate,
As the chairperson of the Australian Multiple Birth Association, I would like to see InHome Care be more accessible to families with triplets or more. The current system through agencies isn’t working as well as it could, and families are finding it very difficult to get help. I’m sure most people can imagine the first six months in a family with triplets is exhausting and extended family can’t always be relied on to assist.
How can you make it easier for these families to access the InHome Care program?
Caroline
loading...
I’m about to re-enter the work force after a year at home with my bub. I’m a qualified child care worker, but I’m taking an office job at a supermarket because I will earn an extra $400 a month than I would working in child care. The pay is terrible, the hours are long, an the work is grinding in child care. But when you’re in the right centre, it’s a wonderful place to spend the day.
The centre where I worked was family owned. The owner/director is also the preschool room teacher. The atmosphere is relaxed and fun and the parents and children notice that. I will miss working there, and I won’t hesitate to enrol my daughter when the time comes that I need to (Nana is doing a wonderful job for now!).
When you pick up your kids from childcare/kindy/preschool today, give the staff members an extra smile. It makes all the difference, because God knows that they’re not working there for the money.
loading...
As someone has has worked in the Early Childhood Field for nearly 20 years thankyou so much for those comments! It is a hard grind. And the pay is crap.
loading...
Yes it is, and I for one will never work in child care again, and sadly I was good at it. People with self respect leave the industry.
loading...
It is absolutely grinding work. Especially when ratios are at the bare minimum. Today I worked alone with 11 children and a casual on her first day with our centre. Ive been there for three weeks. I felt like crying and walking out. I have two degrees and feel like a cleaner. I have no time to actually enjoy anything about my job.
loading...
They could raise it 10 grand a year and it still would barely be enough for all that we do thats how critical the pay situation has become.
loading...
I aplaud childcare workers for all that they do. It’s sad that for all the responsibilities they have the pay is low. Having a stable base of carers within a centre is fundamental for children’s development. What are the incentives to keep child care workers in their jobs for longer?
We always thank the carers when we pick our son and buy them all a Xmas present.
loading...
Mrs_H as a mum with two kids in childcare 3 days a week, I just want to say thank you to yourself and all the other amazing carers out there. It’s not an easy job and it can often be thankless and yes the pay is crap. It can be hard for parents to place our trust in others to look after our precious children but I think the staff at the community run childcare centre my children attend are wonderful. They are so caring and committed to the wellbeing of the children and they have the most fun and stimulating activities for the children too. My 5 year old was so well socialised and school-ready when he started kinder this year, it was barely a transition for him to go to big school!
I just want to let all the carers out there know that you are valued and I appreciate the care you give. Although it doesn’t do anything for you financially, hopefully my comment lifts your morale slightly!
loading...
Thanks so much Holly. The parents who are the ones forking out their hard earned seem to be the only ones that recognise us yet their fees never go towards our wages. This is why the govt has to subsidise our pays.
loading...
My 5th child has just started school this year. I would have to say the only difference in ‘child care’ that I have noticed in the 13 years since my eldest went is the increase in red tape and paper!! I would much rather my childcare centre spend time with my child rather than filling in stupid pieces of paper. If the government are going to demand this paper filling – they should also make it essential that each centre has someone there as a purely admin role so the childcare workers can actually care for my kid.
loading...
Kate, as a single parent with children all above 8, I can’t help but notice the government has once again failed to address child-care shortcomings for school age children. I have obligations to find a minimum 15hrs a week work, yet there is little availability of child-care outside school hours. If I am lucky enough to find a job that works within school hours, then what happens come school holidays? Every working parent I know struggles with this, most relying on family to help out during these times. For many in this day and age, this is not an option. School holiday programs are very expensive, regardless of how much the government may help out, the upfront costs, are just not viable for many, and places fill up at a ridiculous speed, because the need of care during the holidays is so high? When will the government address this issue, rather than continuing to place unrealistic demands on parents? The cost of directing money in this area would surely be outweighed by the benefits of parents being able to work, rather than receive government support.
loading...
Danni
We fund an unlimited number of Out of School Hours Care places with parents also eligible for the 50% Child care rebate for those fees. You are right though, supply can be patchy with many school communities or Councils deciding against opening centres.
Hey folks, am conscious that i’m meant to be answering all these questions and more next week in our full child care Q and A- am jumping the gun a bit. Keep em coming- by email or by video msg and i’ll answer in full then.
K
loading...
I respectfully beg to differ over Out of School Hours Care places. First, legal advice (that I expect is right) told my friend that an OOSHC provider is safe from discrimination complaints because supporting a student with a disability would involve unjustifiable hardship for the OOSHC provider. Clearly, the level of support for OOSHC is insufficient.
Second, for teenagers with a disability OOSHC places are not unlimited as you claim. The Commonwealth funds just 5 OOSHC places for teenagers in the ACT strictly for students in wheelchairs … and refused to fund anymore places when asked repeatedly for support for other teenage students with severe or profound disability. This is lawful discrimination (under Australian law) against students with a disability (which clearly contravenes the UN charter signed by the Australian Government) … see more at http://a4.org.au/a4/node/452
loading...
Kate, I appreciate that, I am lucky enough to have my children in a school that provides such a service, and I have the means of transport to access it (a year ago, I had no car, without adequate public transport, my kids either got the bus home when school got out, or had no way of getting home), but you have not addressed the main issue I raised of school holiday care. I am yet to find an employer willing to take me on, needing 12 weeks off a year. Until this is addressed, any obligations imposed by Centrelink, are just setting parents up to fail. I for one, am fed up and frustrated with trying to change my circumstances, do what is required, and coming up against a brick wall at every turn. This is not a system that supports parents, particularly single parents, in returning to work.
loading...
You’re right, it’s such a juggle. It’s hard even with a partner, I can’t imagine the difficulties as a solo parent.
We currently go through a range of things to try to juggle the school holidays:
- My employer allows me to “purchase” additional leave (up to 4 weeks per year) by salary sacrifice.
- I take a week off one holidays and have my sister’s kids stay with me, she takes a week off another holidays and takes my kids for the week
- Some holidays I’ll take one or two days off per week, and so does my husband, and the other days we send them to vacation care (which is expensive and not the ideal)
- My employer has offices nationally and next holidays I’ll be working for a week in a different office in the city where my mum lives, and she’s going to care for them that week.
- I’m also studying for a Primary Education degree, which will help eventually (but I’m studying part time and I have another 4 years to go!)
I don’t have all the answers, it’s just tough.
As a side note: I am a bit concerned about what happens when my children start high school. The older one won’t be eligible for Vacation Care any more but I won’t be able to leave the younger one home alone. Any solutions from parents?
loading...
I have two children over 8 years and I have just started working full time as a child care worker. Here’s the reason why I can work full time … my 75year old parents pick up the child care duties when I leave home at 6.30am for an early shift and when I dont get home until 6.30 on a late shift. They take my son to soccer training twice a week and my daughter to dancing and netball. On my early week I do the running around. That’s after getting up at 5.30am for work…. There are three single mothers working in my centre, that’s three families who have to rely on grandparents/older siblings as child carers. Sadly the much talked about work/life balance doesn’t extend to single mothers.
loading...
I think it’s interesting that child care centres are getting so much improvement when state run services such as kindy get very little. At the moment we are begging parents to attend every session in the first three weeks as this determines funding for the next year – although enrolments fluctuate.
Meanwhile my daughter can write her name, read alphabet in upper and lower case, and count to 60. These are skills she learnt in child care. Kindy offers play based learning, and the kids in that group are not in the same place.
I am not going to debate which is the better system, but I would love to know why the two systems are so different when we are trying to prepare all children for school?
loading...
Many schools offer play based learning in the earlier years now also.
loading...
Hi Laws for Clouds
Just a tip from someone who used to work in kindergartens and childcare centres: their purpose is not “to prepare all children for school”. It is to nurture children at the stage of development they are in, and give them opportunities to develop and learn at their own pace. The difference is that childcare centres are caring for children 10 hours a day, five days a week. Play-based learning is the most appropriate system for young children, no matter where the caring is taking place. Children do not need to learn to read and write before they go to school – that’s what they will learn to do when they get there.
loading...
I don’t think that the child care difference can be put down to hours since most children don’t attend full time.
What I should have said is ‘Schooling is now changing so all children do the same amount of new entrant classes when the one intake system is introduced for schools and kindergartens. Will a national cirriculum or standards be introduced for pre-schools too?’
loading...
“Prechools have been at the forefront of the new National and State frameworks for 3-4 years. The National Regulations and Act which includes the National Quality Framework, was set in motion Australia wide as of January 1st 2002. This replaced individual state regulations and acts, unifying all states agreements undert the one umbrella.” Quoted from a current Pre-school Director and qualified primary school teacher.
loading...
I think the changes are all great for bigger centers. I feel for family daycare providers though. In our situation we use a mix of family daycare and preschool. Our family daycare “mum” will have less spaces available for children when the ratios change. Also as she has been doing family daycare full time for over 20 years she had no formal qualification and will have to return to study if she wants to continue as a carer. She has been talking about retiring as the changes have such a big impact for her. I would be really sad for this to happen, as would my kids. In this caters case it is just an increase in red tape and not quality of care.
loading...
That’s a real problen – child care is not appropriate for many children. My nephew has a dairy and gluten intolerance, and family day care allows food from home, and my son has ASD and the smaller groups ware much better for him.
loading...
Okay, i can’t resist responding to one more! Family Day care Australia- the peak body for family day carers in Australia supported these reforms. Many states were already at the required ratio so we know it is more than workable. we continue to support the industry make the transition though acknowledging that 1-4 will be new for NSW for example.
loading...
KDot’s daycare you take all their own food, and they have a blanket no nut policy.
loading...
I think with so many food allergies we’re going to be seeing more of this, which is good (although I would do anything to delay having to make packed lunches!).
loading...
It doesn’t seem out of the ordinary round the centres I’ve been to. They have fruit to share, but everything else you have to take yourself.
loading...
Hi Kate
I am having huge problems with the childcare centre my daughter attends. Among other issues, I recently discovered that one of the carers was posting photos of my baby on her facebook page (she was excited to tell me that 60 of her friends “liked” my baby because she is so cute).
I have had my daughter on waiting lists at 3 other centres for a year but cannot get a place anywhere else.
I know I can make a formal complaint about my childcare centre about a range of issues including the facebook incident but what happens then? I fear my daughter will be treated differently by staff and receive even worse care than she is getting now.
What measures does the Government have in place for people like me who are receiving less than satisfactory care but feel like they have no alternative?
loading...
Oh gosh, posting someone else’s child’s photo on Facebook???? I don’t post my friends’ kids’ photos on Facebook, I’m not sure how she thought it was appropriate to post a photo of a child she is responsible for (as her occupation)! Did you tell her that that was inappropriate?
loading...
Libby, if you want to give my office a call on 02 6277 7350, ask for jamila and we’ll do what we can to help.
loading...
You most definitly should be speaking to the director of the centre. I can’t imagine that he/she would condone that behavior. There are strict privacy and confidentiality issues that all centers face, and this is a breach of the Code of Ethics.
At the centre that I worked at, we were extremely concerned about parents taking photos at the end of year party and putting them on facebook. We had to threaten to ban cameras from all events if we found any photos of other children on the Internet. Everyone was very good about it.
loading...
Oh my god that is so inappropriate! You need to talk to the Director ASAP. Seriously bad.
loading...
What was she, like 15???
Dodgy!!!
loading...
this is what happens when you pay a wage appropriate for a 15 yr old
loading...
Yes, early childhood is important.
So why does the Australian Government fund just 5% (up to one hour per week) of early intervention for children with autism when it’s own advice says these children need 20 hours per week of intensive ASD-specific early intervention (see http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/content/D9F44B55D7698467CA257280007A98BD/$File/autbro.pdf)?
The Government offers “inclusion support” for children with a disability but makes it difficult or impossible to use the resources it offers in early intervention, insisting instead that the “supports” are used to include a child with autism in activity that they clearly do not benefit from.
The result is that outcomes for people with autism are much worse than the average for people with a disability in education and in adult life (see http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/mf/4428.0).
Government should act to improve these outcomes, not ignore these facts.
loading...
Thank you for posting this. My son has ASD and we were fortunate to get him into 2 early intervention programs which provide 5.5 hours over 2 mornings. We still pay a contribution towards these services (they are subsidised). We are also extremely lucky to have found a preschool that offers the support he needs but this is only 9 hours over 2 days. Our son is one of the lucky ones as most centres have no clue how to meet his needs, however getting him into these great programs means that I’ve had to give up work and none of these services are eligible for CCR so I’m paying more than we were for an inadequate service at another preschool with longer hours. I’m really grateful for the awesome staff who work with my son but so disappointed in our government’s refusal to provide and fund early intervention and ongoing therapies for every child with ASD. I know the NDIS is coming eventually but this is not good enough. It’s needed now.
loading...
ASD services do need improvement/more funding, agreed.
Did you know that children with behavioural disorders such as ADHD get no funding? NADA. No help at school either. Any help has to be self funded. Some people still think it’s due to poor parenting.
loading...
I am an Early Childhood Educator and a mum of three. We have used not-for-profit, council-run (NSW) services since 2006, when my son was one. I have always been extremely happy with the quality of the care in these services. I also support the reforms 100%, and I am so thrilled to see the changes to curriculum evolving in my son’s (baby) room.
However, we recently received a letter saying that our council could no longer afford to run our centre, and are going to put the centre up for sale/lease. A little investigating unearthed that many LGAs are closing their long day care servies, washing their hands of their community obligation. Our council has even gone so far as to claim that for-profit services receive more funding and tax breaks than not-for-profit, council services- is this true?
Kate, is this a trend that is being watched? It is a huge concern for me that not-for-profit services may disappear. And, love your work.
loading...
Do you recall the ABC bail out in 2008? At the time, I recall someone from the NSW Community Preschool association on the radio saying that the bailout money to ABC was equivalent to a decade of funding for all NSW Community Preschools. Astonishing.
I can’t comment on normal funding, though.
loading...
Thanks for the feedback Sarah. It is a huge disappointment when councils walk away from early childhood services. Luckily we have several examples of in-touch councils recognising that if they want to attract young families and workers to their areas then they need to ensure the essential services and so they are INVESTING in child care. More of it I say.
All in all, when Goodstart took over hundreds of the old ABC centres not too long ago it shifted the balance of not for profit centres from around 25% of the market to around 40%- so they’re on the up.
Public, Private… as long as they’re offering quality care to our kids i reckon.
loading...
I agree anon, there are some councils doing amazing work- Canterbury in NSW is one that comes to mind. Smaller LGAs, and those with a predominately older, male council, seem to be struggling to put value in early childhood services.
loading...
Oh- sorry Kate- you appeared as ‘anon’ for a minute there.
What about the funding issue? I’m trying to convince our council to maintain the service, and need some numbers to back up my argument. Are the council-run services entitled to the same financial benefits as private?
loading...
Very true Kate. But let’s make sure the public are aware – whilst (as some people mentioned) not-for-profit attempt to make a ‘profit’ this is so that the profit can be reinvested back into the centre because all staff in the centre’s wages are on a salary. Private centres – ultimately someone’s ‘salary’ is the profit – whether it be high or low.
loading...
I graduated with a Bachelor of Education (Early Childhood) & due to my decision to find teaching work in the city, instead of completing country service, the only job I could find was in child care.
I worked for a privately operated centre, which like most centres, was run for profit & I was paid $14 p/hr. I spent a good portion of my own money buying supplies (like paper!), used my weekend for curriculum planning & as the ‘Assistant’ was essentially hired to clean, it was pretty much solely up to me to care for sixteen 3-4y.olds (pre-kindy).
Needless to say, I lasted in that job for about a year. I would have earnt more money serving behind the counter at McDonald’s than using my four-year university education working in a childcare centre.
That was in 2004 & I’m hoping things have significantly changed for workers in child care education (who ironically, can’t even be represented by the Education Unions – child care workers fall under the ‘Hospitality & Miscellaneous Workers Union’).
My point in all of this, is that if we want to provide good quality education & care, we need to provide incentives for well educated staff to stay. Teachers in ‘regular’ kindy & pre-school do not have to deal with working the kind of hours as their long day-care counterparts. They’re given school holidays & cleaners are hired, so the assistants can actually assist the teacher. They have time for planning & assessment, & because of these benefits, most kindy & preschool teachers have been working in the same job for years.
Due to my experience working in childcare, I made the conscious descision to stay at home with my baby until he is at least two or three years-old. I understand that being a stay-at-home mum is not an option for many families, so I say again – hire childcare staff with experience & qualifications & pay them well. Because for some children, they spend the majority of their waking hours with these carers so consistency of care is a must. Therefore, don’t we want to give these staff the required incentives to stay?
loading...
I had this same experience, working in a child care centre, but only lasted a term. For that reason I’ve now made a decision to be a stay at home mum until my toddler is old enough to attend a community preschool!
loading...
Hi Zara, I work for a not for profit organization in a preschool- not LDC- as the director/teacher and I only get 4 weeks annual leave a year ( if i want school holidays with my own school aged children I’m welcome to take 8 weeks unpaid leave a year)like my LDC friends, have limited time off the floor for my planning and admin time, and would never ever call our team my “assistants” . Having said that I’m very well supported by my managers, have access to fantastic professional development and future career opportunities. I feel that these reforms can only improve the industry. Early childhood education should be seen as a profession, anything that helps that happen in the wider communities eyes gets my vote!
loading...
Sorry but I fail to see how early childhood education can be seen as a profession whilst ever centres cut costs and have their highly trained staff cleaning toilets, mopping and sweeping, doing dishes, cooking meals … we are worked to the grindstone, it is hard to have respect for oneself, I might as well use my teaching degree to wipe the floors for what it is worth.
loading...
I agree that there are a lot of below standard centers out there with great people unfortunately stuck working in them. I’ve been there and done that. I left wirking on the floor for 5 years for that exact reason.I have now returned to a great organization that value their educators, but I realize that these are very rare. Maybe our question to Kate Ellis should be how will the new reforms stop low quality services getting a high quality rating? Under the old system this happened all the time.
loading...
I have a strong belief that bulling, poor self esteam, eating problems, etc can be drasticly improved with the right attitude instilled in our children. Hopefully indiginous children can benifit greatly from your new plans although you will need to be carefull where not accused of distroying culture. Good luck and best wishes.
loading...
Indigenous kids can and will benefit from greater interest in early childhood.
there is no need to denegrate indigenous culture in order to give them more opportunities. IN FACT, it is necessary to integrate indigenous culture and worldview INTO curriculums so that indigenous kids are more welcomed, included and empowered within education.
Aboriginal and Torres Strait cultures need to be celebrated and honoured in education, not treated as though culture gets in the way of success…
loading...
some courses have a specific unit on educating indigenous children but its unfortunately not a mandatory unit offered at all tafes. I would have liked to have done that unit in my childcare course.
loading...
Didn’t have time to read this article start to finish but the bits I did read just seemed like an opportunity to promote the government and bag the opposition. “We’re doing this and they didn’t do this”. Bit sad really.
loading...
Kristy,
the reforms that I was writing about are being supported by our Government and by every State and Territory Government- of ALL political persuasions. Of course, I am proud that we’ve increased the focus and massively invested in this important area from the Federal Government though. I hope all Governments will do the same from now on!
loading...
You should probably read the whole article. It discusses some pretty important stuff with some positive changes made, and by my count only two mentions of the opposition. Hardly a bagging of them.
loading...
Admittedly my skim was too quick i’ll agree – that’ll teach me. Although it would be nice to see an article with NO dig at the opposition, just put forward your own point. But I guess that’s not politics, is it.
loading...
I should technically be all pro this change but some of it makes me think we are trying to quantify the unquantifable.
Red Rocket has been to 2 centres,one in Cairns and one in Adelaide. The Cairns one closed at the beginning of the GFC, with part of the reason beign they couldn’t afford a number of changes to their doors and other reforms (pre this lot of reforms). Our current centre is physically shabby. Both centres offered the highest quality care because they had staff who were paid well and loved children. They had low turnover of staff and the staff had time out of the room that was scheduled for their programming, instead of cramming it in when they were in the room. Their ratios were lower than mandated.
I think there is a difference as children get older. I want my under threes to be safe and loved. I have been looking around for Little Lad to see if I want to change centres (I don’t think I do) and all they can talk about is the quality of their education, the reports they give (for babies!!!), the ‘curriculum’. They never talk about the vibe. The directors are professional educators dressed in suits, whereas at our centre I chose it because the director sat on the floor at our visit and the children climbed all over him and were all shouting his name to show him/tell him things.
I’m wary of over professionalising (cos that is so a word) something just so we can feel we have quantified something that is unquantifiable. I’m wary of expecting child care to do a whole bunch of educating of my babies that they wouldn’t get munching on snails in my back yard if I was at home full time.
loading...
I should add that the financial reforms this government has put in place are fabulous and I am 100% behind making chidl care more affordable. I believe this mainly as a feminist, given most women are the ones to make the choice about whether going back to work is financially viable. Its my personal view that staying in touch with the workforce is essential for broader economic and personal self esteem reasons and it should always be financially worthwhile to go to work.
loading...
I so agree with you, Dee! I tried for ages to get my son into a ‘quality’ daycare centre and then a place came up at a centre nearby (a centre that was a little tired, and a little unstructured) and because of work, I had to take it. Almost a year on and my little guy LOVES it – it is a total ‘go with the flow’ kind of place, which has actually been great for his development (he is pretty organised by nature) and he is so loved by all the carers there. I wouldn’t dream of sending him somewhere else now. But, I would imagine on paper, this place wouldn’t tick every box. How do you define the actual ‘caring’ of people in a place like a childcare centre??
loading...
The outside of my centre looks like a soviet era prison lol. But the inside is filled with love and laughter. I’m amazed at how many parents are conned by glossy brochures, fancy words and primary coloured paint jobs when choosing child care.
loading...
Looks can be deceiving. My kids went to a local preschool that is old fashioned and in a basic building. But the staff are amazing and have all been there for years. My kids all benefiited from eye checks, occupational therapy and speech therapy if it was needed.
My friends kids went to the fancy boutique style preschool down the road that charges a small fortune and has all the bells and whistles. It also has a huge staff turnover, her kids started school missing some basics and she had to seek out speech therapy for her child herself, the issue wasnt even detected there. Never judge a book by its cover.
loading...
Yup. My 9 month old does two days a week in family day care. I decided against the new, sparkly shiny centre down the road in favour of an unrenovated, slighlty shabby home around the corner, because it seemed happier and more nurturing somehow. It may not be as ‘clean’, but I love the lady who cares for her and reckon my daughter is much better off there.
loading...
We were so fortunate to find a CCC with long-term, highly-motivated staff who took the time to know and love our kids. When we moved to Melbourne (pre-ABC crisis), we found a centre that was in an old house in Surrey Hills, not a shiney new-ABC centre down the road which seemed to be filled with 18 year old carers without experience, but the staff at our centre were clearly respected in the family who ran the business. An old house (safe but old) with loving motivated carers was worth every penny we spent there. My girls were so attached that we delayed moving to a new centre until 1 year after we moved suburbs.
loading...
There are two things I find difficult around the transition from day care to preschool. This year, my daughter started preschool. 15 hours a week (Monday, Tuesday and a half day Wednesday). Coming from 4 full days in long day care is a hard transition – for the parents.
Also, and I am starting to think that this may be specific to my day care, is that there is a big difference between my daughter and other children who have stayed home/gone to family day care, in terms of their development. Please note, I am generalising and not saying that any other kids are dumb, just different. Let me explain further. Chloe can recognise quite a few words (starting to read) can write upper and lowercase alphabet and starting to count. Also further developed with drawing. Now, this was not uncommon for the children in her room at day care. Most of them can do it. I would guess that if she was home full time I would have never taught her all those things. No way, I am not wonder woman with flash cards.
I have spoken to someone who runs a long day care. He believes that we teach too much at day care. They should be more ‘glorified babysitter’ and that we are teaching them too much. I don’t necessarily agree as kids are so smart and can pick everything up!
Anyway, I think that we need to look carefully at the way the transition works. Has anyone else come across this sort of thing, or am I on my own?
loading...
My daughter is like your daughter, but starting preschool I was told by her teacher that learning the alphabet and writing etc. is actually damaging to their long term ability! Suffice to say I am freaking out!! She said it was better that at this young age the focus on literacy should be on actually understanding words in the spoken sense and the better understanding they have of this before they start learning to read and write, the better they will be at reading and writing. She also said that since reading and writing are taught in prep it is better left to those teachers as otherwise the child will be bored in class as all the other kids catch up.
Sounds like national reforms would be helpful so more kids are on an even keel when they start pre-school or primary school
loading...
I have found a similar experience. Although Red Rocket won’t slow down no matter how much I direct her outside to eat snails and jump on the trampoline. Her life’s aim is to learn to read better than her cousins she see’s daily – even though they are TWO YEARS OLDER. (I use caps because I spend a lot of time frustratingly trying to explain this to her!)
She turned four last weekend and is basically reading. This has resulted in moaning that kindy (SA version of preschool) is ‘boring’. I haven’t so much as taught her a letter or a word although we read voraciously. Most she has learned from child care or from snooping over her cousins homework in reception and year one.
They are young for such a short period of time. I want my children’s child care experience to be full of mess and dolls and trucks nad sandpits.
loading...
That’s a mean thing for the teacher to say! Any kid who watches Sesame Street would know their ABC’s!
WHat are you supposed to do, some kids are interested in different parts of the language. For my daughter, she loves names. She can say/write/read heaps of family names. She is always asking how to spell them. Should I say no you can’t learn? you must learn to write cat/dog/other three letter words first because ‘that’s the way you are supposed to learn’? If they want to learn, you can’t tell them to stop! Don’t worry bout that teacher, I haven’t heard that stuff before… Maybe she just doesn’t want the extra work of the kids at different levels…? That way, she only has to come up with one exercise!
loading...
My biggest issue with early childhood education when my children were in that age bracket was the huge gap between childcare and preschool. Because I am a stay at home mum, my children attended traditional preschool, they attended on set days, 9am-3pm and it closed for school holidays. We received no government assistance for the fees because it wasnt childcare and I wasnt in that category of working, looking for work or studying.
If we want people to believe that the government truly cares about early childhood education for all children preschool fees need to be recognised somewhere along the way regarding assistance too. Working parents arent the only parents entitled to financial assistance with payment of preschool fees. Often the family on one income is doing it very tough because they have made that choice for their children and these children deserve an affordable preschool education too.
loading...
Its a state by state thing Lu. Kindy in SA (for 4 year olds, run by the education department, 20 hours a week. Think that is called pre-school elsewhere) has fees of around $80 a term, public and private. I pay more than that a day for child care.
As far as I know we get no rebate for the kindy fees but as the state government heavily subsidises it, it isn’t an issue.
loading...
I’m in NSW and I dont know of any state run centres in my area. Preschool fees are around $55 per day, which I know is nothing compared with daycare which is about $100 per day, but when a family is on one income it can still be a large chunk of their cash. And their childs education is still worthy of support.
loading...
Lu the Department of Education in NSW runs 100 Preschool within local schools, here’s a link to information http://www.schools.nsw.edu.au/gotoschool/preschool/index.php
loading...
I just changed childcare centers. The first was $147 a day, no nappies (!). now he is in the same company but different centre and it’s $90 with nappies included. It’s crazy some of the prices they can charge and get away with. (both have year long waiting lists)
loading...
Hi Sarah, thanks for that. Just checked and like I thought there were none in my area.
loading...
I fully support higher quality care, and I understand that for many families using childcare is the only option for their family to stay financially solvent.
My question is, given your obvious understanding of the importance of the first three years, when will the government start to shift their efforts from first rate childcare, to supporting parents who choose to stay home with their young children?
Historically, society went through a stage where they concentrated on orphanage reform, but then finally came to the realization that supporting the children in their own homes was a vast improvement for everyone. I feel that we need to come to the same realization about child care. Making parents feel more comfortable about putting their children in care for extended hours is certainly helpful to the individual families, but as a whole, what is the cost to society? This is a social construct that has not occurred on a large scale, for long enough, for us to judge the ramifications, and it concerns me greatly. (Please note that I am not implying parents who use childcare are akin to parents who utilized orphanages! We have plenty of childcare experience in this family too.)
http://the-accidental-housewife.blogspot.com.au/
loading...
Historically other people have always looked after the children of the working class. It wasn’t formal or regulated but working class women have always worked and their children were looked after by neighbours or older children.
I take the contrary view that we need MORE people involved in the parenting of our children, not less. I disagree that one parent can provide the breadth of experience for that little under three sponge mind. Flexibility is great, governments assisting to facilitate grandparent care, family day care, small child care centres, large child care centres.
loading...
I thought the paid maternity leave was the beginnings of addressing supporting parents to stay home with their children?
loading...
I’m confused by child care. I am lucky in that financially do not need to work. However now I worry that I am placing my two kids aged 1 and 2 at a disadvantage by not going to child care. Can someone in the child care industry let me know. I am pro child care and pro working mothers too, just that in my situation not necessary to work. I might in the future though.
loading...
Jess, I think all kids benefit from preschool or daycare for the year or two before they start school But otherwise its not something that you can generalise about. Some kids really benefit from daycare from a young age, others thrive being at home with mum.
Personally, the people who told me that my kids were missing out on ‘stimulation and socialisation’ at the age of 1 because they werent in childcare were really just doing the old competitve mum thing. Do what you are comfortable with dont let anyone else make you feel guilty about being the best mum you can be.
loading...
Well said Lu, I am getting lots of criticism for not having my 1 year old in care, for being a stay at home mum. We made a decision to make sacrifices so that I didn’t have to go back to work. If people want to work to afford the 2 or 3 investment properties they own and have their bub in care 5 days, that is their choice. Each to their own!
loading...
Hi Jess, obviously only your family can decide what is best for your children. Of course there are benefits offered by the loving care of parents. there is also much evidence of the positive impact of the interaction offered through services. i’ve attached one quick link to a study here :
http://www.earlychildhoodaustralia.org.au/early_childhood_news/april_2007_us_study_into_effects_of_long_day_care_on_developing_children.html
early Childhood Education are a great organisation to go to if you want any further info too. Hope that helps!
loading...
It is a shame some stay-at-home parents feel they are ‘depriving’ their child by not putting them in child care! There are so many facets to a child’s development and the focus at this age should be developing meaningful relationships & learning through play, which parents & good teachers do equally well. Please don’t feel your care is inadequate Jess- your children are exposed to so many learning opportunities from daily routines and homelife. If they need more stimulation or social play, there are plenty of play groups, toddler library sessions and other community resources, some of which are free or attract a rebate too. I think regardless of your opinion on child care or staying home, it’s important that parents feel completely comfortable with their choice & base it on the needs of themselves and their children. Your concern alone shows you care deeply for your children’s development.
loading...
if you think there is benefit in both child-care and staying home, why not just do child-care part time?
your kids could go 2 (or whatever) days a week, or only half-days, and get lots of benefit in the form of varied activites and new experiences while still getting the security of lots of time with you…
just an idea. I’m a student doing bachelor of education in early childhood right now, so not in the industry fully yet…
loading...
Jess they are not missing anything at 1 and 2! I’m sure that you take them to the park and the shops etc etc. Maybe re assess about 3/4 purely for social development!
loading...
I think you should consider it, for the social aspects, as well as what activities and early learning your local centre could offer to your children.
Personally, my transition from kindergarten (10 months to 5 years – and I loved it) to primary school was seamless and trauma-free, due to already being used to other kids and the “school”-type daily format.
One or two days per week might be really enjoyable for them and you
loading...
Jess, occasional child care (OCC) would be ideal for someone in your situation. Provided mostly by community organisations, OCC offers short sessions (usually 3-5 hours) of care so parents can attend to appointments or take time out, and kids have opportunities to socialise. In Victoria, OCC staff have the same qualifications as long day care workers and the services are subject to high quality controls. Unfortunately, the Federal government cut funding to neighbourhood model occsasional care in 2010. But many services continue to operate despite this – and in Victoria, state government funding cuts, too. Try your local Neighbourhood House or Community Centre for information on where to find your nearest OCC provider.
loading...
Thanks for the comments everyone…really given me some things to think about. I will look in to the various child care options…with bubs so close together they seem happy enough together at home with me and going on low cost outings…but I can see benefit in child care after observing other 3 to 5 year olds.
loading...
Hi Jess,
As a child care worker (and a mum) I don’t see the benefit in ‘formal’ care for young children. In my opinion your children would get more love and attention being at home with you, then in a noisy room with other 1 and 2 year olds. At that age they don’t play with each other but rather alongside. I believe in quality, (If you went along to playgroup, met friends in a park, that would be lots of social time!) rather than quantity (full days at day care where sleep is interrupted and the staff are exhausted and underpaid!)
My kiddies are staying home with me, until 3, when they can go to the local community based preschool. Don’t feel like your girls are missing out. They have the only thing they want and need, your love and attention and in a caring home!!
loading...
Archie, if you’re going to discuss the historical context of non-parental care and the ‘social construct’ you would do better if you actually knew what you were talking about.
Women, of all classes, have always worked. In hunter-gatherer societies, women worked, while older members of the tribe cared for small children. In industrialising nations, women worked, otherwise you’d go to the poor house. In pre-Victorian England, women worked – rich women managed large households and landholdings, poor women looked after rich women’s children and did their laundry, and so on. During the wars, women worked. In fact, it was only for a very brief period during the 1950′s and 1960′s, that middle class women didn’t work.
Do you imagine that society would have risen as it has if fully 1/2 of productive, healthy young people didn’t work? Who do you imagine was feeding the tribe? Historical evidence shows that the ‘gatherer’ (women) part of hunter-gatherer societies fed the tribe at a ratio of about 70/30. It certainly wasn’t the hunters, who were gone on bloody mammoth hunts for months at a time.
So, no, non-parental child care is not a social construct, it is an eons old aspect of the human condition. I think eons is probably long enough for us all to ‘judge’ that the negative ramifications of high quality, government accredited child care are exactly zip.
loading...
Higher Qualtiy Care and smaller ratios is always a good thing! I’m looking into becoming a family day care educator and you need to have a minimal certificate III in children services plus be open to future learning opportunities and I think that’s brilliant.
loading...
Fantastic Nora, do it. I’ve been a Family Day Care Educator for 12 years, I completed my Certificate 111 and enjoyed it. I personally like the EYLF, I find that it applies so easily to the care that I have always provided.
I wish women would stop judging other women about their choices in regard to working and childcare.
loading...
Thanks for the encouragement Coralie!
loading...