by JESSICA BARLOW
Boys, sex, relationships, makeup and clothes. Is this really all we’re supposed to care about? Personally, I’m kind of insulted that these are the issues that magazines aimed at young women focus on.
I’m also pretty frustrated at the increasingly popular practice of digitally altering the appearance and shape of people featured in magazines. Don’t the editors realise the negative repercussions of this?
Photoshopping images of models is a common practice in the world of magazines and in many instances I have no problem with it. Where I do have a problem with it is when the true sizes and physical appearance of girls featured are changed without telling the reader and even more so when this happens in magazines targeted at teenage girls. The reason is that teenage girls aspire to be like the girls they see on the pages. Digitally creating these unreal girls is setting readers up for failure.
How do I know this?
It was repeated exposure to ideals like this that shaped my high school years. Some days I was so upset that I didn’t look as beautiful as the women in magazines like Cosmo and Cleo that I didn’t want to leave the house. I cancelled plans for the same reason.
Any girl who didn’t look like the beauties in the magazines was excluded at lunchtime and my body confidence took a massive dive. The power of magazines upon young girls is simply unbelievable. Their reach extends far beyond the pages and straight into the minds and behaviours of readers.
Who am I? Like most of the stereotype driven content in magazines like Cosmopolitan and Cleo, it’s not important, but the media initiative I’ve just launched is.
It’s called the Brainwash Project and it involves two things: the creation of a prototype magazine that reflects exactly what women want in their magazines, and the collection of signatures to stop Cosmopolitan and Cleo Magazines from using digitally altering the appearance of people in their photoshoots and to put warning labels wherever alterations occur.
Once I have 50,000 signatures and a copy of this prototype in my hands, I’ll be presenting them to the editors of the magazines.

The Brainwash Project
I’ve chosen to start the project by targeting Cosmo and Cleo because they were the most popular magazines when I was at high school and they don’t seem to have as good a body image policy as magazines like Dolly and Girlfriend, which both won positive body image awards from the Victorian government this year.
Ideally I would like all women’s magazines to promise to stop photoshopping or digitally altering the women and men they put on the pages. If they can’t agree to the simple idea of presenting us with real bodies and faces to relate to then at the very least, I would like a disclaimer printed on every digitally modified image to point out to girls exactly what is real, and what isn’t.
I’m asking you as women, girls, ladies, ladettes, and anyone who is interested in what goes into women’s magazines to share ideas and opinions about what you want in a magazine. I’ll use this information to collect submissions and create your ultimate magazine.
It will be a magazine that steers clear of body shaming content, doesn’t present unrealistic or computer generated ideals of beauty, reflects all skin colours and sexual preferences with no bias, includes fresh, stimulating content on a variety of topics, and most importantly, that reflects exactly what you have asked for.
This entire project is self-funded – which means that I, a twenty-year-old student at RMIT, am paying for everything. I’ve started a Pozible Campaign to help raise enough money to get lots of copies of Brainwash Magazine printed and distributed to your hot little hands.
The Pozible website has been put together to help fund grassroots projects like this to raise money. The way it works is that everyone who pledges donations will only have to pay if the project reaches its target. This is the reason my target is so low, and why a lot of projects offer rewards and incentives to donate. Anyone who donates to the Brainwash Project gets access to an exclusive online space where you can get involved with the big decisions involved with putting the magazine together, among other just-as-exciting things.
I can’t put into words how important this project is. Even if magazines don’t directly tell readers to get thinner, they imply it by featuring only stick-thin models in their pages and by editing real women thin wherever possible. Girls learn that they should be a size six, they should know how to apply makeup and they should be attracted to and attractive for, boys.
When I was five I didn’t care about my weight. When I was seven I didn’t care about makeup. When I was ten I was completely happy and confident in who I was. When I started reading women’s magazines like Cosmopolitan and Cleo, all that changed.
The Brainwash Project: it’s for you, your sisters, your friends, your daughters growing up, and your daughters-to-be. Consider the possibilities.
Check out our photoshop fails gallery to see how ridiculous Photoshopping can be:

Kardashian Kollection. Hmmm...
Jessica Barlow is a 20 year old student currently studying Professional Writing and Editing at RMIT in Melbourne. She hopes to leave the world a better place than she found it.








Comments
99 Comments so far
It’s Adam *Levine – typo in the photo gallery
loading...
“Photoshopping images of models is a common practice in the world of magazines and in many instances I have no problem with it.”
Aren’t you either for or against it?
loading...
Why would you want the signatures of the people who read this site? Are they buying Cosmo and Cleo??? I doubt it.
loading...
I read Mamamia as well as Cleo an Cosmo…
loading...
Love the gallery, hilarious!! And made me feel better to see the before and after shots.
loading...
I don;t see why you should limit yourself to “womans magazines”
I see these magazines as containing “things MEN aren’t interested in but girls are” If you want to widen your reading content, widen your choice of magazines!
loading...
Interesting Mia would tweet – this girl is alittle bit my hero. I grew up reading Cosmo when you were editor, it launched your career no? Why hate on what you were so much apart of!
loading...
Hi Jess, thanks for your response. I do admire your passion and I know that you think it can create change but if you research circulation figures and the number of magazines purchased that 10 0000 signatures equates to a nominal percentage that would hardly make a dent in companies like ACP’s bottom line ( and hence not make the CEO or CFO’s raise an eyebrow)I liken it to when we see articles on how for example animals were mistreated during live exports, their is a tsunami of outrage (as there should be, this sickened me) but people are still going to buy meat. Just an analogy to think about, it takes a lot to topple big business and I am just saying that it is a worthy cause but one that is probably futile. I am not trying to be negative, does anyone else understand my view?
loading...
I don’t understand pic number 37… it says ‘extra limb’ but where? Am I missing the blindingly obvious?
loading...
I was wondering the same because I’m sure she is just hugging her leg??
loading...
left arm crossing over and out of frame, right arm holding her breast, extra limb comin gup under her left hand…….
loading...
General announcement to those saying comments such as ‘first world problem’, ‘get over it’, ‘it’s so obvious it’s been photoshopped’, etc.
We are perpetuating an image in the media. The image is very thin, skin as smooth as porcelain, silky hair, perfect breasts, absolute symmetry, not a rogue pore, hair, blemish in sight, all imperfections must be eradicated. It is ‘perfection’, nothing is ‘incorrect’.
By perpetuating this image we are perpetuating an IDEAL. We are saying ‘look at this image. This is what is to be desired. This is ideal. Now STRIVE FOR IT’ (even though graphic designers and advertisers with degrees and fancy computers have spent an hour photoshopping this images)
WHO CAN FULFILL THIS IDEAL? I couldn’t on 1000 calories a day, 2 hours of cardio a day and thousands of dollars spent on cosmetics, solarium sessions, spray tans, waxing, etc. you name it, I’ve done it, including some cosmetic surgery.
I want a disclaimer on these photographs. It’s the least that can be done. However. It’s not enough for me to be told, to know that these images have been photoshopped. Because we are in the process of re-training the eye. We are telling our sons, be with a girl like this, we’re telling our girls, be like this, you’re being told, you’re not good enough, you’re not society’s idea of beauty.
I want to be represented in a magazine, gorgeous with my imperfections. Happy, healthy, intelligent, fun, creative, introspective, curious, into fashion, into music, into science, into cooking, into discussing health, into health, into learning about important things. I want you to have this too, because you deserve it. I will not tolerate being condescended to anymore.
I’m sick of being told that my body type, even in it’s healthy weight range, even with eating beautiful organic food, even with running, playing netball and going to yoga and dancing classes, is. not. ideal. or. perfect.
I’m SICK of our eyes being trained to see one type of beauty, we ALL deserve better!!!!!
loading...
Boys, sex, relationships, makeup and clothes. Is this really all we’re supposed to care about?
Umm..yes? Noting that pretty much every article on this site can be lumped in to one or more of those categories!
loading...
I sincerely hope everyone of every age-group gets to sign this petition.
In those quiet moments when we’re left alone with these magazines those images and ideas are creeping in – changing who we are…..even just a little bit.
If a grown woman is confronted constantly with images of skinny bints the usual reaction is to laugh because life and reality have already woken us up.
Young women however are often lacking in the confidence to question and complain. They’re less likely to demand that their favourite magazine presents the truth.
When I was growing up my Mum would always buy “Women’s Weekly” and leave it lying around – I rarely needed her to explain anything. I did the same in our house and it worked with our kids too.
They graduated very early to much more challenging reading matter which reflected their personal interests – but I felt that good ‘ol “WW” could be trusted to deliver some truth at least .
Cosmo & Cleo never really “spoke” to me and they never illustrated anything with images of people who looked like me…. I love beautiful photography and sometimes those models look amazing – but it’s ART.
Cat-Walk fashion is ART. Clothing design is ART. Fashion make-up is ART.
Reality Photography is ART too if you can capture images with an artistic eye.
Our schools have a lot of catching up to do when it comes to helping kids to tell the difference between ART and REALITY.
Throw in some classes in Philosophy and Critical Thinking and there might be less confusion about how these heightened and stylised images in advertising (and it’s ability to manipulate our world views and self-esteem) turn into multi-million dollar companies run by cynical parasites living off the fear of others.
loading...
best thing i’ve seen..ever! As an upcoming journalist who has been studying eating disorders, fitness and magazines..this is brilliant! This is amazing. Finally someone who is standing up and saying NO, this isn’t alright. It definately influences girls and the way they think they should look and it definately needs to change!
loading...
Thanks Kristy – I’m really glad to have your support! You might like to consider submitting to Brainwash Magazine… Head to http://www.facebook.com/brainwashproject for a link to the submission guidelines. I’d love to have you write something. Cheers, Jessica
loading...
When I read articles like this, it makes me glad – it shows an awareness and a considered approach to the media we consume, or allow our children to consume.
The greatest barrier to these magazines/ images/ messages is how you are raised. Parents have a huge impact on children/ teenagers self esteem and self worth.
Growing up my parents never emphasised how I looked or what I wore, praise was given for what I could do, what I achieved or how I treated others. I think this in alot of ways gave me some immunity to the negative messages the media / magazines peddled in my teens.
I recalled being genuinely confused by why someone would be affected by a picture of someone they had never met, and was only famous for looking pretty!
So campaigns like this are great because they raise the collective consciousness and awareness – and hopefully mean that parents will be more aware of how poisonous this crap is to our children.
loading...
Jessica, wouldn’t it make more sense to get the signatures of 50,000 teenagers and young women in their early twenties rather than those of mostly grown women? Afterall, it’s the teenagers and early 20′s women who are mostly buying Cleo and Cosmo. I think that the magazine bosses would be most swayed by these signatures, rather than those of older women who have moved on to other magazines. Why are you marketing your (good) idea on here? You are preaching to the converted and to a much older demographic. As a high school teacher of many years, I think you’d struggle to get support from the majority of teenage girls – in my experience most are quite ignorant of broader issues and even the ones who aren’t look to those magazines as an escape – not to be ‘taught’ more and lectured. I hope you prove me wrong! Good luck.
loading...
I think there actually are quite a few younger women who read Mamamia regularly, myself included (I’m 21). Many of the older women here would have teenage daughters as well.
I can only speak for myself, but as a teenager I was well aware of the issue of how women are portrayed in magazines and I definitely would have signed this petition back then if it was around. I think there are plenty of young girls who care about this, and other important issues.
loading...
Hi Gracie. I am glad to hear it. My point was that having teenage daughters does not equate to buying the magazines in question. I believe that the ones buying it need to be the ones signing the petition for it to have the desired effect on magazine editors and publishing bosses. Just an opinion.
My other comment, which you’ve misconstrued, was that the demographic OVERALL of Mamamia is older than teenage-early 20s. The odd younger reader such as yourself, and younger that I’ve seen in the comments, would not really affect the average. I could be wrong – I’m not privy to Mamamia’s readership stats – but I’d be very worried if young childless girls were devoting their time to reading parenting/baby posts, which appears to make up the bulk of posts here (hence the name-MAMAmia).
loading...
What an odd comment to make. why would it be worrying for young childless women to read this site? I am 23 and childless and I love this site. It has a good mix of current affairs and relationships articles as well as baby stuff. And as someone who wants kids in the next few years I love the baby articles, they open my eyes to issues I never even thought of before eg I always just assumed everyone vaccinated their kids, didn’t realise it was such a controversial issue! Don’t worry about me at all…! And also I believe at least half of the writers on staff are childless?
loading...
Again…
I meant if ALL the readership was made up of young childless women, not just a small proportion. And I’d be willing to bet it is a small proportion of teenage-early twenties readers and that the majority of readers are from an older demographic. Is it just me, or is it impossible to get a fairly basic point across? I do not believe anything I’ve written above was invalid, incorrect, offensive or anything other than a politely expressed opinion, one that was voiced directly to the author of the article and yet every little thing is misconstrued and argued with. It really is enough to drive you barmy!
For the record, I realise that there are younger, childless readers of this site. I do not believe they make up the majority. I do not worry that they are reading baby posts. I would worry if the site’s readership was made ENTIRELY up of young childless women reading baby posts. And. finally, I don’t dispute there is a mix of articles here, but I do believe the majority are to do with parenting.
loading...
I get what you’re saying, I really do, it exasperates me reading some of the comment battles that go on on here. I was just confused why you would be worried and to be fair your comment didn’t make it clear that you would be worried if the whole readership was young childless girls, it more implied you worried about any young childless girls were reading it. Hence my confusion. Didn’t mean to make you feel attacked.
loading...
FFS. I am so over this topic on Mamamia.
I grew up as an overweight teen reading (aka living my life by) Dolly, then Cleo/Cosmo. I never blamed anyone but myself for my low self esteem. When I realised that energy output – energy intake = weight gain/loss and I started living my life by that principle I became happier, and thinner.
NEVER EVER was I made feel insecure by photos I saw in a magazine. I was made insecure by real people. The girls in magazines were (and still are) just girls in magazines. They are not real. They are not trying to be real. THEY ARE GIRLS IN MAGAZINES.
Get over it.
loading...
That’s your experience, you can’t speak for everyone else. A lot of young girls and women really are affected by these images.
loading...
Bulimic for ten years (aged 10-19) trying to look like the girls I saw in Dolly and Cosmo over here. Just because it doesn’t affect you, doesn’t mean it isn’t eating away at other people’s self esteem.
Basically, I didn’t see my body shape or size represented in magazines. I was in a healthy weight range, but it wasn’t a ‘model skinny ‘perfect’ curves in right places’ body. When you don’t see yourself represented in mainstream media, hollywood, TV, magazines, advertisements you might start to think like I did… “hmm… maybe I don’t fit in…. I want to be like the girls in the magazines who everyone else says is so great and amazing…. even though I’m in a healthy weight range (and at one stage I was bulimic in grade 5) maybe I’m still not good enough….”
This is serious. This is real. There is no effing way that I want my children, especially daughters, growing up and developing into adults in this media image obsessed climate.
loading...
I can see immediately in your comment that you are still very much fixated on being thin, as opposed to being healthy and strong, and that you made a direct link between being thin and happy. From where did you get the idea that becoming thin was the key to happiness? I also wonder if the people making you feel insecure about being overweight took their ideals from the girls in magazines, even if you didn’t?
loading...
If you look at the history of women’s magazines (from the very first issues in the early 20th century), they published material that was based on femininity. Our ideals have been socially embedded in our cultural learning processes. This won’t change majorly, even with time; it’s all we know. I do believe however, a warning for when an image has been photoshopped will allow the subconscious of young girls to understand, these unsanitary images are not real life.
loading...
My response has been eaten, abducted, rejected? Any thoughts there Mama Mia? Help!
loading...
I do agree to a point, but what do teenagers care about? what are they interested in?
I never read a lot of these magazines as a teen, but I think if you want to keep girls interested you need to temper the superficial with something deeper.
Really concentrate on how you approach these ‘light’ topics – don’t write stories about relationships as if it’s a given everyone will have one, or sex is the natural progression when you do.
Don’t use terms like ‘must have this season’ when describing clothes and make up – if you can’t have, that’s it, you’re out.
Don’t confuse girls with an article on confidence and five pages from fashion labels with size 4 or photo-shopped ‘average teens’.
I personally would want to slather social issues in the mix of the lighter stuff:
- make up is great, as long as they aren’t doing these types of tests >(insert article on ethical consumerism)
> here’s some cool clothes this season > now here are some in your actual budget > better yet here’s a fricken pattern why don’t you try making it yourself > article on fair trade
Article on hosting a great party > article on the severe impact of alcohol (not fluff, real stuff) > real life fall out story
I also found the fluff pieces on career options a bit patronising, more diversity of options, more concrete information.
NO CELEBRITY DIETS. EVER.
I don’t know, just back up the fluff with the consequences of blindly following fluff.
Am I over reaching in my wishes for what girls look at and think about? This has made me feel so old….
loading...
@10pm, thanks for your comment! I love what you have written. I’d like to have that kind of content in Brainwash Magazine. I think you’re spot on.
loading...
I WOULD SO BUY THAT MAGAZINE!
loading...
This is why I was encouraged to start a blog a couple of months ago and take REAL photos!!! I now follow other bloggers that are real people (perhaps Instagram-ed but hey! that’s kinda cool photography) and never buy “these” magazines! Seriously with all of us here couldn’t we start up “KEEPING IT REAL” magazine and feature “US” instead of “THEM”?
Dani xx
loading...
I’m so on board with this… As someone else mentioned, even though we know in our logical, clever brains that the images are photoshopped, unfortunately as a 15 year old girl (or even now, as a 25 year old) the brain in gear when I think of my body and comparing it to the lithe, tanned ‘ideal’, isn’t that logical clever brain. It’s unfortunately a silly little brain geared towards negativity, directed at my own body. Luckily I had enough sense to stop buying Cleo and Cosmo when I hit around 15. I couldn’t not compare myself, so I just removed the offending material. Shame the damage was already done.
Amazing work Jess, if this campaign helps even one girl then it’s worth it, though I suspect it will help many, many more
loading...
@Jemily, Thanks for your comment and kind words! That’s exactly it, it doesn’t matter if you know they are photoshopped or not – they still affect you, particularly in your young-mid teen years.
loading...
I am a teenager, and although I know very well all the images in Dolly and Girlfriend have been photoshopped, I tend to overlook that and feel bad anyway. What annoys me is that the Dolly and Girlfriend model searches look for ‘great role models’ etc, but modelling will ALWAYS be about your looks and size and even though one girl may win, there are another thousand that didn’t.
loading...
Its not just the images that you need to target though. Its also the use of language. Language is far more powerful and pervasive than we give it credit for. Images are a red herring.
loading...
I actually like looking at amazing high fashion images, even if they have been photoshopped. It’s not as if we don’t know they’ve been altered.
First world problem.
loading...
Yes but teenagers may NOT know the difference.
loading...
With all due respect, Anon, I disagree. Dismissing it as a FWP plays lightly on the problems that stem from the issue… anorexia, bulimia, anxiety, and depression- just to name a few.
I love the high fashion pictures as well (and have spent far too much money on beautiful big hardback books dedicated to it!), but the high fashion is generally done a bit better, and occasionally DO use models who are larger than my left thigh. I think the problem stems more from the lower end of photography detailing the ‘every day’ girl that we’re meant to be.
loading...
What I want to know is: We are much more educated on Photoshop than we were a few years ago. Therefore we know when we open a magazine that these images are not real and they don’t represent real women. With that in mind, why do we still get affected by these false images? I mean we all know they’ve been Photoshopped.
loading...
Do ‘we’ all though? What about teenage girls? I’m glad we’re talking about this. Maybe some younger girls who don’t know might feel a bit better about themselves if they know.
loading...
Personally, I don’t think many MEN I know realise just how badly these images are photoshopped. I just showed some to my husband and he couldn’t really see how ‘unreal’ they were! If this is how a male pushing 40 thinks, can you imagine what young teenage boys think??!!! I feel sorry for them… And the teenage girls who will never meet their expectations
loading...
Hi Caris, thanks for commenting. You’ve touched on an important issue here. It doesn’t just affect girls but also boys. The magazines have a lot of power.
loading...
When I was 12, I started reading Girlfriend and Dolly and because of those magazines, I hate my body and I’m now 19. It wasn’t just those two. I started reading Cleo and Cosmo as I got older, which I don’t read anymore because my self-esteem and self-confidence is too low as it is. I have absolutely no social life because I’ve never looked anything like these magazines. And its so hard to get over body issues, obviously if I’ve had them for seven+ years. I hate even showering naked because of these stupid magazines
I hate the sex parts too. Not all of us have boyfriends, probably because of low self-esteem from these magazines.
loading...
I started reading Dolly and Girlfriend when I was about 12 or 13 as well and I definitely think they contributed to my messed up body image. These days they’re focused on healthy body image (or claim to be), but back when I read them they were so damaging. I remember Dolly had a monthly column where they asked a panel of teenage guys questions about what they liked and disliked about girls and the answers were absolutely crushing for me as a young girl.
loading...
Reality is that no matter how many petitions you sign, the magazines are still going to photoshop and present ‘idealistic’ images as a primary. They are first and foremost a business and these images are what sells and keeps the business viable. Sounds mercenary and I am sure we would also like to see ‘real’ images but this is not what is going to have publications flying off the newsstands. I think that most people just need to either accept it, do not buy the magazine, or purchase and accept the images and have the self esteem to not care! It is great for Jess to have this passion but I would probably channel that passion into a cause where she can actually make a tangible difference. If Mia has the influence and connections she has and can’t make a change, what hope does anyone else have?
loading...
What hope does anyone have if everyone just sits on their hands and accepts what is without trying to enact change? It’s called a groundswell and it starts with one person. How will we ever know if we don’t try?
loading...
Hey SarahinAdelaide, thanks for your comment. I’m doing this because I have a great passion for it and I truly believe that enough people feel the same way that together we can make a change.
Magazines are a business but it doesn’t mean that they can’t change. In fact, it’s a great reason why they should listen to the 10,000 plus people who have signed my petition so far – as consumers we hold all the power here. If we stop buying then magazines are put out of business. It’s as simple as that. I certainly believe there’s hope, I see no reason not to think that to be honest.
loading...
let’s be supportive.
loading...
Righteous!!!
I’m studying communications at UTS majoring in Social inquiry. I hear you Jess I am also a model, a plus size model! I’m 20 too, and I want a change, BIG TIME. I represent real women. But I dress casual and understated 90% of the time because I cannot buy into these images created by magazines. Why don’t I read stories about how the CEO of Westpac got her job, or how a mother of 5 children works and supports her family? Why aren’t I reading REAL stuff and feeling REAL when I read them.
I want to feel inspired. I want to feel empowered. I don’t want to feel like I should go on a diet every time I open a magazine. Enough is enough. Screw your perfect woman poof. Bring on the real world.
loading...
@Blaise, thanks for your great comment – I loved reading it! I want to feel inspired and empowered by the magazines I read too. I think it’s really important and I wish that they didn’t make so many girls feel so poorly about their image.
loading...
I have never read Dolly, Cosmo or Cleo and I didn’t and still don’t really see the big fuss about those 3 mags. But every now and again when I was 15-17, I would buy Vogue, InStyle and Harpers Bazaar and I absolutely loved reading them. But unfortunately I became obsessed with looking perfect, I wouldn’t leave the house, anxiety and depression etc – basically I had huge body image issues and I still do today.
It got so bad that my Mum banned me from buying magazines and it wasn’t until last year (about 4 years on) that I started buying magazines again. I still love Harpers Bazaar but I hardly buy it. I really love Madison now and I tend to switch every month or so between Madison and SHOP.
Even though I knew when I was teenager that they were airbrushed, I didn’t accept it, I still couldn’t help but wanting that body and I hated the fact that I didn’t look like that. Now, as a 20 year old I fully acknowledge that these models are photoshopped, but it’s still there, that nagging feeling of not being physically good enough or beautiful.
loading...
I think a large part of that phenomenon, knowing they’re airbrushed but still wanting to attain that beauty, is due to the fact that you know that not only you but most people hold those same images up as their ideals. These are society’s images of perfection too and knowing that makes us feel less worthy, aware that we don’t meet those impossible standards. I’m not sure if I’m explaining it well but it’s like it’s not even something you impose on yourself because YOU want to look good for you, but because you want to be accepted in society as someone who can achieve what everyone else desires. That may make no sense when written sorry. It’s right in my head.
loading...
Don’t be sorry, you’ve summed it up superbly! And you’ve made perfect sense of what I was trying to say because even though, in the long run, our views are completely irrational, but socially acceptable. Some girls can’t help but want that ideal, myself included.
It’s hard to explain it coherently because personal emotions and experiences always creep in and cloud the issue.
loading...
Thanks for sharing Bridget! I appreciate it. It’s scary how easily these images get inside our heads and affect the way we think about ourselves.
loading...
“Even the models we see in magazines wish they could look like their own images.” ― Cheri K. Erdman
I saw this quote once and thought it rang true. For the record, I don’t know who this Erdman is I just like the quote.
I’m a 24 year old size 10 professional woman. I don’t buy cleo/cosmo anymore mostly because I just feel they don’t relate to my life at all. I’m not concerned about my own body image but part of the reason I don’t buy the mags is the photoshopping – it just makes them even harder to relate to..
These magazines are filled with products I can’t afford or find completely ridiculous and clothing on women who are photoshopped. I choose magazines more along the line of frankie/better homes and gardens/donna hay/womens weekly/women’s health (although the latter is becoming tedious as well…).
I understand for some magazines are an escape but for me? I’d rather read magazines that relate to my life and contain useful/interesting information!
loading...
This petition hit my inbox last night and I signed it. I find it interesting. I wrote to Cleo a while back asking why they thought it necessary to have a model who’s ribs were sticking out in their healthy body section. I heard back saying they were disappointed I was upset blah blah. No ownership of the issue. In my original email, I dared them to publish my comment. They didn’t.t. I’ve synced noticed that Cleo only publish positive feedback – not even ideas of what readers want more of. That really pissed me off.
As an adult, I can accept that the pages of magazines are photoshopped, but as a teenager I was convinced that those girls were real and that I could get to look like that if only I tried hard enough. I wrestled with body image, depression and anxiety throughout my teenage years and I still have food problems.
I still love and buy mags, especially SHOP and I do see sme diversity in Cosmo’s pages but I feel Cleo have fallen behind the 8 ball and all the mags should declare photoshopped images. Its not fair not to.
Mia, I really want to hear your thoughts on this petition, do you think it will make any difference?
loading...
Pingback: I wouldn’t normally, however….. « nickedborrowedcopied
Am I wrong to say that I don’t care if magazines are photoshopped or not? I accept that a majority of content has been photoshopped – I don’t lose sleep over it and I don’t think my body image has been negatively affected.
I think there are bigger issues to focus your energy on!
loading...
I don’t think it’s fair to say “there are bigger issues to focus on”, because this is an issue that is obviously of importance to Jess. Sure, in the scheme of world problems it won’t rank at the top, but it’s an issue Jess feels like she can make a difference to, and we should congratulate and support that effort.
loading...
“I don’t lose sleep over it and I don’t think my body image has been negatively affected.”
I think that’s great for you (not sarcasm!) and though I myself don’t have particularly good body image, it has nothing to do with magazines for me either. However, there are a lot of girls/women out there who ARE affected in negative ways by glossy, photoshopped images of women pretending to be ‘real’ or ‘just like you’ (just look at some of the other comments!) so it obviously IS a big issue, whether it affects you personally or not.
We’re never going to get everyone agreeing on what the most important issue in the world/facing young women is but if someone tries to make a positive impact on an issue that they personally feel strongly about, then more power to them!
loading...
Wow! I actually thought there would be a much more positive response to this article here. A young, intelligent woman wants to make a change in the world and she’s met with very underwhelming support in my view – at least here where I thought a lot of people would be behind her.
I applaud you Jess for taking a stand and DOING SOMETHING instead of just whining about things like others do. I don’t read women’s mags at all. I wouldn’t waste my money on that garbage to be frank. But I have concerns for my young nieces that they will see these types of images and think they are anything less than beautiful because they compare themselves to figments of someone’s imagination. The women they are looking at don’t exist in reality.
I signed your change.org petition and have just now donated to your pozible fund and I encourage everyone else to do so. I also encourage everyone else to open their minds to the possibility of change.
I wish you the best of luck.
EDIT: realising there is more support in the comments than I originally noted, maybe not as enthusiastic as I hoped but that’s beside the point. It was a couple of the negative ones that made me mad.
loading...
Any reason why Mia has been silent on this post??
loading...
Maybe because not so long ago she posted a cover of Debra Hutton that had had the c**p photoshopped out of it on this site and nominated it as “cover of the year”.
loading...
Give the woman a break, she has more to do than just sit and read our comments – she’ll get to it in time most likely.
I like the artistry in some photo spreads, my only issue is when they are presented as typical girls/women
loading...
Obviously I can’t speak for Mia but I would guess that a) she doesn’t want to “steal Jessica’s thunder”, so to speak, and b). As soon as Mia comments out will come all the “but you were a mag editor and you were part of the problem so you should never change your mind/comment on the issue again!” people. Or maybe she’s just, I don’t know, spending time with her family? Nah.
loading...
Great idea! I don’t know why but despite my 19 year old daughter having many friends,and being overly concerned about the usual things, looks, fashion etc I have never seen a copy of Cleo or Cosmo in the house. She read Frankie for a while when she was about 17 but that is it. I have only skimmed a couple but they seem different.
loading...
When i was a teenager (late nineties earliy 2000s) i use to by Cosmo and Cleo and id had the odd sealed section and then mostly interesting articles and fashion etc now i look it at it and its just so much about boys and sex etc its a shame the magazine has focused on this….ive also been buying Marie Claire for the past 5 years and have found its going downhill too just the articles arent as interesting…or it could just be me and im changing..i now buy vogue and Frankie.
loading...
Me too. I used to be a Cosmo reader but my interests have changed and now I love Yen and Dumbo Feather.
loading...
Great post Jessica! Love that you’ve taken this issue head on and I’m thrilled to see your petition doing so well already.
loading...
Cleo and Cosmopolitan are operated by private companies. Maybe if those 50,000 people voted with their feet and stopped buying the magazines, they’d start taking notice. Until then, 50,000 signatures isn’t going to do more than look like a marketing opportunity.
loading...
I have never been a magazine consumer until I discovered Notebook. I became an avid reader, it had a great mix of everything and wasn’t full of mindless crap. It dissappeared within 12 months – obviously no one else felt the same way.
loading...
I used to be a notebook reader ( loved the recipes, & the articles) I have recently discovered mindfood, a NZ magazine that is pretty good.
loading...
I have stopped buying them. I read Frankie now. It’s rad.
I stopped reading these magazines because they are boring and I’m interested in different things, not the same re-hashed article about blowing someone’s mind in bed. And I think the silly BODY CONFIDENCE articles mixed in with plague of photoshopped images is ridiculous.
But when you’ve stopped buying them can you do more? Yes. That’s what jess is doing. Simple.
loading...
I think Australian magazines really lack substance and variety. In Korea and Japan, they have niche magazines for just about anything you can imagine. Here when I crave something to read on the train I always feel disappointed. Magazines are just glorified catalogues. Even Frankie annoys me. And personally I’d like to see what people my age authentically look like in a magazine. From light wrinkles to ordinary bodies.
loading...
Unfortunately, Australia doesn’t really have the high population needed to support readership of niche magazines.
loading...
#36 is the worst!!! arch!!!
loading...
What would Ita think?
I love a good magazine, but I wonder, especially after watching Paper Giants, if today’s magazines are what the trailblazers, such as Ita, had in mind when they pioneered them.
loading...
While I don’t completely agree that magazines are solely to blame for this, I do think they contribute. I was an awkward teen and didn’t come into myself until I left school, so along with comparing myself to my beautiful long haired peers, I felt equally uncomfortable reading these magazines.
What confused me was the endless pages of airbrushed perfection juxtaposed with articles about body confidence. Weird
loading...
“What confused me was the endless pages of airbrushed perfection juxtaposed with articles about body confidence. Weird.”
Me too! As someone with freckles, I remember how the advice was always ‘freckles are gorgeous so don’t cover them up, let them show…’ etc, and yet I remember only one model with freckles, ever.
loading...
I have always been inspired and happy after reading magazines.
Seriously, I’m a 12-14 size, and I am very short.
I am not model material and yet my whole life I have read these mags and walked away thinkin, “My lfie is awesome! I live near the beach/city, I have cool hair/friends/nail polish… I am happy!”
I think people who pick apart these magazines are often just in a depressed state themselves. Dont like them? Don’t read them.
I feel ‘depressed’ when I see shitty FB comments, so i stopped going on FB.
Take ownership of your life- not just your feelings.
loading...
I tend to agree with you on this in some sense, however I think teenage girls are not as easily able to separate so easily and are more vulnerable to these images.
I remember being far more obsessed with my image and myself in general as a teenager than I do now in my early 20s. It’s a maturity thing
loading...
Hi Jen, wow, I have to completely disagree with you. Popular women’s magazines over the decades have often represented the unspoken status quo that women feel they should live by (take a look at some old 1950′s advertisements or articles from Australian Woman’s Weekly… Even after the Women’s Lib movement in the 60′s, female popular magazines were still pretty questionable). You say that the problem with women’s magazines lies in those who pick them apart due to their depressed state… I’m sorry, but, huh?! The problem doesn’t lie with the collective who unconsciously internalise these pejorative messages (the submissive, Anglo, heterosexual female beauty), but the media itself! Until women like Germaine Greer, Betty Friedan or other feminists of their era actually articulated to women that this deep sense of longing for something more to life than housework was ‘abnormal’, women believed that there was something wrong with them and not society! Likewise, there is nothing wrong with you if want female oriented literature or media that portrays women of all walks of life, in all shapes and sizes, not to mention ethnicies, with a variety and spectrum of articles that focuses on relevant issues other than beauty, sex and fashion. Well done to Jessica for raising awareness of such an important issue.
loading...
I agree with you i spent my teens reading these magazines and never had a problem with body image and as a petite teen i never looked like any of the models but that never bothered me. I think if you can’t leave the house because a magazine upset you perhaps there is a bigger issue there
loading...
“Boys, sex, relationships, makeup and clothes. Is this really all we’re supposed to care about?” No, but they sure are a bit of mindless fun aren’t they?! When you work full time, have kids and are just generally feeling like you don’t get enough time for yourself, these magazines can be a great indulgence. I personally love reading trashy magazines! It’s a bit of time away from the mundaness of the 9-5 world. There is enough depressing news on the TV and radio, in the newspaper, and everywhere else we look.
As for the photo-shopping, I think it’s fair enough in magazines aimed at teenages that it be listed when an image is altered, but personally it would just annoy me to flick though the pages of Vogue or Instyle and see this everywhere. Adults know that the images are photoshopped and most of the time the photoshopping looks great. Why would I want to look at images of Cameron Diaz in a goregous designer dress with bad skin? it ruins the illusion. Magazines are a bit of an escape from the world and do not need to be any more intellectual than they are.
I think you are only the right track with your ideas about young girls being impressionable but are a little bit naive.
loading...
“they sure are a bit of mindless fun aren’t they?”
Mindless, yes; not so sure about the fun.
loading...
Lol! Sex, makeup and clothes are my biggest indulgences in life!!
I agree with you that they are fun and I’m happier with this stuff in my life. I’m not happy when people assume though that that is “all I care about”.
Not so much saying it’s this article, but just generally the public perception is that if I care about my appearance I must be over-compensating for not having a brain. Which is bullshit. Fashion and makeup can be just as empowering. But I’d prefer if magazines didn’t treat me as something that needed to be “fixed”. Which is why I refuse to read Cleo, Cosmo, and stick to Shop and Frankie and Oyster instead!
(and I quite like Vogue – for exactly what you’ve listed above. It’s an escape from the everyday)
loading...
I agree with your comment michaelaarghh! I love print media, its something I grew up with. I consider myself to be highly educated, open minded, curious about the world and having a system of values. Whenever I did read cleo or cosmo, I often felt like they were trying to sell me a ‘lifestyle’. I love fashion, beauty and aesthetically pleasing photos and designs, but that doesn’t mean that all I care about is fashion, beauty, casual sex, and trying to become a PR agent, model, journalist or model (somehow that is the only professions I see ‘lifted up high’ by such magazines). Oh, and the articles they do have on health etc are usually 2 measly pages that are so dummed down… and whenever they had an issue on ‘loving every body’ or ‘diversity’, it seemed fake because all the issues afterwards were back to their old ways/standards.
Give me shop (at least it doesn’t pretend to be about anything else), womens health and frankie and sometimes madison any day…
loading...
oh and p.s. I read european magazines as I come from and non-English speaking background, and I buy them here at my local delis. One magazine in particular which is popular in my home country, is packed full of fashion and beauty BUT also has incredible ‘cover stories’ that focus on woman of all ages (so that a woman in her twenties gets something out of it, as well as a woman in her 40s) which are written in depth, with sensitivity, including the opinions of experts and with examples of different woman involved in whatever situation they are covering. Same goes with their health, money and art sections. I KNOW that sich a magazine would do well here because australian women are intelligent and want to learn and be challenged, thats why magazines with depth and scope are doing well (e.g. madison and frankie – and shop because it focus’s on something and does that extremely well instead of ‘pretending’ to do it all). I’m in my early 20s and I will never buy a cosmo and cleo again. I also don’t have any female friends that buy these magazines.
loading...
Hi aura, great point about the only ‘professions’ magazines seem to consider proper. I remember reading the feature articles about sex, dating, relationships, etc. in Cleo and Cosmo. The writers often wrote little case studies: “Chloe (not her real name) works in PR and blah blah…” I always thought the writers just went round the office – other writers, the designers, the receptionist, any models that happened to be floating around – until they found some material for their anecdotal stories. It always made me think they were too lazy to actually interview anyone outside their own little circle. Or maybe in fact, as you say, that’s all they can imagine people doing!!
loading...
hahaha yep I think that MAY just be it
loading...
This is so true, what you have written about them trying to sell a lifestyle and I think you’ve hit the nail on the head with shop – that is exactly why I like it. It is incredibly consumerist but it does its one thing and it does it well. It caters to different people without making a feature out of it. That is really interesting about the magazine from your home country. It sounds exactly like a magazine I would be interested in reading.
loading...
I think calling someone naive is pretty patronising. I am an idealist and I get knocked down a lot by people telling me you can’t change things. It seems you don’t want things to change. You’re happy. Does that mean that just because a particular problem/social issue does not touch your life then it’s naive for people to campaign against it? For you magazines are escapist, for someone else reading/seeing the exact same thing they’re very damaging.
loading...
Yeah but teenagers read Cleo and cosmo. It’s naive to think that they don’t. And we have to remember them when we get annoyed by a small ‘this image has been photoshopped’ on the bottom of the page.
loading...
I don’t understand this site.
One day we’re talking about how wonderful Helen Gurley Borwn is for creating one of these magazines and the next we’re against them?
I know the response will be ‘We’re a site reflecting all views” but this is completely incongruous.
loading...
Oh and kudos Jess on your idea – best of luck with it.
loading...
This is such a great idea!
What I don’t want in magazines – diet advice. at all. No articles about what celebs are eating what, no articles about what is “good” for you, no articles about what is “healthy” etc etc.
I think it’s incredibly irresponsible for magazines to pass on nutritional information knowing nothing of the readers personal history etc etc. Even if they do have “nutritionists” writing these articles, they can’t know what the reader’s body types are like and no doubt it is impressionable women taking on this advice.
What I do want to see? Funny articles, articles that are empowering. My favourite magazines at the moment are Oyster and Frankie. I love Shop for the fashion advice (which has pages dedicated to different body types and budgets).
loading...
100% agree… The voyeur in me likes to read about what these people supposedly eat, the anorexic would crunch the figures and come to the conclusion its usually a load of crap.
loading...
exactly. When I was at my sickest with my eating disorder I would use these articles as a guide. “Oh Miranda Kerr eats 1200 calories a day. Well if I halve everything she eats then surely I’ll be as skinny and pretty as her.” Then when that didn’t work, I would halve that again, and again.
(for e.g. I don’t actually know what Miranda Kerr’s intake is anymore).
I’m not holding these magazines responsible for my own behaviour because eating disorders are more complicated than merely being about food. But they can assist people in disordered eating and there are more than enough women out there who are self conscious about their bodies and will try the latest ‘fad diet’ in an effort to change what they look like.
loading...