Do You Like This Story?
 Why Australia isnt ready for a female Prime Minister.

Australia’s current Prime Minister Julia Gillard.


By KAYLIA PAYNE

Now, I know this is a shocking title. I’m sure none of you reading this would agree. And I don’t either (cue sighs of relief). But whether or not I want a female prime minister doesn’t matter in the slightest. It’s just that I simply can’t help but think that Australia isn’t ready for one.

Not because I don’t want equality, because I do. Not because I don’t think that a woman is just as capable of being Prime Minister as a man, because I do. But because Australia’s attitude towards our first female Prime Minister is so embarrassing on a world-wide scale, and so completely shameful that it has taught both myself and women everywhere just how equal, and how respected, we are not. And how very far Australia has to come in its attitudes towards women, especially women in power.

Now I’m not saying that the general dislike of Gillard is any demonstration of sexism. Australians have a tendency to loathe whoever is in power at the current time, and to be honest, I love our dissatisfaction. It means that we’re never very likely to settle – and though kicking up a stink about every.single.thing.ever is slightly annoying at times, it is better than the alternative. In fact, I myself am disappointed with Gillard’s performance. As a left-wing vegan feminist I was hoping for a Gough Whitlam style change, not simply another Rudd sucking up to the right-wing middle class and forgetting about everyone else.

 Why Australia isnt ready for a female Prime Minister.

Julia Gillard has faced much criticism that references her gender.

But I am so much more disappointed with the public’s reaction to her. Because the dislike goes further than I have seen it before. Because it is accompanied by not just a lack of respect for Gillard as a politician, but for Gillard as person.

And it seems to me that this severe disrespect stems only from the fact that she’s a woman.

I have both read and seen so many comments calling her a ‘bitch’ or a ‘slut’ with vehemence never encountered before in regards to someone in public office. Her appearance is constantly criticised- not in the way that we laughed at Howard (I swear politicians are elected simply on how easy they make a political cartoonist’s job) but in a way that implies that if she is not attractive, what on earth is she doing all up in our faces.

One only has to go to an ‘I hate Julia’ facebook page to see photoshopped half-naked pictures of her in horrible positions and comments mocking her gender like ‘get back in the kitchen’ or the fact that she menstruates. I even had a customer at Gloria Jean’s comment in what seemed to be genuine horror ‘she might start a war while she’s on the rag!’

Her marital and childless status has been mocked by many – even people I know who certainly would never have dreamed of judging anyone else for it. And what really screams disrespect to me is this: she is the first politician that people go around calling by their first name – Julia. Or ‘ju-liar’ as the more ‘clever’ Australians refer to her. It might seem like a little thing, but I have never heard anyone talking about ‘John’ or ‘Tony’- as if her sex voids her from the type of respect due to a male politician.

And due to the public’s reaction to her, Abbott has played the gender card over and over again without anyone calling him on it or saying that it’s inappropriate (at least not until Gillard blasted him herself in her memorable speech).

kaylia Why Australia isnt ready for a female Prime Minister.

Author Kaylia Payne. She does believe Australia should have a female Prime Minister.

Abbott has consistently gone around making comments like “Are you suggesting to me that when it comes from Julia, ‘No’ doesn’t mean ‘No’”, “I think it would be folly to expect that women will ever dominate or even approach equal representation in a large number of areas simply because their aptitudes, abilities and interests are different for physiological reasons” and “I think there does need to be give and take on both sides, and this idea that sex is kind of a woman’s right to absolutely withhold, just as the idea that sex is a man’s right to demand I think they are both they both need to be moderated, so to speak”.

And yet has never been a lasting outcry to these outrageously sexist statements. General members of the public going around every day talking about the ‘stupid red-head bitch’ and ‘the slag’ and no one even bats and eyelid anymore.

This lack of respect is not just going to affect this generation. Little children will hear their parents talking like this about a woman in power and will take on those attitudes. This will stem a new generation of people that still see women as second-class citizens; as people that don’t command the kind of respect that a man does.

The purpose of this article is to ask you, nay implore you, to think about the way you speak about Australia’s first female Prime Minister. You don’t have to like her. But by calling her a bitch, slut, or any other offensive word thrown only at women, you are guaranteeing that the next female Prime Minister, and women in general, will continue to be treated with the same disrespect.

*Note: the title and introduction are tongue in cheek. Whether Australia likes it or not, I’m for one am very excited that we finally have a female Prime Minister! But for how long? We’ll know soon after 14 September…

This piece was originally published on HerCanberra, and is republished here with full permission. 

Kaylia is a career-student who is currently doing her MA in Writing and Literature. A public servant by day and a writer by night, she dreams of one day having a job where she doesn’t need to wear shoes to work.

Do you think Australia is ‘ready’ for a female Prime Minister? Are you embarrassed by the gendered criticism of Julia Gillard?

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

187 Comments so far

  1. knowerzark

    i don’t believe australia should have a female prime minister. i believe australia should have a capable, steadfast leader who does what they believe is best for the country now and in the future. i couldn’t care less if they have 3 heads and a tail…though that might become confusing.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. Anonymous

    I have nothing against having a female prime minister, but I have no respect for THIS prime minister, purely based on how she got into power (backstabbing), how she managed to stay in power (despite getting less votes) by selling out to the independents and greens – and of course the carbon tax, thanks to which my electricity bill has doubled.. yay! So if using a female slur is inappropriate, let’s just call her a bastard (as per the ‘keeping the bastards honest’ slogan made famous by another female politician.. who then joined them :P )

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Mimi

    Instead of giving a politician the keys to the city, it might be better to change the locks.

    Doug Larson

    Truer words were never said

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Matt

    Calling her Julia is sexist now? Come on, your really clinging at straws there…
    And I have never heard anyone call her a slut. Bitch on the other hand, I have. Just because you don’t really call a guy a bitch doesn’t mean he would escape without equally harsh criticism if he was in the job. And as for commenting on her clothes etc… Well she is a woman, and to ignore the fact that women like to dress up etc and it is more of a talking point to talk about their fashion does not make it sexist, jeez. Women and men are different, why treat them the same? They should be treated with the same amount of respect (or disrespect) but not treated exactly the same.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Missed the point.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  5. Another anon

    I also agree with this article. It isn’t about whether Ms Gillard is a good, bad or other Prime Minister. It’s about the disrespectful way she is treated by press, the opposition, and many others. For example, Tony Abbott or Alan Jones never referred to John Howard as ‘John’, it’s ‘Mr Howard’.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Plenty that call the current PM Ms Gillard called Mr Howard names like Little Johnny, and much worse.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  6. Guest

    I think the next Prime Minister of Australia – one Kevin Rudd, although only briefly – shares the view of the title of this article. Indeed, he said as much, describing Julia Gillard as an atheist, childless ex communist as a reason why she shouldn’t be PM. Oddly enough he seems to have got away with it: while you can find the comment on google, no one suggests someone who holds these views is unfit to be PM, a luxury I doubt would be extended to Tony Abbott.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • linda

      You have your facts wrong Guest. I think you’ll find the Labor caucus voted on whether Kevin Rudd is fit to be PM, and the result was a resounding ‘no’.

      The report that Kevin Rudd described PM Gillard in those terms was a deciding factor (but there were many other factors as well).

      It also needs to be recognised that:

      a) Kevin Rudd’s remark was made in private to Labor colleagues. I’m not saying he didn’t say it, or that it wasn’t wrong or offensive – but he didn’t say it in the media, in parliament, or anywhere else where it was recorded formally. In contrast, Abbott has made all his offensive remarks about Gillard, and about women in general, proudly on the public record (hence she was able to provide them as evidence of his sexist behaviour, and note that he has not been able to refute any of them – they speak for themselves).

      b) Kevin Rudd does not have a consistent public record of making sexist comments and judgements about women over the past +30 years. Tony Abbott does.

      If you think Tony Abbott is fit to be PM, that’s fine, but many people disagree with you. Imagine him hanging out with President Hillary Clinton, referring to her as ‘she’ and making remarks like ‘when Hillary says no she sometimes means yes’. It’s deeply embarrassing.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  7. linda

    Yep. I agree with this article.
    I have to say the treatment of PM Gillard by the opposition and its followers, and the mainstream media, have made me rethink my own approach to criticising politicians whom I don’t like (Tony Abbott at #1, Pyne, both Bishops, Mirabella and Robb are all up there too, and on the progressive side Bandt and Hanson Young).
    I have in the past been guilty of torrid, unpleasant personal criticism when discussing them with friends or on social media. Looking at the vile things said about Gillard, I decided my own declarations were not as bad in degree, but qualitatively they were similar.
    So I resolved to keep my own viler declarations about Abbott private, between me and my trusted friends, and publicly be constructive.

    Point out policy shortcomings, provide evidence for accusations, and refrain from commenting on speedos and botox etc.

    I dunno. I think we as electors need to do that and maybe the unpleasant types in the media and coalition will follow…. At least I feel like less of a hypocrite myself.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Guest

    I blame Tony Abbott and his relentless negativity. If he wasn’t constantly pointing out the Government’s mistakes and taking political advantage of them the PM would be doing so much better.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • guest-er.

      I think you just called out Tony Abbott for doing his job. That’s what opposition leaders do.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Guest

        That’s not the ONLY thing they are supposed to be doing. It’s best they have policies and ideas of their very own.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  9. Gemack

    I agree with your sentiment, because as it stands right now, Australia has less of a percentage of female politicians than Afghanistan does. That’s a problem. I also agree that a lot of the attacks on Julia have been from people who quite literally have no idea why they don’t like her, except that she’s a woman and other people don’t like her. Or, perhaps more insultingly, that there must be something wrong with her because she doesn’t have children. Huh?

    I too worry for the young girls growing up watching their fathers (and MOTHERS – plenty of women are just as venomous in their attacks), and the media crucify Julia. I know I always had political ambition and the reaction to Julia Gillard has definitely swayed me against it. It’s just too nasty.

    That said, taking the Gillard Government on its merit only; I am not happy. At all. At the last election I was in Barcelona, and had to travel 400km to Madrid to put in a vote at the embassy for Labor. That’s how important it was to me. However, since then, I have watched them demonise asylum seekers and implement policies worse than the Howard Government’s, vote down gay marriage, the mining tax has been a dismal failure ($126 million revenue from an expected $2 billion), some sectors of the economy are doing well but others are seriously struggling (manufacturing, retail) to the point where most uni students graduating today are terrified about their job prospects, and put in employment laws which despite good intentions, do ridiculous things (e.g. there is now an onus of proof on employers to prove they did not bully someone. Someone tell me how you prove that!). Oh, and also, the anti-discrimination “loophole” that allows publicly funded religious organisations providing public services to discriminate on whatever grounds they choose.

    Now before it’s said, no I don’t like Tony Abbott any better. I think he’s worse. But I should not be going into an election trying to figure out who’s “less bad” to run the country. I know it’s awful, but part of me hopes he wins so that Labor will take a good hard look at themselves and go back to the values they USED to be about.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Anonymous

    You know what, these political conversations on MM used to be dominated by moderate/progressives, now more conservatives are commenting and liking.

    I’m trying to work out if the progressive MM readers have withdrawn their support for Julia Gillard or they’re no longer commenting after pre-moderation weeded them out or they just can’t arsed trying to persuade the unpersuadable.

    All the same old chestnuts: ALP economic mismanagement – demonstrably untrue, but wheeled out time and time again.

    Julia Gillard is a liar – how soon do we forget all of Howard’s ‘non-core promises’? The children overboard affair? Etc. etc. etc.

    I’m not 100% enamoured of Julia Gillard. I’ve rarely been 100% pleased with any Australian PM’s conduct and decisions.

    BUT, who could vote for Tony Abbott?

    Intimidation of Barbara Ramjan – allegedy punching the wall beside a small, female student politician’s head and staring at her ninches from her face. Inexcusable and Barbara’s account is supoorted by many.

    Punching a 24 yo environmental activist in the face during uni. A guy called Peter Woof who alleges that he caught Abbott acting unethically by changing the locks to thre Student Council offices. That one went to Glebe courts but Woof backed down because he couldn’t finance a court case against the ‘half a dozen’ strong team of barristers and lawyers that Abbott’s family hired for him.

    The journalist Lindsay Foyle alleges that he got into a disagreement with Abbott in the Castelreagh Hotel over abortion, spefcifically, women’s right to control their bodies. Abbott suggested that they go outside and settle it by him re-arranging Foyle’s face for him.

    Do you honestly think that someone who nearly gets into a fistfight over a conversation on abortion has managed to set such a backwards and meddlesome opinion aside?

    In my opinion, vote for the LNP and you will be putting downward pressure on your personal rights.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Bradley

      I completely understand why you posted anonymously.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        Bradley, I’m completely unsurprised that you hold that opinion.

        So, your pro bullying women, pro-assault and pro-life?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Bradley

          Not at all.

          You see, whenever I make a comment or accusation, I stand by it and own it by never posting under the title “Anonymous”.

          I do not support bullying, fullstop ! I do not support assault, and I am pro-choice.

          Again, you’ll notice that I used my actual name to make the comment.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Anonymous

            Bradley, posting using your first name doesn’t mean that I’ll ever be able to identify you.

            Why does it matter? My viewpoint is out on display and that’s all you need to respond.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
        • Bradley

          I should further add, many people feel more comfortable posting anonymously when they are repeating untruths and hearsay. They may be sued otherwise.

          You have repeated allegations. If there was a modicum of truth to these allegations, why haven’t the police been called in ? In the instance of Ms Ramjan, she recalled the matter twenty years after the event. Her only witness, her future husband who is now, like Ms Ramjan, a very close friend of the Labor Party. Have you ever been involved with a uni student’s union ? Break wind and everyone hears it. Why is it that the incident not create a bit a noise around the uni at the time ? Why is it that no one else has suddenly remembered the issue. As Ms Ramjan has indicated, there were several people standing about watching it unfold.

          As for the journo who you state makes an allegation against Abbott not report it to someone ? There was no witness ? The allegation to rearrange the journo’s face was made in the privacy of a toilet cubicle or via email ?

          So yes. I understand why you have chosen to remain anonymous.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Anonymous

            Bradley, I’ve called them allegations and I should point out, ‘re-arrange your face’ is a para-phrasing. Tony is alleged to have asked him to step outside on abortion. I have no idea how it was phrased.

            In any case, Abbott has some undeniable form, his assault on Woof will be in the Glebe Court’s records.

            Also, are you stating that Barbara Ramjan lied, as per your ‘untrue allegations’ comment below?

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
        • Bradley

          I honestly hope that my replies to this comment are considered safe enough to make it through moderation, because like most of us, I don’t like having untrue allegations made against me.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Gemack

      I genuinely think that a lot of progressives/moderates have withdrawn their support for Julia Gillard.

      I proudly put myself in that category, and she lost me completely with her asylum seeker/refugee policy and another nail in the coffin was when they voted down gay marriage.

      One of the problems with the Labor Govt is their social policies are too right for the left-wing, and their economic/IR policies are too left for the right-wing. They are pleasing no-one.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Liz

        That’s a particularly astute last paragraph, Gemack. Labor seem stuck between trying to please two separate demographics and ends displeasing both. Nevertheless, I agree I have never read such vitriol directed to another politician.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Lisa66

        Totally agree re asylum seekers and that the government’s social policies are too far to the right.

        But I will still vote for them. Whilst I agree with the Green on a lot of issues they are not a viable alternative and a vote for the coalition is unthinkable for me.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Anonymous

      Keep whispering me those sweet nothings, you silver tongued charmer, Wayne.

      There was a full page Honi Soit article on the matter and I heard of this through people who were at Sydney uni at the time.

      Direct proof, about as much as you have that he didn’t.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  11. Anonymous

    What a stupid piece. If we weren’t ready for a female prime minister then we wouldn’t have one! The fact that she’s wont be PM after the next election (or sooner if the rumours are to be listed to) has nothing to do with her gender and everything to do with poor leadershp, decision making and general idiocy in the Labor party. To write such an article as this puts the casue of equality back 20 years. Well done on that.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. Anonymous

    I have to reply to ‘Sammy’ about the PM’s so-called lie about the carbon tax.

    This belief is so very mis-informed – if the Prime Minister had not had to deal with a minority government there would’ve been an Emissions Trading Scheme instead of Carbon pricing. Gillard dealt with the issue by the only way she could – confer with the Independents and the Greens. What she should’ve done after the election was say ‘We’re sorry but to ensure Australia begins to deal with Climate Change, we must start with making the big polluters pay.’

    All this rubbish about a carbon tax lie is just propaganda spewed out by an Opposition (plus their media bedfellows and the big polluters themselves) to try to defeat climate change action.

    Do you care about your children’s and grandchildren’s future? If so, you’d be screaming from the rooftops about our slow crawl towards action. Inform yourself about the issue, listen to climate change scientists who’ve been warning humans for thirty years that our planet faces a bigger risk than we can imagine.

    And re the current carbon tax – you are not affected at all monetarily. You (and all of use, except the big polluters) do not pay tax on carbon, and the Government has gone even one step further to make sure you’re not affected by companies putting up prices because they have to pay the tax. You get compensated – yes, you and me. What can you be whinging about?

    If I was running the country, I’d make sure each of us only gets rewarded for lowering our own use of electricity, for making less pollution, because that is what really matters. Aren’t you lucky I’m not the PM. :)

    Actually, everyone, did you know that since the carbon tax was introduced our carbon emissions have gone down? Tell your children. They’ll thank you for their future.

    I’m so pleased we have a female Prime Minister – and a strong one at that. I can’t imagine what it must be like to cop the abuse thrown at her and we are a poorer nation for it. I hope she goes to the Election holding her head up high – and even if she loses, I’ll be damn proud of her!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Sammy

      Well I guess I am glad you are not the PM for its obvious you are ill informed try reading about Agenda 21 I don’t talk about it often because most people just don’t want to know but it will sure open your eyes if you are interested. A carbon tax does not change anything it’s just another tax. As for the ETS did you know it’s already defunct in Europe the only people who get rich out of these schemes are people like Al Gore who live in huge mansions and have private jets.
      Those countries who do the most polluting like China and India do not have a carbon tax and have not cut down on their emissions. So where does it help if our old people die from the heat or cold because they can’t afford heating or cooling does it help the planet ? We had to borrow the money to pay to help disadvantaged people pay their power bills so now we are in massive debt which I might add is not mentioned in the budget that’s right it’s not spoken about because its our children and grandchildren who will have to pay it back.
      The amount of pollution is the same we are just paying for someone else to do it. How is this fair? Our carbon emission have gone down have they ? Well proberbly because of all the jobs lost due to business going bankrupt or moving overseas might have something to do with it. You do realize that instead of making lives better for people in third world countries they are trying to lower our standards for a more level plaing field. We are responsible for such a minuscule amount of pollution compared to big countries it hardly makes a difference. I want a government who cares about our future and our children’s future but that’s never going to happen the days of that type of honesty are over and people see politics for what it really is, one great big con so I say to you read Agenda 21 this has been planned for a long time. By the way if I can tell your a labour pollie so can everyone else. But what do us mere peasants know its for the good of the planet right ?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Jessica

      I think Ms Gillard is moonlighting here on MM.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  13. katherine anne

    I actually think that the attitude towards PM Gillard is less about gender and more about a generational shift in thinking.

    When I was at school, we were taught to respect our teachers, regardless of how terrible or hopeless or even unfair they were. You still called them Sir and Miss, and spoke respectfully about them and to them. Now, I’m reading all these comments about the PM ‘earning’ respect and proving herself worthy of respect. As a teacher at a difficult school, the students seem to think it’s okay to disrespect a teacher until they have ‘earned’ their respect.

    I don’t think it works that way. You respect someone in office/leadership position regardless of how terrible they are. Respectfully disagree with their policies, teaching or leadership style, but don’t disrespect them by using first names or name calling.

    I’ve noticed this as a general trend, not just towards the PM or women in general. E.g. an unpopular male teacher at my school (workplace) is constantly called ‘Martin’ by the students AND parents, as a sign of disrespect. This would never have happened when I was in school.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Lulu

      I don’t think it’s just generational. A lot of the people making disrespectful comments are over 40, and I would expect had the same kind of upbringing you’re taking about, as far as at least addressing teachers etc formally.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  14. Caz Gibson

    Kaylia – I truly wanted to believe that Australia was ready.
    Whenever I’ve had the opportunity I’ve championed the idea that Australia is the most free, least sexist, least xenophobic, fairest country on earth but whenever I see those insults aimed at Julia Gillard, I feel a deep disappointment.
    Thousands of women in the late 1800′s who attempted to have a voice were bullied and bashed and so the fact that we finally have a female PM is of great historical significance. She got into office through the machinations of her party, and if Kevin Rudd replaces her soon it will be for the same reason.
    I fear that we won’t have a female PM again (leading either party) until those who’ve been “spewing bile” about her gender have truly faded away.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Sammy

    Male or female I don’t care what I do care about is the gross incompetence and the lying (no carbon tax ) my whole family has always been labour voters but none of them or my friends will vote labour in the coming election. The only way they could possibly redeem themselves is a change of leadership and policy and then maybe they might just scrape it in.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Sheryl Gwyther

      Sammy, your attitude is so very mis-informed – if the Prime Minister had not had to deal with a minority government there would’ve been an Emissions Trading Scheme instead of Carbon pricing.

      Gillard dealt with the issue by the only way she could – by conferring with the Independents and the Greens. But what she should’ve done after the election was say ‘We’re sorry but to ensure Australia begins to deal with Climate Change, we must start with making the big polluters pay.’

      All this rubbish about a ‘carbon tax lie’ is just propaganda spewed out by an Opposition (plus their media bedfellows and the big polluters themselves) to try to defeat climate change action.

      Do you care about your children’s and grandchildren’s future? If so, you’d be screaming from the rooftops about our slow crawl towards action. Inform yourself about the issue, listen to climate change scientists who’ve been warning humans for thirty years that our planet faces a bigger risk than we can imagine.

      And re the current carbon tax – you are not affected at all monetarily. You (and all of use, except the big polluters) do not pay tax on carbon, and the Government has gone even one step further to make sure you’re not affected by companies putting up prices because they have to pay the tax. You get compensated – yes, you and me. What can you be whinging about?

      If I was running the country, I’d make sure each of us only gets rewarded for lowering our own use of electricity, for making less pollution, because that is what really matters. Aren’t you lucky I’m not the PM. :)

      Actually, everyone, did you know that since the carbon tax was introduced our carbon emissions have gone down? Tell your children. They’ll thank you for their future.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Sammy

        Just cause you post it twice doesn’t make it true.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • John

        So you are okay with the massive debt that this govt has put us in then? Good I hope so cause its us idiots that will be paying for years to come. Not affected by this monetarily . What planet are you living on ? 200 billion in debt affects us all for years to come. I just can’t believe how naive some people are.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • TuesdayTracy

        Completely agree Sheryl.
        I think I heard Gillard say on Q and A when asked about the ‘no Carbon tax’ quote….
        “Well, if the road to your house is blocked, you don’t just sit there all night in your car, you find another way home”

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • John

          You can’t possibly be serious ?

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  16. Karma

    I think one reaps what they sow. She and the faceless men thought they were doing Australia a favour with their bloody coup of a well liked (in the public’s eyes anyway) prime minister. Instead, they have made a bloody mess.

    I am embarrassed that she is our first female prime minister. I had always imagined our first female head of state would achieve that goal by winning an election (not a party room ballot). I cannot admire her tactics to become leader. I cannot admire the way she has tried to grasp onto any available straw in order to form government. I cannot as a feminist, as a supporter of female equality support someone who is so underhand in her actions.

    The boganoid component of Australia might comment on her dress sense, her accent or her childlessness. I think they attack her in such a way as they do not know or understand how to attack her actions.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. Observer

    I moved to Australia in 2009. When the 2010 elections were to come in, I wanted labor to win, because Rudd was in charge and he clearly seemed the better alternative. And then PM Gillard happened. I welcomed that too, because better any labor PM than Abbott, right? And I wanted the female PM thing to happen because it was about time already, we had our first in 1980′s.

    And then, PM Gillard started her policy. And I sat through it. And now, I would rather have Abbott as PM. Because that was just how abysmal PM Gillard has been.It is a complete turnaround, because she has done a terrible job.

    And, I do not think that Australia is not ready for a female PM. If she is a good enough PM and does not do crazies like cutting welfare, I don’t think she would be called the names. The names come from disgruntled poor people. I don’t believe that etiquette comes before hunger.

    About the FB hate pages, have you even SEEN the hate pages for other politicians??

    Also, there’s numerous immigrant hating pages on FB as well. Like fuck off we’re full. Or turn the boats back. Or go back to where you came from. Why didn’t you write an article about how Australia isn’t ready for immigration? Please do not spin PM Gillard’s inefficiency as sexist slander. I am officially sick of this. There HAS to be a limit. Claiming that Australia is not ready for a female PM is a rather serious claim to make. And I will not take it.

    And, as far as people talking foul about her with outrageous obscenities, I go to university and none of the people around me do. Neither does my family. I guess it depends on where you draw your samples from.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Catz

      How can you say Julia Gillard has done a terrible job? Even under the tremendous pressure of a minority government, she and the Government have passed many hundreds of laws and legislation that will greatly benefit this country.
      Unfortunately, this is never highlighted in the mainstream media (maybe this account for your lack of knowledge about it), but that is what matters, not personalities and all that rubbish.
      Rudd used to be the top public servant in my home state of Qld – unfortunately his autocratic style of dealing with people didn’t change when he became PM – I’m guessing his cabinet colleagues reached the breaking point. Kevin Rudd ‘comes across’ as a nice bloke but that’s not what makes a true leader.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Alex

        “Even under the tremendous pressure of a minority government, she and the Government have passed many hundreds of laws and legislation that will greatly benefit this country.”

        Name two.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Observer

        She voted down gay marriage. Paraphrasing what she said about the topic, it was something on the lines of ” I’m the PM of this country, if I don’t need marriage, I think people can live without it.”

        As an immigrant, I sympathise deeply with asylum seekers. I have been in terrible conditions. But bee fortunate enough to get a visa. Her Malaysia solution is dubious. It made me so angry.

        As someone working in the mining industry, her tax has been nothing but perpetual job loss scare for me.

        So, there. That’s why I think she did a terrible job.

        And of course, I can never forgetthe way she became PM. had a man done it to a sitting female PM, it would’ve been the outrage of the century.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Guest

          ‘Leadership spills’ are very common Observer, at least in Australian politics, so cross that one off your list of disappointments and put that down to politics.

          There’s just too many to mention here so check this wiki entry for yourself:

          http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leadership_spill

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  18. tanlee

    Poor title. Not really the point. But I agree that the level of disrespect shown towards Julia goes beyond that shown towards male pms. There is a sense that she is not considered a real leader somehow. Shame on us as a society!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anon

      The Problem with Ms Gillard is that she’s a lousy leader. It’s not because of her gender, and she’s certainly not called anything worse than John Howard was. Plenty of people on the left refer to Mr. Abbott as “The Mad Monk” so I can’t see where the problem is.

      As an individual, I choose to refer to her as “The PM”, “Ms Gillard” or “Julia Gillard. But that is my choice out of respect to the office, and my choice is to not engage in personal and nasty attacks on politicians of any colour. I will talk about her lack of honesty and lack of leadership ability, but I will not call her “Juliar”, it’s just tacky.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Guest

        Well, there you go, it’s all about having an opinion, isn’t it. I believe Julia Gillard has been a fine leader – no other person has endured the knockbacks and the kicks to the guts that she has.

        No PM in my memory (and I’ve voted for four decades), has endured the foul slathering across the social media that Julia Gillard has. No even John Howard and his ethics re the so-called ‘children overboard case’ were somewhat stained forever.

        And yet, this woman with the moral strength of a hundred lions has managed to push through legislation that will benefit Australians for generations. I can’t be bothered listing them here, but if you truly want to be informed, the list is easy to google.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  19. Jen

    As a woman, I’m enormously proud of having a female prime minister. As a mother, I tell my daughter that she too could one day grow up to be prime minister, that anything is possible for women. Why do we cut Julia Gillard down at any opportunity? Regardless of her politics, it is an amazing achievement to be Australia’s first prime minister.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • stef

      My daughters already knew they could be PM if they wanted. Ethnicity or gender are not issues for Australians. Ethics, morality and *competence* are!

      I’m a woman and a swinging voter. I’ll be proudly voting for Tony Abbott on September 14 even though he is that most reviled of creatures – a straight white man, faithful husband and loving father.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        Good point and because he is a straight white man he has been treated appallingly by the media and ridiculed remorselessly for the sin of being a life saver and a catholic. Far more, IMO, than Gillard has copped.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Guest

        Great you’re voting for a white, faithful, loving man… but,

        Aren’t you in the slightest bit concerned about his IDEAS or POLICIES or VIEWS on the future?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Guest

          Haha, well said, Guest. So many people have been sucked in by the main stream media’s anti-Gillard push and (maybe people harbour a touch of misogyny as well?).

          I would rather know what Abbott’s future plans were for the country if he gets in. To vote for his party and not know these things is like putting one’s head in the mouth of a big saltie.

          One would have to wonder why Abbott runs to the hills when asked about policies (not that too many brave journalists risk their bosses’ retribution for trying to pin the leader of the opposition down.)

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Mum of two cheeky monkeys

            There is no such thing as a touch of misogyny. That’s like being ht by a bit of a tsunami. it means extreme hatred. Extreme. I wish people would stop misusing that we’d, there are people in this world that it accurately applies to.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
        • Anonymous

          look at the liberal party website and you’ll see their policies.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Karma

      As a woman, I am seriously embarrassed about Julia’s behaviour

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  20. Gimme-a-break

    Men can be called ‘Bastards’ but women can’t be called ‘Bitches’ huh?
    I don’t condone either term but how can a society complain about a woman being called a bitch while accepting it’s to call a bloke a bastard.
    Or how many words is it acceptable use that refer in derogatory terms to the mail genitalia, when heaven forbid that society accept the ‘C’ word! Once again I don’t condone use of any such words but while we can derogatorily refer to the mail genitalia why it the female genitalia so sacred that any derigitory reference is a complete taboo?!!

    What’s sexist is women can say what they like about men but can’t take the treatment when the tables are turned.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Faybian

      Well clearly you haven’t been on the receiving end of b*^ch or c*^t,have you? Women have been copping this crap for years.
      As the kids say, your point is invalid.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Guest

        ‘Youth is wasted on the young’, GB Shaw

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Anonymous

        Not sure who you associate with to be on the recieving end of these insults, Fabian, but the only time I’m called a ‘c’ is when the local Aboriginals sit outside my grocery store and call me an effin white ‘c’ murderer.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • The wounded bull

        Sorry, we all cop it. For every female gender slur I will quote you a male one. You don’t have the monopoly.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • K

      Don’t mean to be rude, but it’s hard to take you seriously when you spell ‘male’ as ‘mail’! I didn’t know letters had a gender! :-)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  21. WillOnTheHill

    I think a lot of people are missing the point of the article which is well made. I’m an Australian living abroad and I was home recently when the PM announced the election and I was horrified in the main paper in WA there was a whole article about her glasses and the fashion taking up page 5.

    Whether or not you like Gillard, she does deserve respect as a person and the article says this really clearly. Feel free to passionately dislike her and / or her policies / behaviour but please, enough of the discourse about her fashion and the fact she is an unmarried woman.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • The wounded bull

      I think you are missing the point that every Australian PM in history has been called every name under the sun, and therefore any tretment Julia Gillard gets is not gender related. Argue respect for the position by all means, but therefore argue it for every PM in Australia’s history.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anonymous

      You think we didn’t read about John Howards eye brows or Paul Keatings taste in furniture.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Guest

        Did you read about their barren uteruses as well? No? Well that’s
        because these kinds of insults are ‘gender-specific’.

        I can’t really see your blind spot here.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Anonymous

          Julia doesn’t have a ‘barren uterus,’ she’s simply the founding member of Emily’s List.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Guest

            Er… no.

            I was referring to this:

            ‘The Liberal Senator Bill Heffernan has once again called Ms Gillard “deliberately barren” and unqualified for leadership, because she has no children.’ (ABC)

            Evade it all you like, but it’s there for all to see.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
    • RyanS

      Do you think it was just a co-incidence that she started wearing glasses the same day she announced the election? It’s a shallow attempt at winning over voters with a new, yes another, spin doctored Julia. You’re right that the focus is misplaced – someone needs to tell her.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Guest

        Yes, again, here is an example of someone judging the PM by what she wears. For goodness sake – you’re equating her new glasses with the election announcement? Get real! How ridiculous can you get?

        Stop reading the right-wing media and start looking at policies.
        I hope she’s re-elected – love strong women!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Mum of two cheeky monkeys

          You think she developed short sighted ness overnight on the eve of her election announcement! All politicians, male and female, get makeovers at some point. Kim Beasley, for example.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  22. John

    I simply don’t care one iota about Gillard’s gender. I care enormously that she is hopelessly incompetent.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. John

    I simply don’t one iota care about Gillard’s gender. I care enormously that she is hopelessly incompetent.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. Bradley

    Perhaps I’m just a little confused. Is the author saying that gender is what determines her view of the quality of the performance of the person who holds the keys to The Lodge ?

    If gender determines how you cast your vote, then you seriously should not be voting.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. Suki

    Do you think I am being sexist because I expected so much more from her because she is a woman?

    I think subconsciously I expected a higher degree of honesty from her than I would have from a man.

    Perhaps we are holding her to a higher standard so the disappointment smarts all the more.

    Thinking out loud.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • The wounded bull

      ‘Higher degree of honesty’, wow, now that IS sexist.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Sue

      Do you know I think you maybe right we were proud cause she was a woman and we thought she might have had some dignity but she has really let the team down.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  26. b2

    It’s nothing to do with sex and everything to do with trust and competence, this government seems to be sorely lacking in either. They’ve squandered billions of dollars of our hard earned taxes, borrowed billions more and spent it all. And all in the middle of a mining boom, and they STILL can’t balance the books despite telling us for years that they would.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. Carleekins

    Brilliant piece, and one that desperately needed to be written. The thing that makes me saddest is it is often women leading the charge, ‘Did you SEE her outfit at that press conference?’. Not a comment I can ever recall in relation to Howard or Rudd.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. female voter

    What crap. No one like Gillard because she’s been a woeful PM. She knifed Rudd after saying she wouldn’t, she introduced a carbon tax after saying she wouldn’t, and she’s stuck it to women by reducing the single parent payment. I could go on and on about her terrible decisions, but that fact is, none of them would have been tolerated if they were carried out by a man either. Placing the blame on sexism is offensive and she needs to be held to account just like any man would be, being female doesn’t mean she’s a protected species and it doesn’t mean she should escape the name calling and nicknames she readily dishes out herself.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. Sue

    I seem to remember John Howard being called ‘Little Johnny’ for many years. I really don’t believe she’s copping it anymore cause she’s a woman.

    However, I do think she has bought on herself the belief that she is untrustworthy and a hypocrite. I also found the whole ‘I will call sexism when I see it’ speech to just be a political tactic which has backfired because she certainly doesn’t call it when she sees it on her own side.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. caitlin

    totes agree with this article. have re-posted on FB. Ms Payne, I too am embarassed by some of the comments of my family and those that I consider my friends, when it comes to JG….. I have to quickly change the subject, so that I don’t simply ‘de-friend/ family’ such people.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • The wounded bull

      Like totes disagree sorry.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Guest

        Haha, much as I disagree with your political views WB, I do enjoy your posts!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  31. Sarah

    You know what? It IS a massive deal that she is our first women Prime Minister and for that alone I am proud.

    She is calm, articulate, smart and savvy. Could she be doing a better job policy wise? perhaps. But that does not cancel out all her great attributes in my eyes.

    When she was on QandA once (hmm wheres Mr Abbott?) I remember just being in awe of the fact she answered every question decisively and with a cool head and I think in that sense she IS a leader and I respect her so much for it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • John

      She may ‘answer’ questions but doe she answer them honestly?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  32. beansbeansthemagicalfruit

    I don’t think the name calling is due to sexism or ignorance on the part of Australians. Sure maybe a few but when someone is actually asked why they think the PM is a bitch or whatever the response usually has nothing to do with her gender; it’s to do with her performance. I’ve seen people talk online about Kevin Rudd’s small dick and how John Howard’s arse must’ve been stretched from being Bush’s “bottom”. And the stuff said about President Obama would (hopefully) never make it past the mods if I tried to post it. Unfortunately this seems to be how the majority express their displeasure with someone and it starts when we’re in school. It takes 5 minutes on a public Facebook page to see kids calling each other sluts, bitches, assholes, fags… even though they’re arguing about something that has nothing to do with gender or sexuality. I firmly believe you have to be at least 50% insane to willingly enter politics because this is what you and your family are going to cop when you inevitably piss someone off regardless of gender.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  33. Anonymous

    Oh dear, the MM readers have certainly grown up in the last couple of years. I hope McTernan is reading the comments and choking on his haggis.

    It’s all over for Underbelly Labor.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Faybian

      Is that you Meri? How about you just quit it with the BS comments and try to contribute something constructive?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  34. Sasha

    The point is WE elected her in. As a democracy we are all entitled to our views but we HAVE to express them in a civilised manner or else we just look disrespectful towards the idea of democracy as a whole.

    On the international stage, what kind of attitude do you think people have of Australians when they go online or read in the paper the kind of things that are written about her or anyone in power? As our PM (Yes! the one we chose even if some of us regret it now!) it is UNACCEPTABLE to call her a bitch/ slut/ witch and it would be unacceptable to call a male those terms as well.

    Remember, our whole country looks like an even bigger joke if we can’t even show an ounce of respect for her position. This is not a dictatorship where we show our disgust by revolting against her. It is a democracy where we display our views through our votes at the next election.

    We are disgracing every ideal our country was founded upon if we resort to this sad personal attacking.

    She IS Prime Minister Gilliard. You don’t have to like it. But you do have to call her that while she IS the PM.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • no we didn't

      WE didn’t vote her in, she bought her way in. WE don’t like/respect her, because she has lied her way right through her time as leader. She has done untold damage for any other woman wanting the “top job” and for that I disrespect her even more. Can’t see the back of her fast enough

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Sasha

        I don’t CARE if she bought her way in. She is our leader!!!!!! The position and influence she bears in addition to her title demand respect from all of us. You don’t have to like her but you have to respect the fact she is our leader. You can voice your opinion but not belittle her. That’s what I am astounded by!

        Why has she just done a disservice to women though?

        Why aren’t you arguing she has done a disservice to all politicians?

        I don’t understand why it would be any harder for another woman who was good at what she does to become PM in the future…. why has Prime Minister Gilliard “done untold damage?”.

        Are you saying Australians will be influenced in the future by gender?

        That would make me even sadder.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • anon

          RESPECT is out of this great country of ours!!!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Anonymous

          ‘she is our leader!!!!’

          Of course Sasha, how remiss of us to take umbridge at a leader who represents a party that is being dragged through the courts for corruption, who’s unions should be the subject of a royal commission, who lied to us, spins like a top and has overseen the country’s economy trashed to the tune of 250 billion dollars and rising!

          We should keep our mouths shut … like the Germans did.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Guest

            Anonymous, your nastiness to Sasha is very low, sir (or miss). And ever since Abbott and his cohorts have hijacked the mainstream media, this type of behaviour has bred, blighting the whole political scene.
            You too, continue this river of slime (by the way, are you one of those ubiquitous Liberal party staffers who are paid to spend all day commenting on blogs?)

            I can guarantee I’m not a Labor party staffer – I have too much housework piling up while I’m on this blog. I should be doing my real job – writing stories for children. :)

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • NSWvoter

              @ Guest “Anonymous, your nastiness to Sasha is very low” how was that nasty?

              What I think you mean is “how dare you state any opposition to my view, that offends me.” In her first term she knifed Kev, second term she bribed some independents and the greens. Its funny how when I bribe someone I go to jail, when pollies do it they get the top job.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
        • no we didn't

          You might not care Sasha – but plenty of Australians do. She started her term as PM in a deceitful manner and has pretty much stayed that way the entire time. I don’t give a hoot if she is a woman or a man – I would feel the same – betrayed and let down by “our leader”. My pocket has less in it than ever before, my austism spectrum child now has less support due to budget cuts (so much for more money for those with disabilities), my electricity bill alone was $1107 compared to $680 before carbon tax, our country is in massive debt, which it wasn’t before Labor came to power…….and don’t get me started on that voice!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Cg

      No, Sasha, we did not vote her in. She led a first term government to defeat for the first time in eighty years. She was handed government by the traitor twins, Oakeshott and Windsor – two politicians who, because of their personal beefs with the National Party, betrayed their conservative electorates … one of whom I will have the personal pleasure of voting into oblivion on or before September 14 if he has the guts to stand.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        And she’s done a mighty fine job too, within the confines of a minority government! Much better than Abbott and his cronies would’ve done – look at the way he tried to buy the support of Oakeshott back pre-election.

        Good for Oakeshott and Windsor for recognising the untrustworthy Abbott for what he was and still is. Clever and astute men, I say.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  35. DaveMan

    (Yawn) I wish Abbott was a woman so we would not have to listen to all this crap about Gillard being hated because of her sex, she is hated because she is a bad Prime Minister.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • The wounded bull

      But if that was the case, we could no longer make fun of his swimwear without a feminist riot.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  36. David

    if she were a male she would referred to as a dickhead and a tosser – really, the point here is that respect in public office must be earn’t and cannot simply be expected irrespective of what gender the politician is. Australia as actually well over due for an effective and visionary prime minister and if that’s a bloke and girl or a duck so long as they fill that void I, and I think the rest of the country will be respectful and grateful even

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. 30-something female

    My feelings about JG – which have turned utterly since 2007 – have nothing to do with her possession of a vagina, and everything to do with trust – or the lack of it actually.

    She had a chance, was doing wonderfulyl being 2-i-c, until she came upon us all prematurely (how rude!) by doing a MacBeth, with the ‘faceless men’ being the three witches of the story.

    She should have held off, because her time would have come more organically. Now, she’s seeing Banquo’s ghost everywhere.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Zepgirl

      Who do you reckon will be Macduff to Julia’s Macbeth?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  38. Trish

    I was very excited about having a woman Prime Minister but not about her. There was nothing about her that gave me the impression that I should vote for her and sadly she has constantly reinforced that belief.

    I am a woman, I was excited about having a woman as GG and Prime Minister but I have not seen any evidence that she has been competent which has nothing to do with her gender.

    I am happy to admit that I am a swinging voter but I am stuck in the upcoming election. I voted for The Milky Bar Kid (and yes I will probably still call him that if he gets in again, I usually refer Julia as Julia Gillard, Quentin Bryce as GG and I usually refer to Tony Abbott as that racist misogynistic pig and aside from the last one, it is absolutely not reflection of my respect for the person!) and if given the chance I would again. But our options this coming election are so poor that I am at a bit of a loss!

    It is a very common Australian thing to give people nick names, I don’t believe that most of the time we are being derogatory. I agree that Australians have not shown a lot of respect for her but quite frankly that seems to have been reciprocated which is devastating on both sides.

    But politics is NOT about gender. It is about finding a competent person with proven success and leadership skills to run the country. It would be nice if it was a woman but I simply want the most competent person for the job (and just to cover off the feminist workplace issue – I think that is the answer to the board and management issues also).

    Read any book on leadership. Does she stack up? Is she a Gail Kelly or a Jack Welch? I think not. But that’s who I want leading the country. Someone who has proven that they can.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. Bradley

    Personally I believe that Australia will readily accept a female PM…just not the current one.

    At the end of the day Julia Gillard only has herself to blame for her current standing in the popularity stakes. She has shown herself to be dishonest and hypocritical way too many times. Australians tend to let you get away with just so much before they stop looking the other way.

    We are looking, and there are indications that less are liking what they see on a daily basis.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Ash

      It’s fine for people to disagree with her politics or performance, but the name calling and the disrespect isn’t necessary – which I think is the point of this article.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Bradley

        Respect is earned. You may have to refresh the minds of many exactly what is that this PM has done to earn the respect of so few.

        As for name calling, this PM has been called no worse than any of those who have preceded her.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Anna

      Talking about being ‘ dishonest and hypocritical’, it’s puzzling why did most of us take so long in LOOKING at John Howard?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Zepgirl

        I’ve been reading this comment all day. And I *still* don’t get it.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  40. Sally

    I totally agree and think it’s so embarrassing for our nation.
    I think those who proclaim that most of the hatred comes from her ‘betrayals’ are kidding themselves.
    For a start – go ask people who work in high levels of the gov who they would rather work for, Gillard or Rudd.
    There is a mean, degrading spirit amongst Australians when it comes to females in high places. Many of us feel it to some point every day whether we always notice it or not.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  41. Anonymous

    I’m a woman of the same age as Julia Gillard. I have no respect for her personally or professionally. And the AWU scandal is far from finished.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Horse

      Nor is the scandal of Tony Abbott’s slush fund to get Pauline Hanson; or the use of Ashby to ‘get Slipper’.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  42. Miss Finance

    I think it’s too hard to tell if the abuse Julia Gillard has copped is because of her sex or because she’s part of a government that is an embarrassment to this country.

    As for the use of her first name and other nicknames…. have you not heard of Kevin, Krudd, Little Johnny, The Mad Monk (who I have oft heard referred to as ‘Tony’ as well), Wayne (Swan), George W, Billy McMahon…….??

    I think ‘Ju-Liar’ is pretty tame really. As for ‘Julia’, I think part of the reason she is referred to as such is because she has a unique(ish) and easily identifiable name… if she was simply called ‘Jan’ she’d probably be referred to by her surname much more often (or given another nickname like every other politician ever).

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Bradley

      If her name was Jan, then I believe that the line “not happy, Jan” would be ringing out up hills and down dales.

      Thank goodness that she isn’t named Verity. That would cause a few laughs.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Kris2040

      I agreed with pretty much the whole article except for the first name thing, too, MF – Little Johnny, K-Rudd, Krudd, Kruddy, Gough, Bobby, Billy…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Sasha

        I think the point was that Mr Abbott (see what i did!) refers to her as Julia as demonstrated in the quote the author presented.

        THAT shows a lack of respect on his part and is absolutely unacceptable regardless of whether he agrees/ disagrees with her.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Bradley

          She refers to him as Mr Rabbit.

          Don’t see Tony getting upset.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Anon

          She also called Christopher Pyne a “Poncing Poodle”

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Kris2040

            Paul Keating was renowned and celebrated for his sledges.

            Why anyone takes issue with Christopher Pyne being (accurately) called that is beyond me.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
  43. CK

    In my opinion, it has little to do with Julia Gillard being female and everything to do with the way Australians believe is appropriate behaviour. It starts at the top, and weaves its ugliness into home all over our country.

    If the politicians themselves can’t find it in them to respectfully argue their positions and objections, how can we expect any kind of respect shown to them from the general public?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  44. Lovely lady

    I think it is shameful but I don’t think it’s because she is a woman I think its due to her actions. She stabbed Kevin Rudd in the back, she seems to have had a shady past – married men, dishonest dealings when she was a lawyer, she has lied on several occasions a lot more then post previous politicians. She refuses to legalise gay marriage but doesn’t realise in the past living together not married was unacceptable but changes where made. Calling Abbott a masoginist but then not saying anything when her partner makes a racial sexist comment in public. She is surrounded by constant contradiction and I believe she has made a joke out of the advancement of woman.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  45. Mum of two cheeky monkeys

    Today’s news gives us the perfect example of why Australians are fed up with this government and by extension it’s leader Julia Gillard. I read where the government has announced a new education policy to improve literacy and numeracy. The policy is sound. It is worth spending money on – you’ll be hard pressed to find anyone who’ll fundamentally disagree with any part of the policy itself. Three problems though;

    1. The NSW and Victorian governments have already put a similar policy in place and have partially funded the extra staff. This covers more than half the population of Australian children. in NSW, where the new policy would employ 90 new literacy and numeracy experts, the state government has recently employed 50. So the implementation was not well planned, and the timing is clearly for political, not social, gain.
    2. In announcing the policy Ms Gillard used flawed statistics. Based on Naplan, the trend since 2008 has been for improvements in literacy. Her statistician forecasted illiteracy levels in 2025 using data from one outlying year, resulting in a significant overestimation of illiteracy. This is either incredibly sneaky or incredibly stupid. Anyone who knows anything about statistics will tell you that you use more than one piece of data to forecast.
    3. No separate funding has been identified. The policy will be funded by the 1 billion dollars in mining tax that the ATO themselves have stated will not exist.

    So to sum up, great policy, in accurately and incompetently presented with no discernible source of funding, which is already covered by the two biggest states.

    Is Australia ready for a female PM? The better question would be, how much damage to the cause of women in politics does it do to have our first female PM dictated to by factions within her own party? If she could just stick to her guns, be a leader, call the faceless men and the greens on their bluffs? Well, then she might be a leader worthy of respect.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kris2040

      The NSW govt may have hired 50 people, but they sacked a whole bunch last year who were helping the kids with literacy needs anyway!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Mum of two cheeky monkeys

        Yes we were bankrupted by the previous labor government and there have been cut backs, which sucks. But the point is the same. The federal government are introducing a policy already in play in the two largest states, so half the work and the oat is already taken care of. Even if you discount that, there’s still the whole misuse of figures and lack of money to fund the policy.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  46. Olivia

    I am very much in support of empowerment of and respect for women. I can’t help but remember the very disrespectful way Prime Minister John Howard was often treated by media personalities, but somehow this was seen as acceptable. Perhaps we as a society lack respect for politicians and authority in general in this country.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Lulu

      “the very disrespectful way Prime Minister John Howard was often treated by media personalities”

      Which ones?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Sonia

        Mungo MacCallum variously called John Howard an unflushable turd, a little c–t and a shithouse rat and no-one uttered a complaint.

        Furthermore, regarding the first name thing, what about ‘Little Johnny’ or ‘Keven 07′?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Ash

          Wasn’t kevin07 his election slogan?

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • Bradley

        Lulu…you are kidding me ?

        I’ve heard it said that some are so uninformed that they must be living under a rock. In your case I’d suggest Uluru.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Lulu

          I asked a question – which Sonia answered with actual information, instead of an evasion. If it’s that easy, you should be able to think of a name (or two or three) yourself. The only ones I could think of were comedians, which I probably wouldn’t count.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Zepgirl

          Bit harsh, Bradley…

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Bradley

            Fairly tame for me, I’d say.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Zepgirl

              I’m frankly suprised that it got past the moderators.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Bradley

              Maybe it got by because it is in fact very tame ? Have you considered that ?

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Zepgirl

              Yep, and then I rejected it. If someone said that to me at the dinner table I would consider it really out of line.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
        • Sasha

          Bradley that was so rude and totally unnecessary for the dinner party atmosphere.

          Would you have said that to her face?

          Kindly just answer her question or ignore it in the future.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Mum of two cheeky monkeys

            Saying someone is living under a very large rock is ok for dinner party etiquette- id say the tongue in cheek tone has been lost in translation.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
          • Bradley

            Would you prefer that I simply say that I find Lulu’s comment excessively uninformed ?

            Is that less rude for you ?

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • anon

              why not just not say anything.

              crazy idea, i know.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Bradley

              What are you saying, anon ? I’m only allowed to comment if you approve of what I’m saying ?

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
  47. The wounded bull

    How many more times are we going to see this ONE single photo of ONE single placard, taken years ago now, being held up as some sort of compelling evidence of sexism toward Julia.

    Is that seriously all the evidence you have, it is almost laughable how many times this image gets used.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Mum of two cheeky monkeys

      Agree- without context that photo makes it appear as though Abbott organized a rally against Gillard and helped make the signs! Not a smart move to appear in front of that sign on television but if I remember correctly he wasn’t expecting to address the crowd, it happened organically, and the sign was held above his head after he started speaking.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  48. Jessica

    I’m a swinging voter. I’ve voted Liberal and Greens in the past (Greens at state level), and once for Labor. I voted for Julia Gillard because I thought she would advance the cause for women in politics.
    I’m embarrassed that I voted for her. Regardless of her gender, I think she has been dishonest, and has made promises that she knew she was going to break. Nobody likes a liar, and instead of advancing the cause, she has failed spectacularly.
    I agree with “Guest”. She can’t have it both ways. She can’t expect to be treated differently on one hand due to her gender, yet at the same time expect people to overlook or ignore her failures because she is a female.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  49. Jorie

    The fact that Julia has copped some offensive backslash, I think is just due to sexism in general. Offensive terms for women seem to be more offensive and violating than the same word for men: think dick vs cunt, SOB vs bitch, player vs slut, just to name a few. The same with the sexualized imagery described in the article above. It would have been nice to see JG rise above that, make it a non-issue, rather than take it personally and play the female card.

    When in comes to many old school men, I don’t even think they are aware of their sexism, it is so ingrained. I think that for men like this, it is wiser to just beat them at their own game rather than try and get them to change their world view. Making a big deal of being female and drawing offense from sexist slurs would just reinforce the differences between gender in their minds.

    Not that I don’t think these things need to be brought into the light, but maybe JG should take a page out of TA’s book and let other women speak for her on this issue.

    At the end of the day, while JG is female, I do not feel that she is representative of my demographic. I would feel much more strongly represented by a working mother, or single working parent of either gender, as this is by and large how I define myself. It is unfortunate that due to her own political choices her name has become synonymous with duplicity, disloyalty and ineptitude. It does all Australian women a disservice.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  50. Kathryn

    Utter crap. While many of the criticisms – or more correctly expressions – are very sexist in nature, her utter incompetence that leads to those criticisms has nothing to do with what is between her legs. GG Bryce is one of the most beloved Governor Generals we’ve ever had, and there isn’t any pieces or commentary anywhere that she might sack the government during that time of the month… because she’s respected. Horrible stuff was said about Rudd, and Howard, and Keating, and Hawke: it’s the nature of the job. You will be attacked. You will be demeaned. They will have a go at everything, including stuff that should be totally out of bounds. The more competent you are, the less you give them to attack you with, the less likely that criticism can build to such a critical mass where the average person who doesn’t study the nuances joins in with, shall we say, less enlightened criticisms. Australians are totally ready for a woman as leader: but they have zero tolerance for incompetence from anybody.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Bradley

      This Australian is ready for a woman PM named Kathryn.

      I appreciate your honest commentary.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Mylifemychoice

      Brilliantly said Kathryn :) Wish I could “like” but it’s not showning up on my screen for some reason

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • female voter

      best comment ever.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Guest

      I’m sorry to say your point collapsed when it failed to mention any of the reasons you find JG so ‘incompetent’. Your post is just reiterating sound bites for people who can cope with nothing more.

      My questions to you are: why is she incompetent? Go on, list the reasons. What policies do you disagree with? How has she ‘let you down’? What could she have done better? What will the opposition do in her place?

      Do you even know?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • John

        Here you are Guest, borrowed from the website Hot Copper.

        Is this enough for you?

        Julia Gillard made some promises to the voters at Rooty Hill in 2010.
        She has broken those promises. They are as follows…
        …………………………………………………..

        Julia Gillard promised to consult on climate change and instead delivered a carbon tax.
        Julia Gillard guaranteed a budget surplus and instead delivered more huge deficits.
        Julia Gillard promised less debt and now we have a record $160 billion in net debt.
        Julia Gillard promised jobs and national unemployment is now 60,000 higher than when she made the speech.
        Julia Gillard promised to cut company tax. After the election, she scrapped the tax cut.
        Julia Gillard promised to give an early company tax cut to small business and she scrapped that tax cut too.
        Julia Gillard promised to give $2.1 billion for a transport link in Western Sydney (the Epping to Parramatta rail link) and now won’t provide the money for transport in Sydney.
        Julia Gillard promised to build an NBN – over two years later, hardly anyone in Western Sydney has it and no one knows when it will be finished or what it will cost.
        Julia Gillard promised to build 2650 Trades Training Centres in Schools – and 2409 of them have not been built.
        Julia Gillard promised cash rewards for schools that improve and has not yet paid a cent.
        Julia Gillard promised to keep giving children in schools computers and has since walked away from the computers in schools program.
        Julia Gillard promised to introduce a mining tax to help pay for a company tax cut. The mining tax and the company tax cut are now in tatters.
        Julia Gillard promised to pay bonuses to good school teachers. Not a cent has yet been paid to teachers.
        Julia Gillard promised an automatic tax deduction of $1000. Another broken promise.
        Julia Gillard promised to ease cost of living pressures on Western Sydney households and instead introduced a carbon tax and cut the private health insurance rebate.
        Julia Gillard promised more money in your superannuation and instead has taken out $8 billion in Labor super taxes.
        Julia Gillard promised to build more GP super clinics. She’s delivered only one of the 28 promised.
        Julia Gillard said she was cutting waiting list times, but instead they have increased.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Noyna

      Because Bryce has very little real power.
      The author is saying Australians are not comfortable with women in power.
      I certainly don’t think she has bee perfect, but many male PMs have been far less competent than JG and told many more and more vicious lies. Yet people choose to remember only her mistakes. Women who vote for Abbott deserve what will happen.
      It reminds me of all the people in Queensland who nodded approvingly when Newman said he was going to cut the fat…they didn’t realise he was talking about them.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions