Two parents in Pakistan-administered Kashmir have been arrested after throwing acid on their daughter Anusha after she looked at a boy.
When you hear the story, your whole body recoils. The hair on your forearms raises ever-so-slightly, goosebumps appear even though its 26 degrees outside and you can’t help but close your eyes and think: I am so very lucky to live where I do.
Mohammad Zafar and his wife Zaheen have spoken to the BBC from their cells in an attempt to defend their actions.
Anusha’s father said that he and his wife had warned their daughter about looking at boys in the past.
“There was a boy who came by on a motorcycle. She (Anusha) turned to look at him twice. I told her before not to do that, it’s wrong. People talk about us because our older daughter was the same way,” Mohammad said.
He admitted to physically dragging his daughter into the family home and beating her.
His wife confessed that Anusha had begged them for forgiveness.
“She said, ‘I didn’t do it on purpose, I won’t do it again.’ By then I had thrown the acid. It was her destiny to die this way,” she told the BBC.
“I deeply regret my action. I am repenting as I should not have done this. She was very innocent.”
Anusha would have suffered through truly excruciating pain, not only at the time of the attack but through the next two day period as she lay dying in her parents’ home. They did not take her to a hospital until it was too late.
A doctor told the Murdoch press that the teenager arrived at emergency in a “very critical condition” with burns to almost 70 per cent of her body. Anusha died on Wednesday.
So-called honour attacks are not uncommon in deeply conservative Pakistan. Women’s rights activists claim that more than 900 women were murdered during 2011, after being accused of bringing shame on their families.
The National Geographic News reports:
“In countries where Islam is practiced, they’re called honor killings, but dowry deaths and so-called crimes of passion have a similar dynamic in that the women are killed by male family members and the crimes are perceived as excusable or understandable,” said Widney Brown, advocacy director for Human Rights Watch.
The practice, she said, “goes across cultures and across religions.”
Complicity by other women in the family and the community strengthens the concept of women as property and the perception that violence against family members is a family and not a judicial issue.
“Females in the family—mothers, mothers-in-law, sisters, and cousins—frequently support the attacks. It’s a community mentality,” said Zaynab Nawaz, a program assistant for women’s human rights at Amnesty International.
Honour killings are a cultural practice and not a religious one; there is no mention of it in the Islamic holy book, the Koran.
Killings in the name of family honour exist in cultured that remain based on a devaluation of women within society, in that there is an implicit assumption that the woman’s value is completely erased by her bringing the family into ill repute.
The painful and slow nature of Anusha’s death is sadly not unusual. Honour killings are often carried out via methods that are designed to cause maximum pain to the victim before their eventual death. They include being buried alive and stoned.
900 women were killed this way last year alone.
For none of those women, should such a cruel and tortuous end have been their ‘destiny’.
You can make a donation to help organisations that work to stop this barbaric practice here or here.








Comments
39 Comments so far
Im grateful for the post.Thanks Again. Fantastic.
loading...
Unreal article.Much thanks again. Quite Great.
loading...
Quaint article.Much thanks again. Really Great.
loading...
Wow, great post.Thanks Again. Discretion be familiar with on…
loading...
Hate to tell the naive people in Australia,honor killings and violence to women is happening in Australia.
Sadly quite a few migrants from many Muslim countries has no interest in any integration within western society. Culturally they remain tied to family groups and religious teachings that reject western culture.
i work in an area that has many Muslim migrants. I see their daughters forced to leave school, university or TAFE after getting married. I see 18yo Australian born girls pregnant with their 3rd child after being forced to ‘go home and get married.’ I’ve seen both boys & girls beaten for daring to question parental authority.
it’s happening in Australia now.
loading...
Are you in a ‘mandatory reporting’ occupation?
loading...
I wonder how long “honour” crimes would continue if the punishment was the same as the crime? You throw acid on your daughter and leave her to die – your punishment is someone throws acid on you and leaves you to die. You set your sister on fire – you get set on fire. You bury your wife alive, you get buried alive. I’ve never supported capital punishment but in a situation like this anything less just seems unjust. Animals like this need to be made examples of to the rest who think this is OK.
loading...
No Mrs Zafar – you “won’t do it again”. Your daughter is dead.
But you did “do it on purpose”. Whether out of your own righteous indignation or fear for your well being if you did not support your husband.
I’m really not sure how the world can stop this practice – it is rampant and radically under-reported. It is also culturally entrenched, and there is the major problem.
While other women support these practices – either out of a genuine belief it is morally right, or because they are so terrified they are prepared to sacrifice their own daughters to maintain their standing and safety within the family circle – how is it possible to save these girls and women before they are victims?
This particular situation is so horrific, so widespread and so entrenched, that along with the physical sickness I feel reading this piece, it is also accompanied by a sense of absolute helplessness unfortunately.
loading...
I look at boys all the time, myself. Sometimes I don’t do it on purpose (can’t help it), but mostly I do look on purpose.
And, I will do it again and again, and I will admire tham for Anusha because she no longer can. And when I kiss handsome boys, I will think of her too.
RIP Anusha.
loading...
Awful. Awful. We have so far to go in our fight for feminism.
loading...
This is horrific and there is no excuse for this kind of terrible abuse of girls, children, anyone. It is a problem in places where extremism has taken hold but it is not the attitude of all people who live in these countries. As with any culture there are those with extreme views and those with moderate views. I do not believe it is helpful to assume that *all* people who live in these countries would commit such an abhorrent act in a similar situation.
loading...
Some people have questioned whether allowing immigrants from Pakistan into our country is a good thing. I say yes it is good. I never judge someone on where they are from. I am so glad I don’t. I have an amazing friend from Pakistan. He is the kindest (never says a bad word about anyone), most gentle and loyal man I know. He is a well educated (as most who can afford education are!) and devout Muslim man. He has been there for me every time I needed him. With absolute kindness. Pakistan is a very poor country and with that can come a lot of uneducated people. Which is why these things happen. Education is highly regarded in Islam so most families will sacrifice a lot to send their children to school overseas. Obviously there are many problems over there a curruption of power being a huge one. There are lots of problems due to lack of education and cultural problems so these organizations that help are very important. I just really hope that we all remember to take people for who they are and not judge them based of what horrible things have happened in their country of origin.
loading...
Thank you Mamamia for keeping ‘honour killings’ on the mainstream radar. This common cultural practice is abhorrent, and has been ignored for too long. It is extremely difficult to stamp out due to its social context, but clearly education & empowerment of women are crucial factors, given their own role in the oppression.
Another wonderful charity that works to protect the rights of women and girls in the West from oppression justified by religion and culture is the AHA Foundation.
It has a newsletter you can subscribe to. Well worth a look.
http://theahafoundation.org
loading...
I have an idea, instead of stopping anyone associated with this culture from coming to Tis, our so lucky country, why don’t we allow them here, welcome them and show them a new way of life where this is not just unnacceptable but appalling? Why don’t we support all those organisations that are trying to stop this? Hw many people who are shocked and appalled and holding thier children close sre going to put the money where their mouth is and actually donate?
I know this comes across really harsh, but honestly, we have it so good here, why can’t we share it a little?
loading...
There are many Pakistani immigrants in Australia.
loading...
The comments about not wanting ‘more of them’ in Australia disturb me. The kind of people who want to migrate to this awesome country are people who want to get away from the turbulence and horror described in this article, not bring it to other countries. It just sickens me that people can say that they are disgusted by actions such as what happened to this poor little girl yet they say that they don’t want children such as her to come and be protected and have a better life in Australia. How can you read a post like this and only have one thought about it; damn those refugees, let’s protect Australia? It really says a lot about the morality of some people.
loading...
Honour, honour ! What honour could there possibly be in such cruelty? I tell my boys that you have rights – the right to keep your hands to yourselves and the right to be tollerant and understanding. You also have the right, to walk away from people that make you feel ugly and sad. You can never force people to believe what you believe, if your values are worth anything, the people will follow you because they respect and love you. You are never the winner if you have to rule by fear. So, all you weak men of these cultures, you are not strong and powerful you are weak and disgusting. No God worth anything would want you to “follow them” ! Your God will be ashamed of you, you horrible parents, do not deserve to have something as precious as a defenceless child !
loading...
MM, please keep us updated as to what will happen to her arrested parents. I’d like to know what happens next to her ‘mother’ and ‘father’, if anything.
loading...
Why was my comment so heavily edited? I truly don’t understand. Nothing I said was offensive, maybe a bit graphic, but that’s the reality of this abhorrent act.
loading...
Very good question
I really do like the new comment guidelines and pre-moderation, but I haven’t commented much recently (ever since a sentence containing the word “cr*p” was edited out of a comment I made)!
loading...
I am a gentle woman, but right now I’m looking at that so-called ‘mother’ (so she gave birth; doesn’t make her a ‘mother’!) and thinking, “God, someone give me some time alone in a locked room with that bitch.’
loading...
Do these people, and I mean all those that believe in honour killings etc, actually love their kids, show their kids affection? I just can’t wrap my head around wanting to hurt my kids at all. There’s nothing my kids could do that would make me want to torture or kill them, nothing. How could human beings, let alone mothers and fathers, go on living life in the same house, while another human being lies there dying slowly in absolute agony in their presence? The only people I know of are psychopaths. The lack of empathy for their daughters is mind blowing.
loading...
In my experience, people in developing countries who are POOR, are not happy chirpy people. They don’t wake up in the morning happy to jump out of bed/off the floor that they sleep on, put on the kettle for a cuppa, kiss their husbands as they drive off to their job in the office. Their lives are hard. Their work is hard, and it’s almost always physical. There’s no other option, there’s no fun in it- they just do it. Every day. With this in mind, there is *not* much warmth or cheerfulness or even smiling. People live more closely amongst their neighbours than we do, these are the places where it actually does ‘take a village to raise a child.’ I’m not excusing these honour killings at all. I just want the MM community who get to live in a nice house, in a safe and wealthy country to understand that these people’s lives look NOTHING like ours.
loading...
I really believe in situations like this, the acid throwers deserve to have acid thrown on them, so they can experience the sheer agony of it and then live with the scars and pain till the day they die. An eye for an eye. Maybe then the self righteous acid throwers will tell others not to physically maime / kill their daughters because what they have to endure isn’t worth their so called family honour .
loading...
Just read this story to my 13 year old daughter… where we both are grateful that we were born and live in Australia.
My thoughts are with Anusha – the ordeal and pain she went through was beyond horrific.
loading...
And we are told that immigration is a good thing!! Yep bring more of them over here and one day we too can kill our daughters for looking at a boy!! When will people learn to protect what we have?
loading...
The people who come to our country come to get away from things like this, not to continue with these horrible things!
Of all the immigrants I have ever met not one would want to change our country from how it is. Sure they still practice their religion but none of this has anything to do with that anyway.
I honestly don’t know how some people can be so misguided and narrow minded
loading...
Can’t agree with you there!! Last week I had a conversation about arranged marriages!! There’s is no doubt we are not the same country we were 20 years ago and it’s not for the better!!
loading...
Oh, please.
Putting a stigma on traditions of other cultures based on your own perception of what it is reeks of prejudice and a cluelessness of how your own society operates.
Arranged marriage, blind dates, being set up by friends, internet dating – honey, they’re not dissimilar.
Both happiness and abuse exist in all cultures – including whichever one it is that you are trying to “protect” from those scary immigrants!
loading...
Would you prefer we go back to pre-immigration? Because unless you’re Aboriginal, you’ll have to leave. Oh sorry – do you mean only new immigrants, that you don’t like?
loading...
I doubt her mother sat up at night, held her to her breast, introduced her to solids etc… it would have been very basic. Sadly the mother believes she is of no value so she would be very indifferent in assisting to murder her daughter. This horrific cruelty must be stamped out …absolutely no cultural excuses.
loading...
Sorry but I don’t want people who have these type of beliefs in our country. We have enough sickos. What if my daughter meets one of these men who’s religion and belief is more important that human life .
loading...
Its not religion, its culture and they wont have that culture, hence belief if they live in australia.
I know many people who have immigrated from a variety of middle eastern countries at various ages and NONE of then would believe this is right. None of them value a belief over human life. the issues in these countries is that they are not taught that women are equal, but that changes once they cross that boarder
loading...
“THEY WON’T HAVE THAT CULTURE, HENCE, BELIEF IF THEY LIVE IN AUSTRALIA” seriously? Let me tell you something. I had a very interesting conversation with an Indian lady and she assured me that her culture would not change now they were in Australia. Arranged marriages and having to live with the family all their life was never going to change as they see Australian as disrespectful and would never let their children marry one!! We have little enclaves here where the Afgani women don’t need to learn English as they have NO intention of changing there ways!! It is SO simple they are here to reap the benefits and nothing else. They aren’t here with some good will wanting to be just like us!! Remember if you are NOT a muslim you are an infidel……We need to stand up and save our country before it is ruined for our children!!
loading...
I absolutely agree!! Think about how different we are already. A couple of decades ago we weren’t having to intrigrate cultural celebrations of different religions to our kinder children. If you dilute the population with enough people who have NO idea about how we are and how we live, we will no longer have the same identity. It’s so logical. Now the Green’s are finally finding enough courage to fight immigration claiming that it is beginning to have a negative environmental impact on our country. We just can’t keep flooding Australia with muslims and pakistani’s and think its not going to change who we are. We have already seen in the news female circumcision in Sydney and honour beatings….what more evidence do we actually need. Stop immigration and protect our beautiful country before it is sent down the same path as many muslim states!!!
loading...
Our “numbness & speechlessness” is not helping these women.
Just because something is cultural or traditional doesn’t make it “okay”.
Murder, child-abuse & torture will never be okay no matter how much some people want them dressed up as religious tradition.
Millions of criminals have gotten away with it and have used their faiths originally based on peace, kindness & goodness to distort natural, normal behaviour and make it a justification to be evil.
We have to stop shying away from “calling it like it is”………this political correctness is turning sour and preventing innocent people from escaping ugly brutality & bloody murder.
Particularly women – the very second women show their real power, they make themselves a target for horror.
As can be seen by even the last 6 weeks of retaliation by whole communities, female voters and our own Prime Minister – women are finding their voices and we can only hope that those males who smugly thought they still had an unequal hold on power are finally getting the message …
If the men of our western societies genuinely want to make amends they could start by loudly defending the human rights of women everywhere.
loading...
I truly can’t get my head around these so-called “honour killings”.
I’m not here to bash cultures and religions I know very little about, but as I type this I’m looking at my 5 yr old daughter playing in her room, and wondering what it would take to make me throw acid in her face.
The answer is I’d pour it on myself before I’d ever do that, and I’d kill anyone who ever tried.
The thought of what has happened to these women in their lives that they get to a point where they can over-ride that basic maternal instinct to protect their child is enough to send shudders down my spine. To imagine living in a culture or country that sees you as completely without value; little more than a domestic animal that is kept around only so long as you behave accordingly to an alarmingly strict set of rules (to which of course the man are not subject to) makes me want to throw myself on the ground and thank God I was born in Australia.
loading...
When I first read this I just thought, how could you? How could you birth a child, sit up with her at night at your breast, slowly introduce her to solids watching closely for choking, help her take her first tentative steps, teach her to share, to play nicely, to help in the house, send her off to school, talk to her everyday and then – kill her?
loading...
It can only have you conclude that perhaps her attitude towards & relationship with her daughter was not like you describe. Perhaps she was merely seen as a possession that didn’t behave the way in which she was meant to? That is the only thing I can conclude to be able to comprehend this act…
loading...