Do You Like This Story?
holding hands 380x252 She thought I was abducting my own child...

.

I arrived at our local cafe to meet my wife for our weekly session of cross-referencing our calendars. Our respective schedules can change quite drastically from one day to the next (one of the many exciting quirks of a life in the performing arts), so without these sessions our lives would very quickly descend into chaos. Near the top of the list of our biggest fears as parents is to be standing in the kitchen at about 4:30pm on a weekday shouting, “No, YOU were supposed to pick her up!” back and forth as we scramble for car keys and phones and the school’s office number and our self-respect.

With us on this particular morning is our darling three-year-old daughter. Our eldest was at school. On Mondays, there is a yoga class held opposite the cafe in a lovely, glass-fronted room that overlooks the sea. It’s a bit pretty. My three-year-old likes to peer into said room through the glass while the three or four women do their class. The yoga women think she’s adorable; she’s like their little yoga mascot. My wife and I finish our calendar session and say a fond farewell, safe in the knowledge that the next week is mapped out to within a nanosecond. She goes outside, gives our daughter a kiss and leaves. After a moment or two more I finish my coffee, make my way to the counter and pay while exchanging some pleasant small talk with the staff, some of whom babysit for us from time to time. We’re not regulars at this place. We’re part of the furniture.

I walk outside and go and squat beside my daughter who is still gawking at the yoga women, her nose squished against the glass. I tell her we have to go now. She asks if we can go to the park. I tell her that we’ll have to wait until it stops raining. She’s happy with that. So I proffer my hand, she takes it and we wander happily back to the car. We are just arriving at the car when I hear a female voice behind us, “Sweetie. Sweetie?”

I recognise the voice, although the slight quiver in it sounds odd.

I turn around to see a woman I recognise as the yoga instructor approaching us. She looks concerned. She is not looking at me at all. She is bending down and trying to get my daughter’s attention. “Sweetie, where’s your Mum? Where’s Mummy, sweetie?”

Oh dear. The penny drops quickly, like mercury. Oh dearie, dearie me.

I adopt my friendliest smile, “Oh, it’s ok. I’m her dad.”

By this stage I am helping my daughter into the car. The yoga instructor ignores me completely. She is wringing her hands and trying to manoeuvre herself between me and the car door. She speaks again to my daughter, this time with more urgency and insistence, her voice starting to crack, “Princess. Where’s mummy? Where’s your mummy, sweetie?”

Oh dear. At this point I am processing a litany of emotional responses, all of which are making me feel very queezy.  For the sake of the situation, I persist. “It’s ok. I really am her dad. You were chatting to my wife before. I’ll call her if you like. Or we could pop back into the café if you like. The girls in there know us really well.” I’m babbling.

The yoga instructor looks me in the eye for the first time. I smile again, trying way too hard to reassure her. She is visibly shaking. She is a small, middle-aged woman with blonde hair and a comfortable gray tracksuit. Her eyes dart back to my daughter, then to me again. She stumbles through her words like Snow White bolting through the forest, “I’m sorry it’s just we see her at our classes every week and we…we’re all very fond of her and… and I… I’ve never… I don’t, I mean I didn’t…”

“It’s ok,” I say again, starting to feel a bit shaky myself, “it’s great to know there are other eyes on her.”

It’s all I could think to say.

We stand there for a moment. My daughter is in her car seat now, slipping her arms into the straps and struggling with the clip that she can never do up. She looks up at me and barks an order in her inimitable way,

“Daddy, help!”

The yoga instructor’s shoulders slump a little and she exhales a quick, audible breath. I look at her and say, “It’s ok,” again. It’s sounding like a mantra now. The yoga instructor doesn’t know where to look. She is shaking her head quite fast and her eyebrows are raised and she is breathing quickly. She manages some words.

“Right. Sorry.”

“It’s ok, really.”

She looks at my daughter one more time and gives her a little wave. Then she turns away very quickly and walks at an awkward pace back towards her yoga class, rubbing her forehead. She is still shaking her head. She doesn’t look back. I know this because I watched her walk away until she was out of sight. I couldn’t move.

And now I’m sitting here writing it all down, and can’t help but think about the whole episode from the yoga instructor’s perspective: a little girl pressing her face against the glass and watching the yoga class, as she always does; the little girl’s mum saying hello and apologising for her daughter’s intrusive behaviour, as she always does; the mum leaving; the little girl smiling in on the women doing their yoga; a man approaching the little girl, squatting down and talking to her, then taking her by the hand and walking away with her.

And in the short time it took me to get to the car, this woman had decided that she must go after the little girl and make sure she’s alright. This small, middle-aged woman scuttled out of her yoga class – and that’s the other thing! Did the yoga class watch it all unfold in horror? Did they all question who I was and what was happening?

“Does anyone recognise him? Anyone?”

“No, I’ve never seen him with her.”

“I haven’t either.”

“Oh God.”

And she came right up to the man who measures six foot two and weighs 90 kilos and asked the little girl where her mummy was because she felt she had to; because they’re all very fond of this little girl who stares at them through the glass on Monday mornings. The yoga instructor in the comfortable tracksuit didn’t look the other way or let it slide or shake it off or just shrug and presume the best. She chose not only to assume the worst, she chose to do something about it.

On the drive home from the café I was angry. I felt ill. I was frowning and shaking my head and muttering profanities, most probably because I couldn’t shake the thought that somebody actually believed I might have been abducting a child. My child. But once I got home, and with the benefit of a sliver of hindsight, all I could think was, “What a champion.” And I said it out loud to myself. “What a champion.”

We are constantly informed of how much evil exists is in the world. We are bombarded with horrendous stories of child abuse, abduction, murder; you name it. We get it from those who report fact and we get it from those who create fiction. I feel like we’ve never been made more aware of the capacity for people to be horrible creatures.

I can’t presume to know what motivated that yoga instructor to do what she did. Maybe her actions were fuelled by paranoia. Maybe she’s been convinced to believe that a man on his own taking a little girl’s hand has as much chance of being a paedophile as he does of being her father. Maybe it was just blind instinct. I don’t know. I don’t care. I choose to stand and applaud her, because I believe what she chose to do was the right thing; was good.

Next Monday I am going to walk into that yoga class with my daughter in tow and introduce myself properly to the small, middle-aged yoga instructor. I am going to offer her my genuine thanks. I will not accept any embarrassed apology she may offer, because she owes noone an apology, least of all me. And if it feels like it’d be ok, I will give her a hug. And then I will tell her that I think she is a champion.

Mike is best known for his performance as Paul Keating in Keating! The Musical, which had its debut at the 2005 MICF. He will perform with his wife, Fiona Harris, in their upcoming comedy play, Plus One, at the 2012 Melbourne International Comedy Festival.

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)
*

225 Comments so far

  1. Cerenatee

    Everyone saying the woman is wrong is either unbelievably ignorant or doesn’t have children. A 3 year-old will walk off with anyone. Tell them there’s a puppy somewhere and they’re game to see it. So rarely, if ever, will you have screaming. In addition, the woman had JUST SEEN the little girl with her mother. She saw her every Monday WITH HER MONDAY. To see her walking away a little while later with some strange man she had never seen was cause for alarm, to any normal adult. It’s not male bashing. I’m sure she would have done the same thing if a strange woman had started walking off with her. Finally, even if the cops had been called, it would have taken a few minutes to get the situation figured out. That’s why so many children are abducted. Because people like you don’t care enough to ask a question.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. Cerenatee

    Everyone saying the woman is wrong is either unbelievably ignorant or doesn’t have chidlren. A 3 year-old will walk off with anyone. Tell them there’s a puppy somewhere and they’re game to see it. So rarely, if ever, will you have screaming. In addition, the woman had JUST SEEN the little girl wiht her mother. She saw her every Monday WITH HER MONDAY. To see her walking away a little while later with some strange man she had never seen was cause for alarm, to any normal adult. It’s not male bashing. I’m sure she would have done the same thing if a strange woman had started walking off with her. Finally, even if the cops had been called, it would have taken a few minutes to get the situation figured out. That’s why so many children are abducted. Because people like you don’t care enough to ask a question.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Ash

    I do think the woman’s actions were brave, in this situation the child was perfectly safe but how could the instructor know that? She saw a child she sees regularly led away by a strange man. Better to be safe than sorry I think.

    In reading this I couldn’t help but think of Thomas Bulger and how many people must’ve have seen him led out by the hand by those two boys and how different it could’ve been if someone had stopped to ask him “where’s mummy?”

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. René Kåbis

    And this is how the male sex is automatically demonized and instinctively criminalized… by assuming that, unless proven beyond a shadow of a doubt, every man alone with a child is a sexual predator — no exceptions.

    Makes me think twice about ever having children myself. And that’s just sad. When did men become 2nd class citizens? When did we become “guilty until proven innocent”? This is a world I really don’t want to be raising a son in, because he will be severely disadvantaged for life simply by having been born male.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Anonymous

    “Right. Sorry.”
    “It’s ok, really.”

    No, it’s not. We need to stop catastrophing everything we see.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. David

    When my son was about 3, he threw a temper tantrum inside a target. I picked him up and hurried him to the car so he would simmer down. When i had a chance to think about the situation, i wondered why nobody said anything. Here was a dark haired man, rushing a screaming blonde headed 3 year old out of a store, to a car. Did anyone take notice? Did anyone think of asking if everything was ok? Did people just assume someone else would do something? Or did everyone just hope it was fine? Personally, i wouldnt have cared if someone stopped to check us out. I would have done the same thing or i like to think i would have.
    Whether you are in a crowd of people watching a person on the side of a building yelling for him to jump or watching some violent act occur thinking someone else will do something. I hope im the one telling him not to jump and everything will be ok. I hope im the one to step up to stop some random violent act. I hope im the one with enough courage to follow my gut.
    For those of you that that think it was none of her business. Shame on you. Im glad someone had the courage to do what they thought was right despite the rarity of occurrence. Can you say the same about your actions or do you just look back and wish you did something?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Tonya Hermann

    This is just sickening! What, now every father out with his children has to stop to be interrogated by strangers why he is with his own children? There are millions of fathers out with there little ones every day and a handful of stranger abductions every year. Get a perspective, people. If the little girl had been struggling and yelling “mommy, daddy” or “help, let me go” ONLY THEN the woman’s reaction would make any sense. What a society do we live in where grandpas are thrown out of Barnes and Nobles kids book sections and daddy’s are accosted to defend their being with a child.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Louise

    I think those of you saying the woman was completely in the wrong are ridiculous. I would rather have my husband questioned for five minutes than someone not following their gut and my daughter being abducted. It happens everyday I for one would would have done the same thing.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Andrew

      It does not “happen every day”. Despite what the media tells you, stranger abductions are exceedingly rare.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Steve

      Well, it’s very nice, Louise, that you are willing to volunteer YOUR husband to be accosted by strangers for five minutes everyday just for being out with his kid.

      Let’s put the shoe on the other foot: would it be ok if the same were done to YOU? If you were the one who had to constantly be questioned? You don’t see the embarrassment, anger, and inconvenience that would cause? Would YOU appreciate strangers assuming that your child is not yours, and you’re just some monster looking to snatch him/her up?

      The double-standard is beyond ridiculous…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  9. Aimee

    Nope, she jumped on the “worst-first” thinking bandwagon.

    What if you were the child’s uncle? Grandfather? Genuinely-trusted family friend? What if your daughter was with any of these people and got shook up and had a meltdown because she just wasn’t as used to spending time with these men as you? (I can remember melting down in public with my grandparents when I was about 5 because I was homesick.)

    Had your daughter been in a cranky or otherwise unhappy mood, or fussed about getting in the carseat, you KNOW one of these paranoid women would have called the cops on you. NOT EVERY MAN IS BAD! Sheesh.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Yan

    OMG. As a father, I really wish you would NOT thank her. I am tired of being a suspect because I’m male. I’m tired of being a suspect because I’m a bit older than a typical dad. I’m tired of women assuming I am a pedophile / abductor / criminal – just because I’m male.

    Please don’t thank her. Next time she’ll call the cops and you’ll have an arrest record as a pedophile. How will that go down in the performing arts community? Think you’ll get any gigs?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. James

    Well written essay, but you came to the wrong conclusion. What the instructor did was wrong. You were right to be angry. Please don’t thank her.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. Laura

    The woman was not brave she was a nosy busybody. People are saying it’s good she got involved. But, involved in what? Nothing was happening for her to get involved in. There was no reason for her to question a man being with a child like this. Had he grabbed her and push her screaming and crying into the car, yes I could understand. To assume that a man with a child is up to no good it so very wrong.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. Guest

    I don’t think the yoga teacher was brave at all, and I can’t believe the support for her on this site.

    Are you all teaching your sons to just accept and deal with the fact that, after a certain age, they’ll be assumed to be pedophiles and kidnappers? That’s a great world view to have, and to pass on to your children.

    The brave ones are those who recognize that not every male is a pedophile.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. Beth

    I don’t think the yoga instructor was “brave” at all and I can’t believe all the support for her.

    What are all of you teaching your sons – that the minute they reach a certain age, they will be assumed to be pedophiles and kidnappers, and they’d better just accept and deal with it? That’s a really great world view.

    The brave ones are those that don’t think every male is a pedophile.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Kylie

    Thought you might find this article over at Free Range Kids interesting.

    http://www.freerangekids.com/thanks-for-assuming-im-a-pedophile-just-because-i-was-out-with-my-grandson/

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. CC

    This reminds me when I was visiting my Dad in Sydney in the mid to late 80′s when I was about 11. My Dad was at the counter of a bank in Kings Cross and I was sitting about a metre away from him on a chair. A woman approached me and asked who I was with and I said my Dad. She said that it was ok I could tell the truth at which I reasurred her I was with my Dad and he approached us and was able to convince the woman that I was infact his daughter. The problem was that I had an uncanny resemblance to a girl about the same age that was missing and featured on all the milk cartons at the time. That girl has still never been found and I feel guilty in a strange Sliding Doors kind of way that I wish I was that missing girl and because of that woman’s bravery she could’ve reunited a girl with her family.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. Pingback: Courts separate mother and child « PetaJo

  18. bubblesrhi

    I just can’t help but think the yoga instructor was so brave – and you were such a good sport to take it the way you did.

    Situation isn’t ideal, no – but it is what we make of it.

    And heaven help us if it was that ‘other’ situation – we’d be praising the yoga teacher for being so quick to take action.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. Alistair

    So – a few things from a male/dad-of-a-3yo-girl point of view:

    1. It is a fact we implicitly accept that there is a ‘need’ to be vigilent as to who is engaging with children in our society. Yes, I would want someone who cares for my daughter in the community demonstrating this level of care, too.

    2. However, that does NOT detract from the shock and humiliation that I guess would have been the immediate rection of Mike’s. This is not discrimination… this is a generalisation around the intentions of men.

    3. When caring for my daughter for whatever reason, I get asked a lot “So! You’re ‘playing’ mummy today, are you…?” I look them squarely in the eye and say, “No. I’m being a father.” Big difference. You would rarely hear the same being said in reverse, would you? My follow up line when I get the inevitable nervous, gaze-avoiding response is, “The only thing men can’t do is breast feed.”

    4. Asking children black and white questions does not always work. Years ago at a friends’ 3yo child’s party in a local park, I was helping lift party goers up on the slide in a veritable production line. The host said it was time for cake, and kids started to wander off. I looked down at the little girl next to me and said “It’s cake time! Let’s go!” She took my hand willingly and we walked towards the festivities… when the host took me to one side and said… “Ah…Al…that’s ‘not one of ours’…” The girl had walked maybe 25m away from the park with me. I dropped to my knee, white faced, and said “Darling, are you here with your mummy?” “No, my Nanna.”, she said. “You need to go back to her now, I’m sorry.” At that, she burst into genuine tears, and sobbed “…but I wanted to have CAKE!!!” Oh, great. First child abduction, then psychological abuse. I walked away thinking “Oh God… that’s how easy it must be to abduct a child…” I was mortified.

    5. Loved you in ‘Keating!’…

    …Al

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. Anon

    If anyody were to physically come between me and my children, and I mean anybody, in the manner this woman did, with such vile unfounded accusation, then I would consider this an assault and react with swift and deft consequences.This woman had better be very careful who she picks on and who she comes between next time. She is not noble but instead corrosive to society. Paranoia is not a virtue.

    End of story.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Blah!

      Boo to you!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Mortified

        God forbid this should ever happen to a child that you love….no doubt you will be the first to point fingers and accuse others of turning a blind eye.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Mortified

          And I agree with Blah…BOOOOOOOOOO to you

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Suanne

          God forbid “what” happen to your child? Nothing happened here.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • Anonymous

        Since when did being a man out with his child become suspicious? What lesson are we teaching our children with actions like this?

        Girls — fear all men, they are probably out to get you
        Boys — once you reach a certain age you are presumed to be a predator

        The chances of a non family related abduction of a child are next to nothing. That little girl was more likely to get hurt getting into the car seat or in an accident on the way home.

        Basing your actions on fear of things that aren’t likely to happen is dangerous and has many unintended consequences. You can warp a kids view of the world and you can take the focus off things that REALLY might bring harm to a child.

        Boo to you.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Guest

      I agree Anon…. unless the child was snatched by someone running by and ‘grabbed’, this was way out of line.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • A momma

      Thank you for your response. I’d fully support my husband’s response in a situation like this.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Guest

        Except that the man who wrote this story says that he wants to say thanks to the lady and somehow that’s not okay. So what you are really saying is that you would support your husband’s response if it’s the one you want him to have. Because the person that this happened to has the right to say how he feels about it, but everyone is discounting his feelings because it’s not what they think he should feel about it.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Pophouse

      Absolutely! Abduction is so extremely rare… people need to mind their own business if they can’t be positive.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  21. Melissa

    Good on her and good on you for taking it so well. Most people don’t want to ‘get involved’. We are overly paranoid. But you just never know…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  22. Lovena

    You’re on the Circle right now! Looking forward to the tune. Like the other readers I too am curious as to what will happen when you next see the yoga instructor. Bless her!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Kate

    I wish more people would have the guts to step in when they are concerned about a child. Good on the yoga lady – and good on you for seeing her as a champion.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. Anonymous

    I want a follow up to this article please!
    with how it all went – brom both sides and from any of the other women in the class

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. Anon for today

    I’m so impressed by both of you – her for saying something, and you for understanding why she did. I’m not as brave as that – which does not mean I have not sometimes jotted down licence plate numbers if something doesn’t feel quite right. It makes me feel paranoid and I hate myself for doing it, but I think I’d hate myself more if I didn’t and something really had happened.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. Liza

    I’m glad you can write about this positively in hindsight, however, reading this story made me feel ill. I don’t think the woman is a champion. I don’t believe there was any reasonable excuse for what she did other than being over paranoid.

    I remember when I was a girl and my dad would take me out for special daddy/daughter outings on weekends and on a number of occasions women would approach us asking if I were okay and where my mother was. My dad took it in his stride but it would infuriate me that these women could be so presumptuous and I would often let them have it (they usually weren’t so concerned for my safety after this).

    A man once tried to persuade my younger brother and I into his car whilst we waited for a bus after school so I assume that attempted abductions are probably not uncommon but fathers are pretty hands on these days so it’s time people got used to the image of men with children as a norm. I would hate to think of someone harassing my husband like that when he was out with our children alone.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kris2040

      I actually kind of got the feeling that Mike didn’t have much choice other to write that he was thrilled that this lady fronted up and challenged him. Imagine if he’d written that he was pissed off about it?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • zabie

        Well, he didn’t have to write about it all so I think he did have a choice. Plus he was honest in that his initial reaction was to feel angry.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Kris2040

          Yes I know he didn’t have to write about it. But imagine the response if he had written about it and just left it at being pissed off? I would be filthy if someone did that to me with my daughter. But I’m a chick, so it probably wouldn’t happen to me.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Victoria

            I understand why you would feel affronted if someone indirectly accused you of abducting your own child but surely the idea that people you don’t even know are looking out for your kids is a pretty damn comforting one?

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
  27. Kathy

    Having to meet to “cross reference schedules” , worrying about forgetting to pick your children up because your lives are so dam busy! It’s actually funny that you would be offended that someone cared enough to question the safety of your children. Next time you should be so lucky!!!!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. smashleigh

    working in child care, i sometimes need to ask people coming to pick up a certain child for their i.d. sometimes i feel like the person is annoyed that they are being asked for id if they are picking up, say they’re grandchild/niece/nephew etc. but if we have never seen the person, then it really could be anyone coming in and taking the child.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • kathrynoncoast

      Same for me. I have seen the look some people get when asked for ID. No way am I letting a child go without seeing it though. :o )

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Nadine

      When picking up my niece or a friends sons from preschool for the first time I had my ID ready.

      The staff knew I was coming that day, they had been provided with a copy of my license, and I had the younger brother with me when I arrived.
      They asked and when they realized it was in my hand to give them before they asked for it they just smiled.

      If I have children in preschool I hope the school will be as diligent.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Miska

      The problem is that we assume “just anyone” is likely to come to pick up the child. This happens rarely, if at all. Our society has become absolutely batty about the idea that a child molester is lurking around every corner, just waiting for us to drop our guard. The paranoia. It’s turning us into crazy people, like this yoga instructor.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Guest

        It’s not because of the assumption of child molesters that most kindys and preschools have these policies. It is because of custody agreements and court orders regarding the child.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  29. kathrynoncoast

    Mike, I think you are champion too. I love the fact that you can see past the fact that you are the Dad, and not just bang on about the fact that this woman was worried. There was a similar post a while back about people being paranoid about paedophiles. I commented and got blasted for it. I would rather offend someone by actions like this lady than feel guilty forever that I didn’t intervene. Bravo to both of you!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. lucindainthesky

    This is a very positive view of a positively bizzarre situation. I don’t understand why the woman approached in the first place. Just because you haven’t seen someone with a child before it is hardly a reason to assume that it is someone the child doesn’t know. It isn’t a reason to intervene to me. By the sounds of it, the interaction between Daddy and daughter was perfectly normal and there was no “scene” or struggle. So I honestly don’t see how the intervention was necessary. If anything I think she should have spoken to Dad first and just made small conversation to see if anything was suss. OR how about saying to the child “Oh is Daddy looking after you today? Are you being spoiled rotten are you? Where are you off to with your Daddy?” Child centred conversation will give someone an idea if something is amiss, but there is no need to make a situation awkward to find out. And by making it general rather than an awkward line of questioning, the adult in question will either look put out/or hesitate to say anything; or they will participate in the conversation without a beat “yes mummy has things to do today but we are going to XXXX. She loves watching you all at yoga! You might have a little mascot on your hands” etc etc.

    In my personal opinion and experience, asking a 3 year old “where is your mummy?” could get a vast number of responses that have no bearing on why they are with someone else. She could have said “mummy has gone shopping to buy me presents” and it she still may or may NOT be with an abductor.Also many 3 year olds will get shy and not respond at all, particularly if they have a parent to hide behind.

    I would recommend anyone who suspects something is amiss with an adult/child, is to initiate conversation with both adult and child, ask general questions about where they are off to, what they are up to today and don’t give away that you are suspicious. Then if you remain suspicious, document the conversation, time, place, number plates and what the people look like, and anything else that strikes you out of the ordinary. You can give it to the police immediately if necessary. You are NOT going to be able to pin that person for child abduction in public even if they are one. Try it and see what happens!

    Most abductions are by parents in custody battles anyway.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • zabie

      I don’t agree, I can see it from the woman’s point of view. She had seen the child with her Mum just a few minutes earlier (and probably on previous occasions). Now the child was being walked away by a man she’d never seen before, with Mum nowhere in sight. In asking the child “where’s Mummy?” she probably wasn’t looking for some articulate explanation from her, but just for signs of distress or confusion. Remember, the woman would have been feeling extremely nervous and panicked. Imagine how you would feel if you suspected, but weren’t sure, that you were witnessing a child abduction. It would be very scary. You only have split seconds to react and you risk a lot either way – do nothing and you risk a child’s life; intervene and risk huge embarrassment and awkwardness if you’ve got it wrong.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • lucindainthesky

        I can definitely see the woman’s point of view – particularly if she hadn’t seen Mike and daughter interact before they walked away. However I still think she approached it the wrong way. A child could seem distressed and still NOT be being abducted. A conversation with the child that included the suspect would be enough to detect if something wasn’t right. I stand by my initial thoughts that she didn’t have the right to treat Mike the way she did. After the first, “it’s ok I’m her Dad” she should have backed off. Her actions could have actually put her own safety at risk, as well as the child’s, had he been an actual abductor. The other thing is, there is about millionth of a per cent chance that he was actually an abductor. You wouldn’t be rude to someone on a hunch that they might be a paedophile, or a thief, or a wife basher… you observe and speak to them normally until they give you strong reason to believe your suspicions are right. So why is child abduction different? It would have been different if this woman had seen the mother walk inside to pay for her coffee and some random walk up from nowhere and lead the child away, but she didn’t actually see anything. I think her intentions were good, but I think it wouldn’t hurt her to think about how she approached the situation.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  31. kylie

    oh, and on the flip side, my son is autistic and when strapped to a pram screams like a banshee, i am horrified not once has my father or husband or even me, been pulled up leaving shopping centers, and he yells ‘help me’ or, “you hurting me”

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  32. kylie

    i had police called on me for leaving my children in the car, one was 8 years old and vomiting the other was 2. what i did was wrong, i know that, but at the time with 2 kids with severe gastro, i was on my own interstate and on the last nappy. i stood there and watched the woman call the police, she was talking to my kids, they are friendly, people do. but the cops came within 5 minutes…. i was so annoyed as she has a 1-2 year old, and had taken a moment to judge the situation and called 000, as i was being roasted by the police for leaving kids in a quiet car park locked in the car where i could see, yet her car was running door open and no one within 2 meters of the door, i still find that wrong.
    however, on the drive home as i was shaking from the ordeal i forgave her because, althou she was way off in this case, who is to say that given a different circumstance that what she did wouldnt save a life? i am thankful that some stranger cared enough for my kids, some random children in a car park made her go outside her comfort zone and she protected them. provided people mean well who am i to judge?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • AJ

      I don’t think what you did was wrong, it sounds perfectly reasonable to me in that situation.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  33. Anastasia Beaverhausen

    Lindsay Lohan

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. tanlee

    I think this is a very generous response to what occurred. Yes, it’s good to know others in the community are watching over our children but sometimes the paranoia of others does more harm than good. Men can feel unable to show affection to children in public in case they are mistaken for pedophiles. Children can be terrified by stories of stranger danger. It concerns me that the yoga instructor did not look Mike in the eye at the start. His initial emotional response suggests he clearly felt under suspicion. She could have approached him openly to resolve this matter without making him feel bad. They were in public. There were plenty of people around. Good on yer Mike for being generous enough to believe otherwise.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • a

      As Mike said, he is not a slip of a person and if I was to approach someone who I thought was potential abductor, I am not sure I would have the courage to look them in the eye or address them. And if she had addressed Mike or even a real abductor would their answers not be quite similar? An abductor would possibly lie and try and convince the person that they were the kid’s father.

      Kids usually tell the truth and so that’s why I think the yoga instructor felt it would be best to address the child.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  35. Nikki noo nah

    Wonderful story Mike, bought a tear to my eye, and I am so grateful to Champions like the Yoga Instructor out there. Please peeps, never 2nd guess yourself for approaching myself or my family in the same situation. We would appreciate the effort for the best result. It should be all about the kids and their safety not anyones pride….well written!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. Shannon

    This may have been said elsewhere, but I have to wonder if, had the situation been reversed and it were the father who was well-known and had left and a strange woman bent down and talked to the little girl and led her away, would anyone have batted an eyelid?

    That said, I applaud this woman for acting on that gut feeling that something may not have been right. Much better to be a wrong a thousand times than ignore that gut feeling and be right – with horrible consequences.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. essessesse

    That made me cry. What a beautifully written piece.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  38. merindakennedy

    Can I just say that first and foremost… what a fantastically written article. I also want to add that the yoga instructer was incredibly brave to go out and speak to your little girl and make sure that she was safe. I’m sure that many people have seen something and had a gut inspinct that ‘something wasn;t right’… but chose to not say anything.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. Jay

    I am a very vigilant parent and I still appreciate any help I get from strangers to keep my kids safe. Was it on mamamia that I read about a man carrying his kicking and screaming child out of a full SCG, and only one person taking any notice and asking a question?

    Your yoga lady rocks Mike for caring enough about the kids in her community to risk some embarrassment. And you rock too.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  40. E

    I love everything about this.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  41. YoungDietitian

    I think there are 2 champions in this story. The yoga instructor for following her gut instinct and the author for recognising (after a profanity laden drive home) that no harm was done and this wasn’t a personal attack but rather a concerned member of society doing what she felt she had to to protect a child. Society could do with more of both these personality types.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  42. JosieY

    What a champion.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  43. Anonymous

    Thinking about it, I find the woman’s question really odd. I mean, even if the girl had of answered it doesn’t explain anything. If she said “at work” or “over there” or “I don’t know”, that’s doesn’t tell the woman that she knows this man and that’s she’s ok. So I don’t know what she was expected to achieve with that, other than letting Mike know she suspected him, which, if he had been a predator is quite risky in that situation (caught in the act, can’t just run off because his car is still there etc.)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • MissLauren

      I guess by questioning the child, if the man was really trying to steal her it would make him uneasy and cause him to react, where she would then know something is up.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Hannah

        It’s not the best question to ask, but in a situation like that, I know I’d come out with a stupid question that I’d kick myself for asking later. It was the act of talking to the child about her carer and finding out if she felt safe that was important.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  44. justanotherday

    i think i’d rather feel embarrassed than be a victim.
    on a lighter note it’s embarrassing taking my then 11 year old son to a bakery in the barossa, only to have the nice old lady behind the counter ask my son if he is having a nice day out with grannie!!
    remind me to never have a child in my 40′s again ;)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Natalie

      I can relate. I’ve got a 7 month old boy and i’m 46. I knew one day the question would come. “Is he your first grandchild?”. I think I handled it well and so did the lady asking the question….

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • justanotherday

        lol..get used to it as it will happen. again and again. and each time it does, it completely catches you off guard. only because i forget how old i am. or that i may just be looking my age. i could even feel a little offended when people ask me i f i have grandchildren. it’s up there with being asked if you’re pregnant when you are not. all funny. ;)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  45. Elle

    If your daughter was screaming out or looking visibly disturbed then I personally would have stepped in if I saw it happen, but if not then why say anything? why make YOU as her dad feel bad, if I was in your position I would have let her have it, calling her a deviant for even thinking that way. The fact when you said your her dad and she kept asking where mummy was, would be the last straw for me, I suggest your wife find somewhere else to do yoga rather then be annoyed by brain dead morons.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Jay

      Harsh.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • blu-k

      yeah, I’m with you – this is really worst-first thinking to assume it’s an abduction

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • B.

      Until you live down the road from where Daniel Morcombe was abducted. When SO many people drove past and did nothing. I’ve wished so many times that it was me driving on that road that day, seen what was happening and stopped. I wish I had the opportunity to interfere. I wish someone was as brave as the yoga lady.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  46. reader

    why didn’t yoga woman ask the staff in the coffee shop first. The whole situation would have been avoided if she had just asked someone.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • peppy

      Maybe she didn’t want to waste time asking, in case the little girl was being taken – in which case she would have kicked herself for the rest of her life for not just going straight out and sussing out the situation…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Kris2040

      Or just go “Oh that must be her dad”?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  47. Elle

    I think you’re both champions.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  48. Deni

    The best approach, if you were that suspicious, would be to make light of the situation: maybe ask “ooh is this your daddy is it sweetie?” With a smile Instead of “where’s mummy?” and looking all panicked and shaky. That comment annoyed me. “Daddy’s” exist too, yoga woman, have a little faith! The child-taking stats are actually quite low, there’s a huge media beat up about it trying to make ppl scared as usual. Are we that distrusting and suspicious of people these days? It’s pretty sad really.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      I agree. The best way to handle something like this is lightly. Start a conversation. In this case, as the child and her mum are known to the yoga woman, she could have asked the girl if this was her Dad without implying she suspected anything, just as a way of introducing herself.

      If Mike had been a stranger abducting a child, this woman’s behavior would have made him more dangerous.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jay

        I don’t think this woman had very much time to think about the best approach. Full marks to her for doing anything. Children being safe is more important than an awkward moment between yoga woman and the dad.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Em

          I agree she was probably panicked, impulsive and as it turns out, wrong. But I’d rather have people like her around anyday!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  49. Jess

    There’s a fine line between looking out for a child in this kind of circumstance and just being rude.

    Like many of the comments below, I commend you for being able to look at the positive side of the incident.

    However, I can’t help but relate this to my own experience with a similar occurrence when I was a child. I was with my younger sister (we were probably about 9 and 7 at the time) and my mum’s partner of many years. My sister had an exceptionally close bond with him and even called him ‘Daddy’. He was a lot older than my mum – in his 60s at the time. I can’t remember why my mum wasn’t with us but we had just gone out for dinner with him and we were getting back into the car when a young woman came rushing over to us. “Excuse me, excuse me… I’m doing a research project for university about grandparents’ relationships with their grandchildren”.

    It was absolutely humiliating. Even as a 9 year old I could feel his embarrassment.

    So I guess from my perspective and in my story, the lady who rushed over to us wasn’t wrong for assuming what she did but it was still unnecessarily rude and made us very uncomfortable.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  50. Miss B

    It’s interesting to hear it from the other side. We certainly are always bombarded by the horrible things that happen every day and how we can prevent them.

    Us urban dwellers are labelled as assholes because we rarely make eye contact, walk right past the homeless guys without a second thought and would probably step right over a convulsing teenager in Kings Cross on a Saturday night.

    So when someone does go with their instinct and try to protect a child, it does show that there is still some heart in the world, but unfortunately, it hurts the poor dad’s heart.

    It must be insulting and harsh and make you question yourself, but I hope you don’t, Mike, because I bet it was nothing personal.

    In this case, she was wrong, as people often are, but if she had been right, if someone had come and taken your beautiful little girl that wasn’t her dad, it would have been all so different. She would be an absolute hero.

    It sucks that she made you feel bad, but it could have been worse.

    I

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Pete

      Yeah… I don’t think many people would ignore a convulsing teenager.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions