by NATALIE KAPLAN
This time last week, I was told that my ten week old pregnancy was no longer. I was prepared for the news, as after miscarrying in May this year I had been very, very anxious counting down the weeks this time round. When I started spotting on Tuesday, I had an inkling of the way it was going to go. The scan on Thursday confirmed the worst.
I went to work on Friday feeling ok. In fact, better than ok. I felt like a weight had been taken off my shoulders. While I grieved for the baby that wouldn’t be joining us in February, I felt like it was easier to let go of than the one that would have arrived at Christmas. My anxiety had lifted and I was excited, in fact almost elated, about the next six months and what they would entail. The night prior, after debriefing with my husband, we’d decided to leave it alone for the time being. We already have two divine girls that we are so grateful for. Gorgeous, spirited little ladies that drive us mad and make us laugh in equal parts. And, I had just been promoted into my dream position at work. Four weeks prior I became a segment producer at The Circle.
So it is now that I am in mourning. Sad, angry and uncertain about what lies ahead. I know there have been things written in the media this week about The Circle and the team I work with. And every word is true. Truer than true. I have never worked in a more inclusive, creative and inspiring environment. The last twelve months here have been a joy. “You’ll get another job,” family and friend say in support. But like a toddler, I am defiant. I don’t want another job, I want this one. And I have only been here a year – there are people who have worked on the show since its inception, and people who came years, many years before.
We sat around in tears yesterday as our “resident psychologist” Sabina Read gave us an impromptu counselling session after her last segment on our show. She talked to us about grief. About loss. And she validated what we had all been feeling. That we have lost something very special. That this was unlike any other workplace she had experienced. And while that the ‘powers that be’ can dismantle everything we have worked very hard to build, they cannot dismantle the connections we have made with each other. That we can take these connections with us wherever we end up. That the love and support we show each other cannot be diminished.
We are a talented bunch. We are experienced, creative, funny, smart and generous. I know, that although it may take time, we will all end up in a great place. But this does not make the grieving process any easier at this point.
In our final days we are pitching in and leaning on each other. We are putting together a ripper of a final show and we will go out with a bang. But I think what makes this so hard to swallow, is that we have all lost something unique. This loss, like a miscarriage, is permanent. Because, even though I may have a subsequent pregnancy, the baby won’t be the same. And like grieving the loss of an unborn child once you know the personalities these little beings become, I am grieving the loss of a workplace that I know cannot be replicated. And that just makes me sad.
Natalie Kaplan is a television producer, publicist and parent. She has worked for The Circle, Offspring and Neighbours. She is presently procrastinating.








Comments
94 Comments so far
You me like a nice person and no one likes to lose their job, but the fact is that the show didn’t attract a big enough audience! Maybe Mamamia can write a post about television ratings to enlighten all the outraged viewers!
loading...
Haven’t been this upset since Molly died on ACP.
loading...
Molly never died— it wasn’t real!!!!!!!!
loading...
Replace that stupid Breakfast show with the circle! I can’t bare that they have been axed when it is such a wonderful program
genuinely upset!!!
loading...
Keep the show- sack Yumi for saying you can catch Hepatitus from a computer- how fucking ignorant- that was about a year ago!!!!!!
loading...
Anyway sad about Sonic Youth calling it a day.
loading...
Read a herald sun article stating that Gorgi urged viewers to start a petition to have the show returned in a once a week “kick a***” format. Perhaps a petition could be started on Mamamia to get the ball rolling for a pilot in a new format with Gorgi, Chrissy and Colin Lane once a week in a different time slot (mid-day its got to be better than Dr Phil). I really enjoyed the show and would love to see it returned.
loading...
as a male (sometimes) viewer… kind of miffed as to why the show got cancelled…
only really began watching it here and there after the ben roberts saga, and must say the format and style really grew on me…
wish them all well for the future, and hope they go on to bigger and better things ;o)
loading...
Thank you so much Nat for sharing what is obviously a very personal time in your life. I have loved working with you over the years in your various guises
I hope we get to work together again down the track.
Lots of love
Troy xxx
loading...
What an incredibly sad & heartbreaking week… And what a beautifully honest piece. Nat, you are without a doubt one of the strongest & inspiring individuals I’ve ever met. I count myself so lucky to have you as my friend. Sending you all my love, to a very beautiful & talented woman, mum, wife, sister, daughter, producer & special friend xxxxx
loading...
I came across the circle by accident while I was breast feeding my daughter. It happened to be the day that Gorgi announced she was pregnant. I have watched the show since. Even if I couldn’t physically sit down to watch it which was the case most of the time it was always on in the background while I work from home. I think the show was fabulous and feel greatly for the presenters and the people behind the scenes who put the show together. I also feel for the viewers who tuned in each day, it was like having 4 friends in the house sharing life experiences and laughs.
While it may not have rated like rival shows it still had a loyal following but channel 10 couldn’t see beyond the revenue line. What ever made them axe The Circle over breakfast is completely beyond me. I wish the presenters and producers all the best and will miss their cheeriness on my TV each day. Hopefully the network will come to its senses and bring back the Circle or a similar program, who wants to watch/listen to American programs?
loading...
Nat, what a beautiful piece. I totally understand how you feel. While it is years since I moved on from ATV, I felt safe in the knowledge that you were all still there making great television for the women who have made the brave decision to stay at home and make their home their work. The show changed, the hosts changed, and many of the behind the scenes crew changed, but the core values were still there, held aloft by Pam and Mim, and it is tragic that the show has been sacrificed to bolster that mess up there in Sydney. My love to you and, and thankyou again for such a deeply personal post. MWAH! ad/.
loading...
Beautiful Nat. All my love to you.
loading...
A beautiful and honest article written by a beautiful and honest woman. Such a sad week for you Nat. Life can be so unfair, but you’ve handled it all with such strength. I will miss your smiling face every day, but don’t worry you won’t be able to get rid of me! From, another sad Circle Producer.
loading...
I watched the circle from the beginning. It was great when I was recuperating from surgery and all I was capable of was watching tv and sleeping. At this stage I can’t think of a replacement for it.
loading...
Very well written piece from my beautiful friend Nat. You are an amazing woman xxxx
loading...
Sad to see the show go! I have been watching since I was at home with my newborn baby boy. They feel like part of my family!
loading...
I love what Marieke Hardy has to say about The Circle’s axing:
http://mariekehardy.com/blog/post/circle-of-life/
loading...
You are right, that is a fantastic post. Thanks for linking.
loading...
Wow. Now I am doubly sad.
loading...
I love this! And great to have that insight. Have never watched Breakfast, and never plan to, you can tell Paul Henry is a complete twat just from the ads.
loading...
I was very sad to hear that the show had been cancelled. When this show began I was suffering from severe post natal depression, with the mornings being the worst time of the day. There were many weeks and months when I found very little to look forward to in my day and I craved the normalcy of my life before I was ill. The Circle provided me with sometimes the only bright point in my day. Even if it was just a few minutes, I can honestly say I felt less alone and less isolated because of these lovely ladies. I kept a gratitude journal during this time as an exercise suggested by my psychologist and there are many days when “The Circle” appears on the list. I know this might sound a bit strange but looking back at those very dark and sometimes terrifying days, I remember looking forward to 10am. I don’t think you achieve that sort of relationship with your viewer unless you have some pretty special people in front of and behind the scenes, so I can understand the reaction from the public and why this isn’t just another show to get the ax. It feels like a little family is being broken apart. Best of luck to all involved. You were great. You made me laugh and cry and unbeknownst to you, held my hand through some of the darkest days of my life and I’m going to miss you xx
loading...
Well said Tanya. I think many people will agree with you that having those girls appear on our screens felt like catching up with a bunch of your friends every day.
I hope you are feeling better now. x
loading...
I am really sad this show is ending, perhaps disproportionately so. On maternity leave, life can be lonely. Watching this show felt like catching up with mates. I sincerely wish you, Natalie, all the best, and to everyone on the Circle xx
loading...
Natalie, this post is beautiful. So sorry for your two losses. Sucks. But we’re sending you hugs Xxxxx
loading...
1. Everyone needs to just lighten up!
2. It might not have been brilliant, but it was a hell of a lot better than Ch 7 & Ch 9′s morning shows that are on at the same time!!
loading...
Hi Natalie, Firstly l’m sorry for your personal loss. That’s so sad. But l’m also sorry that you could align the loss of a baby with the loss of a TV Show. l fail to see how they compare and it saddens me that you draw comparisons to them. There is always another TV show. Good luck Natalie.
loading...
I don’t think she is comparing them. She is giving us the context for how she found out the news.
loading...
You do understand that it’s not about the axing of a TV show, but the loss of her job?? It just happens that she works on a TV show?? I feel that you’ve missed the point….
loading...
No I think the point is the 2 should not even be compared ever .Shame , I wonder if losing your job even impacts you at all on a financial level like it would devastate other families .
loading...
I am really sad to hear that The Circle has been dropped. I had the absolute pleasure of being interviewed by the team when I released my book in April 2010. Everybody was so delightful to work with, the producers, the floor crew as well as Chrissie, Yumi and Georgie.
Unfortunately due to work commitments I was unable to watch the show on a regular basis, but often caught up with segments on the website. I just find it extraordinary that The Circle will go off the air, but 10 Breakfast, Being Lara Bingle and The Shire remain!
Natalie, thank you for your sensitive post, you certainly have had your fair share of challenging times – but I wish you, and all the team the very best. I know what it is like to work with a great group of people, finding joy in everyday, just loving to go to work each day… and then through no fault of their own have that team change. It will be a big loss for you all, but I wish you all well.
loading...
I work in television and I know how difficult it is to replicate an amazing experience on a show with incredible people – it comes only once in a blue moon. I think the choice to axe The Circle is a bizarre choice by Channel 10, but a network that puts a show like The Shire on in primetime clearly has misguided ambitions.
I feel sad for Natalie that she lost this special opportunity! I have been searching for years to find a job that makes me as happy as one or two have previously. You just have to keep hoping, because that’s all you can do!
loading...
I feel sad too Natalie. Sad for you (I am very sorry for your loss – I’ve been there and know it ain’t no fun) and all the wonderful people who’ve worked so hard to put such an AMAZING show to air each day. It was a show that always managed to put a smile on my face just as easily as it brought tears to my eyes. The Circle was THE perfect balance of REAL people, real conversations and so much less bullshit and hype than we see on many other shows.
I feel like a spoilt child saying this, but I’m “keeping it real” in honour of you and everyone else who worked on The Circle…”I want my Circle back!”
While I know that talent like yours/theirs won’t go to waste – you will all surely be snapped up by other shows or networks – I can’t help but feel cheated that I won’t get my fix of a show that was just perfect as it was and should never have been taken away from me!
I look forward to the great things you will ALL do post The Circle – and sticking it right up those TV execs who clearly don’t know a good show when it’s staring them in the face. Now…how do we get you all back working on a Prime-time version of the show? Hmm…
loading...
Thanks for sharing Natalie. Sending you lots of hugs. Xxx
loading...
PS: I also feel for Natalie as I lost a bub in January at 10 weeks and lost another in May at 6 weeks (would have been due at Christmas too) You are doing a great job keeping it all together with this added bonus of your ‘dream job’ being taken away. But as the old saying goes, things happen for a reason. So I am sure, that you being a very strong, talented woman, you will come out the other side of this and find something very exciting waiting for you! Good luck! xx
loading...
I turned on the Circle one day when the kids were home sick and have to say that I found it mind numbingly tedious and full of infomercials. Not sorry that it’s gone and can’t understand what the hype is about.
loading...
Totally inappropriate comment for this particular post.
loading...
Why comment on something that you have no interest in then? I don’t understand why someone comes on a forum for a particular article they have no strong feelings about?? Especially if it’s basically someone speaking of losing a job they loved. Why stick the boot in with “not sorry it’s gone”. It’s like approaching someone who’s favourite footy team has just lost and telling them “your team is terrible, get over it”. Everyone is entitled to their opinion obviously, but with so much negativity out there, why not just use your energy to comment on something you have a positive opinion on? It’s not like you said anything ground breaking, just that you didn’t like the show. Could you not have just turned to the person next to you to say that instead of posting on an article with a poignant tone? Obviously you’re not alone with 23 thumbs up, but I just don’t get it.
loading...
I didn’t say I wasn’t sorry that people have lost their jobs, I just have an opinion that the show wasn’t great and I’m not sorry that its been cancelled. Just because my opinion isn’t “positive” as you say, doesn’t mean that I’m not entitled to express it. It didn’t appear intelligent to me, and pretty crass.
loading...
With those previous names (of shows) on your resume, you must be bloody good. I send you love and support and a kick up the bum to the people of australia to speak up and demand more from our media. Like what em said about being left with crappy american gossip shows, is that what we want???
You go girl!
loading...
I love The Circle, especially when I record it (not able to watch it live during the day) then watch it at night skipping right through the informercials & ads – cuts the show down to about one hour of actual segments.
Not sure how ratings work and if this contributes to ratings or not.
I have felt quite sad this week hearing about the people behind the scenes like Natalie (I’m sorry that you didn’t get to see your baby grow more Natalie). I think you forget that there are a few hosts but so many other people who lost their jobs. Even worse when we are losing talented Australian crews to make way for re-runs and US shows which feature many guests we won’t even know.
I watch lots of Australian product on DVD because the main commercial stations just won’t show it (Spirited, Tangle, Love My Way etc). I’m glad Offspring & Puberty Blues are on Ten otherwise they would have lost me as a viewer.
All the best to Natalie and everyone hoping to continue working in the tv industry.
loading...
I too had a miscarriage in May, my due date was 25 December. One of the things that has kept me sane the last few months is my job. It challenges me and keeps my mind on something else for most of the day.
I’m thinking of you Natalie, thanks for sharing your story.
loading...
I’m so sad for you Natalie, you’ve lost two precious things in the last couple of weeks. It’s such a pity that The Circle is finishing, but I guess if it wasn’t rating, it was always on the cards. I’m convinced if they got rid of those ridiculous infomercials, it would have performed much better. I enjoyed watching if I was at home at the right time, but those ridiculous, repetitive infomercials were an insult to our intelligence. The hosts and other staff deserve much better.
Good luck to everyone for the future, I hope Channel Ten realises that maybe with some tweaking, it could be a smash. Definitely with Chrissie back on the couch!
loading...
Have to agree – I loved watching the girls discuss issues on the couch, but as SOON as the infomercials came on, I’d flick over. An insult to the intelligence indeed. It’d be a much more watchable show without them – perhaps a prime time version would work! Looking forward to Chrissie on Can of Worms, though! LOVE her!!
loading...
I’m sorry that the show was axed, but truth is that it lost something when Denise and Chrissie left. Whoever put that group together knew what they were doing because they were a perfect blend. Without Chrissie’s intelligent wit and fabulous laugh and Ding Dong’s general craziness, Yumi and Gorgi just didn’t seem right to front a show like that. Plus I think the revolving door of guest hosts was a bad idea… especially Colin Lane – I really can’t stand him I’m afraid.
Infomercials are a necessary evil, but if you’re at home at that time of day they are a perfect chance to check on a sleeping baby, empty the dishwasher, answer some emails… any myriad of chores. But the content around that needs to be good enough to keep you coming back to the telly… The Circle lost that for me.
loading...
I too just lost my baby at 10 weeks. I’m feeling your pain.
loading...
Me too, today was my due date
loading...
My heart is bursting with pride and sadness for Natalie, my daughter!
loading...
How gorgeous!
loading...
I can only agree totally wih you, Ruth. And to Natalie congratulations on all of your achievements ,and our thoughts are with you at this time, however you are an amazing girl who will continue in an upward journey.
loading...
I don’t have an issue with language so Yumi and Georgie’s language weren’t offensive to me….’talk about kicking people when they’re down !
Sorry to break it to the “tut tut” brigade but this is how real people speak most of the time – including women.
In fact, it’s almost a feminist/political issue when people try to “control and sanitise” women’s language in the workplace, socially and yes, even on radio and television.
“The Circle” hasn’t been “given the flick” because of candid language – it’s going (for now anyway) because of financial considerations.
As I’ve said in other posts about this show (and others highlighting women’s opinions & issues), there’s always a drive to “shut down” women’s voices…….’sad when it comes from people who should be aware enough not to side with those impotent misogynists.
Step up and be a hero Channel 10.
loading...
My thoughts exactly!
I feel there is so much happening in the media lately, particularly aimed at women, that these sorts of decisions are becoming more and more like feminist issues. I’m not really a feminist, but I feel these things are happening more often and we need to stand up and be counted.
loading...
Natalie, I will really miss the show. I loved watching it on my days off work and uni with my Mum! We laughed and cried along with all the hosts. It was so refreshing to see intelligent, warm and kind women (and men!) together on my tv.
loading...
I’m so sorry for your losses Natalie.
The Circle was a small part of the Australian television landscape that celebrated women in TV. hopefully all of the talented men and women who worked on it will continue to work on projects with the same heart.
The Circle didn’t rate well, but it had some very good parts – which hopefully once tweaked and improved will lead to a great TV success down the road.
loading...
Natalie, thank you for sharing your story, a very hard time beautifully expressed.
Partly because of this post, and partly because it isn’t going to be on anymore, I decided to tune in to the Circle…. Just in time to hear Yumi say she “hadnt has a ro%t in two years” then to Georgie swearing!!! Come on guys this might be the last show but you are still being broadcast….Totally not appropriate in this timeslot. I’m starting to understand why this is getting the flick…
loading...
Oh come on, lighten up! It’s a fabulous show that will be terribly missed by many.
loading...
It may be missed by many, but that is only because it was watched by few.
loading...
I have absolutely no issues with swearing, in the right context. Would I swear when speaking with my friends with their kids in earshot? No I wouldnt, and this happens to be the Circles target demographic. It’s about knowing your audience. Not appropriate
loading...
I’m pretty sure daytime TV is considered more adult than early evening prime time – how else would shows like Jerry Springer have been aired during the day?
School-age kids are at school, and any littlies should be too little to understand, or guided (away from the screen if you decide) by their parents.
PG.
Swearing is becoming more and more normal on TV – whether we like it or not.
loading...
Oh FFS lighten up!
loading...
why aren’t your kids at school? If you want bland- there’s Channel 7 and 9 for you. Actually, I think the show has been unusually timid since Chrissy left and the Dudroot-gate storm- this last episode, looks like they’re letting their hair down a little. Pity they didn’t do it more- would have offered a much more interesting alternative (and James Matheson was hilarious, with his on-the-edge appearance yesterday).
loading...
Hello Natalie. It is said that there are only two things in life that are certain….death and taxes. Make that three ! It doesn’t matter how successful or unsuccessful a TV show is, it will ALWAYS come to an end.
I feel great sorrow that you have miscarried. Nothing and nobody will ever replace that life. You have lost your job on a TV show. Like a bus, there will be another TV show coming along any minute and it will have your name showing at the end credits. You will work with more creative and dedicated individuals. Unfortunately, regardless of how successful or unsuccessful it may be, that show will be axed one day….and you will move on again.
That is the circle of life in television.
loading...
I can’t believe quality shows like The Circle get cancelled while reality crap like Being Lara Bingle and The Shire carry on. Disgusting!
loading...
It’s called ratings Rufus.
And considering BLB is slipping I’ve no doubt it will get another look in after the series finale next week.
loading...
Sigh. DIfferent timeslots people. And ratings – people weren’t watching it!
loading...
Its not the ratings. Its the advertisers.
15 year old girls watch ads and spend a lot of money (Hence crap TV).
Stay at home anybodies, not so much.
loading...
I tend to disagree Polly, stay at home anybodies tend to be the ‘grocery buyer’ – the most coveted of all demographics!
loading...
My heart goes out to you right now… I recently lost my baby at 10 weeks, been made redundant earlier this year, one of my parents (overseas) is terminally ill and that parent’s mother (my grandmother) is now on her way out – sad how all these things can happen at once… hope all your friends and loved ones are getting around you to support you at this difficult time – blessings and peace
loading...
I always liked the circle especially when Chrissy was one of the hosts. Her leaving left a gap in the show. The final straw for me was the dreadful comments made by Yumi & George Negus. I stopped watching that day.
I am really sorry for Natalie and the other behind the scenes people who are losing their dream jobs. Fingers crossed it won’t be long before a new, wonderful opportunity comes your way.
loading...
Bec, Don’t believe everything you read in a tabloid hate campaign. Yumi never made distasteful comments. Negus (arguably) did. She just asked Negus to confirm it- “Are you, George Negus, intimating he is a dud root?”. The tabloids (and men in general, particularly in the ADF) find Yumi makes a more enjoyable target than Negus. I think blokes subconsciously find it easier to attack a woman because they know she can’t come round and punch their faces in, whereas a man conceivably can). The worst Stynes said was that Roberts-Smith looked dim/brainless- Channel7 did show him standing in his jocks and muscles and tatoos staring vacantly into the middle distance. His own mother could make such a joke and it wouldn’t be mean or distasteful. He is, after all, a man brave enough to bare his chest at bullets, Channel 7 cameras and Men’s Health coversshoots. Male media commentators say infinitely more offensive things/”jokes”- insulting rape victims (Sandilands), inflaming race riots (Alan Jones) and saying Aussie Olympians should be drowned (Steve Price).
Sad that even her defenders, including Mia Freedman/John Birmingham et al, accepted the tabloid version of events and said “I don’t condone what she said, but the response was disproportionate, she made a mistake, move on.” She didn’t make a mistake. Her mistake was being an articulate, strong, attractive, Eurasian woman sharing a couch with a confusing George Negus. She gets tarred by Negus’ words and her punishment is nationwide vitriol and hate.
Conservative tabloids commentators/shockjocks (almost all men) know that Yumi ticks so many boxes that indicate to their flock that she is not “one of them”, even “unAustralian”- Asian, woman, opinionated, single-mother, inner-city, gay-friendly etc- that she makes an easy target. Luckily, there is also a sizable (if not the majority) demographic that appreciates that and I’m sure she’ll continue to find rewarding work.
loading...
Your opinion is wrong in SO many ways.
Do you really think that the show has been canned because Australia couldn’t handle an articulate, attractive, gay friendly Eurasian woman sitting on a couch ?
It’s a thing called “ratings”.
Keep searching for negatives to justify your opinion. It would seem that you will find plenty. Chip on the shoulder….I would say “yes” to that one.
loading...
bradley, if its ratings then why keep Breakfast, which costs more, yet has a third of the ratings in a market with three times as many viewers?
I think you just swallowed the tabloid demonisation of the Circle and believe its axing is justification/karma (for which you seem to derive some joy). Yet its ratings are actually up from the start of the year, (most recently it was 60,000 and rising) and dudroot-gate made barely a dent either way.
loading...
Because 10 is trying to make inroads against Today and Sunrise. That could take years, but if they can eventually build up their viewers it will be well worth it. A show like that can become a huge part of a station’s overall brand and image.
loading...
Fair enough. No doubt that if they were rating better, they’d still be there. But I do believe it could have been handled differently and without the unnecessary Yumi-blame that feeds the Herald Sun (their current article revelling in the idea of Yumi being out of work and flipping burgers when they have no idea about the terms of her contract and they ignore that she’s on the radio nationally every day). And management needs to take some responsibility for their lack of resourcing (no replacements of Swan and Drysdale, while Stynes and Coghlan are not natural fits- Coglan an ex-school teacher and Stynes who got expelled from high school) and promotion. And I believe the absence of a morning show (when most of the audience is female) for women by women is a feminist issue.
loading...
Sorry Anon but I saw the show, I heard what she said. Taking pot shots at a highly decorated special forces soldier is not articulate. Her and Negus didn’t give a second thought to him or his family when they sat there making those derogatory comments. Imagine if a man bad said a woman needed ivf because she was a dud root? Articulate, strong, attractive? She was none of those things that day.
loading...
Hi Bec,
I can see where you’re coming from, but despite what Derryn Hinch would have you believe- the Circle is a chat show in which different people give their views, with each responsible for their own words. The show did not “attack” Roberts-Smith. In fact, most of the episode was Gorgi saying how handsome he was (“the perfect embodiment of masculinity”). You can watch the footage- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OnWCGLwSDqg
The footage also shows Stynes never said Roberts-Smith was a dud root (and noone mentioned IVF). She just asked Negus if that was what he meant by his confusing comment. (about which he has since explained, and the footage justifies it, he was speaking in general terms about masculinity and buff blokes, not about Roberts-Smith (who he knows personally) or IVF). To tar a commerical rival and make a villain out of Stynes, the tabloid media took Negus’ words out of context and applied them almost entirely to the Circle in general and Stynes in particular. Check out the Herald-Sun site now- all they want to do is humiliate and mock Yumi.
Yumi’s (as opposed to Negus’) only “pot-shot” was to say he looked brainless (and he hardly looked like a scholar in the pose CH7 had taken of him), and that was in the context of Gorgi saying he was “the perfect embodiment of masculinity”. It’s hardly the stuff deserving of the vitriol she’s received.
Please recheck the footage and tell me if I’m wrong. Ask yourself whether the tabloids would have an interest in distorting the truth and creating a villain out of Yumi (why is it all on her and none on Negus?)? Ask yourself whether you’re willing to reconsider your position in the light of the facts?
loading...
the day they dissed an Australian war hero, was the last day I watched too.
loading...
I’m watching it right now, and feeling quite sad, I’m going to miss this show. There just isn’t enough smart funny australian women on TV. They look like they are having a good time today though. Lots of laughs, good to see Crissy back.
loading...
Natalie, thank you for opening your heart and eloquently sharing your story of loss. You contributed to high quality television, that entertained, inspired and informed (financed by ah bra and vacuum cleaner infomercials) and gave a voice and opportunities to many strong, professional Australian women. I am sure that achievement will stand you in good stead in your next challenge.
But looks like Channel 10 sees which way the wind is blowing for them- no space for Australian women but “Andrew Bolt has a short programme on Channel 10 on Sundays. It is noted that his programme is very popular in country areas, yet unfortunately many country areas are unable to receive Channel 10. As stated previously by Mrs Rinehart, Mrs Rinehart hopes that should Mr Bolt’s time permit, that he would consider longer programmes on Channel 10.”
loading...
Love or hate Andrew Bolt, his show rates extremely well.
If it didn’t rate it would have gone to the television graveyard where all of the shows that didn’t rate well end up sooner than those shows that were mega hits.
loading...
Andrew Bolt’s show is funded by Gina Rinehart.
He doesn’t need ratings or advertisers.
loading...
Please stop making this a feminist issue. The Circle bombed in the ratings, that is why we won’t be seeing it anymore! If The Circle performed well, it would remain. Simple as that! If there was no place for Australian women it would have never been made in the first place. I am an Australian woman, on Mat leave and refused to watch The Circle for a number of reasons (infomercials, Yumi and George’s comments – mainly their non apologies) I have a feeling other people may feel the same. We didn’t tune in, so the network is dropping it!
As for Andrew Bolt he is a total fool, but his ratings are steady. So, he keeps his spot for now.
loading...
Thumbs up given for your request to stop making this a feminist issue.
I disagree with the statement that Andrew Bolt is a total fool as much as I would disagree with the same comment dissing a left wing commentator. No one is always 100% totally wrong no matter how much you may personally disagree with their stance on an issue.
loading...
I thought Yumi and George did apologise? I agree the comments were dreadful, but I am sure both Yumi & George did apologise?
loading...
But it is a feminist issue. It wasn’t neccessarily axed because it featured women, but because the ratings WERE low, and the most obvious reason when compared to simialr shows seems to be that it featured an all-women ensemble. The public rejected the show BECAUSE it was different. Of course the comments made by the women weren’t always PC, but ratings weren’t great even before then.
loading...
The Circle could have been a great show but the advertorials for steam mops, make up etc all the time turned me, and many other people I know off. I can guarantee that this is why its ratings were so poor. The hosts themselves and most of the content was actually lively and interesting, but who has the patience to sit through those crappy advertorials? Not me! Why have them? Don’t normal ad breaks pay for the show? If it had been cut down to 1 hour without advertorials, I bet it would have been more successful. I’m sorry you lost a job you love, by the way!
loading...
Couldn’t agree more!
loading...
Every show at this time has a plethera of bad advertising. Quit with this lame arguement it’s been made already. These people lost their jobs today and a show that gave voice to women in a largely male TV landscape was scrapped.
Sorry to ‘The Circle’ cast and crew it must be awful for you all right now.
loading...
Oh Lizzie, I couldn’t agree more. I really like the show and as a SAHM, I part if the target audience but I will not waste my time watchIng infomercials so while the presenters and the content of the actual show are interesting and worth the time, I don’t watch because I won’t abide advertising. I’m sorry that you lost your job too. Not so sure it should be compared to a miscarriage though, actually thought that was in bad taste, everyone is entitled to their own feelings and if this somehow helps you through a tough time, I get that, I just think writing about the circle ending could have been done without the miscarriage references.
loading...
I think it was related more to the sense of grieving perhaps… I’ve had a similar experience of EVERYTHING happening at once… as someone who recently had a miscarriage (I’ve had 2 in total in the last 2 years), recently started new employment, etc etc I connect with how she is feeling….
loading...
I don’t think she was comparing them at all; rather saying she was grieving for both in a different way, & I guess the double whammy they happened at the same time…
loading...
yes
loading...
The level of advertising on Australian commercial television is JUST ridiculous…(compared to say – the UK) puts me off watching most programmes. I don’t even watch Downton Abbey on 7 cos of the number of ads on there- it’s not just the morning shows. Basically I just watch SBS and ABC channels…
loading...
7 and 9 have informercials too. It’s how they get paid for a period where there aren’t that many viewers out there. They’re typically sold in advance and finance the whole year’s running cost. The rest of the commercials are cream on the top.
loading...