By LARA CAIN
I’ve just started a new diet. It involves eating lots of fruit and vegetables, holding back on the ‘sometimes food’ and going for walks. It’s amazingly effective. I desperately wish I’d known about it before I spent thousands of dollars on books, pills, powders and ab crunching machinery trying to shift those pesky kilos. I think this revolutionary diet model slipped under my radar because all it offers is good health, whereas other products offered me weight loss, romance, fame and fortune all in one tasty meal replacing shake.
Our obsession with the weight loss industry surely pushes enough money through the economy that it almost balances the toll taken on the health system by the so called ‘obesity crisis’. Okay, so I’m no economist but I do think a lot of us would benefit from a few minutes in the ‘thinking corner’ having a long, hard look at the notion of ‘balance’. I know I have.
Over the years I have swung between superfit and supersized depending on where I was on life’s great game of snakes and ladders. I’ve battled my weight using a range of tactics I would very much not recommend. In the 80s, a fitness instructor told me that if I just ate one Mars Bar a day, I’d give myself enough energy to keep functioning without any other unnecessary calories. I passed out a few times but I did lose weight.
In the 90s, my GP prescribed some tablets closely related to speed, which had me racing around my office like a greyhound. I had bad breath and a crazed look in my eyes (also like a greyhound) but I did lose weight.
In more recent times, I’ve had three kids and it’s become something of a ‘last chance saloon’ situation, but fortunately I’ve matured enough to realise that the supermodel ship has sailed. I’ve learned that a healthy lifestyle is easier to maintain if I lighten up a little on the pressure for perfection.
I feel proud of myself for reaching a point where I no longer torture myself on a daily basis about my appearance because, quite frankly, it’s not a fun way to live.
I would find it easier to feel proud of myself if I wasn’t so frequently reminded of the terrible burden I am placing on the rest of the population. As someone who won’t be pulling on the skinny jeans any time soon, I keep company with celebrities who are pilloried as bad role models despite being smart, articulate and funny. I am subjected to stock footage of wobbly bottoms and heaving man bosoms behind voiceovers about anything from fast food to school sports to that great unifier of the masses – the misspending of taxpayers’ dollars.
If we are to believe the headlines, hardworking, thinner Australians are subsidising fat people’s wanton destruction of the Australian health system. Fat people seem to be the last remaining group at which it is socially acceptable to throw verbal rotten tomatoes without anyone telling you it’s discriminatory. If we’re not careful the real health crisis we’ll be facing won’t be an increased incidence of diabetes and heart disease, but the mental health problems derived from constantly making people feel so darn bad about themselves.
I would also like to see the odd, balanced headline about the cost to taxpayers of alcohol, driving cars, work-related stress and other things that are equally about someone’s choice to put themselves at risk. In fact, where are the stats on adventure sports? I have friends who are dealing with their mid-life crises by taking up hobbies like aerial acrobatics and pole dancing.
People all around me are boot camping their way towards 40, building meaningful new relationships with lower back and knee specialists as they go. Do I begrudge anyone a rescue chopper when they choose to barefoot ski the Sydney to Hobart just to get back a little mojo? No, of course not. I might even watch the live stream on their blog.
In making light of this, I’m not suggesting we should not look after our health. You only get one body and it’s the vehicle that carries you for the whole road trip of life. Like it or not, it needs regular maintenance and providing the right fuel is, indeed, one’s own responsibility. But I do think we might need to relax our attitudes a little and make like a school sports day – where getting a ribbon just for making an effort goes a long way, self esteem wise.
Most people who are carrying extra junk in the trunk are well aware of it, and they’re trying to do something about it, even if their progress is slow. If someone close to you is worryingly overweight, perhaps you could ask them what they think they need (a walking buddy? Some babysitting at gym time?) before giving them an economics lecture? And if someone you don’t know is worryingly overweight – that guy at the supermarket or that woman on TV – perhaps you could mind your own beeswax?
There’s a good chance they are already their own harshest critic.
Dr Lara Cain Gray is an academic, writer, librarian, curator and mother. The order depends on the day. She has held research and curatorial positions in Australia and the UK but is currently on a career break to look after her beautiful, maddening offspring.
Around two thirds of Australian adults and one quarter of Australian kids are overweight. And new reports show that the number of adults in healthy weight range has dropped by around half in the past 30 years alone.
This infographic comes from The Conversation (who, by the by, are a great source of news and research) and shows in an oh-so-dramatic fashion just how much heavier Australians have gotten over the past 3 decades.
There are plenty of news reports honing in on the economic cost of obesity and suggesting obese Australians are ‘wasting taxpayers money’. But as a society, what is our role? Would you suggest that an obese friend should lose weight, the same way you might berate them for smoking? Does the community have a role to play in making obesity less socially acceptable? Or do we all just need to mind our own business?







Comments
110 Comments so far
And perhaps those carrying a little extra weight can hold back on criticizing those that are on the skinnier side.
I work in the fashion industry and hear the call ‘you wouldn’t understand’ every day right after a woman complains about a garment clinging to her ‘wobbly bits’. It infuriates me! I actually do know, and I worked damn hard to lose the 20+ kgs of unhappy weight I put on while in an unhealthy relationship. Yes, I am petite but I still know what it’s like to have to shift those kgs – only to have my hard work used against me in a way that reflects a put down.
It’s funny that people can openly discuss a skinny person’s appearance/weight, but those that are considered ‘fat’ are out of bounds.
I just think that no one should comment on another persons weight/appearance and save everyone the grief of being upset.
I’d love to see the day when women try on clothes and focus on the good bits – instead of focusing on the bad. Lets embrace ourselves and each other!
loading...
Were you trying to be funny by being exactly the type of silly person the article refers to? My father is diabetic, so my sisters and I were raised on the diet of a diabetic: fruit and veg, lean meat and fish, legumes and brown rice, skim dairy and very little sugar. We’re overweight anyway. Care to diagnose that, champ?
loading...
Calm your farm there!
The article is clearly talking about NOT attacking overweight people.
So you are overweight – care to have the doctor or a nutritionist diagnose it champ?
I eat the same, but an underlying iron deficiency and adrenal fatigue / hormone imbalance was responsible for my issues, not my diet..
loading...
I can… It can be your portion sizes are way to big, your not eating 5-6 smaller meals a day (healthy portioned meals) instead you may be eating 1-2 large meals which in that case your body would hold onto and store the cals/fat, which would result in you having a very slow metabolism.
Also exercise plays a HUGE roll in losing weight. You can’t get by very long with one or the other. They have to be put into place and maintained.
Eating healthy should not be called a “diet”. It is a lifestyle and no doubt 9/10 times a person can and will lose weight with proper meal plans and workout schedule… Proven fact …
loading...
There is no way I don’t know that I’m obese. I don’t need to be told. I eat less food & have a healthier lifestyle than most people I encounter & I am still obese. Life just sucks sometimes.
I have a variety of medical issues that make losing weight almost impossible, including some nasty medications. I don’t, however, have a sign around my neck stating this & most likely, the average person wouldn’t understand anyway.
I have been stopped by complete strangers in supermarkets to have my trolley inspected. I have been subjected to humiliating diatribes in public. Fatism is allowed, in fact encouraged, by society.
Oh, & by the way, I have been a tax payer since 1985 & have never been on welfare benefits. My tax dollars have been spent on people I could consider a waste of space: those drug addicted or too stupid to wear a seatbelt or helmet. I don’t get to choose & neither should you.
loading...
Pingback: On the short shorts manifesto: Mamamia and body image |
I was more than happy to find this internet-site.I needed to thanks on your time for this glorious learn!! I definitely having fun with each little bit of it and I’ve you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you blog post. louisen.com
loading...
Pingback: On moving, memories and Mamamia | This Charming Mum
And maybe we should stop telling people not to smoke when they are pregnant! Fat kills and we should never underestimate that.
loading...
Smoking kills. People die in car crashes. Healthy marathon runners can die of heart attacks. Cancer. Skin cancer easily prevented by suncream/hat/shade. If people are fat, it’s not necessarily by choice. People die every minute. It’s a fact of life.
loading...
How is it any of your business how someone wants to live their life? Or throw it away? Get off your high horse, show some compassion. Noone NEEDS to smoke, yet everyone needs to eat. Food is not something you can avoid. It’s as much an addiction as a drug
loading...
While I may have opinions about the physique of people around me, I don’t think it’s in anyone’s interest for me to voice them, least of all the people who are potentially aware of health problems or have low self esteem because of their appearance.
Let’s just keep it to ourselves people, and allow everyone to get on with their own lives.
loading...
OK, I don’t tell people they’re fat – even though fat people are more than happy to criticise me because I’m too skinny, apparently. At 165 cm and 55 kg……
BUT. No-one can tell me the woman on the right hand side of the photo above is healthy – unless she is post-menopausal.
loading...
Where in the article does it say that obese people are healthy? All it is saying is that overweight people know that they are overweight. Berating them doesn’t help.
loading...
Great article! Honestly, my weight is my own business. We all have health issues and I’m fully aware of mine. I don’t need to be told to lose weight or that I am unhealthy. At the moment my weight is the least of my problems and I will deal with that just as soon as I have enough mental resources for it.
loading...
“There’s a good chance they are already their own harshest critic.”
Amen to this, sister. AMEN.
loading...
Obesity, in 99% of cases, is self inflicted, so why should people with a decent amount of self control have to subsidise their lifestyle?
loading...
Anorexia, in 99% of cases, is self inflicted, so why should people with a decent amount of self control have to subsidise their lifestyle?
….doesn’t sound quite the same does it…?
loading...
I’m sick of people complaining about smokers. I’m an ex smoker but the way smokers are treated is just disgusting. I’m also sick of having to dance around the feelings of fatties. They didn’t and still don’t care that skinny people can feel bad about their bodies too, and it doesn’t stop fatties pointing out that someone is a bit skinny.
Fatties can’t have it both ways.
loading...
Thank you.
At least I’m paying a hefty excise (70% on each packet of cigarettes) for my social crime of smoking – and I can only do my crime in my own home these days, apparently……
Bring on the junk food excise!
loading...
Thankyou! I loved your article and it re-motivated me. My weight loss through diet alone has been very slow and were I able to exercise more without passing out because of an iron absorption condition, I would have had the weight off a lot sooner. Then again, nor would the weight have gone on in the first place. Unfortunately, society simply sees it as over eating and doesn’t consider the other possible factors that can contribute. I already feel lousy enough about my weight, lack of ability to buy flattering clothes that don’t cost twice as much and assume I am a frump without the subtle barbs from the skinny people who so effortlessy eat chocolate every day without consequence. Despite having a fairly healthy self concept and compensating sense of humour, it’s not particularly reassuring that my substantial weight will ensure my survival should we have a nuclear winter in the near future. But I guess the skinny people won’t be laughing then.
loading...
“My weight loss through diet alone has been very slow and were I able to exercise more without passing out because of an iron absorption condition, I would have had the weight off a lot sooner.”
That is an excuse ….. weight loss is 80% nutrition. If you’re obese, the weight should fall off as soon as you restrict calories.
loading...
Back off. Quit fat bashing. It may work for you, but everyone’s body works differently. Ever heard of Cushing’s disease? That’s not a choice!
loading...
That is a really horrible thing to say. Nasty, in fact. Clearly this poster is trying her best to improve her health. Comments like yours are just discouraging and not helpful in the least.
loading...
Thank you Lara for another excellent post. I love the things you say and the way you say it. This one was particularly thought provoking. Vilification, bullying and scolding don’t seem helpful strategies in any area of life, certainly not this one.
loading...
Well said Shankari. Thanks for reading
loading...
I thought I ought to share this link, as it compliments this article very well. Coincidentally, a friend of mine who is a nutritionist posted this on FB today.
The crux: this website is a very wise and informative site from a nutrionist who is known as the ‘Fat Nutrionist’. She says: ‘yes I am what society calls fat, but I am healthy and eat well’ – and is in fact highly educated in the area of nutrition.
It’s an informative and handy site for those wanting to learn to eat for health, it is not another ‘bloody’ diet. It also discusses some problems with the social side of being fat, and the fact that society assumes if you look overweight you aren’t healthy and are a burden on the medical system.
The truth is, you can be very fit and very healthy and still not fit into society’s vision of what fit and healthy supposedly is. It comes in a lot of shapes and sizes, and cannot be represented by an image. And whose business is it to question someone’s health stats based on their appearance?
Have a read: http://www.fatnutritionist.com/index.php/a-little-101-i-get-to-exist/
loading...
Oh, and Ps, forgot to say. The ethos of ‘reducing the amount you eat and exercise a lot’ doesn’t actually always = weightloss. Eating the right food and exercise will make you healthy though, just not necessarily ‘skinny’.I can attest to that. The above site examines this as well.
loading...
Thanks for contributing this link Fi. It’s great for all of us to read, learn and consider different perspectives and different approaches to research on this issue.
loading...
Please spare a thought for the obese people who are suffering with illness and pain………they eat a normal diet (sometimes even less) but their weight keeps creeping up due to being unable to move significantly enough to burn it off…. Add medication to this mix ( prednisone for eg) and the problem is exacerbated……….I’m bringing this up because so many of these people cop the criticism and abuse that comes with being extremely overweight – the naive advice of the “skinny experts” of “just get up off the couch and run around the block” doesn’t work with these people and yet they have to endure the insensitive remarks and the dumb-ass questions like “don’t you think you need to lose weight?”……every overweight person lives with this burden every second of the day and doesn’t need to be reminded of the fact.
loading...
I know that you mean this in a kind way. I totally agree that people who gain weight because of illness or medication should not be subjected to insenstive remarks and dumb-ass questions but do you think. I just think people should keep those remarks and questions to themselves and challenge their own thinking.
It’s plain rude and cruel regardless of why the person has gained weight or what they’ve tried to do about it..
loading...
Thank you so much for a great post. As a teen I was anorexic and was hospitalized a couple of times, this led to a life time of weight obsession and unhealthy habits. I am now nearing 40 and after a car accident that rendered me virtually immobile for a while my weight crapped up. I am finding it hard to shift it, but will tell you that I am eating healthier than ever and much more active than I was before. As a friend of mine who is a personal trainer said to me, I am used to being very skinny eating very bad, now I’m a little over the optimal weight but am healthier. I prefer to be that than the skinny person obsessing and stressing over how I look.
loading...
Not my idea originally but it’s a gooden;
Take the money you’d spend on diet pills, potions, shakes and fat blasting machinery and give it to the poor. And instead of using all this crap that doesn’t work long term, try eating less (or better) and move more. Simple!
loading...
Hey Lara,
I particularly liked the part where you said:
“Fat people seem to be the last remaining group at which it is socially acceptable to throw verbal rotten tomatoes without anyone telling you it’s discriminatory. If we’re not careful the real health crisis we’ll be facing won’t be an increased incidence of diabetes and heart disease, but the mental health problems derived from constantly making people feel so darn bad about themselves.”
Thank God some one else noticed. I am overweight. I also throw up my food, and am constantly battling my self but no one knows/realises because I’m the fat girl. It’s just not associated that someone overweight could actually not be ok with it their weight. That they don’t have the strength or support, or the understanding of exercise and nutrition regime to get them where their health needs to be
loading...
Oh Bec, I really feel for you after reading this. I have an eating disorder and am in the process of recovery, as I’ve been going through it I’ve realised that it can be really hard for people who aren’t underweight to get help, as a lot of GPs/other medical professionals don’t believe them. Throwing up your food isn’t ok, and it must be really difficult for you to be, as you said, battling yourself. But there are people out there who will listen to and believe you. A great website to have a look at is http://www.bodymatters.com.au – they can provide help and services or refer you to someone else who can. No matter what your size you deserve to have support if you need it and you most definitely don’t deserve to be discriminated against.
I hope that reads as I intended it to. xxx
loading...
Hear hear! I am with you 100%
loading...
If it’s so hard to lose weight just don’t get fat in the first place! Fat parents with fat kids should be ashamed of themselves; by allowing children to become overweight all you’re doing is setting them up with life-long health risks and difficulties associated with losing the weight they had no control over gaining. The other day at a gathering I witnessed an overweight woman yelling at her chubby 6 year old daughter for not eating more than 2 sausages! She was telling her she needs to ‘eat more than that’ when the daughter was clearly not hungry anymore. What’s worse is her husband is overweight too and recently suffered a heart attack! Disgraceful.
loading...
Judgement is a heavy burden, you must be feel quite tired by now.
loading...
As a teen I didn’t begin to menstruate until I was 18. While the doctors tried to work out why and gave me hormone treatments, I put on three stone in two months under the care of that doctor whilst on a very strict diet and exercise regime which I followed to the letter which was reinforced by my parents. Before doing this diet, I was only very slightly overweight. I also lost virtually all my hair. Fine for you to say don’t put the weight on in the first place. That initial weight gain has stayed with me my whole life and fuelled an ongoing metabolic disorder in a vicious cycle.Your ignorance Anonymous is quite astonishing. Don’t you think I would have avoided putting the weight on in the first place if I could have?
loading...
it annoys me that people cant do the ‘right thing’ by society. we are either too skinny, or too fat! i went through a period of being obsessed with exercising, bulimea, and generally worrying about not getting fat (i was slowly killing myself). i would get comments about “oh your so skinny!”. it would frustrate me, because im sure i wouldnt be getting comments such as “oh your so fat!” if i had of been fat..
loading...
A person’s weight is tied up with so many other not-so-tangible issues! You’re right – guilt trips (whether they be from friends, family or random strangers) JUST DON’T WORK! For me, they only compounded the insecurities that caused my problem in the first place!
The thing that really turned the lights on for me, was the realisation that dieting is near impossible for me when I’m cooking for my family every day(3 kids under 4 and hubby with the metabolism of a racehorse! Lol!) so it was a matter of figuring out how to serve up food for all of us to keep us all healthy and well fed but that I could still eat and maintain a steady pattern of weight loss after having my last baby. And it works! Slow and steady, but it works!
loading...
Thanks for sharing your story Lara. I wish you a lifetime of good health and happiness.
loading...
Thanks and back at ya, Tonia.
loading...
Every day is a new day and I try not to let the dietary lapses of yesterday guide my menu for today. Thanks for the thought-provoking article.
loading...
That sounds like a good policy Kasper.
loading...
If two thirds of the population are overweight then hadnt we better be looking at what we consider overweight?
loading...
That has to be one of the most idiotic questions ever written… I actually cannot believe you had time to think about what to type and you still wrote that. You need to have a good think about what you said.
loading...
Great way to totally miss my point! Might be a good idea to take your own advice I think. I will explain though since its obviously gone waaayyy over your head.
If two thirds of the population are considered to be overweight then why arent we seeing the expected results of that? Because statistically we arent. Nowhere near. Not only do Australians weigh more than we did 20 years ago, we are taller, our feet are bigger and our children are growing faster than we did as well. These statistics are based on BMI data which time and time again has been proven to be flawed. Most elite sportsmen are considered overweight if you consider BMI data due to their large muscle mass.In 1985 the decision was made to drop the BMI weight categories by 4.5 kilos. You were within the healthy weight range one day and overweight the next. BMI data is that arbitrary. I dont believe its a reliable indicator of obesity and disease and health statistics are showing that. If two thirds of the population are overweight then why arent most of us diabetic, hypertensive and riddled with cancer then. Take those two thirds of people and do more extensive testing, including blood pressure monitoring, glucose and lipid readings and then we would have a much better idea of what is really going on. But to bang on about how two thirds of us are overweight according to BMI data? Doesnt really mean all that much considering how flawed the data is in the first place.
loading...
great point bush pig – it is also well known that many of these “overweight” people are actually healthier and have a longer life expectancy than many inactive people in the healthy weight range not to mention considerably healthier than those who are underweight.
loading...
Rudge, please share your “evidence”.
loading...
Umm, this country IS riddled with cancer, type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease. All diseases that being overweight or obese increases your chance of developing.
loading...
But not anywhere at the levels you would be expecting if the population was indeed two thirds overweight. And you need to consider all lifestyle factors including smoking,inactivity and poor diet. Sedentary thin people are not nearly as healthy as “overweight” active ones.
loading...
After reading your comment, my bullshit detector is off the scale, bushpiglet.
http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/Lookup/4820.0.55.001main+features52007-08
http://www.modi.monash.edu.au/obesity-facts-figures/obesity-in-australia/
The sooner we tax food in the same way as we tax alcohol and cigarettes, the healthier people will be.
In fact, the excise tax on cigarettes already covers the medical expenses of smokers, AND THEN SOME.
And I noticed you didn’t mention alchohol consumption in those lifestyle areas you mentioned.
loading...
With you Claire – also – just because the average woman is now a size 14-16 doesn’t make it healthy! Yes we are taller, but not 15-25kg worth of extra height! Just because the majority of people are overweight, doesn’t mean it’s ok.
loading...
So someone who wears a size 14 to 16 is automatically unhealthy? “healthy” is such an ambigious term. It can mean whatever we want it to mean cant it?
loading...
Actually, MissMin, you’d be surprised how much difference only a few inches makes. My sister is about 2 and 1/2, maybe 3 inches taller than me. When she was a size 16 she was 96 kilos. When I was a size 16 I was only 70 kilos. That’s a pretty damned big difference.
loading...
“So someone who wears a size 14 to 16 is automatically unhealthy? ”
Unless they’re 5’10 or taller, then usually they are.
loading...
YAY SA WINS
loading...
Wait it moves… come on SA, there’s a bit where the eastern states beat us – we’ve got to work harder!
…or less hard, I guess.
loading...
Just wanted to say how much I enjoyed this post.
Thanks Lara!!
loading...
Oh thanks, I’m glad you enjoyed it.
loading...
I’ve become interested in the “health at every size approach” which advocates that – healthy bodies do come in every shape and size. They aren’t saying that you can eat what you want, but they do go back to the old fashioned advice – eat a diet low in saturated fats and refined sugar, move more, and eat less. As long as all of your predictors for health are good (blood pressure, cholesterol, etc etc) then what size jeans you fit into are irrelevant.
It is very freeing to adopt this kind of mentality. Not easy, but freeing. My focus is on trying to be healthy. I know I need to eat healthily and do exercise to acheive this. By default, I know I will lose weight too. I may not become Miranda Kerr, but if I can run around with my kids without getting tired then that is the goal.
However, I do think as a society our perception of what is normal is getting warped. What is a normal portion size is one big area!!
loading...
I sometimes wonder if the rise in Australia’s collective weight is somehow related to the decline in smoking. I know when I was a smoker 20 years ago I was much thinner. Now of course I’m not suggesting we all take up smoking to reduce waistlines, and I know there are plenty of overweight smokers out there, but I’m genuinely curious. Does anyone know if stats on this exist?
loading...
This just seems like a massive whinge. If a smoker or alcoholic wrote the same things you’d tell them they SHOULD be hearing a lot of loud messages about how bad smoking/booze are for them. Because it’s true. Why is obesity any different?
Plus while you would berate a mate for smoking or boozing too much, as a society we are too polite to directly tell friends/family “your weight is really unhealthy for you” bluntly. Seems the obese are getting off lightly in that regard.
On the other hand, it’s a shame there isn’t better promotion of real proven solutions (such as AA and QUIT programs) to help people with weight issues. Would be nice to see that info, rather than just a whinge.
loading...
Would you bluntly tell a skinny person “your weight is unhealthy for you”? Personally, I’ve actually known more skinny people who were dangerously unhealthy and potentially putting their lives at risk, than people who were dangerously overweight.
You just can’t determine someone’s health by size alone.
loading...
When I was at my thinnest, (still within healthy BMI however) people would often tell me I needed to “go eat a burger”. I was not unhealthily underweight – it’s just my genes. Don’t agree with what Seahorse is saying, but yes, people do bluntly tell thin people they are unhealthy.
loading...
I guess my point was that I don’t think it is fair to tell anyone they are unhealthy based on weight (whether under or over the “average”).
Size is only one factor of health, and not necessarily a determining one!
loading...
Fatties are always telling thin people how lucky they are. I would really piss me off because I was incredibly active and was careful about my diet. Luck had nothing to do with it.
So I’d say, “yeah, it’s so much better than being fat”
Of course the fatties didn’t like that, but they were so self absorbed that they didn’t know they were being offensive.
loading...
I would think that saying someone is “lucky” due to their size is meant more as a compliment as an insult?
As one of those “lucky” people, I probably take it for granted somewhat. But it also means I thankfully don’t have a chip on my shoulder about my weight, which I am only assuming would be the reason you respond so callously in that situation.
And calling people “fatties” is ridiculously insulting.
loading...
I dont think you should berate anybody for anything if you can help it. All you are going to do is come across as one holier than thou little chickie. You dont have the right to judge another.
loading...
What is considered ‘skinny?’ for most of my life I have been about 20.5 on the BMI, and have had to endure unwelcome comments about how thin I am. Including hypothesis (based on nothing by several people) that I have an eating disorder. This is not the case, never has been, and I am tired of assumptions. I am trying to figure out what the perfect ‘medium’ of weight is, so people will leave me alone!
loading...
When I was sick I got very, very tired of people coming up to me, telling me I was too skinny and that I should eat more. It was none of their business, and believe me, I knew full well that I needed to eat more. As if I didn’t know! Eventually I got so sick of it that when someone told me I needed to put on weight my response was ‘How about if I take five kilos off your ass?’ These were total strangers too, not people I knew and loved. People would come up to me in the street and at university.
loading...
Overeaters Anonymous !!
loading...
I got inspired by a free podcast called Fat2Fit radio. Live the lifestyle of the fitter, healthier person you want to become and eventually you get there. Same as what pretty much everyone has said below….stop eating crap and do some moderate exercise. And, given I didn’t get from size 10 to size 16 in a month, allow a decent amount of time for the ‘magic’ to work.
I’m using the My Fitness Pal app too. That’s a good ‘un.
loading...
Yes because if weight loss was as simple as what this article described then the problem of obesity wouldn’t exist.
loading...
Exactly. It’s a pretty complex web. I have a lap-band. I’ve lost about half the weight i would like to, but two years on haven’t put any of that back on (well i did put ten kilos on at one point and was absolutely heartbroken, but managed to get that back off). People think it’s the easy option ( ha ha ha! it’s not trust me), but i know without it there is just no way i would have lost weight and kept it off. I just know it. Getting over the guilt of thinking had made this choice was the hardest part. Why would i choose this life. I don’t care what any of you say about choice. When i realised how much guilt i had been carrying for so long from being overweight, i had a complete emotional breakdown, but from there haven’t looked back. You can make all the simplistic comments in the world, but we all have a problem we just can’t shake – that i have learnt. It’s a long and complex journey for each and every person – and each and every persons journey of recovery from obesity looks different.
I work with drug addicts. Full on criminal ones (that drive me to eat!!) Quite a lot of people who stop using methamphetamines and amphetamines end up putting weight on, and a lot of them face more stigma as overweight people than they did as drug addicts. So to those who say, we pussy foot around overweight people, dont tell them the truth etc, trust me. WE DON’T. They know and get enough abuse.
Also, if there is one thing i have learnt about recovery, focusing on the drug or vice itself (whatever that may be), will never work. EVER. So lovely as this article is, talk to me a few years down the road. Lets see where you’re at then. Hopefully where you want to be, but that won’t happen by focusing on anything to do with food and exercise in my view.
Anyway, like i said, complex. I wish anyone who is struggling with anything all the best. You have my support, faith and goodwill and not my judgement, and that is the first step to getting where you want to go
loading...
Eva, I agree that there is much more to the weight-loss journey than the focus on food and exercise. It is a complex psychological process for many people. This is a light-hearted article but, as you point out, it is a serious subject. I wish you the best of luck with your own journey.
loading...
I agree Alison. The basic equation (energy in vs energy out) is simple, but the social and psychological factors surrounding our ability to strike that balance are very complex indeed.
loading...
From a scientific point of view, it IS that simple (in MOST cases.) It’s the emotional issues attached to food and dieting that seem to make things so complicated.
http://ameliaalisoun.wordpress.com/2012/06/04/food-and-feelings-can-we-ever-learn-to-separate-them/
loading...
Actually, as new research shows, it’s not that easy. A small study in this case but other research is starting to show the same thing.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/01/magazine/tara-parker-pope-fat-trap.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all
This is why it is far more important to focus on health and fitness rather than just your weight.
loading...
Preaching to the choir! All it takes is CLEAN EATING. Not diet eating- CLEAN eating. There is a big difference. I love how you mentioned health not weight-loss. I tell my clients every day to aim for health number one and weight loss will usually follow. The hard part is that so many people think they are already eating well when a lot of the time their diet is full of processed heavy foods (usually labelled as lighter, ‘healthier’ options). Education is the key!
loading...
What is ‘clean’ eating? Not eating processed foods?
loading...
Pretty much. Just trying to maximise the amount of natural, fresh foods and limit the stuff with labels. As lame as it sounds (and I try not to say this much) its more of a lifestyle switch. No one can stick to diets but if you just swap your foods for fresh alternatives as much as possible you’ll feel a lot better. No ones perfect but if you live everyday eating clean your body will thank you for it (and you’ll feel pretty shite when you eat something really processed).
loading...
If only it was as easy as the ‘celebrities’ make seem, and they all seem to say they breastfed and their bodies bounced back ( in six bloody weeks). I know all the right thongs I should be doing, but after looking after the needs of my four kids and husband plus various animals, I’m too knackered to pound the pavement or prepare a balanced low fat meal. Cop out maybe, but more just pure exhaustion. One day I hope to put myself back towards the top f the list but until then, I’m raising 4 happy and very healthy, active children who follow all the things I should o myself and eat lots of everyday food balanced with sometimes food. No good bad or reward food in my house, just not much packaged processed food. One day I’ll about face and follow their example. Great article, I might put it on a tee shirt to wear until the day I do!
loading...
Anonymous, it sounds like you do have a lot on your plate but it all works hand in hand. By putting your own needs first by exercising regularly and eating healthy, lean food and taking some time out for yourself (even tiny amounts), it would become so much easier to perform all your mum duties.
I used to be exactly the same as you. I always put my family first and although, I was incredibly strict with my childrens’ diets and their physical activity I neglected myself by eating substandard meals on the run and not exercising. One day I decided enough was enough and started to look after myself first. As a result, I have more energy than ever, get sick less often, we ALL eat well and I don’t seem to need as much sleep. I am happier and healthier and setting a good example for my children.
Every time I hear women say that they don’t have time or they’re too exhausted to eat well or exercise, I want to shout my own story from the rooftops but don’t want to come across as preachy. I recognise that you need to be in the right headspace and want to make the necessary changes but I also know that the sooner you make those changes, the easier it will become in the overall picture!
loading...
I hear you and I am one of the first people to tell my friends that exact thing, but my fourth bub was (& still is more often than not) not a very settled baby. I tried exercising with him in a sling, two in the double pram and the eldest on a bike but it was too difficult. Im lucky to get 4 hours of broken sleep, it was only a couple for the first year, so even walking is just too much right npw. I don’t have family nearby to help out so I do my best until then. I know I would be a better mum if I were healthier but when my only time out is grocery shopping, you take and do what you can. Glad you have got it sorted though, good luck with yours.
loading...
I think one of the important things to remember is that not everyone processes calories the same. I have some friends who would have to spend 2 hours at the gym and eat next to nothing to reach an “ideal” weight. Quite often, this means they’re not getting enough nutrients each day and their mental health suffers.
For these people, a BMI which is classified as overweight is actually the healthiest for them. Yet they still get judged and told to lose weight.
loading...
I am one of those who needs to eat virtually nothing and exercise excessively to be ‘thin’. I can, however, eat properly and exercise moderately and be a size 14. I’m healthy & happy at that size.
Being healthy is more important to me than being a certain size and I’m guided by my doctor in this regard.
loading...
That infographic, and the statistics, suck.
They’re usually based on BMI, which is pretty much proven to be complete nonsense as a health-future predictor.
All the BMI tells you is what a population’s mass is compared to their height. (Which is not a great indicator of how healthy a person is!)
People should look to way more than their weight to know how healthy they are. Yup, what you eat and how you exercise are important, but some thin people can eat McDonalds 24/7 and sit in front of the couch, and some bigger people can eat nothing but non-starchy vegetables and go to the gym every day and still *look* fat (AND still be “overweight” according to the BMI).
But Laura is exactly right… fat people are our own worst critics. And the pressure out there on fat people really sucks. I can’t count the amount of times I’ve burst into tears because of something someone has said, even not directed at me… just because it’s so insensitive.
Yup, I’m losing weight (although I’m doing it the super expensive way with Jenny Craig – it is working, and I think I am learning *how* to eat as well as losing weight), but I felt shamed into doing it.
Shouldn’t weight loss and getting healthy be something we should get excited about, rather than getting shamed into???
loading...
I agree. Wouldn’t it be lovely if we all felt so great about our bodies that we couldn’t wait to feed ourselves nourishing food and enjoy the benefits of activity – rather than feeling shamed into doing it. I’m not sure how we reach that point though!
loading...
Think it’s pretty tricky to get to that point … because it’s easy to get excited about delicious food, it’s a short term reward.
But we have to put in a lot of effort in the long term to achieve a body that does what we want it to and looks the way we’d prefer.
I’ve never been able to make myself exercise for the sake of being healthy, but it helps if I attach a short term reward to the act. Something like the mental silence that I get from swimming, or the chance to listen to a whole podcast while going for a walk, or a chance to hang out with my kids or the dog while walking or bike riding, etc.
loading...
I completely agree with the majority of that argument. Yes there is a whole lot if conflicting information and too many people are willing to judge others rather than fix the cracks in their own lives. I am however married to a personal trainer and take good care in looking after myself and everyday I see all the political correctness that we can’t use the word fat! If someone calls me skinny it is still judging so why only allow it one way.
Good on you though for being proud of what you have achieved! Its not about being size 6, it’s about being happy & healthy!
loading...
Great article, Lara.
loading...
Yay! A health related post on Mamamia. Ok you’ve come about it with a slight body image angle but I’ll take it! More please!
loading...
I think a major point of changing an unhealthy lifestyle that is often overlooked is educating yourself on portion control. If you eat a huge amount of healthy food you’re most probably not going expend all the necessary calories to obtain/maintain a healthy weight.
Also, unlike smoking (which you can see people doing), you can’t really get a good idea of how healthy someone is by the way they look eg I have never been bigger than a size 8-10 but I have also never been able to run 2km or even get through one 30 minute beginner’s workout on the Nike training app without taking a break (yes, Beginners!!!) and yet no-one has ever berated me about being “unhealthy”. Looks are deceiving people!
loading...
I’m with you one both counts! My sister is a dietician, and I’m Obese (but not for much longer – HOORAY!!!) I was complaining to her that when I started getting serious about getting back into shape I realised that I had no idea about what my portions should look like. I still can’t convince DH that I’d like a ‘portion’ of ice-cream at night! As I go on in my slow drive for a healthier me I find that I am now naturally defaulting to much healthier portions. I have rewired my brain.
As far as the exercise business, I’m actually quite fit and have excellent endurance, but to look at me you’d assume that my endurance relates to movie marathons and popcorn.
While calories in/out makes sense, the total equation is more complex.
loading...
Love this article! So sick of people judging the outside and concentrating on appearance rather than behaviour.
Let’s learn to love our bodies. Also love the work that bodymatters is doing- check out: http://www.ditchingdieting.com
loading...
Thanks Justagirl. Yep, health should absolutely be our priority, but I’d love to see people getting healthy within a supportive, non-judgemental community.
loading...
Completely agree – just as long as getting healthy isn’t equated with getting thinner!
As one who has struggled with an eating disorder that left me underweight, the focus on being skinny that our society has is really unhelpful.
I wish we could all learn to exercise for the joy of moving our bodies and testing our skill, to neither starve nor stuff our feelings with food and to be mindful and supportive of others. Don’t just meet for a coffee – enjoy a walk outside before grabbing a drink. Bush walk and enjoy the beauty of this country. Eat good, wholesome food.
loading...
Well said
loading...
I do not think people should berate their friends for being overweight, like people do with smoking. Smoking is more simple to criticize because it focuses purely on health, not the way a person looks.
Honestly, though, I do wish that more people would adopt a healthy lifestyle. Make walks part of the daily routine. Pack lunches to work. And most of all, make time to feed your children a healthy meal!! What can be more important than that? Fresh fruit does not break the bank. My grocery bill is much higher on days where I include meat and chips.
I gained 50 pounds when pregnant and afterwards was considered overweight. I indulged when I was pregnant, and I shouldn’t have. After my son was born, I didnt feel healthy. However, eating plenty of fruits and veg and walking everyday with my baby allowed me to get back to my original weight in 6 months. Simple, but it absolutely works.
loading...
Great article! Everybody’s wasting taxpayer’s money in some way.
The couples who choose to have four children. Smokers. Drinkers. People who drive cars, and thus need taxes to pay for roads as well as hospitals after car accidents. I could go on forever.
Even the people who are just unhealthy enough to have untreated high blood pressure for much of their life (which can happen without being overweight) – hypertension causes heart failure, which costs more to treat than most common cancers and more to treat than a motor vehicle accident.
To the journalists who like to imply that fat people are wasting taxpayers money … I’m here as a thin person to tell you that I’ll happily pay for their bypass surgery! Because taxes and society are about helping each other. Anyone that begrudges that can go see how warm their money keeps them at night.
loading...
Excuse me, the people who choose to have four children? I can tell you my husband and I contribute a massive amount of taxes from our small business that makes us wonder why the heck we do it. Sorry, but that just isn’t as cut and dried as a smoker or drinker.
loading...
I wasn’t trying to offend anyone, Anonymous.
My point was that I’m happy to pay taxes for whatever it happens to be that individuals need in society, and that we shouldn’t judge one group as being more deserving and another as less deserving. I’m just as happy for my tax dollars to go towards yours (and my) cost of raising kids as caring for people with weight related health issues
I’m also happy to pay for healthcare for smokers and drinkers, because addiction is hard to deal with and I don’t want people to be out in the cold because they’ve managed to get stuck with it. Same for being overweight, which has many parallels with addiction. All of these things are about the choices we make, and the fact that society puts out its hand to help people who have some sort of need.
loading...
I find it so silly when people do the taxpayer whinge! Don’t far people pay tax?
loading...
Lara with the greatest of respect – anyone with Dr before their name should be smart enough to know that a proper diet and some exercise will help you lose weight. Its called eating properly – theres no magic to it. The formula has been around for years. Its the self discipline that goes with it thats required and is the much harder part.
loading...
I think that’s kind of the point, Anonymous…
loading...
Thanks ‘Anonymous’. I agree, it seems like the most obvious thing in the world, doesn’t it? I guess the point I was trying to make was that it can be a difficult journey for some, and particularly when I was a teen/early twenties (long before the PhD), the mixed messages from advertising and even from health professionals were overwhelming. As I said, I 100% agree that we should all be taking responsiblity for our own health – I just don’t think everyone responds positively to being made to feel bad about themselves.
loading...
the messages from advertising are surely ones that any intelligent person is able to decode – they are just trying to sell you something. I also think that any GP who prescribes medication for weight loss should be questioned. These things don’t work. Doesn’t everyone know that? I am still baffled by how very obvious this all seems.
loading...
New research has shown it is not just about energy in, energy out. My two children eat the same, are both active. They are completely different body shapes. I also recall reading that women are actually most fertile at 15% above their supposed “ideal weight”. ideal for who?
loading...
Well actually if you’re exercising regularly, you’ll probably gain muscle which will cause you to gain weight
loading...
You’re right Anonymous, it’s a simple formula and not rocket science – pretty damn obvious really. But even in my circle of friends, it’s amazing how regularly it gets overlooked in favor of “all or nothing”: either pig out on every bad food imaginable, or realise its time to lose weight and get stuck into the diet pills, weight-loss tea, the amazing diet where you eat nothing except protein….etc. It’s as though healthy eating alone is simply not an option that’s even considered! I don’t think self-discipline is an issue in these cases; rather it seems to be misunderstanding or a loss of touch with normal eating patterns.
Some of the unhealthiest attitudes to food and weight have come from friends whose own mothers were constantly ‘on a diet’ while they were growing up. Therefore I think it’s really important that this simple message/formula is pushed and pushed. It seems simple to us, but a lot of people get seduced by the advertising industry and buy into this ridiculous notion that ‘diet products’ are necessary for weight loss.
loading...