Do You Like This Story?

jessica rudd mamamia Jess Rudd writes: This spill is ours. Own it.

Tomorrow, when I fly in, I’m coming home to a political situation that most Australians think is a dog’s breakfast. What’s happening is ugly as. It’s infuriating. Messy. I agree. It is and it needs to be sorted out.

But unlike what happened in 2010, when Australia went to bed with one prime minister and woke up to another, now we have time.

This leadership ballot is happening in caucus, the group of 103 Labor MPs and senators we elected, but that doesn’t mean it is not our vote.

We are their employers. My Dad works for me.  I often remind him of that. He is my local member and I helped put him there. I walked into a church hall and in the privacy of a polling booth I put a one next to his name.

You’re all employers too. You might not be related to your employees, but that doesn’t mean you don’t have access to them. When they aren’t doing their jobs, you can tell them. When they are misbehaving, you can reprimand them.

I live in Beijing, a city with a population the size of our whole nation—twenty-two million people.

Like us, they get up in the morning. They have a shower and wonder if their favourite top is dry yet. They get dressed and go to work. They have lunch with their colleagues and bitch about HR. At the end of the day they swap heels for runners and go home. They order dinner from the grease-stained menus on the fridge, call their mum and switch on the telly.

At the same time each night on almost every free-to-air TV station all over China is the same national news broadcast. I don’t mean it’s similar, I mean the exact same show. In sync. You can flick between stations and the same guy is on your screen telling you what is going on, or at least what he’s allowed to tell you is going on.

You can’t just go, ‘this is boring, that guy’s tie is feral—I wonder what’s happening over on The Project.’

You can’t write to your local MP about it because you don’t have one and a complaint to the network is a complaint to the government.

When you watch international stations like the BBC and CNN, stories about China often disappear. The screen goes blank.

There’s no Twitter or Facebook. Don’t get me wrong, there are social media platforms and they’re epic. But in China it’s all still new and risky. People do say what they think but they worry about the consequences. Controversial posts are mysteriously removed from China’s equivalent of Twitter, Weibo. They just vanish.

We, the people of Australia, are different. We have power.

We are not a passive audience in a crowded cinema with popcorn on our laps waiting for the previews to end.

We are participants. We have a voice and I think we should bloody well use it. Get up and say something. Say it loudly. Be heard.

You might think Julia Gillard is the ant’s pants. Fab. Say it.

You might think my Dad is ace. Cool. Write it.

You might think everyone sucks. Scream it.

Tweet something. Rant on Facebook. Put a video on YouTube. Put a sign on your front fence. Have a chat with your neighbour. Tell your friends. Email your local MP. Ring them up. Stop them at the news agent and make them listen. Call your local radio station. Have a rally Vote in an online poll. Write a song about it. Get on Mamamia and say, ‘OMG she’s just saying that because she’s KRudd’s daughter.’

Look, I know the parliament can seem alien at times—believe me, it’s even weirder when you’re there—but it is not out of reach. It’s ours. We own it.

Let’s own this spill, people. Let’s make it ours. Make your MPs work for you. Tell them what you want. Because unlike my mates in China, we have no excuse for simply sitting back and letting it happen.

Jessica Rudd, is a Canberra-born, Brisbane-raised ex-lawyer, ex-campaign worker and ex-PR consultant who lives with her husband in Beijing. She has written the occasional column, a host of legal letters, countless press releases and two novels Ruby Blues and Campaign Ruby.
 Jess Rudd writes: This spill is ours. Own it.

So, if you were in caucus, which way would you vote?

Editor’s Note: We’ve been surprised that some readers have not understood that this is an opinion piece so we thought it might be helpful to clarify a few points. Jessica Rudd is the daughter of Kevin Rudd who is expected to challenge Julia Gillard for leadership of the ALP on Monday. That much is clear. Neither Jessica nor Mamamia is purporting this piece to be impartial political analysis. Jessica is not Laurie Oakes and has never pretended to be. But she is someone with a unique and undeniably newsworthy insight into the biggest news story in Australia this week.

Mamamia publishes opinion pieces every day and sometimes they are political. We publish views from the left, the right and everywhere in between. Tony Abbott, Jenny Macklin, Kate Ellis, Julia Gillard, Sarah Hanson Young and Malcolm Turnbull are among politicians who have had opinion pieces published on Mamamia in the past 12 months.

Mamamia is not the ABC but we do try hard to publish a variety of views to reflect the diversity of our audience but also TO START CONVERSATIONS among you, our readers. Because we don’t ever underestimate your intelligence. We know that you can see who wrote a post and make your own assumptions about their beliefs and motivations.

We are proud to publish Jessica’s posts here on Mamamia, just as we always have been. Yes, the invitation has been extended to any other politician or family member of a candidate who has something to say about this extraordinary and quite bizarre time in federal politics.

That invitation is ongoing.

And we are also pleased to announce the appointment of our first dedicated political correspondent for Mamamia, journalist Lauren Dubois who today files her first of many upcoming pieces from Canberra which you can read here.

- Mia Freedman

Kevin Rudd wins office during the November 2007 Federal election.

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

1,678 Comments so far

  1. Dorothy

    Whilst I respect Jessica’s right to defend her father, I also respect the dignity and commitment Julia Gillard has shown to the ALP, to the bigger picture, and her lack of self-aggrandisment. She is not looking for the photo opportunity or cheap popularity decided by many people who wouldn’t even vote for the ALP. The decision about who leads the parliamentary ALP is up to the members of Caucus to do what their values and belief system tell them to do. Put aside the past – it is gone. What we have is now – and we have a female Prime Minister doing a great job leading a minority government.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Just Saying

      Agreed. Wholeheartedly.

      Anne Summers brilliant article in The Age http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/political-news/the-gender-agenda-gillard-and-the-politics-of-sexism-20120225-1tv7n.html sums up her unwavering tenacity and strength of character despite nearly everything being stacked against her.

      Throughout this whole disgusting mess one thing that has stayed the same is the respect that the majority of the caucus have for our first female PM.

      She can hold her head high tomorrow no matter what the outcome as she has conducted herself with grace, intelligence and dignity.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Louisec

        I never liked Julia before all this, but now I am a huge fan.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  2. Kylie

    In our house we hope Rudd gets up because Labor seems to have lost its way and if Gillard lost to Abbott God knows what we’d be in for.

    AS residents of the Sunshine Coast we are proud of Kevin Rudd.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Caro

      Kylie, what do you think we’d be in for under an Abbott government?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  3. Robyn

    How embarrasing for Australia, that the previous PM ousted is attempting to be elected as Prime Minster again. Respect your party’s decision and do not stand for re-election. Australia is worth more than embarrasing our great country. Resepct the decision made, how embarrsing to you and move on in the backgroud please.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Sybil

    So where is the piece purportedly representing the other side that was promised. No sign and please don’t tell me it’s the piece by DuBois- believe me that ain’t it.

    This should have a huge banner at the top reading “This is a political announcement on behalf of the Rudd Family who are angling to be elected (by applausometer) First Family of the newly and undemocratically created Republic of Ruddstralia.

    Now Therese Rein will be holding her own press conference. It doesn’t get much worse than this, one family is trying to completely bypass the normal democratic processes of this country and all this site can do is enable them.
    With every second I get more appalled at this crap. Editors what the hell are you doing?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Em

      Definitely think a subtitle should be added. She can keep her hokey ‘own it’ effing title. How about ‘a political advertisement brought to you by the Kardashian’s, sorry Rudd dynasty’. I think the reason we’re all getting MORE frustrated, not less, by this article is the complete lack of acknowledgement or public insight by MM as to why we’re frustrated. Apart from saying we don’t understand opinion. It’s opinion masquerading as a community service announcement. That’s why.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Mia

        Em – with respect, it seems you’re taking exception to the content of the post more than the fact it was published.
        We’ve published many political opinion posts and this is merely another one. You’re not telling me that anyone would seriously think Jess did not have a strong preference for the way this might turn out!
        I think – wait I know – MM readers are smarter than that….

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Anonymous

          Sigh, it’s a little disappointing that you’re still choosing to ignore what the complaints are about.

          The complaints aren’t that there is bias because Jessica Rudd should have written an apolitical piece, it’s that it was packaged as an opinion piece while choosing to ignore the fact it was the EXACT message that Therese and Kevin were spouting at the same time. It was PR, it was not an ad hoc opinion piece, and your readers saw through it Mia.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Em

            Yes, and I take it back, it’s not opinion at all. I doubt J Rudd believes there is any merit to what she’s written any more than I do. Or MM does. The content doesn’t matter. Getting publicity was the goal I guess. That’s just fine, we can say we don’t like it!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
  5. pinkstorm

    Jess, you speak much truth about our freedoms.
    Good on you for speaking out for your dad.
    There was a time I admired your father a lot. Sadly, his recent actions have started to change my views. To be honest, those words about saving us, that I heard the other day, made him appear rather deluded.
    He should have stood beside Julia Gillard and got over his want to be PM for now. He could have laid the leadership stories to rest and given Julia a fair chance after the 2010 election. United, they would have won the next election. Polls mean nothing 18mths ahead.
    To bring down the government because of your own bruised ego is not something to be proud of, especially when you are supposed to be working together and on the same side.
    If we are honest, Julia should have been “the one” in 2007 but I think Labor was still too much of a boysclub to trust that a woman, with red har and no kids could win. She is clearly the most effective negotiator in Aussie politics and as such the most able to achieve change.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • rainbow

      great comment, not sure what anon above is on about

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Faybian

      You’ve repeated yourself, a lot and while cyber yelling. This is your opinion only.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anonymous

      I recognize the mysoginist tone of this post, sounds all too familiar.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Just Saying

      Sounds like all that matters to Anonymous is that our PM is POPULAR and well liked.

      I prefer our PM actually DO something for our country not just talk about it.

      Pinkstorm never CLAIMED to be speaking on behalf of women, please RE READ her comment and you will clearly see that.

      If you are indeed a WOMAN, which I highly doubt, I actually find you to be an embarrassment to our gender. It is clear that you are just regurgitating all the existing sexist rhetoric that has been thrown at Julia Gillard by the right wing media during her time in office. Yawn.

      Despite the fact I cringed whilst reading your thoughts and do not agree with you in the slightest, I wish you all the BEST. I hope that you never ever find yourself in the same position as our PM, which is that your gender (in which you have no control over) is used against you like a weapon.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Em

        Funny. I alerted the moderator to his post (lets not pretend) this morning. I doubt any post that referred to Jess as a ‘bitch’ or having got where she is because of her ‘genitals’ would still be online HOURS LATER. mmmm ‘bitch’ has disappeared..or maybe it was ‘bimbo’. Either way, dinner party rules??

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Louisec

      Abusive and ignorant.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Lynne

      Anonymous: Hear hear !! i fully agree with everything you have written. Julia Gillard needs to see the light, resign on Monday morning and hand over to Kevin Rudd

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  6. Anonymous

    Seriously this article has left me PISSED…

    as the events have unfolded, Jessica Rudd knows what her intention was – she backed the same pretence up on the Project on Friday night. This is just absolutely pathetic.

    Mamamia, you have a responsibility to your readers – and no matter how many times you try to peddle the “but, wait – it’s an opinion piece!” people will be unchanged in the view that both you (for publishing) and JRudd (for writing) tried to pull the wool over our eyes.

    What a total BS front, “it’s our spill! let’s own it”

    Wrong Jessica. You got the call from Daddy before you even wrote this article that he was going to challenge so you tried to garner as many of your contacts as you could, one being mamamia.

    Gee mamamia – maybe you have just been used after all

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Guest

      Oh yeah. This piece by Meg Clement sums it up well: http://meganclement.wordpress.com/2012/02/25/a-family-affair-a-lone-julia-is-no-match-for-kevin-therese-and-jess/

      ..there’s still more to come..Sunrise appearances and 7pm project…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Faybian

        Well Kevin’s making sure he puts his mug on the tv over and over. 4 press conferences and currently an interview on the today show which was going so long that we’re now watching a documentary.
        I guess it’s part of the contact your local MP campaign, but it’s getting a bit old. I’m glad that Julia’s just given the one press conference and has been otherwise going about her business. I’ll be glad when it’s over.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Oopsyboops

      Thats what I’ve been thinking a lot about since this was published. I feel that MM was duped into running this piece as an “opinion” piece when it really was part of a carefully orchestrated campaing to win the “peoples” vote. And I resent that. If I were the MM team I would be pretty pissed that I had been coerced into it.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Mia

        Not pissed. Not coerced. Pleased to have been the first media organization to hear from Jessica Rudd.
        In her own words.
        We treat our readers with the utmost respect and we never underestimate their intelligence.
        Whatever Jess has written, I can’t imagine anyone not knowing what side she is on.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • nicky

          Off topic but if you respect our intelligence so much then please stop banging us over the head with photoshopping. We know everything in mags is fake / airbrushed / photoshopped. Sometimes fantasy is fun.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Corey

            Very off topic… And I am happy to be banged over the head about photoshopping. I think the “fantasy”, as you put it, is damaging.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
        • Oopsyboops

          No fair enough, it was always going to be clear what side she is on. And I think that is the issue. I was actually interested too see a piece by her. And I have no issue with running a piece. But this piece, these words, leave a very bad taste.
          Because it is quite clear that she is using this piece to manipulate the public. As is her Mum, and Kevin Rudd himself. And yes, I realise that any political piece by any candidate is trying to manipulate us, however they don’t do it in un underhanded way. Tony or Julia will flatly say, vote for me, I’m the best candidate.

          I just feel that MM is all about truth – the work on photoshopping, educating about anti-vaccers etc. Even your sponsored posts have “sponsored posts” labelled on them. We understand that. To run a piece that is so blatantly manipulative galls. All it needed was to be labelled as “political advertising” and I would have taken it as such. It is quite clear that a lot of people here also feel manipulated.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Mia

            Interesting. But political advertising?? I don’t even understand how that would work.
            We do carry political advertising on Mamamia because political parties understand what a large and influential audience our readers are.
            This is an opinion piece by someone whose motivations are crystal clear, in my opinion….

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Sybil

              It is part of a PR campaign by one family, each of whom have used identical phrases in identical statements. The fundamental anti-democratic nature of this campaign has been repeatedly pointed out. It is exceptionally heartening that, despite the disingenuous denials, virtually all of the readers saw through it immediately.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Faybian

              Probably because the speeches given by Jess’s mum and dad had the same phrases peppered throughout them, people got suspicious of this particular post. I know I did and lets face it. Most of us are cynical enough about politicians as it is.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
        • Snap!!

          But Mia this is what we have been trying to get through to you & your haven’t addressed it at all. It wasn’t in her own words!! It was EXACTLY the same message her mum & dad were bleating. It was part of their campaign!! And yet you constantly promoted it as some type of exclusive.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • Anonymous

        Oh, Oopsyboops you are sweet in your naivety. MM is in the media business and I promise you they knew EXACTLY what they were doing. Anyone reading this article can see clear as day as to what Jessica Rudd was doing. I have to say Jess used her media contacts very well, when you consider the staff of MM (and this includes Mia herself) backs the author and the article to the point of completely dismissing and belittling their reader’s concerns. So don’t feel sorry for them….I promise you they do NOT deserve your sympathy. MM, Mia and Jess only used one person & that was us – Their readers.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Mia

          Whoa, that’s a bit harsh.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Sydgrl

          Yes but it backfired, badly, on Rudd and MamaMia.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  7. Lionel I Parker 87 ww2 hero

    Rudd saved Aussie from going down the drain like the rest of the world,75 thousand back on the job and the only the only person to defeat Abbort!The members of cabinet are there because Rudd chose them and now they should all go to the back bench where they belong!Rudd defeated Howard and he will defeat Abbort!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Sybil

      They should all go to the back bench? That would be a novel way to conduct government, Rudd now minister of each portfolio, though of apiece with this attempt to be elected supreme leader by popular consensus. Hell, let’s just give him a sceptre while we are at it.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • anon

        If you believe the rest of the cabinet, that’s not that different to how things actually were under Rudd.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  8. Pingback: Leadership fight live – Gillard hits out at lazy talk of election defeat as …

  9. gbag

    Jessica, Therese, and Kevin please put your egos in your bottom draw and leave us all alone. I for one am sick of the Rudds in politics. The damage to the ALP is going to resonate for a long time. If Kevin had denied he would ever challenge when he became FM he would still be FM.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Why the hell SHOULD he deny he’ll challenge? Its every politician’s right to challenge for leadership of their party. Why the hell should he be denied that? Who is Julia, or anyone, to say they shouldn’t be challenged? Gillard challenged KRudd. Turnabout is fair play. What makes Julia so special she should be exempt from being challenged?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  10. Elizabeth

    I think it stinks that Rudd knowing he doesn’t have the numbers in his own party wants the leadership based on a popularity contest!

    I also think it stinks that he has been paid a motza to be the foreign minister and all he has done is wage war on his own party… great big waste of tax payers dollar there.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. Pingback: A family affair: a lone Julia is no match for Kevin, Therese and Jess | Megaphone

  12. PaulBennett

    G’day Jessica.
    ll
    If you want to help your Dad, research Julia Gillard’s links to the Fabian society.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Sydgrl

      She may be better off researching the personal qualities of a sociopath. Then shel may have a better understanding of why this happened to her father.

      Well it didn’t really “happen to him” he did it to himself.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  13. Pingback: Democracy. It’s a beautiful thing. | a blog life

  14. Curioser

    Great Article:

    http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/political-news/we-need-to-talk-about-kevin-20120224-1ttxx.html

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Juliette

    Jessica it is sweet that you love your dad but Hitler was also very popular with the populace and if there had been twitter and blogs they would have been zinging with support for him. Did not mean he was a person fit to lead a nation. I am not saying your father is like hitler, but mass popularity is no measure of anything.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • anon

      1484 posts. It had to happen.

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin's_law

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Guest

        I think it has happened earlier in the thread too!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • anon

          Phew. This means that I didn’t, in fact, read every single response.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Anonymous

            lol…that everything comes back to Hitler eventually?

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
    • guest

      What a disgraceful analogy and clear misunderstanding of Hitler’s regime. Hitler was popular because his own people were terrified of him. He was feared, not revered. If people didn’t fall in line they lost all they owned and worse.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Tim

        Hitler was also Christian.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Cleo

          I fear Rudd. and hate him with a passion. never liked him, never understood how anyone did. anyone who supports him now clearly doesn’t read newspapers. he may not have Hitler’s policies, but he seems to have some of the personality traits – a touch of meglomania maybe?

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • fee283

          not even close to one.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • Corey

        Hitler wasn’t that popular.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  16. Sam

    I am glad Kevin Rudd is challenging Julia Gillard’s leadership as I thought it was wrong of Labor to change their leader mid-term- the previous term of office and it put me off voting labor last election
    .

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kate!

      Two wrongs dont make a right.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jen

        Two wrongs don’t make a right indeed, but what Kevin Rudd is doing is entirely different to what was done to him. It’s not a second wrong.

        If someone found a legal loophole to take my car, is it wrong for me to try to use our legal system to take it back?

        I don’t want an Abbott vs Gillard choice. We elected Kevin Rudd in a landslide. So far, Gillard has become the PM twice, and neither of those times was she actually elected by us.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Ken Dally

          Sorry but unless you live in Rudd’s electorate you never voted for him you voted for the party. That is the reality of the Australian political system

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Jen

            I’m aware of how our system works, but we all know when we walk in to cast our vote, we’re thinking of which party leader we’re going to be voting for.

            There is an unstated assumption, almost a promise, that we are locking in the PM we want. The first time Gillard got to PM, she got it without our votes. The second time, she got it by making deals with independents. We didn’t elect her. Twice.

            Focus on the logistics of our system all you want, but in 2007, we elected Kevin Rudd, not just the ALP.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
  17. Nat Wolfenden Woods

    Hi Jessica,

    I really need your Dad to get in and come through on his plan for small business and manufacturing in this country. I am so sure he would win if it was up to the people.

    Thanks and good luck.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  18. Em

    I’ve commented on this piece a few times but I have to add I do like that MM have included a pic of Rudd family after his election win. Gives context to J Rudd’s clear purpose in writing the article. And if MM’s purpose was to provoke & stimulate then admirably accomplished. I still would still have preferred to see J Rudd come out and honestly say she thinks her dad is the best person to be Prime Minister and why. The ‘have your say’ stuff is just rubbish and we all know it. I feel bad Gillard thinks this isn’t Celebrity Fat Loser, because it is. What’s that quote about not underestimating people’s stupidity? However MM readers are evidently not stupid (some paranoid) but not stupid.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. mschiefgirl

    What rubbish. And for MM to have sided with the Rudds and their campaign hy publishing this is a serious misjudgement. It also shows lack of respect for the position of PM which is not a directly elected position, although the Rudds may wish it was. However, I agree we are lucky live in a democracy. And pathetic calls for people power on this issue is just an embarrasment when we are not subjected to the true injustices experienced in actual dictatorships are military regimes, where people power is accompanied by a threat to civil liberties or life. I am yet to see any justification citing what Gillard has done to have Kevin Rudd react this way. It’s all about KRudd. And isn’t this article all about JRudd, and promotion for her new book?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Mia

      We have not actually sided with anyone. We simply published a post, one of many. We’ll be publishing another this evening.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Em

        I hope this evening’s is a post by a sympathetic and popular member of Gillard’s camp who can write persuasively about how we should trust the Party to make the right decision and have full confidence in their choice.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Jackie

          We should run a book on who it will be! Wayne Swan, Bill Shorten…mabye Tim, shame she doesnt have an daughter..

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Louisec

          But please do not let it be by Tim or her parents. That would be very inappropriate. If it’s by her colleagues or past colleagues fine.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • Trog

        Will this post be an expansion on the comment that looked like it was written by one of Tony Abbott’s daughters? The one that was pulled down earlier?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Guest

          Ooh, do tell. Missed that one.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Trog

            Just a guess. There was a comment up that looked like it was written by an Abbott intimate. Perhaps a close relative or work colleague.

            I can’t find it now.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
      • Sydgrl

        Mia, I have a great deal of respect for you and what you have done with MM. But I don’t think you are understanding what members are trying, desperately, to tell you.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  20. Nick

    The reason that we are in this mess is the Greens. You can argue that “well they did it to themselves, they did the preference deal etc etc,” but if it was not for Bob Brown and his principles about the Carbon Tax, Julia like her or hate her would not of lied to the public, her ratings would not be in the toilet, and with as much respect to Ms Rudd, her Father would not have a chance to “save the party”.

    This situation has been caused completely because of Julia being forced to lie to us the population and therefore carry the same popularity ratings as the previous Prime Minister for three times as long.

    Bring on Bill Shorten, make a faceless man the front man, and see what the power behind the labour party can deliver? Well at least until the Libs are in next election.

    BTW I think that the best outcome for the people would be that the loser of the spill resign from Parliament, therefore forcing an election, where we the People can decide….

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Shelly

      Oh yes, the Greens. The silent little radical gremlins in the middle of this shit.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Corey

        Just don’t feed them after midnight.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  21. The Claw

    All I have to say is: if you think Kevin Rudd is the best person to win the 2013 election, because he’s more popular than Julia Gillard now – how popular do you think he would be if he had spent the last year and a half being attacked 24/7 by the Opposition, the Murdoch press, and talkback radio? How popular do you think he WILL be in a year and half’s time after being attacked 24/7 by the Opposition, the Murdoch press, and talkback radio?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Shelly

      Perhaps a little more popular than Julia is now? – If not about the same? Either way, Julia isn’t going to lead the party to victory in the next election.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • The Claw

        Disagree. To be only a few points adrift in the opinion polls after eighteen months of relentless bad press is a fantastic achievement, and the ALP could easily go on to a victory in 2013 under Julia Gillard. Especially given the complete absence of policy and talent on the opposition benches. But another change of leaders will make them a NSW-style laughingstock.

        Obviously the situation wouldn’t be as bad as the last NSW state election, since the state government was terrible, whereas the current federal government has a fantastic record of achievement – major legislative reforms negotiated through a hung parliament, and the best performing economy in the western world.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • mschiefgirl

      If Rudd regained the position of PM, he would be attacked but not attacked 24/7 by the Opposition, Murdoch press and talkback radio because the men running these entities are obviously more comfortable with a man seizing power that a woman. Gillard has been held to a much high form of scrutiny and subjected to sexist and particularly personal vitriol than any PM before her.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  22. Vladie

    Now you are in Brissy and Kevin ya Dad has made the challenge to get his job back the one we the people elected him to have I pray God convinces the ALP party to put him back in charge of this nation, We so much need a Father to lead this nation. I also pray that as a family you watch this movie ASAP http://youtu.be/i9VT_NBIVfs

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Guest

    Hard to keep up with this post!

    Hey Mamamia, that James Button article is surely worthy of it’s own separate post on here (you know how you do it with many of your posts..take a news story, quote parts of it and make your own comments about it).

    I believe this is the biggest story to come out of all this..the truth behind the toppling of Rudd. Major news. Surely you can’t ignore it?

    Would be a good way to show your readers that you cover both sides of a story. Get your new political staff member to knock something together.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Guest Also

      (I have posted in this post as ‘Guest’ in case the powers that be think I’m changing my name)

      “you know how you do it with many of your posts..take a news story, quote parts of it and make your own comments about it”

      This made me laugh. So true. Recently with the Punch ‘what four words do you say all the time” or some such nothing was even changed, just a straight lift of an idea for a post.

      Anyway, the Button article should be posted, if he wants it to be. In the interests of balance there needs to be a counter article of some sort. If MM wants to wade into politics and be taken seriously it is not good enough to throw your hands up and say ‘hey look if someone offered an article fine but we won’t seek it out’. Not good enough. MM’s approach to politics has long been sketchy. The appointment of a political editor is great, but MM will end up not being taken seriously if all it does it post political articles that suits the agenda.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  24. female voter

    This piece by Jessica Rudd is pure campaign messaging – it is NOT an opinion piece and Mamamia is completely unprofessional in not running opinions from Julia Gillard. This is not about people power Jessica its you trying to get your dad elected – who in my opinion is a purely self interested meglomaniac.

    I will NEVER support any person who is rude, angry and aggressive to staffers particularly to women serving him a meal on a plane – absolutely disgraceful, undignified behaviour, In private sector he would be sacked long ago.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Alesandra

      Agree with you 100%. I only read MM ever so occasionally and each time I do I remember why it misses.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  25. Jackie

    ATT: LIBERAL STAFFERS & MEDIA ADVISERS
    If you read back through the 1400 or so comments, so many of them saying they would vote Liberal if Malcolm were leader…the time has come for the Liberals to have a smooth transition back to the only leader that can capture the hearts & minds of a polarised nation.
    BRING BACK MALCOLM!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Guest

      That is to be expected from a left-leaning blog. Go read a right leading blog and Tony will be backed by the majority. Opinion on a site that has such a defined ideological base as MM (not everyone is leftish but after 3 years of reading I would say that is the readership bent) is really not that much to pollsters and the like looking to see what people think. This is not a negative comment, just pointing out that MM is not a broad representation of what Australia thinks – if you ever want a demonstration read a topic on MM and then go read a similar topic on a News Limited topic and see the difference in the comments. I like that the comments here tend to be free of extremists, from either the left or the right.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Alesandra

      Oh Jackie, you are so sadly uninformed. People saying that they would vote for Malcolm Turnbull if he were Opposition Leader is called messing with their heads or political cross-dressing.

      Every poll I can I put a tick to Kevin Rudd’s name. Yes I would vote for him I say. I would vote for him ahead of Julia Gillard. Absolutely I would Labor if Kevin Rudd were Prime Minister. Rubbish! I wouldn’t vote for Kevin Rudd and I wouldn’t vote for Julia Gillard.

      My rusted-on Labor friends do the same thing with Malcolm Turnbull. It sucks in people like you. And it sucks in the pollsters too. And it even sucks in the pollies. And the faceless men? Who knows what goes on in their faceless heads?

      Malcolm Turnbull’s poll numbers were in Pittsville before he was ousted as Opposition leader. A bit like Julia Gillard’s polls.

      Jackie, Malcolm Turnbull should have joined the ALP. He’s Labor on the inside. He didn’t join because he’s not Labor on the outside, and the unions would have stopped his rise to power.

      Coalition voters don’t like Malcolm Turnbull. He often undermines his leader. He also did stupid things (hello Godwin Grech). Most Liberal MP’s would gnaw off their right arm rather than serve under Malcolm Turnbull.

      Have you ever watched Malcolm Turnbull playing with his iPad in parliament rather than engage in what he’s being paid to do? Have you ever gone through some of the naughty statements that he’s made on climate change? And have you ever wondered why’s he’s not on the front foot engaging in more proactive discussions in the area of his portfolio?

      Malcolm Turnbull has a brilliant mind but he’s not Coalition leadership material. He tried it once and botched it miserably. John Howard made a mistake encouraging Malcolm Turnbull to stay on in politics.

      Kevin Rudd also has a brilliant mind but he’s not leadership material either. I suggest you read David Marr’s Quarterly Essay on Kevin Rudd to understand the man’s limitations.

      Jackie, your comment is sadly simplistic. If Tony Abbott does manage to become PM after the next election, I think he will be a great Prime Minister. How do I know? I know because this time I’ve done a lot of research. I don’t want to be caught out again as I was in 2007. I stupidly voted for Kevin Rudd. You see I was a Labor voter then but I didn’t vote For Julia Gillard. I will NEVER vote Labor again.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • MLS

        Love it!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Jackie

        Alesandra, you are entitled to your opinion, as am I. My opinion is not uninformed & I know I am not alone, but thanks for the well thought out comment, good reading.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Nat Wolfenden Woods

      Great point. Bring in anyone else except Tony Abbott. Please.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Lulu

        There’s SO much I like about Tony Abbott. And I think he’ll make a great leader.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Lulu

          What the????? That wasn’t me, I promise.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  26. Pingback: The novel 1984, what would have they done about blogs - burnt all the computers?Ideas Woman is here to help you

  27. marniequin2

    Hi Jess. and very kind regards -

    While I’m sure we all admire your family’s loving support for each other, I wonder if you might read my post with some degree of objectivity and respond. (I know that that my request for some objectivity is a ‘big ask’ of a family member, but is there not perhaps some cause for concern here?)

    RE: ‘Kevin Rudd’s NINE HOURS of . . . ?’

    What qualities / or lack thereof are showcased in the account (below )
    . . . NINE hours of Mr Rudd’s time in Washington?

    How appropriate were his behaviours in response to:-
    i) criticism (egregious as it was)
    ii) lack of Prime Ministerial support

    Did he make an appropriate ministerial response? Subjected to vile criticism and not supported by his Prime Minister, Mr Rudd’s response was to firstly ditch his current job and related serious commitments and position himself for the PM’s job.

    Was this a mature response to the situation? Was it:-

    rational / irrational?

    appropriate / inappropriate?

    responsible / irresponsible?

    As a response to criticism and lack of support, does not Mr Rudd’s behaviour
    showcase his :-

    Wilfulness?

    Egocentricism?

    Chaotic decision making?

    Impropriety?

    Impetuosity?

    Lack of discipline?

    Emotional immaturity?

    Poor anger management?

    Is his behaviour perhaps an indication that Mr Rudd, his anger
    out of control, does indeed become ‘unhinged’ when stressed?

    And that chaotic decision making is one outcome . . .

    Kevin Rudd’s NINE HOURS of . . . ?

    Kevin Rudd arrived in Washington last Tuesday, 21st February at 4pm US time.

    He had a 90 minute dinner meeting at the Pentagon with Kim Beazley, (Australia’s Ambassador to the USA) Leon Panetta (US Secretary of Defence) and key staff from the US defence department.

    He returned to his hotel room at 9pm.
    A few hours later and without prior notice/discussion, he resigned as Minister of Foreign Affairs in a speech made from his hotel at 1.20am Wednesday.
    He announced that his duties in Washington would be performed by Mr. Beazley
    and
    those in London would be performed by the permanent Secretary of his department.

    Some meetings appear to have been cancelled.

    (Note: In September 2009, Kevin Rudd appointed Beazley as Australia’s Ambassador to the USA. The appointment began in February 2010.)

    It would be interesting to know if Mr Rudd had talked about his intentions prior to making his resignation speech. At what point did Kim Beazley learn that he’d be standing in for Kevin in Washington the very next day?

    Indeed, how much of everything did Mr. Rudd tell Kim Beazley?

    Serious commitments ditched by Mr Rudd due to his resignation were :-
    a) talks in London on the future of Somalia !!! and piracy !!! in the Indian Ocean
    b) talks in Tunis regarding the future of Syria !!!

    In a nutshell:-
    Kevin Rudd’s response to Wayne Swan et alii was to
    a) ditch his significant responsibilities,
    b) resign without notice
    c) position himself for a campaign / challenge of Julia Gillard’s Prime Ministership.

    Do we not have here evidence of serious mental/emotional deficits which support the credibility of Julia Gillard, Nicola Roxon and others.

    In a word (or two) :- ‘Loose Cannon’

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. Sybil

    Yes you censored an opposing view. Blatant bias along with running a PR campaign disguised as opinion, a new low

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. Jenson

    Why was the Button article removed??

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Mia

      Cutting and pasting an entire article from somewhere else into a comment field is a breach of copyright.
      We will reinstate the comment but we cannot publish the entire article as part of that comment – just a few pars for the purpose of commentary.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Sydney girl

        I disagree, Mia. In my legal opinion, the article was clearly attributed, so there was no breach of moral rights. The links were also made available. I would argue that the copying of this article falls under the fair dealings exemption under news reporting. This exemption allows news articles to be disseminated because there is a clear public interest in the reduction of obstacles for the publication of news articles, regardless of source, insofar as attribution is clear.

        I’ll agree though that it is a fairly new area of law in relation to social media, without established case law, but I’d also argue that the chances of James Button suing Mamamia for breach of copyright are extraordinarily slim.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • anon

          To be fair, whilst it must be reassuring to MM to get Sydney girl’s legal opinion, they may need to check with their own legal counsel, and then stay on the safe side anyway for cross-jurisdictional reasons (big smile on my face as I type this, no offence meant at all, just a joke about anonymity and proliferation of experts on the internet – for all I know you’re a well-known ip barrister whose identity is verified on this board).

          And there are lots of sites out there that don’t allow whole passages to be pasted. Copyright is part of it, but it’s also just a matter of readability – this is a discussion format rather than a research dump bin.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Anonymous

            This!! Mamamia really really needs legal counsel. They are out of their depth when they deal with news and politics. The big media organisations have in-house lawyers and QCs on tap and they are kept very busy. MM clearly doesn’t have the skills or experience to wing it.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
      • Louisec

        Mia, why did you not just leave the link up?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  30. rainbow

    why was the button article removed???

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Liz Sheean

      Forgive my spelling error. I get it is the Labor Party. I am distressed. I made an error. I am sorry. But maybe I, like so many others, find all this just too much hard labour. Let’s all pick on one another and mimic the Prime Minister and her Senior colleagues? As for Kevin Rudd’s behaviour…I have had personal accounts from friends who have worked closely with him. Yes, it does sound like he was tough to work for. Kevin 24/7 etc etc. My friends had young children at the time. Being tough to work for is a problem I agree (and must be resolved internally with the appropriate domain) but I will still say that Julia Gillard and her Senior cabinet have behaved in ways I cannot forgive REGARDLESS of what Kevin Rudd did or didn’t do. The role of government is to provide some sense of stability for the people they govern. One would expect the most senior members to set exemplary examples of decent behaviour. One can forgive a certain amount of argy-bargy but the recent personal attacks of Kevin Rudd were awful. Anyone who takes our supposed concerns about bullying of children and work colleagues seriously would feel dismay and despair at the shocking display of unnecessary personal attack we are witnessing. If we are talking about egos…well, there are egos all round in this mess.
      The truth is Julia Gillard began to lose my respect when she could not explain to me in any credible way why she broke her promise to Andrew Wilkie. I accept politicians can need to go back on promises but I expect them to justify it to me in a clear and sensible manner. Julia Gillard failed to do that for me. Her recent comments about Celebrity BIg Brother are awful. The opinion of the public can be equated to the opinion of the audiences that watch Big Brother? How dismissive of the FACT that ‘the public’ prefer Kevin Rudd to her. The more she opens her mouth at the moment the sadder I become.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Louisec

      What is the Button article? Is there a link for it?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • rainbow

        it has been added as a post in its own, the one about why kevin was dumped in the first place.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  31. Liz Sheean

    I have sent this to as many Labour members I can find.

    I am not sure if any Labour Members are interested in the views of the public. Recent reckless behaviours would suggest otherwise.

    I am writing to express my disgust at the behaviour of the Prime Minister and Senior Cabinet Ministers. I am a Labour voter and have been all my life. The undisciplined, immature, vicious personal attack on Kevin Rudd, regardless of what he has or hasn’t done, leaves me devastated. I once admired Julia Gillard, and many members of the senior cabinet. I once believed in the Labour Party and what it stands for. My admiration and faith have left me after the events of the last few days. Instead I find myself stunned and devastated. Julia Gillard is no longer someone I could EVER vote for. As Prime Minister, she has betrayed my trust through her absurd, unnecessary, self-interested, illogical criticisms of Kevin Rudd, regardless of whether she is ‘right’ or ‘wrong’. Once things become personal you end up with egg on your face and Julia Gillard has ended up with an omelette on hers. She should not air her dirty linen in public. A good leader would contain such venom and set an example. As for the rest of you. You have ALL betrayed our trust. You should set examples to us all, not set examples of how to bully your colleagues. We are so concerned about setting better examples for children who are bullied and here we have the biggest boys and girls of all showing us all how it is done. You should be ashamed of yourselves!!!

    It is clear now that Kevin Rudd is the only hope the ALP has of staying in government in any meaningful way, whether it be in power or in opposition.

    Even though I live in a safe Liberal seat, I will vote Liberal next time just to add to the Liberal vote and send whatever sad little message I can. While my vote may not count for you, I am aware that I am not alone in how I feel.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Are you serious, have you really not read anything about Kevin Rudd’s behaviour over the last year? This is one of the more one sided summaries I’ve ever heard!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Michelle

      It is the Labor Party, not Labour!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • anon

      Got them coming and going, huh?

      “They did not offer an adequate explanation of why he was knifed.”

      “The undisciplined, immature, vicious personal attack on Kevin Rudd, regardless of what he has or hasn’t done, leaves me devastated.”

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • missb

      Please read the insightful article by James Button which helps explain what happened to cause Gillard to challenge Rudd. (Googling James Button Rudd will lead you to it!)
      It changed me from a fence sitter to someone who wants Gillard to communicate better and keep her job.
      I also urge everyone to spend at least a few hours looking for articles and opinions on both sides and make up their own minds; Gillard looks like a horrible usurper, but maybe that’s not the case when you look deeper?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • GWH Lohrey

      Bravo! I support Rudd and have stated why elsewhere in this blogforum, in The Age, etc this week. In all my reading, however, I have yet to come across any recognition that Rudd was suffering from serious health problems before he was deposed in Julia & her henchpeople’s coup. He had a gallbladder operation shortly after and later on a new heart valve to replace the one he had had replaced many years earlier. Rudd had rheumatic heart disease as a child (something which is considered almost extinct in OECD countries these days but which is still endemic amongst the indigenous community in Australia in 2012, much to the shock horror of medics round the world). So, without his gallbladder problems of 2010 and with a renewed heart valve, he probably IS a new man! It was also without question a hugely stressful time in Australia (and globally it continues to be so). Rudd did not bleat about any of this but carried on. How would the Australian electorate like to be dealt with all this injurious treatment, the defamation, the treachery, the bullying in the media, and especially when he was out of the country doing his bit for Australia? Shame on those who have participated! Whatever happened to the Land of the Fair Go? Bravo, Tony Albanese! As for comments elsewhere that negative commentary about Gillard is sexist, some of it was (Ditch the Witch, etc). That all disgusted me and did nothing to advance the cause of anyone mouthing such things. I am a feminist, however, and I do not buy the line we have to stoop to engaging in a coup-d’état to prove it. Criticisms of Gillard are, in more thoughtful and considerate people, not triggered by sexism, but by the scurrilous way she came to power, her disingenuousness, etc.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Louisec

        A new man, come on?! What does a gallbladder problem or heart valve have to do with banging his head repeatedly against a wall over a very minor matter?! Oh I suppose the gall bladder was the reason he refused to speak to his head of department for four whole months?!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Louisec

      How can a man run a country when he is incapable of working “with” people?! It is well known now that for four months prior his ousting that he refused to speak with his Head of Department!

      Then what about his melt down/tantrum when he repeatedly banged his head against a brick wall, screaming and swearing, when a press conference ran one question too long.

      And there are many more incredible examples. I am glad that the truth has come out about his instability and unacceptable behaviour. The majority of the party now refuse to work with him. And no wonder!

      They can not all be wrong.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  32. Ideas Woman

    I cannot believe MM removed the reply from James Button which I read in full. Hope he puts it up somewhere else. Shame on you MM for doing that! Your website just lost its’ credibility.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      I am shocked and surprised at the bias this site is now showing, for days Mia has been saying that all views are welcome now the team is blatantly deleting views from the other side. It’s unbelievable.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Lana

        We have comment guidelines which we impose on all comments no matter which side you are on. If you are rude or abusive you get shown the door

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Anonymous

          Please, Lana, tell me how posting an article was rude or abusive? I have not once been abusive to a single person/comment on this article!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Mia

            No article links have been removed – only abusive comments.
            Sometimes our spam filter picks up comments with links in them. I’ll go check and re-instate any acceptable comment.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
    • Mia

      Ideas Woman,
      As stated above, the comment was removed by our moderator for copyright reasons. I read the James Button article this morning and thought it was very interesting. In fact I tweeted it.
      So accusations of bias are, once again, incorrect.
      The deleted comment has been edited to a few pars (cut from the bottom, not edited selectively- before you ask…..) and reinstated.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Ideas Woman

      Why was A dose of reality’s comment removed? It can be found here: http://ideaswoman.com/blog . I am posting not being a supporter, but to give another side to the story. I personally do not like Gillard nor Rudd but I am finding the spill and the reasons for it, all very informative, especially about the [Queensland] Heiner Affair which got little press in Victoria at the time.

      Moderator, please tell us the reasons why the comment was deleted. Fairfax printed it, why not you?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  33. Caz

    OMG! That guy’s tie is feral, I think I’ll get my serious and unbiased political info from the Project!

    REALLY? This is what Jessica Rudd and Mamamia believe to be the intelligence level of their readers? This level of ability is to be applauded in our ‘dumbed down’ society? If my 6th graders handed this in they’d get a B, if I was in a good mood.

    Jessica Rudd – 27 year old ex-lawyer, ex-PR Consultant will soon be able to add yet another ex to her name – ex-propagandist and hopefully, ex-author and writter of ‘opinion pieces.’

    Now, that would really be ‘FRIKKIN AWESOME.’

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. Mel

    I want to thank Kevin Rudd for his invaluable contribution to Australia.

    Before I laid eyes on him I was an apolitical, ripping my hair out and run off my feet Mum who simply voted Labor because of my Bankstown Irish Catholic background. I didn’t care who was in power, I was too busy to notice and just grabbed my politics on the run with a 10 second news grab here and there.

    Thank you, Mr Rudd. You and Ms Gillard have exposed the ugly underbelly of the Labor Party and shaken Australian out of their apathy.

    There’s no more ‘she’ll be right mate.’ We are all taking notice now and that is your lasting legacy.

    You are accountable, we pay you, you are a SERVANT of the people!!

    Every other Prime Minister has sort to serve the country. Some were bad, some were brilliant but they had at their core the desire to better the Nation.

    Kevin Rudd did not. All the world was Kevin’s stage and he thought Australia and her people were there to serve him in his quest for world domination.

    I loathe this Government and I’ll say that at any and every dinner party I attend till they are gone.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. TwoDogs

    Gillard’s approval rate plummeting

    ……Ms Gillard has taken a hit personally, with her approval rating falling 4 points to 36 per cent and her disapproval rating rising 2 points to 56 per cent. She remains virtually equal with Mr Abbott as preferred prime minister, rating 46 per cent to his 47 per cent.

    Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/political-news/rudd-still-the-peoples-pick-20120224-1ttrx.html#ixzz1nLk7EilM…….

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Excuse me Mamamia team, but why was the James Button article removed and not this one?

      Seriously, what has happened to this site? You’ve lost your integrity and it’s very sad to see.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  36. Demondes

    Is everybody in the labor (labor) party caucus blind or living in a fantasy world . Each and every way you look at it julia gillard has no hope in the world of leading the labor party to winning the next election !.I cant beleive the people who will vote for her can not see this. She is not a bad person and is doing her best to revive the party but has to much public support against her to be able to claw her way back its an impossible task ! The only way for labor to win at the next election is to install Rudd as leader again regain a massive lead in the polls which are showing the way now and will keep labor in government for a further 3 years and then work on uderpinning the future of the party so these scenes of disaster and bitterness do not appear again. Swallow your pride for to keep labor in government after the next election Rudd must be installed as leader unless of course you want Tony Abbott as your next prime minister . Its inevitable, that unless the caucus votes Rudd to lead the labor party again Abbott will be in the top job in the country come the next election (MARK MY WORDS)!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. Pingback: I happen to agree – no matter who you wish to be in place, we need to own our politics better. | It's About Time

  38. SK

    wow! Over 1,000 comments and counting. I love that MM has the ‘scoop’ from Jess. It is her opinion, she is entitled to it and share it with whom she pleases. its an opinion piece just like any other we read on MM. Love it or loathe it.

    The only thing I want to say is that, it isn’t about winning elections. Its about who can represent and run this country effectively. I have voted Labour all my life, was brought up in a Labour home. BUT please note LIBERAL party – put Malcolm Turnbull in and I will vote for him. WHY? because he seems the most measured, fair MP of the lot of them. And I am well aware that all the ‘usual sneaky’ suspects of the Howard govt are still there (BBishop, PRuddock et al) and they will be wanting their piece of the action… again! BUT if we can have JHockey Dep PM and Malcolm for PM – tthen I am in. At least MTurnbull has life experience and I have to say I was stoked to see him at a Sydney TEDX presentation. Speaks volumes.

    In the meantime, I will watch the Labour party implode, blame each other and generally make a mess of things. Sad days indeed.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. Wonder

    Sorry if this is a silly question.. is Monday’s caucus vote a secret ballot?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Petal

      Yes.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • GWH Lohrey

      Yes…it could be more interesting than presumed…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  40. Caro

    The Heiner Affair

    Evidence SHREDDED in the sexual abuse case of an Aboriginal teenage girl while in State Custody

    Kevin Rudd is Mentioned at the STANDING COMMITTEE ON LEGAL AND CONSTITUTIONAL AFFAIRS

    Kevin Lindeberg submits to the STANDING COMMITTEE ON LEGAL AND CONSTITUTIONAL AFFAIRS (see below) that Kevin Rudd ought to be placed under oath when Mr. Lindeberg swears that

    “It is open to suggest that two such people caught up in this network and sitting in the Federal Parliament should be questioned under oath in the same way I was to ascertain whether or not they held the same state of knowledge as the Hon. Anne Warner and the Hon. Pat Comben did in those critical days. They are the Member for Griffith, Mr. Kevin Rudd MP and the Member for Lilley, Mr. Wayne Swan MP”.

    START RESEARCHING and do as Jess Rudd says – CONTACT YOUR MP

    All Senators are in possession of documents and are sitting on them – WHY?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  41. Robin Barker

    Thankyou James, this is one of the best summings up of the Rudd affair I have read. It is fair and I believe truthful.
    It’s a shame all this information hadn’t been out there in 2010.
    ‘Can I say this?’
    KRudd has never fooled me and I have a great deal of trouble ‘getting’ his popularity. There are many good talented people in the Labor Party and it always puzzled me how Rudd got the top job. Anyone could have won the 2010 election, the Liberals were in disarray, their time had come.
    Julia Gillard has had a tough gig and all manner of mud thrown at her. She has managed to maintain her dignity and, as you say, run a happy office. She is talented and intelligent and the LP caucus should give her the opportunity to show us what she can really do when she is not undermined every step of the way by someone in her own party – this does not exclude beating Tony Abbott at the next election.
    I admired your father James.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      The Mamamia team removed the article! Can you believe it?

      But no, they don’t have an agenda, not at all.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Robin Barker

        My comment (above) was in reply to a piece by James Button which seems to have been removed.
        It was well written, logical and devoid of any rude or offensive language.
        Weird

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Anonymous

          I posted the article. They seem to wax lyrical how all points of view are aired on this site, but then they delete what was an exceptionally well written and interesting article written by a man who worked for Rudd.

          Not a good look Mamamia team.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Sydney girl

            Mamamia team, why was james Button’s piece removed?

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Anonymous

              Yep, I’d like to know too Sydney girl, how did it break the dinner party rules?

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
        • Robin Barker

          In my haste I didn’t pick up that the James Button article was cut and pasted (doh).
          I can understand that there are copyright issues, which is probably why it was pulled but thankyou Anonymous for putting it up.
          The excellent article is available to read in today’s Herald – hardcopy or online.
          I urge anyone interested in this fascinating saga (we must keep some perspective here; if we were in Syria half of us would be dead, if we were in China half of us would be in jail – an exaggeration but you get the drift) to read it.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • Phoenix

        Too late, though, for whatever reasons. I, too, thought it was an excellent article and – like many others, I suspect – I went straight to the article online and uploaded it to my Facebook page. It’s in all the major newspapers today and has probably gone viral by now…..

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Claire

      I would also like to know why his post was removed.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Sydgrl

        If MM had to remove it for legal purposes why didn’t they just leave the link on???? Surely that could not have caused any problem?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Frazun

      I read the Button article in the SMH this morning. Not sure how it could be considered rude or abusive. It simply gave a different perspective. It made for an interesting read!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  42. Shelly

    Looks to me like people power is alive and well after all if the currently reported opinion polls are any gauge. KRudds popularity with ‘the people’ seems to be outstripping Julia’s by far more than a nose.

    I’m thinking that if the caucus still want to have Julia as their leader on Monday, they sure aren’t taking any notice of what the people of this country are saying. (but what else is new)

    There’s no doubt in my mind that ‘the people’ are sick to death of this labour government. So, seems to me, the choice they need to make is…which leader shows more potential in giving the PARTY a victory in the next election.

    Julia surely won’t – Kev seems to be looking to have more than a snowballs chance in hell and then, come election time, we’ll see which party actually gets over the line.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • ML

      Not even the Media Army can protect them from themselves. They’re gone and good riddance.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Sydney girl

      You might think that the polls will help swing caucus votes Kevin Rudd’s way, but you would be wrong.

      You see, there are worst things than losing an election. There are worst things than being in opposition.

      And the thing that would be worse than losing government? Allowing a man who is most likely a sociopath to be Prime Minister. It would be contrary to the national interest.

      Consider the following from today’s West Australian:

      John Mendoza, who resigned as Rudd’s mental health adviser, says the former PM is “not fit for office” and he will “leave the country” if Rudd returns to The Lodge. “There was constantly work being done on ridiculous timetables,” he says. “There’s a litany of discarded policy and wasted effort during the Rudd years. The public was never told the truth.”

      Mendoza told ABC radio yesterday he quit from the Mental Health Council because Mr Rudd’s leadership was dysfunctional, erratic and chaotic.

      Kevin Rudd’s one-time senior adviser on mental health says the former prime minister was removed from the top job for his “own wellbeing”.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        “You see, there are worst things than losing an election. There are worst things than being in opposition.

        And the thing that would be worse than losing government? Allowing a man who is most likely a sociopath to be Prime Minister. It would be contrary to the national interest.”

        I’m afraid I disagree with your quoted point there Sydney Girl. There won’t be anything much worse to the labour party than losing an election. (Apart from perhaps the realisation that choosing Julia over Kevin actually LOST the election for them)

        Calling Kevin a sociopath is a little harsh don’t you think? After all, if, his own party think he’s sociopathic, then it wouldn’t say much for their sense of judgement to send out such sociopath to represent us as Foreign Minister rather than have him represent the country as Prime Minister. No sense of common reasoning at all in that type of strategy. They’d all need therapy for being so dopey and thinking THAT would serve the country’s best interest.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Sydney girl

          It’s not just me who holds grave fears for Kevin Rudd’s mental health. Dr John Mendoza, an adjunct professor in mental health and a former Rudd adviser, has said publicly that in his medical opinion, Rudd is a sociopath. He said it again on Adelaide radio yesterday.

          http://www.sunshinecoastdaily.com.au/story/2012/02/24/rudd-unfit-to-be-pm-ex-advisor-john-mendoza/

          As to your next question, well – it was a mistake to allow him to continue on as Foreign Minister. But many people in caucus believed that Rudd deserved a second chance, and would hopefully, in a calmer and familiar environment, be able to function more effectively.

          This was wrong. But it is now being rectified. Yes, there are worse things than opposition. Kevin Rudd being Prime Minister again is worse. It is contrary to the national interest.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Kylie2

            I just did an INSEAD leadership program and our professor stated that the proportion of Psychopaths in a population of CEOs is more than double the proportion in the general population.

            There are a lot of senior leaders in corporate life who should be very grateful that the people who work under them cannot vote them out!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • West

              I agree with Sydney Girl. I voted for Kevin because he seemed a good man and anyway have always been a labour voter. However as the months went on and I watched him on television I began to wonder, uncomfortably, if I’d helped vote in someone with borderline narcissistic personality disorder – literally – to lead the country. Now as i watch this whole thing unfold on the screen – Kevin giving his press conferences – I feel like I am watching someone in the ascending stage of mania, gradually losing touch with reality. While at first I felt angry with him for putting himself ahead of the country’s stability, now I just feel this is just one of those sad situations where mental health is the issue.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
        • Louisec

          From all the reports of Rudds behaviour – anger tantrums; refusing to speak to senior people for months on end; banging his head repeatedly against a brick wall; and all the rest you can look it up yourself I’m sure the label of sociopath is quite apt.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  43. Mel

    Mr Burnz further down you have replied to a comment with the following:

    Sounds like a nice story, a few weeks off work. Under liberal you wouldn’t get a few weeks off you wouldn’t have a job to go back to and would have no legal rights regardless of how long you had worked there and why you were fired. But hey ignorance is bliss yea. But if you want to put down the union guy’s driving their holden’s whilst batting for your pay rise, whilst your liberal friends are driving BMW’s and Merc’s whilst trying remove any workplace rights feel free. What was the name of the factory your husband worked in again?

    IGNORANCE IS BLISS? Many years ago it was the worker who voted Labor. My parents and theirs and theirs were Labor voters and hard workers and so was I.

    Blissfully ignorant.

    Then things began to change. I could feel it but couldn’t work out what was going on. One day I heard Liberal voters being called ‘rednecks.’ I was confused because when I was growing up it was the Labor people who were driving the clunkers. It wasn’t ‘cool’ back then to be a Labor voter.

    You see, by stealth, the institutionalised academics and intelligentsia, the government funded ‘arts’ clique and the cultural elite, the chardonnay socialists and moral righteous have taken the ‘workers party’ as their own.

    They have no interest what-so-ever in the ‘worker’ and wouldn’t know how to get to the western suburbs if their life depended on it. The workers are now nothing more than sheep for the Labor Elites, the votes they need so they can keep their lifestyle and their noses in the trough.

    Liberal voters are no longer the silvertails, they are the middle income, small business, most of the military and anyone who has common sense or has seen through this Labor charade and refuses to be used by them.

    Lets think about Craig Thompson, shall we – yes Fair Work is much more to Labor’s liking than Work Choices.

    The only ones crying about Work Choices were the ACTORS paid to ACT in the ALP election campaign! One of whom I know for a fact was born with a silver spoon in her mouth and wouldn’t know a day’s work if it bit her on the bum.

    They nothing else to use against Howard and Costello so they whipped up the ‘worker,’ their sheep, and made them believe that it was heinous and they’d all be burned at the stake, their first borns ripped from them and put in slave camps.

    It was emblematic of the way Labor uses the ‘worker’ and I find it repugnant beyond words.

    You have been brainwashed, Mr Burnz. I do not know ONE employer in private business who doesn’t pay well over award for valued employees. If they want to sack thieves and those who turn up drunk then they should be able to!

    Stop being a ‘useful idiot’ and letting them deceive you.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Tracey

      So well said, thank you

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Louise

      Can I nominate this comment as the best response to JR’s article?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Jackie

      Well said, but can I add from the Liberal side, there are many of us, moderates, who are horrified at the swing to the right our party has taken. The federal party has become so reactionary & the “stop the boats” stand & the head in the sand views on climate change have made it very hard to stand behind a party that was once progressive & fought for the rights of the individual.
      On both sides the major parties have alienated long time supporters. I don’t know who I will vote for next election…
      Malcolm, where are you?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  44. me again

    funny

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  45. Luce

    I am completely baffled to why anyone would have an issue with Jess Rudd writing this piece. It’s not a news story – it’s an op ed. Why can’t she support her father if she has a forum to do so? There have been politicians and commentators of all persuasions who have been published on this site.

    I think it’s overly simplistic to use Kevin Rudd’s personality as reasoning for Julia Gillard’s original challenge. Kevin Rudd was a powerful, intense person with an extremely high pressure job. There were those who got along with him and those who didn’t. I have friends in the public service who absolutely despise him. I know someone who worked for him directly for over a year who admires him greatly.

    I don’t think anyone with any insider knowledge of Canberra would deny that Kevin Rudd could be difficult, quick to anger and extremely demanding to work for. I also doubt that the same couldn’t be said of most politicians. Whether Kevin Rudd is a difficult man is completely irrelevant to the debate over who is best to lead this country.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  46. Sydney girl

    I have been thinking about this blog post quite a bit, and I think the reason I am most concerned about Jessica Rudd’s unprecedented foray into politics is the precedent it sets.

    Are all politician’s children now fair game? It has been a long-standing convention in Australian politics that the children of politicians, even as adults, are off-limits. Jessica Rudd has changed this.

    But, as Ms Rudd has made herself a public figure through her book deal (which, by her own admission, she only got because of her father) and ill-considered blog posts like this one, she has laid herself bare to a vitriolic political campaign which she is unequipped to handle, because she clealry lcks the requisite political judgement.

    And just as an FYI, Jessica, talking about ‘flying in’ from Beijing (for what reason? Why was your presence here so desperately needed?) makes you sound the the spoilt, pampered millionaire’s daughter that you are.

    And it’s behaviour like this from you, and your family, that reminds your father’s caucus colleagues of why exactly they rose, almost as one, to dump your dear old dad.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      I have to agree, the ‘when I fly in’ thing made me roll my eyes.

      I’ve always found them to be very false with their ‘hey we’re just like everyone else’ attitude.

      Malcolm Turnbull cops a lot regarding his wealth and lack of concept of an ‘average Australian (think about the whole ‘I used to live in a rented house’ comment) but somehow Rudd flies under the radar with this even though he’s a mutli millionaire.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anon

        Not a Lib voter but I have massive respect for Turnbull. He’s made some mistakes but I remember seeing him on an episode of the Chaser – the Libs were all going to some political event, I seem to remember, and instead of the chauffeur driven car, Turnbull caught the train in a suit listening to an ipod. I can’t help thinking that Turnbull as leader of the Op would be in the best interests of Australia – he’d force the others to raise their game which Abbott doesn’t.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Anonymous

          I completely agree, I’m not a Lib voter but I too have a lot of respect for Turnbull – he’s smart, driven, focused and forward thinking. The only reason he isn’t the Opposition Leader is due to him actually wanting action on climate change (shock horror).

          He’s always great on Q&A too and popular with people (in general), it’s very short sighted of the libs to have him in a relatively minor role when he could probably bring them victory in the next election.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Tracey

            I have so much respect for Turnbull, he has already made a success of himself, he has been in the real world, not just a career politician who’s out of touch with the majority of Australian’s. Unfortunately I think that is the reason he is not the opposition leader, he spoke directly and actually answered questions, not just spin that was fed to him by an army of advisors, and the media fed on it and took him out of context on several occasions twisting his words around. I like this, I for one am sick of the spin and just want straight talk and action.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
  47. MG

    What is it with people? All those comments that Jess is self righteous etc, have a long hard look at yourself – you are doing the exact same thing. The only reason Mamamia would lose readership is because of the overwhelming whinging and bitching and self indulgent posts that a great many of you have written or responded to- not the fact that they published an opinion piece. I am not an ALP supporter, I live in Kevin Rudd’s electorate- I did not vote for him, does it matter no. What I got from Jess’ post is that we are lucky we live in a country where we have a choice and can make an influence on what matters. Yeah Yeah you can get into the nitty gritty of how parliament works and tell her she has no idea.. once again not the point and she has a better insight than any of us of what goes on behind closed doors. If you’re going to whinge and bitch about something- have the balls to do something about it. Good on you Jess, be free, say what you want.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  48. A dose of reality

    Perhaps Rudd supporters, and even Jess herself, should read the below article (on The Age today) to get a sense of what it was like working for such a narcissistic and dysfunctional man:

    Kevin Rudd was ultimately responsible for his own downfall, writes his former speechwriter.

    I WORKED for the Rudd government for just over a year in 2009 and early 2010, including seven months as one of Kevin Rudd’s speechwriters. I only met him four times in that period so I don’t know him well. I know Julia Gillard even less well. But I know many people who have worked closely with both of them, and I base the comments that follow on their experience, plus my own.

    Rudd did some good things as prime minister. He led the government’s brave and successful response to the global financial crisis. He increased foreign aid and fought for better cancer treatment. His apology to indigenous people changed Australia and will be remembered for years to come. Though he was humiliated, and in a sense defeated, by his backdown on the emissions trading scheme, he worked extremely hard to get a good result at Copenhagen.

    He could be funny and charming, when he chose to be. Though he was often wooden in his speech-making, he could be great with the ”punters”, as he liked to call them. I saw him orchestrate with folksy brilliance a convention of 3000 Lions Club members into a state-by-state Mexican wave. Personally, I was grateful when he agreed to speak at the launch of a writing prize in the name of my father, John Button, a minister in the Hawke and Keating governments.

    But Rudd’s prime ministership failed, and the failure was, above all, his own. The story of his government, and of its end, has still not been fully told. The consequence has been deep damage to Australians’ faith in politics and in government.

    The truth is, Rudd was impossible to work with. He regularly treated his staff, public servants and backbenchers with rudeness and contempt. He was vindictive, intervening to deny people appointments or preselections, often based on grudges that went back years.

    He made crushing demands on his staff, and when they laboured through the night to meet those demands, they received no thanks, and often the work was not used. People who dared stand up to him were put in “the freezer” and not consulted or spoken to for months. The prodigious loyalty of his staff to him was mostly not repaid. He put them down behind their backs. He seemed to feel that everyone was always letting him down. In meetings, as I saw, he could emanate a kind of icy rage that was as mysterious as it was disturbing.

    He governed by – seemed almost to thrive on – crisis. Important papers went unsigned, staff and public servants would be pulled onto flights, in at least one case halfway around the world, on the off chance that he needed to consult them. Vital decisions were held up while he struggled to make up his mind, frequently demanding more pieces of information that merely delayed the final result. The fate of the government seemed to hinge on the psychology of one man.

    [comment edited for copyright reasons - to read the full article you can google 'James Button The Age']

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • anon

      “Even in Labor’s weakest, most mistake-ridden area – asylum seeker policy – the government has been quietly and successfully moving large numbers of people out of detention and into the community.”

      Oh boy! free rent in a fully furnished house! oh way to go!!!!!
      Welcome to the land of milk and honey, except for it’s LEGAL citizens.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  49. Southern Man

    The Heiner scandal which hasnt been sorted is a national disgrace Bryce and Rudd are in it up to their necks.An election is what is needed followed by a royal commision into the heiner matter.Kevin is guilty of Pink bats BER Open borders Election now so the most incompitent govt since Whittlem.Which started in 2007 can be booted out Kevin or Julia as PM? ELECTION NOW

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Mel

      The Heiner Affair is a disgrace and a stain on our country. And yet again the media choose to ignore it in the interests of preserving the Labor Party.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  50. Miss green

    The best outcome of this situation would be for K Rudd to win on Monday, for the Libs to finally realise the T Abb is just a national embarrassment and has no chance against K Rudd, and have a Turnbull v Rudd election. Win win.

    The alternative is Gillard v Abbott. We may as well all move to New Zealand.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Mel

      THOUSANDS of New Zealanders are moving here every week because of the prohibitive cost of living caused by their version of the CARBON TAX.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Trog

        Mel, you got a source to back that statement up? How is a self-proclaimed Bankstown girl qualified to speak for all NZ immigrants?

        You’re pushing more barrows than Bunnings.

        The Carbon tax is coming in. What’s your beef with it? There’s nothing more free enterprise than a ‘user pays’ system is there?

        Or do you shed the core values of your ideology when self-interest seduces?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • anon

        I second a call for a source. Something that not only has net migration figures for kiwis, but also breaks it down by motivation.

        That would be a darn comprehensive study, given all that’s going on over the Tasman.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Marnie

      I don’t find Abbott an embarrassment at all.

      I find Gillard, the faceless mob and Kevin the most embarrassing people in the country.

      But of course, all this is Abbott’s fault. Of course it is.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • MLS

        Totally agree, Marnie. You can bet by tonight their spin doctors will have worked out a way to blame Abbott for the unmitigated disaster that is the ALP.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions