Do You Like This Story?

Syria 380x237 A way to understand Syria.

Protestors in Syria

I am at work. I’m a scientist. I’m a professional. My job is not to sit here writing down my feelings. I work with databases and it’s about as unemotional as it comes. Yet I’m compelled to write this now because I’m fighting back tears and there’s an uncomfortable, sickening feeling in my chest and a lump in my throat that won’t go away.

You know the one. My office has large glass windows, and the IT guy is looking at me and pretending not to notice my red eyes. You see, I am a professional, but I’m also a mother. Today I don’t want to push the emotion away and move on back to my comfortable space. And the catalyst is a dead child’s pink pyjamas.

It started during a few moments of procrastination this morning – a quick check of my twitter feed. A link to an article on the recent massacre in Houla* appeared. It interested me because I’ve been ruminating on whether social media is really useful in generating not just social awareness but real social change, e.g. Kony-style campaigns.

I also clicked on it above other links to articles in my short space of procrastination time because I, like many others, have been horrified, disgusted and, if I am truly honest, morbidly fascinated, with how on earth this type of massacre involving so many children killed at close range could occur.

Within this excellent article was a reference to the “gutsy front page” of The Independent on Sunday, a British tabloid newspaper. This drew me to open the link to the online front page of that paper, and then seek out the article and photograph the chilling headline refers to.

As the front page of the newspaper clearly warns, the image is really distressing. Of course, it is not the worst incident I have seen in a photograph, because unfortunately through history massacres of men, women and children have happened on a far larger scale.

But what this picture did to me was personal. You see, the small girl lying dead on the left of the picture is wearing pink pyjamas. They are almost identical to the ones my own 4 year old daughter was wearing last night. Those pyjamas bring that small lifeless body into my own living room. And because of that I make myself look properly at the photograph, and all of the children. I don’t skim over it because it’s too hard to look at, as I usually might. I make myself look into the lifeless staring eyes of the dead children. I really see their blood-smattered legs and feet and their horrific wounds. It’s intimate, and so it becomes real.

The TV images last night of the bodies wrapped in white sheets didn’t cause the same reaction in me. I think that although we may feel horrified and sad and even dwell for a few minutes on the plight of the poor people in the situation, until you put yourself and your own children there and feel even a small measure of the grief and trauma the surviving parents and family are undergoing, or the terror the children must have felt before their beautiful innocent lives were brutally ended, it’s not truly real.

So what do we do with this outrage, the horror, the heart-wrenching empathy we feel?  If we lobby our politicians for change, how can we know that they will support the “right” course of action, or the “right” side for that matter? Is there a “right” side at all? After the mistakes and the bloodshed that has happened in the war against oppressive regimes thus far, how can we be sure we’ll do more good than harm? After all, the six children and their parents that were killed in a NATO airstrike in Afghanistan the same day are just as precious as those in Houla. As an individual with no influence and limited access to the evidence and facts, I seem to be truly impotent when it comes to these issues.

I don’t know the answers to these questions. I do know that one of the saddest things is that we see and we feel, but then we forget so quickly. I do think that if we could harness the aching hearts of mothers (and fathers, sisters, brothers, aunts etc.) in a true protest against violence wherever it rears its ugly head, we have a better chance of filling the void in the world left by these innocent children.

Maybe we should make more of an effort to really look. It is not enough, but we can start by ensuring that these people are actually real to us.

* Syrians are being massacred. Over the weekend more than 100 were shot, knifed and otherwise slaughtered. At least 32 of them were children. The UN says it was almost 50. There was video. While more than 15,000 have been killed since uprisings began against the Bashar al-Assad regime, it was the weekend’s attacks that prompted international outrage.

Late yesterday afternoon Foreign Minister Bob Carr issued expulsion orders – in line with major European powers like Britain and Germany – to Syrian envoys giving them 72 hours to leave Canberra. So far, stronger action against Syria has been vetoed by Russia in the United Nations.

UN special envoy Kofi Annan met Syrian ruler Bashar al-Assad in Damascus last night in an effort to revive a peace plan.

While Syrians die, emails have emerged that reveal the Syrian first lady’s luxurious shopping habit. Asma has been ordering expensive, custom furniture and designer shoes and clothes from overseas under false names.

- Here’s Mamamia’s cheat sheet from June, 2011 which explains how the Syrian uprising began.

Melanie Butcher is a geologist and mum of two with a passion for bicycles, travel, political discussion and social responsibility. You can occasionally find her on twitter and Pinterest.

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

48 Comments so far

  1. The Manhattan Project

    This article hit a real nerve as we have just started a social movement to glamorise peace and raise money for women and children affected by war. We launched on Friday night and I read part of this blog out as part of my speech.

    Melanie is right that there is no right side in war. We have to be looking at the alternative choice, that is to end all wars. The 21st century must be built on emphaphy and trust at a human level. We need to bypass governments and change the conversation on a global level that still sees war as acceptable. Women are the ones that must to do this. Pleae join us at http://www.facebook.com/manhattproject and let’s change the conversation.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. Cathy Crawley

    I don’t watch the news, I watch the Today show in the mornings and that is it. I was stunned yesterday when I saw the photograph of so many deceased children. I am at a loss for words to explain how angry, bitter, and horrified I am to see such imagery. I can not believe that anyone could be capable of this type of behaviour, at times like this I’m disgusted to belong to the human race.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. gemack

    I also feel overwhelmed and don’t know what to do about such atrocities.

    But I do know a lot happen under the watch of the UN who should be equipped to at least do something. Many of the members of the security council do not act in people’s best interest for fear of diplomatic repercussions. Also, I wonder how much our foreign policy is influenced by what will be popular with voters – which sadly isn’t often international issues such as these.

    So that is why I think expressing care & concern is important. I do think it is at the very least good for our decision makers to know that Australians do care, and would like to see an end to this.

    :(

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. isabelle

    I have just read the article and saw the image of these poor little children and I too cannot stop crying and visualising the horror.
    I now cannot wait to pick up my son from school and hug him.
    What is wrong with these people? Don’t they realise that these children cannot harm them? I just hope that the children did not suffer before dying but who knows what these monsters may have done.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Tea

    This post hasn’t gotten a lot of comments compared to others published today, and in that sense may be regarded as ‘poor performing’. This is the first comment I’ve left on this website and I feel compelled to do it so that you know that your readers (at least this one) do very much appreciate Mamamia’s coverage of the dark and heavy issues as well as the lighter content.

    This was a sobering and well written article. Thanks.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Silverdragon

      Tea – I agree – I can’t for the life of me figure out why this article has attracted so little response!! Are we all ‘atrocity fatigued’? Surely it can’t be that people don’t care. I’ll chalk it up to the sense of helplessness…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Melanie

        I agree. Also, maybe people (Australians?) are more likely to discuss the lighter, humorous issues so that they don’t have to put their emotions out there? Elsewhere in the world I’ve noticed that people are generally more comfortable with strong emotions in a public setting – even at work or with people they barely knew. They were less afraid to talk candidly about the very dark, complex, important issues. Mind you, often times (especially in “developing” countries) those issues were VERY real to them.

        Thanks to all of the people who have written kind and heartfelt comments.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Meerkath

      I think that even the media in this country have become immune to lives lost in the Middle East. That is criminal. Their lives are no less worthy than hours. I have experienced the heartache of a friend who lives in Doha this week, where a fire in a local shopping centre that contained a nursery/child care killed many children. Even though most were ex pats it hardly received any coverage here yet as she said, Doha is basically like a small town, everyone knows everyone and all were deeply affected. It is the same a Syria. We turn a blind eye because it makes us uncomfortable and it is easier to just turn away, and the media doesn’t help. This should be frontline news, and maybe it will be in the days to come. Thank you Mamamia for a measured, yet deeply emotive article helping to bring this crime to light.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  6. nonna

    I remember signing a petition supporting the Syrian people in their quest for democracy. In fact, I sign a lot of petitions. It’s quite astounding really how global petitions now have a positive effect on people’s lives. In this case however, I am now wondering what happened. Reminds me of Bosnia all over again. Here is a link to a petition which you can all sign to stop this hideous situation in Syria and it might help. I have signed. http://www.thepetitionsite.com/10/stop-the-murder-in-syria/

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Thinking of those babies, those families

    I cried my eyes out on my way home from work the other day, listening to a story on JJJ’s Hack program. We often hear of massacres and it devastates me, but Melanie is right – those little children, their little bodies – it’s so real and personal. I think of my 16 month old little boy, and I think of how scared those babies must have been. How does this happen? I don’t know what the answer is to stop this from happening again but I hope they are at peace, whereever they are. I kiss and cuddle my baby boy and cry for those lives lost, but am conflicted with relief for living where we do, where I can do my absolute best to keep him safe.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Anon

    A girlfriend and I were lucky enough to visit Syria for two weeks in June 2010. The people there are incredibly warm, generous and welcoming.

    A young Syrian family invited us in off the street. We ate (the 21 year old mother in the home cooked us an 8 course meal, served on a rug on the floor of their small living area), drank tea, laughed and enjoyed each others company, despite some language barriers. The wife was so excited to have two young western women in her home that she insisted on dressing us up in her finest clothes and giving us “Syrian” makeovers. On leaving at dusk there was a chill in the air and the wife insisted that she wrap a gorgeous silk scarf around my head for the walk back to our hotel, now a treasured keepsake.

    I’ve attached a photo of their beautiful, cheeky three year old son, Mohammed.

    I’ve not experienced greater warmth or hospitality anywhere in the world.

    Like the author of this article, the photos that are emerging from Syria have brought me to tears and left me feeling physically ill.

    Please support the international condemnation of the atrocities that are currently being committed against its people.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Thank you for your post, Anon. Your story and your photo have brought tears to my eyes. A little, Syrian boy, looking so happy. It’s a gorgeous photo and sounds like you had a wonderful experience with great memories. Thinking of them, and hoping they are safe.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anonymous

      Oh this made me cry

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  9. onandon

    I would like to understand what is happening more, can Mamamia please do a
    Dummies Guide to the conflict in Syria?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. KatieG

    Thank you so much for such well written pieces and for continuing to bring important issues into daily discussions. I find these conversations so interesting because they are so linked with our political realities and yet, we make them not so when it comes time to vote. The reality is, we do have power. every one of us is a powerful individual with a voice and a vote and we can make people listen if we act together and not allow tabloid media to polarise and dissipate our voices and our power. Would the beautiful, genuine comments made here be the same about Syrian refugees when they start landing in boats on our shores? We want people to be able to escape these situations, we want to take mothers who lose children in our our arms and yet, when it comes to the crunch, we vote in droves to turn them away or lock them in detention when they use the only power they have left and flee their war torn countries. make it an election issue. Make Australia exerting political power to undo veto power in the UN and election issue. We who have so much, can afford to make these issues the ones to concentrate on rather than the same old fighting over who will get $5 more in tax rebates. I feel a great sense of urgency around these issues when I hear of such senseless slaughters and it always makes me think of a phrase I love; “If not us, then who? If not now, then when?”

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Silverdragon

      Very well said, KatieG.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  11. Holly

    Thank you for this thought provoking article. I have been one of those people skimming past these stories and pictures because I can’t help but imagine the grief and terror if it was my own pink pyjama clad baby caught up in this horror. I resolve to really look and make these people real to me. As you say it’s in no way enough but at least it’s a start.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. Mimi

    brings me to tears…thank you MM for publishing – im not really sure what the answers are for this just pray that those children are now at peace…how awful :(

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. Chrissy

    Its not forgetting, or not expressing horror because the people dying aren’t western, for me it’s total helplessness… What effect can I have and what can I do? I donate to red cross and amnesty international, I cry, I look, I pray and then all I can do is pick up my kids, make dinner and go to bed.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Mel B

      We can all contribute by keeping these events in the public consciousness. By talking about them online, and with friends and family. By acknowledging the horror and keeping the issue in our own minds.

      Though the events are so horrific, I think “remembering” fosters a sense of kindness, love and empathy toward others, and gratefulness for what we have compared to the misfortunes of others. That is surely something.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Chrissy

        It is mel b, I agree, it just never quite feels enough I suppose

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  14. SuperLadyjuliet

    The world is scared of the Arabs. Plain and simple.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Craig

      I’m not scared.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Emmy

      No, the “powers that be” are scared of losing access to all that oil.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Faybian

        I think it’s a bit more complex than that. It’s not the first massacre/genocide that’s been ignored/not acted upon.
        Rwanda, not really oil rich.
        Serbia/Croatia/Bosnia also not really oil rich
        There’s more of course

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  15. Nic

    I want so much to take those children and gather them into my arms. I want to cry with their families. I want to scream and yell and fight against those that would harm such innocence. More than anything, I want so badly to be able to turn back time. I want to be able to stand between those children and their murderers, I want to protect them and save them and take them some place wonderful, somewhere that they could live as children, grow up and experience life they way they were meant to.

    But I can’t and it’s filling me with rage and sorrow and regret.

    Rest in peace sweet children, I don’t know if I believe in any one particular religion, but I desperately hope that there is some sort of heaven.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Silverdragon

      Nic, you made me cry. Yes to all of that.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  16. neola

    I think the editors of the Independent made the right judgement call with the way they presented that image on page 3. The cover was powerful for its lack of picture and compelled – no, dared – you to open it. More people will connect with it this way (and kids won’t see it by accident). What will a high-selling issue of a British paper achieve, I don’t know. It’s a shame a massacre like this had to occur to finally get the conversation started around international watercoolers, but at least its happening. Well done Melanie, for taking the time to remind all of us to take time.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. Steph

    Thank you MM for publishing an article of real substance. I don’t know what the answer is, but a start would be to give the issue as much prominence as we do fashion, celebrities and other superficial crap.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Silverdragon

      Or preferably more. Good call, Steph.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Craig

      I think MM has presented a lot more articles of substance in the last 12 months. Not sure if it is a conscious decision, but my observation.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  18. bootheels33

    A beautiful and absolutely awful post. Thanks, Melanie, we need this! And thanks for the cheat sheet as well – it helps my attempts to grasp what is going on, and why this is so. But still, it is so hard to understand how this can go on and on and on…..

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. thegirl

    Just so tragic. Thank you for this article.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. Silverdragon

    Why is everyone posting anonymously today? Can’t we say what we feel with our usual monikers? Can’t we condemn horror with our own identities? I would have thought this was one subject on which we could comfortably stand up and be counted, even as we squirm helplessly in the face of such hideous inhumanity.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. anonymous

    Thanks for making me really stop and think about this.
    I sent my little girl off to kindy today in pink pyjamas for “pyjama day” with the usual bustle of our daily grind. Somewhere a mother is mourning the loss of her baby killed by maniacs. It’s hard to know what to do but feeling grateful for what I have is a start and genuinely feeling a stranger’s loss.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  22. Silverdragon

    Horrendous. I sort of wish I hadn’t looked because it makes me too sad to think that human beings can do this to each other. We are so much more sophisticated in our barbarism than animals, who at least for the most part, only kill to survive.

    Every day I treasure living in Australia and holding close my own pink-pyjama clad daughters and hoping that I can preserve their innocence for another day. And my heart breaks for those families, the whole community, for the trauma that will never be healed. Sometimes it seems a long way away, but it is only by the grace of being born in a settled country that it is not my family in those photos. I don’t know what the solution is – I wish I did. :(

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Anon

    The killing of innocent children is always and forever an abomination. From what I hear though, the Syrian people are in support of the government and say that these attacks are focusing on terrorist cells. I guess even terrorists have children. Suffer the little children when adults are madmen.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Anon these killings are done by bashaar al assad. He is killing sunni muslims and sparing alawi muslims. It is a sect war and the alawi muslims are saying that it is terrorists responsible for the massacres.

      Thank you mamamia for posting this. People need to know whats going on. There are so many Videos on youtube and it will absolutely break your heart. Woever supports bashaar al assad is an oppressor and those of you whp stay silent are oppressors. Please show ur support for those being massacred and support the right of the syriN people to protest against him without being murdered! May God bring bashaar al assad and his army down

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Silverdragon

        I ask this in the most genuine way, because I want to understand. Would it be better if fundamentalist types like the Muslim Brotherhood took over in Syria? My understanding of why the West is hesitating to intervene is at least partly because they want to avoid a hardline religious regime taking over.

        In all seriousness, I think God needs to get out of the equation – religion is an excuse for far too much horror.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Anon

          Silverdragon God is the reason why syrians have hope and the absence of God is why the alawi sect are committing these Unspeakable crimes. If you believe your life has no room for God thats ur business but you shouldnt impose ur beliefs on others.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Silverdragon

            Ah, but I don’t impose my beliefs on others. I certainly don’t kill because of them. I may share my beliefs (though I seldom do) but not at the point of a knife or gun.

            You did not address my actual question, re the Muslim Brotherhood.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Anon

              I am not going to comment on the muslim brotherhood because i honestly dont know enough. But if syria looks at the way the Lebanese government is run and how all different religions and sects are represented equally then things would be ideal. You just imposed ur beliefs on me when u clearly knew i believed in God. The Alawi sect arent sharing their beliefs theyre just mindlesdly killing.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
          • Silverdragon

            As I can’t reply to your reply (I guess there’s a limit!) I’ll answer here. Thank you for responding to my question – the scenario you suggest sounds ideal – I wonder if it could be achieved.

            As to “imposing” my beliefs, I suspect we’ll have to agree to differ on the meaning of that word. I simply expressed an opinion that is contrary to yours. This is not an imposition, as you are in no way obligated to take it on board. It is simply expressing a different view.

            Thanks anyway for the conversation – I understand that religion is a touchy subject (hence why it’s never on the menu of polite conversation at dinner parties) and a very personal one and there was certainly no offence intended. You believe in God and that He has some power over the situation. I believe that, on the off-chance there is a God, there’s no way on earth or in heaven that He can possibly answer the prayers of everyone on every side.

            I also separate religion from faith. Personal faith is fine with me and I’m very happy for anyone to believe whatever they want. What is done in the name of religion (and I don’t differentiate between the creeds) however, can be a whole other story. Hope that makes sense.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
  24. Anon

    I remember seeing a film, ‘Shooting Dogs’ I think it was called, about the Rwandan genocide where a character proposes that the world intervened in the Balkans much earlier than in Rwanda because those in the West could look at the victims in the Balkans and see their sons and daughters, parents and neighbours. In Rwanda, it was more distant, it was old tribal problems flaring up again etc and, crucially, we didn’t look at the victims and see our own families and friends. As someone who went to the Rwandan war crimes tribunal in Arusha and heard some downright awful things, I’m not sure I can understand that mentality, that need for the victims to resemble people I have personal relationships with, to know, fundamentally, that it can’t continue and to care enough to do something about it.

    Having said that, if that works to make people disgusted, horrified, furious about atrocities like these such that it compels them into action, that is positive.

    Thanks for the article!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Guest

      OK, but what do you want to do?

      I think there probably was some racism involved in intervening in the Balkans and not Rwanda (although that cuts both ways – apparently it was much harder to raise charity relief for the Balkans because there was a view that Europeans fighting and killing each other was their own fault whereas it’s more accepted in other areas of the world) but some of it was simply geographical. In the Balkans you have a nice convenient coastline and can get troops in and out by sea and have aircraft carriers to launch airstrikes. Rwanda is landlocked and the nearest ports are hundreds of miles away across shocking roads. It’s actually really hard to put troops on the ground when you don’t have access to a coast.

      Now Syria of course does have a coast and getting troops in would be relatively easy. But what would they do? What do we want to do there? Support the rebels – perhaps not, an Islamist regime is unlikely to be good news for regional peace or the non Muslim population of Syria. Overthrow the Assad regime? Well perhaps but then you become responsible for security there until a new Government emerges and the experience in Iraq might be a guide to how that goes. Some of your soldiers will die as will quite a few insurgents, some non violent civilian protestors and there will inevitably be “collateral damage” (ie dead children) when somebody responds to being shot at by firing back in the diretion of the school it’s coming from.

      I actually do believe that Western values are mostly superior to the alternative and that the rest of the world should adopt them. But if you want to impose them by force the only way you can do this is by putting young men and women with guns on the ground, and a lot of them, and accepting that not all will come back.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        I HATE YOU!!!! I am not the person that I am today because I have adopted “Superior Western Values”. I am the person I am today because I was given the superior opportunities that are available to those of us that live in the West. I am thankful for it and for that I am a very productive person in society. But I have never been and will never be inferior to you, no matter what you would like to tell me!!!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Guest

          Thanks for the mature and rational response. Has it occurred to you that there may be a link between these “opportunities” that you’ve taken up and the values of the West? In any case I make no apology for thinking that democracy, the rule of law, freedom of the media, outlawing FGM etc are superior to the alternative. Your views may differ in which case good luck to you.

          Incidentally, why do you hate me so much – I thought I was abundantly clear that despite my views I am absolutely not in favour if imposing them on others. So you hate me not despite what I do or want to do but for incorrect thoughts I hold. Not clear why you think I see you as inferior – if I knew you I would judge you by your behaviour not where you come from although I’d be interested to know given the astonishingly defensive response.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...