Do You Like This Story?
Screen shot 2012 07 16 at 5.40.51 PM The Shire. Did you watch?

Vernesa and Sophie

Last night, we met Beckaa.

Beckaa is a 19-year-old, self-described party girl. Her parents love the first letter of alphabet so much that they used it twice. She likes to shop using a credit card but that’s okay because daddy picks up the bill.

Andy is a 22-year-old electrician. His hobbies include “chasing girls” (we assume that’s a little less catch-and-kiss and a little more “honk if you’re horny”) and playing practical jokes.

Sophie is a Beautylicious Ultrasound Cavitation Manager. And ah no, it’s not just you. We don’t know what that is either. Sophie has a very expensive pair of breasts and at age 27 she’s already hooked on botox – which fits with her philosophy of “if you can afford it, why not?”

These are just some characters from Channel 10′s new show The Shire, who we met last night.

Here are some of the others… [text continues after the gallery.]

Kerry: When she's not running Beach Burrito, Kerry is riding the rollercoaster of romance with Spock.

Billed as Australia’s answer to programs like America’s Jersey Shore and Britain’s The Only Way is Essex, The Shire will follow ‘real’ people and document their everyday activities.

Sort of.

You see, The Shire is one of Australia’s first ‘dramality’ shows. That means it’s part reality television, with a little bit of scripting thrown in – so when things get a little boring, you can still write in a shock tidal wave or a pregnancy scare.

But with a two drink limit for all of the cast – we’re not sure if this is going to be the biggest thing since coloured jeans or if it’s going to flop like heeled Havianas.

This from Fairfax yesterday:

But just how real is real? Ten is using the word ”dramality” to present the show as a blend of drama and reality. In truth, the industry name for the genre is ”soft script”, so named because it generally involves putting real people into structured situations and ”soft scripting” the outcomes.

The loudest and laziest comparison is Jersey Shore, but The Shire probably owes more to the modern progenitor of the genre, the 2004 MTV series Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County. In a similar fashion, it featured a cast of pretty young things falling in and out of love with one another.

Laguna Beach was followed by The Hills in 2006, and the popularity of those shows has now blown out to a bona fide genre, which includes the US’s Jersey Shore, The City and Baldwin Hills and the British knock-offs Geordie Shore, The Only Way Is Essex and Made in Chelsea.

For non-Sydney siders – The Shire is a real place. It’s a region of Sydney and at least for the purposes of Channel 10′s take on the area – you should be picturing southern cross tattoos, fake breasts, tandoori chicken tans and cars that struggle to make it over speed bumps higher than 5cm.

Some people couldn’t wait to watch it. Others said they’d rather eat bark. (For the bark eaters: we suspect you might have been watching Australian Story on ABC instead, in which case you should read this post).

But we suspect there were more than a few of us who ‘accidentally’ fall on the remote and “oops, how did that happen, I wasn’t really watching, it was just on in the background”… i.e. let it play through the full half-hour time slot.

Ratings-wise,The Shire did well last night but it didn’t hit it out of the park like many predicted. It debuted with 941,000 of us tuning in – that compares to 925,000 for the debut ofBeing Lara Bingle last month.

Most importantly for the show’s ongoing commercial success, The Shire was number one in the key advertising demographics for it’s timeslot. It also dominated social media discussion overnight, becoming the number one trending topic on Twitter – and generating some pretty funny responses:

The highlight of the show for us, was the intense discussion between Vernessa and Sophie re: whether you’d rather have intelligence or good looks (which occurred while they used some kind of cellulite melting machine. WTF?).

After some high level debate between the women, the vote was split 50/50 – but that was only because if you’re smart, you can get rich and buy pretty. Now that, ladies and gentlemen, is logic.

So, were you watching The Shire? Are you a fan of dramality television? Could you tell which parts of the show were scripted?

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

193 Comments so far

  1. Jackie

    Hi just wanted to let every one know that I bought a RF Fat Cavitation machine the same as Sophie’s mine came from Bodilite I was told that it was approved by the Australian Therapeutic Goods Administration prior to purchase and that it would come with an Australian CE certificate and the correct manuals! Please do not be sucked in by the owner of bodilite Solutions I paid $17,000,00 for the machine and the results are poor to say the least.
    If you are thinking of buying a machine for your Salon make sure that it is Approved by the TGA and a compliant Australian CE certificate government accredited course and good after care service.
    Wouldn’t like to see any one sucked in like I was, losing clients refunding and paying for a machine that has just been knocked up in a back yard.
    Take care every one and don’t let any one rip you of your money is hard earned!
    All The Best
    Jackie

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. Dee

    Worst of the worst ! Should receive an award for ‘best show to mock’

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Jacqui

    I thought it was going to be terrible – so i didn’t watch it.
    the onyl bad thing about the situation is that people watched it for the sole purpose of bagging out the people in the show – sure i agree with these people on many points but i chose not to watch the show for those points
    if you don’t like something – don’t watch it! easy peasy :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Kris2040

    This just popped up on my newsfeed. Cue the defenders of the West!

    http://www.triplem.com.au/sydney/shows/grill-team/blog/listen-forget-50-shades-of-grey-listen-to-mgs-50-shades-of-mount-druitt/20120718-gr9w.html

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • call me cynical

      MG on triplem….bogan central

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kris2040

        Never said it wasn’t. It is funny though!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  5. Anna

    I have very poor taste in TV, so this was going to be right up my alley. (Speaking of alley, 3 days later and still no post on Candace Alley??), Anyway, even I was appalled at The Shire. Watching those brunettes was just too painful, so I ended up canning it. I spent alot of time around “The Shire” in my time, and it just doesn’t depict it at all. They’ve tried too hard to emulate Jersey or Essex, rather than just let it be it’s own show. I forecast a change of timeslot to 10pm, followed by an axe.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. Leon

    Maybe it wouldn’t be so bad if the people were at least attractive……… I just want to scratch my eyes out everytime I see the promos. And in typical Channel 10 fashion, their best show, The Project, had to cross promote it tonight

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. fifi-lulu

    Just caught a bit of The Shire…..more like Bogan Central.

    Seriously though, the highlight of last night’s programming was when Sammy the dog was dying on Revenge. So very sad. He’d gone back to his original home and was being comforted by the two people that loved him the most in the lead up to his passing.

    Pass the Kleenex. I was bawling my eyes out.
    I think Revenge really captured how heartbreaking it is to lose a pet.

    Don’t think I would kiss someone who is not my fiance right after though.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Revenge fan

      But Jack’s the love of her life – she just isn’t admitting it yet …

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  8. Miss

    It will be hard work selling property in the Sutherland Shire in the coming weeks…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. Simone

    I watched about ten minutes before posting it on my blog, wherein I liken it to Satan’s smegma.

    http://bingellsblog.bigblog.com.au/post.do?id=1022749

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. hellopetal

    I was flicking & watched this for five minutes then turned over to something else. I saw some ridiculous looking girls who I didn’t think existed in Australia, only in America. I saw a male friend rub his face in his female friend’s cleavage. It was a joke but I don’t do much reality TV unless it has singing or cooking in it & not always even then!

    I know people who live in Cronulla & thankfully have never met people like these depicted in the show. (I know they are real people but I can’t quite bring myself to believe it.)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. Diamond

    Beckaa or whatever your name is, your nose is awful, you deserve a refund!!! I can’t believe how boring that show was, I am sorry I missed the abc while I watched this awful show!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. Bel

    Posted a comment last night that was rebutted by a couple of haters….. Can I just say, told u so. Bekkkaaa (or how ever she spells her name does not live in the shire, but at Blakehurst (has her whole life) that is in the St. George district, not Sutherland shire. And the other two orange bimbos, hail from central coast and now lives in homebush, and bankstown previously and now share same u it in homebush. For all those comments where people said, people like that do live in the shire, you just haven’t met them yet, the shire is a community, if those girls lived at cronulla, they would have been known. The show is fake, it’s a shame it will damage what is a lovely part of sydney.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. Mimi

    i loved The Hills and Laguna beach and found that those people were more real and down to earth than these weirdos just going by the commercials as i didnt bring myself to watch the show…….the tv ads were enough to turn me off!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Bel

      Both those shows are great, agree. And the city as well. Great group of people, good mix of drama, and they do have jobs, most are likable, perhaps with the exception of Spencer Pratt. Heidi went a bit ott with the plastic surgery in the last few years tho

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Mimi

        Yes totally agree with you on Heidi and Spencer!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  14. Anonymous

    Drag Queens and Closet Gays

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. aj mahoney

    id give their face a rub in the sand.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. Cathy

    So lame. They are all embarrassing. I don’t mind Jersey Shore cause they just threw them together with alcohol. The result? Non scripted fun, fights, drunken antics. This lot are thrown together, loosely scripted without the alcohol, in a non M rated time-slot and most of them actually don’t come from the Shire.

    Cast the most fake individuals you have ever met and throw into the mix that most of them couldn’t out think a glass of water; I give you the Shire.

    Oh and really Beckaa? You’re a waste of oxygen spending Daddy’s money. Not cute.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. Lucy Ormonde

    I’m really interested to know how Channel 10 cast the show. Does anyone know?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Gemma

      Two of the male cast members were on The Project last night and said that they had to audition for the roles, Lucy.

      Assuming the casting call went something like this: Tragic 20-somethings required for prime time dramality series. Really, really, ridiculously good looking people only. IQs over 80 need not apply.

      Or something to that effect.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • aj

      Threw some goon down the nearest gutter and grabbed the first bunch of trash bags that had a sniff around.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • aholst

      I live in Cronulla Lucy, and last year sometime there was one of those pull off tab posters on a telegraph pole near my flat. It was from Channel 10 and said something along the lines of – Are you in your twenties? Live in Cronulla? Love going out? Want to be in a reality tv show?
      My husband (born and bred Shire, I’m just a blow in from the North Shore!), both groaned when we saw the ad, especially when most of the tabs were already ripped off. We knew the storm was coming! We’re not all bogans, promise!!!!
      Here’s my wrap of the show on my blog on the show, but afraid it doesn’t live up to Em Rusciano’s tv reviews – she’s the best…
      http://bigmouthinthesouth.blogspot.com.au/

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  18. Redhead

    I didn’t watch it but saw a preview where some blonde says she spends $15,000 on her credit card each month and her dad pays the bill? Who the hell is this idiot father????

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. Nat

    Watched it on the website today. So bad it was funny. The beauticians and the tacky ‘princess’ were hilarious…..reminded me of the SBS ‘Pizza’ show. :-) )
    The others just seemed awkward and BORING.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. maddi

    i watched it. i loved it.
    but i love being lara bingle as well. i dont know, i just love lighthearted “reality” shows. its fake. get over it and if you dont like it dont watch it…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. Le Shire

    Well I actually think it is the best! I watched it and I am definitely not like a faked tanned Botox bimbo, actually studying law :) Half the people saying its crap still watched it anyway, even if people just watch it to laugh at it, they’re still watching it and getting the ratings up. I also don’t think there is anything wrong with Botox, it’s their decission! I mean when I get older I will definitely get Botox, not in my lips to look fake, but to get rid of creases and wrinkles ;)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • alyssakt

      Yep, definitely don’t get Botox in your lips – it doesn’t go there.
      Collagen pumps up lips and lines.
      Botox affects muscles and nerves so that skin doesn’t move as much when smiling and frowning etc = less wrinkles, allegedly.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        ha ha – errrrr………… Botox in lips???

        hope I wont have the need for a lawyer in a few years time!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  22. Jen

    Hahaha loving all the ‘this isn’t us’ cries from some Shire residents.. Funny when houseos came on.. All you heard was that it depicted the people in the west perfectly!

    Perfect demonstration of ‘Not in My Backyard’

    This show is as real as the boobs on the tandoori chicks. It was absolute rubbish and I won’t be watching it.. But I will be reading the tweets, they were hilarious!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Yes the tweets were amazing. I actually laughed out loud several times.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  23. Mike

    Didnt watch it but I suspect all the cast were STRAIGHT. I may watch it if there is some GAY activity. As you know 99% of soaps dont believe there are any gay people on the planet
    IGNORANCE I suspevt best describes this SHIRE which I have not even watched yet LOL

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Jules

      There were a couple of gay guys on it. Someone on Twitter called them bogays – lol.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Nat

        The gay boys were the best ‘characters’ on the show. Maybe they should have a show themselves!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  24. Selena

    Sophie, Vernesa and Beckaa are the freakiest things I’ve ever seen! Just as well they are funny to watch.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Zelphie

      i saw a photo of beckaa pre nose job. She looks better

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  25. Anna

    I watched Australian Story, which was just brilliant. I turned over to watch NCIS and my eyes nearly fell out of my head. What the hell is wrong with those girls? Those lips are so wrong I don’t know where to start.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. MissV

    Whilst I respect people and the way they live their lives, I wish this show would make it incredibly clear that a minority of people live and think the way the “actors” on the Shire do.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. Caz Gibson

    We watched most of “The Shire” because we’ve had media-related jobs for years now and we try to watch “everything” at least once.
    It was grimly hilarious and a total caricature of life in that part of Sydney.
    I grew up in Sydney and, until I was 16yrs spent about half of the week in Auburn (total “Westie” territory) and the other 2-3 days in Bundeena which I think is part of the Shire as it’s just across the bay from Cronulla.
    Not to be taken seriously (as it ‘s a total piss-take) the “kids” are only a little bit younger than the “Jersey Shore” “kids” who look like desperate 39 year olds looking for a “casting couch”.
    This is “Kath & Kim” meets “Big Brother” and it makes poor little Lara Bingle’s show look like an episode of RPA.
    Are there people like this in our modern society ? You betcha’……and now that this show’s appeared as part of our already dumbed-down TV fodder – you can guarantee seeing “Shire-clones” walking our streets and turning up at our fancy-dress parties.
    But hey, us Aussies love a chance to dress up as stereo-types and Vernesa and Sophie will be total hits this season.
    As for me, well………..”I’m so prettee”……..lol.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. stacey87

    live in the shire, in Cronulla. I am 25. I am definitely not taking this too heavy, it all just seems so dumb haha…

    However, I would just like to let everyone know that what I watched last night bared no resemblance to the life of me, my friends, and family… the only realistic thing about that show was the nice scenery shots they showed of the bays, sunsets etc.

    I think in any location across Sydney there will be “eccentrics” and “tarts” and all of that. But this ridiculous show should definitely not be seen as a portrayal of the area I have grown up in.

    There is so much more to this area than plastic surgery/botox, surfer boys, lovestruck teens. Our community is also made up of wonderful, hard working parents and students, delightful children, wonderful senior citizens, a variety of people with different backgrounds. Small businesses, gay couples, studious high school kids, caring volunteers, committed sports players, etc etc.

    Of course there are alot of negative sides of people in the Shire, just like every other area. But I would hate for people who viewed this show to think that our area is actually made up of the majority of these characters.

    Besides, I get that it is just a crappy entertainment show, but it wasn’t even interesting or that funny/dramatic… just fake and boring and totally un-relateable….

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. Jules

    I thought it was a bit of lighthearted fun!

    For all the indignant Shire residents out there – don’t worry, I’m from Melbourne and I know you’re not all like that, as does everyone else who watches the show… it’s clearly just a bit of fun, if the cast were all Actuaries and Librarians it’d be a pretty boring show, we all know that.

    For all those crying “won’t someone think of the children!!!”, again, don’t worry… these caricatures of real people aren’t ever going to be role models, if anything it’s going to turn kids off wanting to be like that, kids aren’t dumb, they can see these people are not anything to aspire to.

    It’s just a silly, vapid show that has everyone throwing things at their TVs yet unable to look away – lighten up, I actually enjoyed the laugh it gave me!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. maggie

    Vernesa and Sophie – WTF?
    Beckaa – Really Scary!

    Neither of these “characters” are the norm, no doubt. Channel 10 must of dug around a fair bit to find these people.

    The rest just look like beach kids. They obviously put the freakiest characters on the first episodes to pull you in. By the looks of the pictures above of the cast a lot of them look a little more “normal”.

    Never been a fan of these types of shows, watched it last night, and it hasn’t change my mind.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  31. Mrs Woog

    Vernesa and Sophie are both actually from Burwood. True story.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  32. Kate26yo

    Wow. I’ll admit I watched it, in disbelief yes, but nonetheless I gave it a go. I hadn’t read too anything about it leading up to the premiere, but I had heard about it from friends.

    I will just say that this is everything I dislike about the Australian context presently and it reminds me of Mia’s blog about porn recently and it shocks me that this is how some Australian women are portrayed and this was merely an example of two girls who feel the pressures of society to look a certain way…. I assume for their self esteem and to attract the opposite sex. I saw several young people being interviewed on and i hate myself for quoting today tonight, but it was a classic example, on body hair – they were discussing that it is ‘unclean’ and ‘disgusting’ and ‘just not right’ for a women to have any body hair and a young man went as far as to say that he would be ‘so turned off’ if he got with a women who had any hair ‘downstairs’. I saw a recent debate about this issue on ‘The Project’ as well.

    The advertising industry has a lot to answer for, to make us feel so low and marketing the only answer as ‘products’ and ‘services’ that promise to make you look and feel a certain way. I was a classic example when the two most controversial characters were discussing beautiful children versus smart children – coming to the conclusion that the ‘smart’ children obviously created the fat burning machine they were using at the time.

    The girls on the program I see as almost victimised. They are just an extreme example of what lengths people go to now to ‘look good’ and more sadly ‘feel good’. But relating it to another blog of Mia’s recently that we are a country of ‘wuss bags’ where they will willingly sit and get their fat blasted by a machine but not work out and break a sweat.

    I like many others kept flicking between 4 corners and The Shire… and I just couldn’t comprehend how when there is so much destruction in the world at the moment, that rubbish like this can be broadcast. No wonder mental illness statistics are skyrocketing.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kate

      I agree, the more I thought about the show, the more concerned I was with how these girls and guys are being portrayed.
      There is a lot of concern about how our young people are growing up and the lack of role models etc… and then this is aired on our TV’s!! What are young people going to take away from this.. that it is ok to be objectified and to objectify… Smarts are not valued, looks are…
      I turned onto 4 Corners and I think my brain exploded, going from such a shallow, self centred show to one where children and families were experiencing such heart ache and devastation.
      Its reality TV like that, that will hopefully inspire young people to do and be better and hopefully make the world more compassionate.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Susan

        We have a generation of girls whose role models are / have been Paris Hilton, Linsay Lohan and the Kardashians. This is what we get.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  33. soyabean

    I am watching it now. Amazing. I love my crappy TV shows, not going to lie.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. Its real enough

    I think the point people seem to be missing is not whether everyone who lives in “The Shire” is like that or not. The real problem is that there are lots and lots and lots of Australians like that, regardless of where they live. There are thousands and thousands of young girls in this country whose only thought is how they look. There are bogans everywhere. Whether this is real, “dramality”, scripted or not, this is a fair representation of a PORTION of Australia (please note I am not saying it is all Australia). And in fact is a representation of people all over the world – hence the success of all these other types of shows.

    You might say “but I don’t know anybody like that” and maybe you genuinely don’t, but trust me, there are plenty of people like that out there.

    So yes, it is dreadful television, but it is a relfection of us.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. Lulu

    Dear Channel 10,

    If you insist on showing this manure, would you please not infest my screen with ‘sneak peeks’ (a.k.a annoyingly long ads) while I am trying to watch Masterchef or NCIS. Please.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. Kris2040

    Here’s a bit of help for non-Sydney people:

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kris2040

      The North Shore people:

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Kris2040

      Eastern Suburbs:

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Loose

        What about Sydney according to the inner-west and the western suburbs?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Kris2040

          Inner Westies is below. There isn’t one for Westies as far as I’ve seen. I didn’t make them up.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • sundress

            Western suburbs:

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Kris2040

              Haha! Good one! Thanks, sundress. I had wondered why there wasn’t one.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Kathy W

              OMG AM LAUGHING SO HARD!!!!

              I used to be a westie – and moved to the Northern Beaches in my late teens.

              My God you should have heard my Westie friends accusing me of selling out, turning to a snob and ‘do I want my can of VB silver plated now I’m moving to silvertail territory’ hahahaha LOVE IT!

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
    • Kris2040

      Inner Westies:

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • soyabean

        looool ‘do they even have small bars?’

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Lulu

          Heh, I think the Inner West equivalent in Melbourne is probably Northcote/Fitzroy.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • anon

            Yep, except the bogans are to the North, West and outer South East!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
      • goose

        I grew up in the East and now live in the Inner West. Sadly identify with both! Haha. My husband is a westie though, so I obviously got over the cultural cringe. And anyway, someone has to live there ;)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Lulu

      I don’t know the geography of Sydney at all, so what’s that orange section marked ‘too close for comfort’?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • ashamasha

        yep, sorry I’m a Perthie…no idea what any of that means….I don’t know the regions/suburbs and their cultural makeup, so it makes as much sense as a similar map of Perth would make to you LOL!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Kris2040

        The bit marked “Australia” is The Shire, and on the other side of Tom Ugley’s or the Captain Cook bridge are suburbs with high migrant populations.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  37. Zoomey

    I don’t want to look at this image of Vermesa and Sophie on the beach ever again. I’m sure they’re beautiful girls but I hate this image for so many reasons I haven’t workshopped, I just know every time I look at it, I die a bit inside.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  38. Leo

    I watched it and think some of my brain died from the experience… Seriously? What the? Who let that get up there?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Me Myself I

      I only watched the same snippets from the Today and Morning shows. Holy shit Batman, that was enough. Biggest piece of crapola I have ever seen and boy have I seen some crap in my time!!!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  39. Frau

    Mammamia, could you please do an article on Four Corners last night instead of the Shire (trash). It was horrific, anyone who is a parent (or not) could not have watched it without being affected. I would love to know what organisations we could donate to to do something that would directly help the people involved.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  40. Beck star

    I don’t know how Ch 10 can produce quality like Offspring and by the looks of it Puberty Blues and then follow it up with the Shire! Ridiculous

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kris2040

      I think they’ve made and are showing Puberty Blues to show the history of the Shire. I have a feeling there will be some common characters. It’s to show what the Shire was 30 years ago!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • alyssakt

      I think Channel Ten have scored with a mega shit hat trick here – Lara Bingle, The Shire and soon I Will Survive.
      None should survive a single week on air – and yet Channel Ten seem to be confidently sticking by them. Who is running the show over there?>!!
      12 year olds??
      And did Lara write the “soft script” for The Shire last night?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  41. Barb Fisher

    I saw the very start of the show after Masterchef finished and could not reach for the remote fast enough. Thankfully Australian Story was on the next channel and my faith in humanity was restored by the amazing story of Jessie Taylor. What an amazing woman/family.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Jude

      Wasn’t it a heart warming story. Loved it as well. Especially the gushing grandma.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • jamilarizvi

      It it such a beautiful story isn’t it Barb? We’ve covered it before here on MM – if you want another dose of the amazing Jessie Taylor: http://www.mamamia.com.au/news/i-fostered-a-14-year-old-refugee-at-27/

      Jamila

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Ali

      Barb I completely agree. To think I’m the same age as Jessie – her work and her generosity and selflessness was incredible. To that whole family, the world is a better place because of people like you.
      To Channel 10 – you put shame on anyone who lives in The Shire. What a disgusting portrayal of young Aussies. I didn’t watch it but the ads were enough to leave me completely appauled.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  42. B

    All I can say about this is that I urge Christopher Pyne to watch this show (after his recent teacher-bashing comments) and then comment as to whether teachers are the current problem, or do we as a society have some serious, SERIOUS social issues to contend with?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Teacher

      As a high school teacher I see this type of thing all the time. Kids with far too much money, (usually as a result of their parents), cashed up and with nothing to do. So they buy things to compete with one another and become vain, vapid non contributing members of society with a massive sense of entitlement.

      Don’t get me wrong, there are kids out there that are fabulous, talented and most deserving of praise! Unfortunately, they are not the ones that end up on television, or in the media. It is the first group that make people furrow their brows and mutter about “what is wrong with society today”.

      For all those who teacher bash, you teach a class of 30 kids day after day when only half are interested in what you have to say. That’s 15 who deserve your time and another 15 that actually get your time when you have to break up fights, stop them from trashing the classroom etc. After a student threw a chair through a window, (because they were bored and wanted to see what I would do), they looked me in the eye and said, “it’s ok, my parents will pay to have the window fixed. Why are you freaking out?”

      Try dealing with that.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • agreeing teacher

      As a high school teacher I see this type of thing all the time. Kids with far too much money, (usually as a result of their parents), cashed up and with nothing to do. So they buy things to compete with one another and become vain, vapid non contributing members of society with a massive sense of entitlement.

      Don’t get me wrong, there are kids out there that are fabulous, talented and most deserving of praise! Unfortunately, they are not the ones that end up on television, or in the media. It is the first group that make people furrow their brows and mutter about “what is wrong with society today”.

      For all those who teacher bash, you teach a class of 30 kids day after day when only half are interested in what you have to say. That’s 15 who deserve your time and another 15 that actually get your time when you have to break up fights, stop them from trashing the classroom etc. After a student threw a chair through a window, (because they were bored and wanted to see what I would do), they looked me in the eye and said, “it’s ok, my parents will pay to have the window fixed. Why are you freaking out?”

      Try dealing with that.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  43. Anonymous

    I kept watching because it made me feel good about myself; I felt so superior in terms of intellect, looks and career!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  44. Fine

    Shows like this are an opportunity for Australians to reflect inwardly about class and classism in Australian society. As a country we are proud egalitarians, having let go of the shackles of Anglo aristocracy in favour of meritocracy (or having a ‘fair go’).

    But is this really the case? Shows like the Shire give Australians a too-easy platform to deride cohorts of our population who, on first viewing, appear to lack a certain urbane sensibility (and implicitly, a level of education or professional esteem) that is valued by many as a marker of success. I sniff a hint of bourgeois snobbery that warrants discussion.

    The mythology of egalitarianism lends itself to glossing over critical social distinctions in Australia; disctinctions drawn along class lines and educational attainment. We always note how different Australia is from our US or UK peers, who, we often agree, are hamstrung by class divisions and entrenched hierarchies. I really wonder if we are any different.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • A-Dubbs

      Whaaaaaaa? I might need to re-read this post once. Have woken up a bit…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jules

        Hahaha – agreed. Actually some good points raised and worth dicussing but every sentence has at least two four-syllable words in it – my brain is like totes buzzin’ n sh1t.

        I agree though Fine, it is a myth – snobbery exists as much in Australia as it does everywhere else.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Jules

        Hahaha – agreed. Actually some good points raised and worth discussing but every sentence has at least two four-syllable words in it – my brain is like totes buzzin’ n sh1t.

        I agree though Fine, it is a myth – snobbery exists as much in Australia as it does everywhere else.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  45. FuFu

    I weep for the future.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  46. duffy

    Beckaa was feckin scary.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  47. Bel

    I’ve just read about 100 comments/status’ on face-book from friends and family who all live in “the shire” as do I. Let me set the record arrow straight here. The typical “aussie kids” portrayed on the show are a fairly decent example, lots of surf loving, hard working tradies and smart young girls, out here. The clueless, unintelligent, “rapper types” and “brainless orange bimbos” are not. They have quite obviously taken some locals and brought in “actors” (and I use that word loosely) to portray a more multicultural shire. But unfortunately to be a successful “imported cast member” your iq had to be that of a 2 yr old. For those of us who actually live here, we will all be feeling like we have had a really bad one night stand in the morning! And will be denying where we live. I hope it dies a quick death.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kris2040

      Such a Shire person comment! Reminds me of the bloke I went to Tafe with who told us quite confidently that no-one in the Shire was gay or took drugs. Clearly hadn’t seen the float in mardi gras or the bongs and needles around Cronulla.

      Heaven forbid the Shire be multicultural and have dickheads living in it!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Bel

        Sorry can see how my previous comment may have come across sounding a little racist and skewed. It was written last night when I was in a bit of a rage when the show just ended and I was so appalled I could hardly articulate properly or type susinctly. Let me have another go. Yes the shire is made up of lots of diversity, none more so than my own family, Irish father, Aussie mum (English heritage) married into an italian family myself, so inlawa are Italian, my brother in law born in south Africa, and lived then other halfmof his life in Canada, another brother in law is Lebanese, and we have Muslim cousins (by marriage) and German ones on the other side. So fair to say, my family is a true mixing pot that is the shire and has been for 70 years. My comment was meant to be: they have selected some of the dimmest representations of young people and unfortunately the rest of sydney now thinks this is a factual recount of the lives we lead. Also there has been a few statements on various media outlets that the two orange bimbos I previously referred to are actually from Burwood. Pls don’t take offense at that, but they are imported. Also the “rapper” last night sung about his “south/west boys” or something to that accord. And I have been told he is from bankstown. I know that there are people like this all over sydney, but this show is telegraphing this council in a negative way.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Coco

      Oh Bel, I do feel sorry for some of the shire locals like yourself. But you really don’t do yourself any favours by by claiming the rappers and orange bimbos are imported to give a more muliticultural feel to the show. Isn’t that the problem? That places like this have a misguided sense of patriotism where only your blonde surfer types are considered “typical aussie kids”? (I can’t believe I’m defending those girls but It has to be said)

      And the rapper guy Joel is from The Shire. Maybe you just mix in different circles.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Bel

        It’s not their ethnicity I have an issue with it’s their lack of brain matter, why could the show not have selected a couple of nice hard working girls from cronulla let’s say, Indian, Indonesian, Italian what ever, that actually have a brain, and have finished school that would be great to see how their daly lives unfold. They have chosen these two for this exact reason, people can’t stand how stuck up they are (and this also includes the self proclaimed princess with the bad dye job, shocking hair extensions, and the sugar daddy in the back of the limo) finish school, get a job, and support yourself. Take pride in the way you look, be a decent member of society, if any of these seriously live here, they will be so outcast once the show is done, they will move out. It’s just embarrassing.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  48. Connie

    Where the hell was Bilbo Baggins???

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  49. The Shire. It's BANALITY

    There. Fixed that for you MM.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  50. Gin & Tonic

    I watched.
    I am a reality TV tragic, but i felt like I was watching an episode of Kath and Kim.

    There were some clangers that made me think their lines were straight from the pen of Jane Turner and Gina Riley…
    “All the labels Gucci, Guess and Thomas Szabo, lots of bling”
    “I totally think my lips would look better if they touched my nose”
    “Would you rather have a child that was pretty or smart?”

    GD Star Rating
    loading...