Do You Like This Story?

jessica rudd mamamia Jess Rudd writes: This spill is ours. Own it.

Tomorrow, when I fly in, I’m coming home to a political situation that most Australians think is a dog’s breakfast. What’s happening is ugly as. It’s infuriating. Messy. I agree. It is and it needs to be sorted out.

But unlike what happened in 2010, when Australia went to bed with one prime minister and woke up to another, now we have time.

This leadership ballot is happening in caucus, the group of 103 Labor MPs and senators we elected, but that doesn’t mean it is not our vote.

We are their employers. My Dad works for me.  I often remind him of that. He is my local member and I helped put him there. I walked into a church hall and in the privacy of a polling booth I put a one next to his name.

You’re all employers too. You might not be related to your employees, but that doesn’t mean you don’t have access to them. When they aren’t doing their jobs, you can tell them. When they are misbehaving, you can reprimand them.

I live in Beijing, a city with a population the size of our whole nation—twenty-two million people.

Like us, they get up in the morning. They have a shower and wonder if their favourite top is dry yet. They get dressed and go to work. They have lunch with their colleagues and bitch about HR. At the end of the day they swap heels for runners and go home. They order dinner from the grease-stained menus on the fridge, call their mum and switch on the telly.

At the same time each night on almost every free-to-air TV station all over China is the same national news broadcast. I don’t mean it’s similar, I mean the exact same show. In sync. You can flick between stations and the same guy is on your screen telling you what is going on, or at least what he’s allowed to tell you is going on.

You can’t just go, ‘this is boring, that guy’s tie is feral—I wonder what’s happening over on The Project.’

You can’t write to your local MP about it because you don’t have one and a complaint to the network is a complaint to the government.

When you watch international stations like the BBC and CNN, stories about China often disappear. The screen goes blank.

There’s no Twitter or Facebook. Don’t get me wrong, there are social media platforms and they’re epic. But in China it’s all still new and risky. People do say what they think but they worry about the consequences. Controversial posts are mysteriously removed from China’s equivalent of Twitter, Weibo. They just vanish.

We, the people of Australia, are different. We have power.

We are not a passive audience in a crowded cinema with popcorn on our laps waiting for the previews to end.

We are participants. We have a voice and I think we should bloody well use it. Get up and say something. Say it loudly. Be heard.

You might think Julia Gillard is the ant’s pants. Fab. Say it.

You might think my Dad is ace. Cool. Write it.

You might think everyone sucks. Scream it.

Tweet something. Rant on Facebook. Put a video on YouTube. Put a sign on your front fence. Have a chat with your neighbour. Tell your friends. Email your local MP. Ring them up. Stop them at the news agent and make them listen. Call your local radio station. Have a rally Vote in an online poll. Write a song about it. Get on Mamamia and say, ‘OMG she’s just saying that because she’s KRudd’s daughter.’

Look, I know the parliament can seem alien at times—believe me, it’s even weirder when you’re there—but it is not out of reach. It’s ours. We own it.

Let’s own this spill, people. Let’s make it ours. Make your MPs work for you. Tell them what you want. Because unlike my mates in China, we have no excuse for simply sitting back and letting it happen.

Jessica Rudd, is a Canberra-born, Brisbane-raised ex-lawyer, ex-campaign worker and ex-PR consultant who lives with her husband in Beijing. She has written the occasional column, a host of legal letters, countless press releases and two novels Ruby Blues and Campaign Ruby.
 Jess Rudd writes: This spill is ours. Own it.

So, if you were in caucus, which way would you vote?

Editor’s Note: We’ve been surprised that some readers have not understood that this is an opinion piece so we thought it might be helpful to clarify a few points. Jessica Rudd is the daughter of Kevin Rudd who is expected to challenge Julia Gillard for leadership of the ALP on Monday. That much is clear. Neither Jessica nor Mamamia is purporting this piece to be impartial political analysis. Jessica is not Laurie Oakes and has never pretended to be. But she is someone with a unique and undeniably newsworthy insight into the biggest news story in Australia this week.

Mamamia publishes opinion pieces every day and sometimes they are political. We publish views from the left, the right and everywhere in between. Tony Abbott, Jenny Macklin, Kate Ellis, Julia Gillard, Sarah Hanson Young and Malcolm Turnbull are among politicians who have had opinion pieces published on Mamamia in the past 12 months.

Mamamia is not the ABC but we do try hard to publish a variety of views to reflect the diversity of our audience but also TO START CONVERSATIONS among you, our readers. Because we don’t ever underestimate your intelligence. We know that you can see who wrote a post and make your own assumptions about their beliefs and motivations.

We are proud to publish Jessica’s posts here on Mamamia, just as we always have been. Yes, the invitation has been extended to any other politician or family member of a candidate who has something to say about this extraordinary and quite bizarre time in federal politics.

That invitation is ongoing.

And we are also pleased to announce the appointment of our first dedicated political correspondent for Mamamia, journalist Lauren Dubois who today files her first of many upcoming pieces from Canberra which you can read here.

- Mia Freedman

Kevin Rudd wins office during the November 2007 Federal election.

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

1,678 Comments so far

  1. Julie Zilko

    It’s such a pity that Mia’s ‘blog’ doesn’t have a ‘like’ button it it as does Facebook, as there are many comments here I’d love to concur with, such as your comment kiu!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      To the left, thumbs up sign

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • xxxx

      Also, you can reply to people by using the ‘reply’ button rather than post a new comment.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  2. kiu@yahoo.com

    This is a Greek tragedy and narcissism is a very appropriate term..

    look at the political class and you see the kind of backgrounds they come from, children of migrants with very large chips on their shoulders.

    I would vote for them but never ever work for some of them at all!

    The well educated public know this but the masses get sucked in by the propaganda.

    Tony Abbott is the epitome of all the bad things the liberals have become. the repugnant and far right extremists, god help us all !

    Thanks Mia for the freedom to say this you are a great editor for allowing us to have our voice, hugs to you and the Australian people who are greatest in the world. kisses

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Julie Zilko

    Mia. I think you are creating a wonderful service with this ‘blog’ (though it seems far too sophisticated to just call it a blog). I didn’t know about it until reading an article mentioning it in The Age today. Good for you!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Julie Zilko

    Glad you too the time to listen to the John Mendoza interview, Claire. If you were able to vote on Monday, would you give it to Kevin or Julia?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Claire

      Thank you for the link, Julie.

      I contacted my local member of parliament this morning (see my earlier post). This was part of my submission:

      “Mr Rudd has proven he was incapable of running a functioning and effective office and was appropriately removed. Mr Rudd’s megalomaniacal attempt to divide the party and regain power is a direct and self-centred attack on my right (and others’ right) to be governed by a capable and effective leader.

      “In my opinion, Mr Rudd is single-handedly destroying the ALP and the ramifications of his divisive and disloyal behaviour will be seen and felt for generations to come. Indeed, he has made an absolute joke of government and the Australian Labor Party. Destroying a political party of which you are a member is one thing, but dividing Australians, undermining the government and paralysing its ability to govern for pure self-interest is detestable and repugnant.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jackie

        I called my local MP today too & told her receptionist that I would be more than happy if she told Mr Rudd to F@#$K OFF, she laughed & said she would pass it on.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Anonymous

        “Mr Rudd has proven he was incapable of running a functioning and effective office and was appropriately removed. Mr Rudd’s megalomaniacal attempt to divide the party and regain power is a direct and self-centred attack on my right (and others’ right) to be governed by a capable and effective leader.

        “In my opinion, Mr Rudd is single-handedly destroying the ALP and the ramifications of his divisive and disloyal behaviour will be seen and felt for generations to come. Indeed, he has made an absolute joke of government and the Australian Labor Party. Destroying a political party of which you are a member is one thing, but dividing Australians, undermining the government and paralysing its ability to govern for pure self-interest is detestable and repugnant.

        That sounds like a copy/paste of what the Rudd haters in the Labor party have been sprouting…aren’t you capable of writing your own words?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Claire

          They ARE my words, so I take your comment as a compliment.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Anonymous

            I’ve seen those same words sprouted over and over again by Labor politicians so I doubt very much that they are your own words

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Claire

              It doesn’t matter how many times you say an incorrect thing, it’s still an incorrect thing.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
      • Julie Zilko

        Excellent Claire!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  5. Bec

    My Aust. History is a little rough (thanks to the education system for that one) but didnt the G-G sack the Whitlam Govt in the 70′s and give the Liberals power? Why can’t good ol’ Quentin finally do something instead of just rocking up on Anzac and Australia day for photos and can’t she force Gillard to call an election? (again, knowledge of how it all works a little rough) Oh no, of course not, her son in laws grand (sshh its a secret) plan is to grab the PM job after Gillard, Gillard ain’t going anywhere if Brycey can help it

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kathy

      I’ve also wondered about this potential “conflict on interest” with the GG regarding Shorten (her son in law). Apparently even if K Rudd wins the ballot he can not assume the Prime Minister position without the approval of the GG. I don’t think Rudd will get the numbers but it would be interesting to see how the GG handled it if Rudd did win.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • anon

      Flippant response: because of a little something called the constitution.

      Slightly less flippant response: the GG doesn’t get to dismiss just on a whim, but only in prescribed situations – eg if one of TA’s censure motions succeeds, it’s game on since that would mean that the PM has lost the confidence of the lower house.

      More flippancy:
      I know the education system is a shocker, but there are ways…

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1975_Australian_constitutional_crisis
      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reserve_powers

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • charlotte

      I know…. wouldn’t that make for an awkward sunday night roast situation! Still, maybe she’ll be forced to take a stand. Surely. please.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • bowerbird

      In 1975, the senate had blocked the government’s supply bills, meaning the government essentially could not function for three weeks before the GG finally dismissed it. That was a constitutional crisis. Despite all the hyperbole and rhetoric, what we have now is nothing like a crisis. In fact, the government has done remarkably well getting legislation through the parliament – given that it’s the first minority federal government we’ve had (I think. Certainly the first in a very long time).

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Shane

        It was only called a constitutional crisis by the ALP and their supporters. The reality was a storm in a teacup.
        We had an election within a month. Just because the ALP didn’t like what the people said doesn’t make it a crisis any more than this is. Apart from that, the Whitlam government was diabolical.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • anon

          It was called a constitutional crisis because the GG exercised powers no one had hitherto believed he had.

          It resulted in one of the few times in history (despite many attempts) that amendments to the constitution were passed.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Shane

      Yes, in 1975 the GG sacked the Whitlam Government, but power wasn’t given to the Liberals, not by a long shot.
      The libs were asked to form a caretaker government and writs were issued for an election the following month. It was at this election that the Liberals got into power.

      If the people had wanted Whitlam, he would have won that election, but they didn’t, he and and the ALP were given their marching orders by the people.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  6. Anti christ

    Jessica, ask anyone that has worked for your father what it was like and it is a sad nightmare…

    I would rather kill myself than work for a man like that but i have A LOT of admiration for those that did……..

    …. that’s why these ministers have come out and said the truth, that your being used for HIS propaganda is even more Machiavellian

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Julie Zilko

    Hi Em,

    Actually, Narcissus was a character from Greek Mythology, a hunter who was so exceptionally proud, that he disdained those who loved him. Nemesis saw this and attracted Narcissus to a pool where he saw his own reflection in the waters and fell in love with it, not realizing it was merely an image. Unable to leave the beauty of his reflection, Narcissus died. Says it all!

    The word Narcissism comes from that. In everyday speech, “narcissism” often means egoism, vanity, conceit, or simple selfishness.

    Just for your info, In ancient Greece the concept was understood as hubris. So if I happen to write that in a post, you’ll know what I mean!

    Really pleased you’re taking an interest in these words, as they are great to use in normal speaking with people… well, certain people, at least.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Jackie

    I think the piece is more about the importance & value of democracy than Kevin propaganda. I’m sure Jessica has written for Mamamia before & regardless, what happens on Monday in Canberra is out of our hands.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. gojulia

    Jess, your mum and dad have trained you well. You talk about having your own voice and the need for every individual to speak up, but all I hear here is your parents’ prerogative.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. GEORGIE D

    I’m SHOUTING OUT LOUD! KEVIN BE OUR PM!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Cleo

      Yeah, the Germans loved Hitler too.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  11. GEORGIE D

    I’m SHOUTING OUT LOUD! BRING BACK KEVIN!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. GEORGIE

    BRING back KEVIN RUDD! Big supporter, I hope it all comes true on Monday!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. Julie Zilko

    As Jessica said, this spill is ours. So here I share an article printed in The Australian newspaper the day before Kevin resigned as foreign minister. It’s worth reading.

    We need to talk about Kevin’s restoration again

    BY:_CHRIS WALLACE From:_The Australian February 21, 2012

    IF you feel completely bamboozled by the present federal ALP shenanigans, let me share some knowledge from inside the parliamentary triangle that you cannot possibly be expected to know unless you’re in it.

    To the outside world Kevin Rudd is a charming, intelligent Cheerful Charlie. People can’t understand why he was dumped as leader in the first place and why there’s such a terrific battle being waged to stop him becoming prime minister again. Insiders know he is not what he seems.

    The trouble with Kevin can be explained in three easy points.

    First, Kevin never developed leadership skills beyond the command and control mode practised in the China he studied so closely as a student and diplomat.

    That’s putting it politely. It’s the foul, chronic abuse he subjects people to behind the scenes — cabinet ministers, public servants, staff and RAAF stewards alike — more than the F-bombs accompanying it that make those who know about it feel he is unfit for office. Clinical narcissists don’t change their spots. It’s a character issue. Kevin’s character makes those who care about the sane operation of government desperate to head off a restoration.

    Second, Kevin doesn’t have it in particularly for Julia Gillard; he has it in for whoever is in his way. He is congenitally unable to play for the team. He plays only for himself.

    Kevin is and will continue, as he has from his arrival in the federal parliamentary Labor Party, to undermine the Labor leader unless he is that leader.

    Labor will indulge and reward his practice of permanent party terrorism at its peril. One would think it grounds for party expulsion rather than ascension to the Labor leadership.

    Third, Kevin’s not the sophisticated high-flyer people think he is. Kevin has a single undergraduate degree, only made it to the middling level of the Australian Public Service and never was an ambassador, only a relatively junior diplomat. He got promoted to the APS senior executive service in absentia while working for the Goss government in Queensland. He’s either pig ignorant or wilfully dismissive of a system of cabinet government that has served Australia well for a century. After his systematic dismantling of it last time, no one believes he will practise proper cabinet government if he becomes prime minister again.

    Gillard is not blameless for the present situation but she is being blamed for the wrong thing. Gillard does commit an inordinate number of political fumbles that obscure the achievements of what is a pretty functional government presiding over the world’s most successful economy.
    Gillard’s bigger problem is unerringly poor judgment about human beings. Where others instinctively seek out quality, she is drawn to dross. Gillard effectively made both Mark Latham and Rudd: in each case, it was her numbers that delivered them the leadership. Now she and Labor reap the whirlwind.

    When the histories are written, Gillard’s clumsy moves in securing Laurie Ferguson’s preselection in Sydney will be emerge as the defining moment when she got the NSW Right offside and sparked the emergence of a new, effective and unremittingly hostile factional leadership determined to square up.

    Combined with the nervous newbie backbenchers who haven’t been around long enough to see governments recover from mid-term lows and be returned to office, and some youngish and talented caucus members of longer standing impatient with hanging around the greasy pole’s lower climes, it is a combustible mix.

    Add the media, which lives for leadership contests, and which overweighs political theatre relative to government outcomes, and you get an actual conflagration. But does the Labor Party have to go up in firestorm? Does Australia have to restore to the prime ministership a man who proved unable to rise above his personality disorder before and is unlikely to do so now?

    A few weeks ago two of the Howard government’s most senior ministers lunched together and mused that in 18 months, Australia will get its first DLP government: the Abbott government.

    It’s the old story. When progressives tear themselves in two, the forces of conservatism benefit. Labor can stop and choose not to relearn old lessons the hard way. Alternatively, if Rudd and the Regurgitators get their way, Labor will have plenty of time under prime minister Tony Abbott to reflect on the sickness to which it temporarily succumbed.

    Chris Wallace is a member of the Canberra press gallery and publisher of http://www.breakfastpolitics.com.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • valentina

      Thank you for that article, so Informative and direct. I did shudder a little when Rudd said today that Abbott has neither the temperament nor intellect to be the PM. Abbott is more conservative than I am comfortable with, but he is a Rhodes scholar and truly his temperament seems far more suitable than Rudd’s! Thanks again for sharing your knowledge.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Is T Abb a Rhodes? Because I know a couple of Rhodes scholars, and if he is, I AM IMPREZZ because those I know are seriously, the smartest people I’ve ever met.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Rick Morton

          He is!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Julie Zilko

          Yes, Abbott is a Rhodes Scholar, but so was Bob Hawke and Kim Beazley.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Whippersnapper

            Well I am equally imprezz (with a z) that Kim B and B Hawke are Rhodes. I don’t discount their intellect because they’re Labor politicians!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
          • Valentina

            Malcolm Turnball is a Rhodes scholar too. Wonder if Rudd thinks Malcolm’s temperament and intellect is beneath his also? Bah!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Julie Zilko

              Australian political Rhodes scholars…

              Tony Abbott, Kim Beazley, Neal Blewett (former Labor health minister), Zelman Cowen (former Governor General), Geoff Gallop (former WA Premier), Bob Hawke, Malcolm Turnbull.

              And a few other interesting ones: Geoffrey Robertson (international lawyer), Mike Fitzpatrick (footballer), Richard Flanagan (Tasmanian novelist), and the only female – Anastasia Katherine “Anna” Donald (née Courtice; 1966 — 1 February 2009) was an Australian pioneer in the field of evidence-based medicine.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
        • Trog

          How ingenuous of you, Whippersnapper…

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Whippersnapper

            Oh pooey Trog, so sue me for not knowing this one thing about T Abb.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
      • Charlie

        I like this comment – infinity

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Anon

      The reference to Kevin having just a single undergraduate degree reeks of intellectual snobbery. Not a Kevin fan, nor a Julia fan, but seriously? One degree does not make a PM worthy?

      As much as it pains me to admit it, Kevin has been an excellent foreign minister and is very well respected internationally. Personally, Tony having been a Rhodes scholar does nothing for his appeal. In a leader, I look for integrity, critical analysis capacity, ability to communicate with colleagues and with the Australian electorate, strategic nous, decision making ability and vision. A degree does not guarantee those qualities.

      Perhaps the first two of those “three easy points” are pertinent or true, but this article just lost all credibility with me with its nauseating intellectual snobbery.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • nenebe

        “In a leader, I look for integrity, critical analysis capacity, ability to communicate with colleagues and with the Australian electorate, strategic nous, decision making ability and vision.”

        It would be great to have one of those, wouldn’t it??

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Julie Zilko

        Anon, I agree with you that the weak part of that article was saying Rudd only had an undergraduate degree.

        Also, I am not impressed with Abbott being a Rhodes Scholar either.

        But you say: “In a leader, I look for integrity, critical analysis capacity, ability to communicate with colleagues and with the Australian electorate, strategic nous, decision making ability and vision. A degree does not guarantee those qualities.”

        It’s obvious that Rudd lacks integrity, critical analysis capacity, and the ability to communicate with colleagues. For these reasons alone he should not be reelected PM.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  14. Phoenix

    And now (surprise, surprise), Jess is to appear on Channel 9′s ‘The Project’ at 6pm…….

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • lacer

      Yes and she was on Triple J yesterday afternoon.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  15. Luc

    I like a bit of fluff and froth (hi Zoe, love your work!)

    But if we are going to have political commentary (because that’s what this is really!) surely we could have something less banal.

    A bit of a cop out, I think.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. Bec

    I know Tony Abbott has already had an article published on Mamamia but I’m just curious to know that leading up to the next election will we see an article published here if one of Tony’s daughters happened to write one?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rick Morton

      I could honestly say we’d love to have that. Would be yet another interesting piece. Consider this an open call!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Lulu

        And in the interests of fairness, you’ll of course welcome something from Julia’s kids.

        Oh wait ….

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Rick Morton

          I said earlier I’d love to read something from Tim or her mum on here! Genuinely.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Sydney girl

            Both the Prime Minister’s partner and elderly mother have far more class and self-respect than debasing themselves on a blog in a shallow grab for votes, Rick.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Rick Morton

              Be that as it may, doesn’t change the offer.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
          • Julie Zilko

            Me too! Though as gojulia has said, it seems that Jessica is mouthing her parents’ opinion here, not her own. Of course, she could have just been influenced by her parents. I hope not. I hope Jessica has more moral fibre than Kevin.

            Not sure about that though, because last year when Jessica appeared on Q&A she said that Kevin was really happy being foreign minister… and she waited for the audience groan. Nobody believed her then, and they cannot believe her now.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
          • Linda

            or, God forbid…..Tim’s daughter. Wrapped in the Australian flag.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
          • deborah

            But why, exactly? When I go to vote I’m not voting for someone because they have a nice mum or a grand boyfriend, or a charming wife who holds their hand and smiles encouragingly, or a sassy daughter who drops ‘eff’ bombs….I can’t imagine what you think TIm Mathieson might add to the MM readership’s understanding of the Prime Minister’s leadership or political achievements, any less than I can understand why you chose to publish that laughingly-described op-ed post from JRudd (political propaganda would seem a more accurate description).

            And please don’t bother to go over the reasons outlined ad nauseum already – we get that you have the right to publish whatever the heck you want, and I’m a bit over being lectured at by people disguising bitterness and revenge as clear-sighted opinion.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Rick Morton

              Honest answer: we’re not part of the mainstream media. If you want an analysis of the political landscape and the numbers and what not, go to Mr Green on the ABC. He’s ace and we don’t do that here. Sometimes people want to get involved in something topical through another means. You might not get anything from a personal entry point, but many people do. Op-eds aren’t necessarily meant to be sources of unlimited knowledge. We do cheat sheets for that which (hopefully) breakdown complex issues so people CAN take something away from them. But sometimes, whether they agree with it or not, people just want to know what someone close to the fray thinks. What someone has to say. That’s not news, that’s just something related to it. It takes all sorts and, like we say, anything’s up for discussion!

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
          • Louisec

            Spare us!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
          • zabie

            It’s not quite enough to say that you’d love to hear from them. Unlike Jessica Rudd who is a regular contributor to the blog, it is quite probable that Julia Gillard’s family members have no idea that it exists. So while you say you would welcome their contribution, unless you actually seek it out, it’s a bit of a token and hollow response.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Sally

              Agreed. I made the same point several comments ago and was rather haughtily dismissed by Mamamia staff! They are quite determined to pretend they have the upper hand here

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
        • backagain

          Lulu that’s a really snarky comment. What good does it serve?

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Lulu

            I wasn’t snarking at Julia – at Rick if anybody (apologies Rick!), because I feel that the whole warm fuzzy family campaigning by KR’s family puts JG at a disadvantage. It’s a bit dog-whistling.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • backagain

              Sorry Lulu, I thought you were bringing up the old Julia/No Kids thing again and having a dig ’bout that..my apologies to you. :)

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
  17. zabie

    I have been genuinely appalled over the past couple of weeks at Rudd’s behaviour. Either he is an incredibly selfish egomaniac who doesn’t care who or what he tears down to regain power or he’s just completely delusional and really believes that Labour and the country need him. It’s just bizarre and so destructive to the Gillard government just at a time when the government was starting to gain traction, get some important reforms through parliament and slowly turn the polls around. As a longtime Labor supporter I am so, so angry at Rudd and what he is doing to this government. There is no way I would vote Labor again under his leadership.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • demon des

      good zabie the labour party doesnt need average people like you in the party . I to have been a labour voter all of my life as has my mother and all of my family if you were serious you would have been apalled at the way the party got rid of kevin rudd in the first place and you would never had voted for them again but i suppose you always have 2 BOB EACH WAY !!!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Phoenix

        Not nice, Demon Des. You don’t know what Zabie’s feelings are regarding the ALP’s decision to replace Kevin Rudd, as she hasn’t expressed them.

        By the way, it’s ‘Labor’, not ‘Labour’. As a lifetime supporter of the Party, I should think you would know that….

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Anonymous

          thanks for the english lesson phoneyx you must be the type of person that sits around waiting for a car accident so you that you can be the first to ring a toe truck (sorry tow) !!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Phoenix

            Actually, no, Demon Des. Just pointing out the incongruousness of your attack on Zabie….

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
        • susan

          It used to be the Labour party, this changed in 1912 according to wikipedia…it does puzzle me as to why people spell it labour..it’s not like the word is never in the news or placards etc.

          1912 was a very long time ago! not many would be alive today to know that spelling.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • zabie

        I’m “average”?.. ouch!

        I didn’t have a problem with Gillard replacing Rudd as leader because I understood the fairly basic concept that it’s the caucus which chooses the party leader not the voters.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Julie Zilko

          Good for you to understand the concept of how a leader of a political party in Australia is selected, zabie.

          As someone wrote on Facebook today:

          Note to Kevin: the Prime Ministership is not a gift of the Australian people. It’s a gift of Cabinet. That’s the case if you’re in the ALP or the Liberal party.

          The man appears to have no idea how the office of Prime Minister works.

          Actually, there was a better explanation, but so much has been said on this issue that I can’t find it now!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Phoenix

          ‘Not Average’, Zabie. You’re right on target ;)

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  18. Case Evans

    I did what Jessica said and voiced my opinion! Great piece that really got me thinking! http://tiny.cc/smfkv

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. guest

    From the editor’s note:

    “We’ve been surprised that some readers have not understood that this is an opinion piece so we thought it might be helpful to clarify a few points.”

    This is creepy and condescending. It’s obviously an opinion piece, but the problem is that it tries to masquerade as though it is not. If Jess had just written “I support my Dad and you should too, here’s how” or similar no one would have minded because it would be honest. This article isn’t.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Vickie

      But that isn’t what she said – she said make your views about however you feel about this clear, whether that’s pro Rudd or not.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • guest

        It’s clearly designed to help her Dad. Kevin is more popular with the public than with his colleagues. She wouldn’t be telling people to “make their views clear” if she thought it would help Julia crush him.

        I don’t begrudge her supporting her Dad at all. If I were in her position, I’d want to do everything I could to help him. I just think she should do it in an honest, straightforward way, rather than using sleazy PR tactics.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  20. Greenleaf

    When this was posted yesterday it said Jessica would be commenting after she arrived but that’s not there now – just wondering if this was still going to happen?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Tulipgirl

      She did comment. Can’t remember the post number, but it’s around 800 I think! She also replied to a few others’ comments.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Greenleaf

        Thanks – page 3 if anyone else is looking

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Tulipgirl

          Glad you found it. It’s hard to keep up with this one!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Julie Zilko

      Yes Jessica Rudd, where are you? Why haven’t you come back onto this site to comment on various opinions here?

      I’m disappointed in your lack of commitment to the process…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  21. hugh

    John Faine on the abc said publicly that he had misgivings about Jessicas book as being another member of the political class using their fathers name to get a book deal. when jessica was asked about this she replied with this sentiment.

    Probably and shrugged it off and didn’t want to know..

    interesting to say the least.

    to some thats being extremely selfish and in poor taste.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Careful- I got censored from this site for saying that yesterday

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  22. jill

    David Suzukis daughter is interesting as well … her father is am amazing man with no inferiority complex and has done a lot for the environment.

    that would be an interesting piece ed team

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nicki

      David Suzuki doesn’t have an axe to grind as a politician, either.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  23. Anja

    Just an FYI for those that are playing the ‘Rudd thinks he’s in China’ line, hopefully you know what I’m going to say, but if not its important so here is.

    Still today, a political figure in China doing what Rudds doing would be ‘made to go away’ in one way or another, there would be no ballot, nothing. His family might be too, or Jessica’s piece might read more like a denouncement of her father in the hopes that she can continue to live her every day life. That’s why, as the article says, people view the public voicing of an opinion with a fair amount of fear.

    By contrast, because what happened with Gillard was at the instruction of the party, it would be fine.

    Weather you agree or not with what’s happening, it’s happening precisely because this is Australia, a country where governance sometimes happens as a secondary activity to party politics, and someone who disagrees with the party, or the government, is free to do that in virtually any way (with a few quite obvious exceptions).

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. You can call me Susan

    Shallow much? Now that I’m thinking politics, and I will always vote Liberal, I am thinking that Malcolm Turnbull would be a great choice. Not only does he have a fabulous business pedigree; he also has a generous heart which we all saw here through the obituary he gave to his beautiful dog. Brains and ‘Beauty’?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nicki

      I would definitely vote for the Liberals is they were on the same page as Malcolm.

      Trouble is, Malcolm and Kevin are pariahs within their own respective parties.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  25. HayleyN

    I read the article because it was written by Jessica Rudd, not Kevin Rudd’s daughter. I think we should give Jess some credit, she is a talented, well educated author who has an opinion. She is not condescending, that is just the tone she writes and both her books, and the artlice about pregnancy the other week, were written in the same tone.
    Good on you Jess for writing it and MamaMia publishing it. I found it educational and interesting and I look forward to reading more of what you write in the future.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • B

      I was about to leave this exact comment. You summed up my thoughts perfectly :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  26. Gypsy

    I love you Jess and your Dad, voted Labor during Kevin 07 even though I am a liberal voter. Had to get rid of Howard. I though Kevin did a great job. Cant stand Julia and I think it is a real shame that our first female PM will forever be tainted with how she first got the job and then the second way she got the job.
    If she leads to the next election it is Tony Abbott who will get my vote

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. lacer

    In my opinion this whole thing was a media beat up, until Mr Rudd’s ego got in the way. If he truly wanted what was best for Labor he would have said definately he’s not running for PM and would stay as foreign minister. I heard you yesterday on Tiple J, Jessica and you said you are a Labor member, and if that is the case you would care for Labor as a brand. All your father is doing is making the Autralian public think Labor is hopeless and out of control. I think julia is doing a great job with a minority government. Julia Gillard has had no honeymoon period from the media, it has been relentless. I am happy that Julia is doing her best to close the gap between the rich and the poor. Most media outlets are owned b very wealthy individuals who don’t like what she’s doing. Also I think they believe Kevin is easily beaten that’s why they are pushing for him.
    I truly hope Julia Gillard remains as our Prime Minister.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Julie Zilko

      Couldn’t agree more Lacer.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  28. Jk

    Gillard Rudd and Abbot have embarrassed this country.Gillard and Rudd with their childish behavior and Abbot with his no policies attitude. Instead of fighting like school kids they should have been doing what they were elected to do, and that is, to put this country first,Not to feed their own egoes. Shame on all of them, I never thought i would ever be ashamed of my country, but sadly i am.
    I’m not voting all this time, I’d rather pay the fine .

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Mel

      Check the Liberal website and you’ll find plenty of policies. It is embarrassing that the voting public do not think and research for themselves, instead relying on ten second news grabs from Labor supporting media outlets.

      Mr Rudd hasn’t imposed a China style blackout on the internet yet.

      Start googling!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • B

        Labor supporting media outlets?!!!! Please, we all know that in this country we are dominated by a media that supports a Liberal government – let’s not play pretend here!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Caro

          Oh dear, B, you must be one of only a handful of people who believe that. Yes, the Daily Telegraph has FINALLY seen the error of their ways after enormous reader pressure but the SMH, ABC and most of the commercial TV networks are nothing more than Labor propaganda outlets.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  29. guest

    This whole political situation is a shambles. I am so disgusted with all the political parties in this country, Australians are being shafted. I just purchased a book called ” Australia the Stupid Country” its available on Blurb, what a read,really shows how we are being used and sold out by all parties. I recommend it. I for one am thinking of heading for other shores permanently.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Mel

      Me too, I’ve had it.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  30. Alright, I reckon this post is coming up to the most commented on on MM ever, next to Cadelgate and anything to do with the AVN.

    PS, where are the MM staff? you’ve all gone silent the last hour or two, are you in an editorial meeting or something!?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rick Morton

      We’re *everywhere*! Still reading and commenting here and there, but I think our case has been mostly put!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Clare M

        Hey Rick, do you guys get media monitoring? The West Australian quotes this post today, although doesn’t name this site so probably wouldn’t get picked up. Can give u reference details if you do collect, (I’m a bit of a monitoring junkie).

        I’ve said my piece below, but interesting in light of the criticism that one of the lines about it reads ” echoing her mother’s message”…

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Rick Morton

          Oh the Oz ran it, SMH ran it I think, it was on Channel 9, The Punch. As media reports, obviously, and not op-ed pieces ;)

          I don’t think anyone disputes this is a message the entire family shares, do they? No one here does. It’s clearly on message, but we thought it interesting enough to run given the newsworthiness of the leadership tussle. And of course, we thought it obvious the context given the connection between Jess and Kevin!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Clare M

            On the flip side, take it as a compliment that your readers want the best for the site and perhaps found this below-par.
            Seriously, I’ve written for publications that never got feedback which made me wonder if anyone cared! This site reminds me a lot of country newspapers, where everyone gives you feedback and feels a sense of ownership…

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Rick Morton

              I’ve often said that! Online and country newspapers, you certainly know what people care about! I’ve done both, what’s wrong with me? :)

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
          • Phoenix

            Good points, Rick. But given that the majority of comments appear to be not supportive of this piece by Jess, I have to wonder if – should it indeed prove to be part of a deliberate, orchestrated and wider campaign to influence Australian voters (and by the hour, it does)
            – then it may well have seriously backfired!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Rick Morton

              Opinion pieces are designed to influence. Or provoke. Or prompt. That’s what they do. Campaign or not, it doesn’t matter. We’d run op-eds from the PM or LoO or more during an election campaign, both with obvious agendas, as it’s just what these pieces are all about :)

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Sally

              Rick, good opeds generate discussion (and prompt or provoke thought as you say) but this has failed to achieve that. People aren’t angry or even particularly engaged with any issues raised in this article because quite frankly in substance it’s as slim as Victoria Beckham. What they are angry about is that it was allowed to be published at all. VERY big difference and not exactly what constitutes a proper debate

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Rick Morton

              But this is what jess had to say. Far be it for us to demand she change her mind, it hardly seems appropriate. We wouldn’t seek to change the views of any other op-ed contributors either. Look, obviously you don’t have to *like* what she had to say or how she said it. I think we agree on that much. But I find it odd that someone writing about a restrictive media in China (among other things) is facing calls she should never have been allowed to have been published on this site, in Australia, which enjoys the liberties of implied free speech.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Sally

              To be fair I think by now all sensible people have quite rightly established that this isn’t what Jess had to say at all but is simply a slavish parrotting of the strategy cooked up by her dad’s spin doctors. Are you still trying to pretend this piece is anything else?
              And please spare us the censorship line. All your readers are asking for is a little more judgement when running bits of PR without any critical thought or sense of publishing responsibility.
              It’s pretty clear the official line from Mamamia is to refuse to publicly confess you have been foolish to run this. But I would hope that in private there is some soul-searching going on and a few basic lessons have been learned.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Rick Morton

              Actually, no. I think I’ve been over this ad infinitum. You want us to be wrong because you think we are. But we clearly disagree phenomenally on that point. If we received this post tonight knowing the feedback, we’d run it again. Because our reasons are the same as they were from the beginning. No one pretened this piece was anything but the opinion of a woman connected to Rudd. I don’t know how much clearer I can make this.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Sally

              And I don’t know how much we the readers can make it clearer:

              You. Were. Wrong. To. Publish. This. In. Its. Current. Form.

              Thanks for listening anyway Rick. Appreciate the time you take to reply even though I am truly frustrated at what is presumably Mamamia’s genuine inability to understand the difference between an oped and PR.

              Have a nice weekend.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Rick Morton

              Your opinion doesn’t make it wrong just because you say so. We’re all media professionals here. Opeds ARE public relations. There literally is no difference. So we get it. Trust us, we do. We just don’t agree.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Phoenix

              It seems you’ve shut down replies to this particular thread (which beg its own question). The point being missed is, it doesn’t matter how many invitations you issue to Julia or Tony, they’re BUSY! Far too busy doing what they’re supposed to be doing! Julia G does not have a host of close family supporters with nothing better to do than flood the media on her behalf, so your invitation is meaningles. , It’s not important in the greater scheme of things and those people don’t see the MM site as RELEVANT to what they have to do at the moment. For heaven’s sake!!!!

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
    • Kate Hunter

      Posts with more than 1000 comments are rare but not unknown. I got more than 800 when I wrote of my lukewarm feelings towards my dog. The fact that so many people are interested in the leadership of our country restores my faith a little :-)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Sally

        No doubt there is intense interest in the leadership issue.

        But I think you will find 95% of comments on this particular post are loyal readers expressing their dismay that a good site has allowed itself to be manipulated into running PR for the Rudd camp.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  31. Judith Peters

    Lots of ‘faceless men’ here or in this case, ‘nameless bloggers’ – I wonder who you are?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • anon

      Can’t speak for others, I’m just someone with a view on a topic, and without the desire to engage on a political level with clients should they google my uncommon name (it’s not ‘anon’).

      For what it’s worth
      - I have a face
      - I am behind a closed door
      - I am not in a backroom

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  32. hyu

    No Claire, it has made people think and i am proud to be an Australian that has such smart, savvy and wonderful readers here………..

    Congratulations to them.

    Mia and team i hope you have learn’ t a lesson, the polity is smarter than you think .

    Great blog and it was a win, win for the public, who are smart cookies.

    Well done to them!! as for mia and their advertisers, i might just boycott them , thanks for letting us know who you are…………..(wink) but no thanks darlings.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  33. Axe

    This post calls for political engagement. This is a good thing.
    Apart from that, the whole leadership thing is abhorrent to intelligent people who think that there are more important things to worry about and spend money on.
    KRudd has trouble making decisions apparently and it is Ms Gillard who pushes legislation through. She did it when she was deputy leader under Rudd. He was away from office one third of the time he was prime minister and that is when things were finalised.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. anon

    Wow, amazed to be on a site where I agree with so much of the feedback. It feels very warm and fuzzy.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. Valentina

    I have followed this whole saga with great interest and after watching Rudd’s latest press conference must say that I find him condescending, vain and annoying. In fact, and it both surprises and pains me to say this, I found Abbot’s performance at his press conference more rational, restrained and attractive. Rudd will now be remembered as a political suicide bomber. Election please.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. Clare M

    Hi Mia and team.
    Just spent ages reading through the comments. So interesting. I really think this was a lost opportunity for both the Rudd camp and Mamamia:

    This piece is more like PR talking points with campaign key messages lines ( that we heard on radio/tv from Rudd and Therese) than an actual thought-out original opinion. That this was so thinly disguised undoes any good it could have done for Rudd, and it makes you guys look like you’ve been had or don’t care because it’s all about the web traffic.

    The condescending responses from MM to commenters aren’t a good look. As someone commented below, the dinner party seems over.

    Totally get why you would run a piece by someone closer than most of us to this political drama – but it’s a shame for Jess, MM and your readers that it turned out the way it did.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Clare M

      PS – this was said with love, by the way.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  37. CW.

    What a mess. Ive been following the comments since last night when the piece was published and ive got to say MM, youve really outdone yourself here. First of all, insulting your readers with what is believed they dont understand what an opinion piece is and then adding that little extra special editor note at the end is just plain condecending. Rubbing salt into the wounds dont you think? You wonder why your readers are pissed off!
    Secondly, if there is anything you want to take away from this, is please do not get the Ex -Pm daughter or any relation for that matter to write a political ‘opinion piece’ that in fact is the same ‘opinion’ as her fathers during this very unusual time in politics. Its just not appropriate. This can be proven when the press conference was aired this morning, K-Rudd said the exact same views as what Jess had said in her article last night. I have nothing against Jess personally. I think she is a great writer but i do not agree you should have published something like this. It was like she was selling his point across and favouring her fathers reason to contest the leadership. If you wanted a political unbiased opinion piece, you should have got Laurie Oaks to write one.

    Learn from it MM coz if you dont, you will loose many of your loyal readers. Insulting them will get you no where and it wont be tolerated.

    You have been warned!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kathy

      I’m not insulted. I’m not a Rudd supporter either. I’ve also checked the “About” section the Mamamia website and directly quote that “On Mamamia everything is up for discussion”. I guess that would include what Jessica has written.
      I don’t always share the same opnion as the writers on this site but that’s life. We all have diiferent opinions. What I do like about the Mamamia website is that they do try to encourage respectful discussions.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  38. jeanette

    Lets outsource our politicians and get Obama as pm.

    He can choose the best brains from all parties including the Greens and form a new party.

    Anything but this……….

    its a very bogan way to go….

    peace

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. Chris

    So the Rudd family have called for people power to prevail. Here’s my comment:
    Yes, Kevin Rudd was shafted and it was a bad move – blind Freddie could have told the Labor Party it would come back to haunt them.
    But any sympathy I had for Kevin Rudd has well and truly gone out the window after the last few days – not only have his comments and his behaviour been appalling, but the fact that all the family have come on board (Therese giving a press conference, Jessica writing a column on Mamamia) is quite sickening. Mia, if you want readers to believe you are not siding with the Rudd family, how about inviting Julia Gillard to write a post for you.
    Gillard has done a good job in holding a minority government together under difficult circumstances, and delivering some much-needed reform in this country.
    The only thing that will come out of this whole sorry saga is a huge win for Tony Abbott. Despite what the Rudd family thinks, now is not the time for people power – the appropriate time for that is at the next election.
    Now is the time for the ALP to sort itself out, put Kevin Rudd firmly in his place, and get on with the job of running the country while they still have a smidgin of a chance to do some good before we are saddled with Abbott.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • zabie

      Agree agree agree

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Phoenix

      Agree, too. Only I think Julia has a lot more to do at this very moment, and a lot more on her mind, as PM of this country than to sit down to write an opinion piece for MM….. Shame, though, because she really does deserve a right of reply. Unfortunately, she doesn’t have an orchestrated family behind her….

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  40. bassbassgirl

    I really, really, really want an alternative to the rubbish political options available to us at present. The Labor party may as well be a coalition for all the different factions within it. The Libs/Nats are just as bad.

    There seem to be many politicians who are in parties that don’t represent their values, so I propose that we have a complete overhaul. On Monday all the pollies can sit down and brainstorm what their core values are and then make up new political parties that align with these values :)

    As it stands I don’t know what party represents what anymore, because they all seem to be able to talk the talk, but don’t follow through with the actions necessary.

    All I want is a party who will deliver real and timely improvements to public education and health and take real action on climate change. Is that too much to ask?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  41. sandy

    I may not vote for Kevin but I sure would vote for Jessica after that fine piece of writing

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  42. jen

    how much payment was done of this piece if any and is it illegal when its a public figure that’s running for the people……

    our politics has become so Americanized as a result……sad and shallow.

    Like Greece and Europe, they are in it for themselves people, wake up!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  43. Julie Zilko

    Here is an interesting radio interview on the way Kevin Rudd performed when he was Prime Minister. Leopards don’t change their spots.

    Kevin Rudd’s senior adviser on mental health John Mendoza says he quit his job due to the former PM’s dysfunctional leadership.

    http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-02-24/john-mendoza-interview/3850764

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Claire

      Thanks. It was well worth the listen.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  44. Victoria

    Good on you Jess, and Mamamia for publishing this. I support Gillard, but Jess’s point is that everyone should speak up where they have the freedom to.

    Go for it!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  45. Anthony

    Please give me a break. Kevin Rudd is no hero. The Kevin 07 campaign was an absolute sham. To the nations detrmient here we are 5 years later facing another sham. It’s almost as though the stupid people have forgotten how woeful this guys was as the leader. These interjections from his family members are just further embarassment and these interjections along with everything else further galvanise the people to hurry up and get rid of this bunch once and for all. Kev, the girls and the Labor party. Give me back my dignity and my country. I’m embarrassed to be Australian right now.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  46. Jay

    I am not sure what I think about this opinion piece. It’s absolutely identical messaging to Kevin’s in his press conference earlier…’Let your MP know what you think’ etc. Less like running an opinion piece to me and more like running a press release verbatim. A PR coup for the Rudds, and a mega newsworthy traffic booster for this site. Not sure what I feel about it. Uncomfortable that’s for sure. Bit too partisan for me I think.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  47. sparkle

    I think Mamamia was right to publish Jessicas post. From what i know about this site, their job (or motivation) is to publish stories that are of high interest to readers. I know I was drawn immediately to the site when informed Jess had contributed this post. I am interested in what she has to say. Does that mean i cannot identify her post as having an agenda..or being a blatant PR exercise? Of course not. Anyone with half a brain will recognise that but it doesnt take away the fact that the story does interest people, and for that reason alone I for one am pleased that MM published the post.
    Anything that opens a dialogue about the future of this country and gets people thinking and debating is a bloody Good thing!

    BTW I am not a KRUDD supporter..I think Gillard is the wise choice but my comment is about freedom of speech and the right for MM to publish this post BY Jess.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  48. Sydney girl

    I am embarrassed for Jessica Rudd.

    Her behaviour is unedifying, and it’s really just sad.

    Kevin Rudd is going to lose on Monday, and he is going to lose quite badly.

    Jessica, your family are not the Australian version of the Kennedy’s. You have no public role. No one has elected you to anything.

    I’m actually also really stunned that Kevin Rudd would allow his family to be so front and centre on his campaign. A normal, sane man would want to protect his pregnant daughter from this mess.

    But Kevin Rudd is a rolled-gold sociopath, and his family clearly suffer from Stockholm Syndrome.

    But guess what? The rest of the ALP have stopped drinking the Kool Aid, and Rudd will be very, very lucky to get more than 30 out of 103 votes on Monday.

    And then hopefully, we can finally excise the cancerous growth that is Kevin Rudd from the body politic.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Jay

      I for one do not wish to hear from politicians’ families about their campaigns, but I dispute absolutely that Jess Rudd, or any woman in her position needs their father’s protection, pregnant or otherwise.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Sydney girl

        I said ‘want’ not ‘need’. I don’t know about you, but even in my 30′s, my father wants to protect me from nasty things, and if he got the sack because all his colleagues hated him, he’d want to protect me from that.

        Perhaps Kevin Rudd doesn’t want the same for his daughter?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Jay

          You are right, no parent wants nasty things for their child, however old. I doubt whether the Rudd family would characterise family advocating for Kevin’s campaign as ‘nasty’. Jess seems an eminently capable spokesperson.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Sydney girl

            Another strawman, Jay. I’m not sure if you’ve noticed, but this spill is pretty nasty. Feelings about Kevin Rudd run high. The vast majority of people who actually know him know he is a sociopath.

            Why any father would want, or encourage, their child to make a spectacle of herself like this, at a time like this, is a question which really goes to the Rudd family’s collective judgement.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Jay

              Fair cop Sydney girl. I take your point.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
      • Anonymous

        Likewise! I’m the same age as Jessica and, although my father continues to offer ideas, suggestions and cautions, as appropriate he wouldn’t dare sensor me, especially when I was pregnant! (I think he might’ve actually said that he’d rather negotiate with terrorists than try to ‘make me’ do anything when I was pregnant. From the little I know of Jessica through her writing, I rather suspect that she’d fit that category)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Louisec

      Brilliantly said! Clear and concise and right.

      Love the Stockholm syndrome bit too!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  49. helen

    Mr Rudd has nothing to lose and the a.l.p are getting really nasty…………….

    Keep that in mind when the verbal vitriol flies.

    What happened to having gentlemen in politics?

    sad days for all and the media in this country, the world is watching and laughing at the same time.

    Your dad is cool as he is an anarchist, its affecting the business community….go rudd go!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  50. Liz

    Find it pretty funny that people are holding up the ABC has an example of objective and unbiased journalism.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Happymum

      I know! Hardly unbiased.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Mel

        They are the taxpayer funded Labor propaganda department and I’m sick of them.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Miss green

          So tune out!

          Same thing applies here – anyone clicking on to this article knows that it isn’t going to be pro Tony Abbott or Gillard, so why waste your time reading it or complaining about it.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Lulu

          There have been a number of *independent* enquiries into the matter, & none of them have found any evidence of ABC bias.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • lacer

          I would say they use to be biased now they are the same as any other media outlet, that’s Howard’s legacy.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Sally

          Have you watched 7.30 lately? Absolutely not biased towards Labor. My husband (a Lib supporter) reckons it’s biased the other way.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions