by KATE HUNTER
Last Monday, my friend Lou asked me over for lunch, ‘We’ll be healthy,’ she said, ‘I’ll cook you an nice piece of salmon.’
‘Lou,’ I replied, ‘We’ve known each other since we were seven. Have you ever seen me eat fish?’
‘Oh my God!’ she said, ‘Are you allergic?’
‘No,’ I replied, ‘I just don’t like it.’
There was a silence. Lou couldn’t have been more shocked if I’d told her I was actually a man and had been since primary school.
‘What if I make a nice soy dressing?’
‘No, really. I’d prefer a cheese sandwich.’
‘How can you not like fish? Did you have some off sushi once? Maybe you choked on a bone?’ Lou persisted.
‘No. I just don’t like the taste. It’s so … fishy. It makes me gag.’
It was beyond her comprehension. To Lou, fish is a treat, a luxury. I’ve tried to appreciate it, but I can’t.
Sometimes people will offer me some white fish – saying it doesn’t taste fishy.
‘What’s the point of that?’ I say, ‘If it’s not fishy, why are we eating it? Even the most unfishy fish will be fishier than chicken, so can I have some of that please?
I hate being like this. It’s so unsophisticated to not like fish. I’ve been to barbecues where my hosts have splashed out on a whole side of salmon but I blush and say I’d prefer one of the kids’ sausages.
I’ve been Barramundi fishing in the Northern Territory but ate bread and salad instead of the day’s catch.
At a pinch, I can choke down a prawn, but an oyster is my worst nightmare. I see an oyster and all I think is, ‘ear infection.’
Who knows where this aversion to fish comes from? My parents are big on it. Mum even likes tinned fish, which to me is cat food with fancy labels.
My husband likes fish and our kids are keen. I’ve tried not to pass my fishism onto them, but I do most of the cooking so it’s rarely seen at our table. If I go away though, it’s a fish-fest at our place. Every night is like the seafood buffet at an RSL.
I’ve come to terms with the way I am. My husband and kids accept it – why can’t the rest of the world?
Jamie Oliver jeers at people who don’t like fish. In his second book, he refers to them as, ‘Cranky buggers who haven’t tried beautiful fresh fish, properly cooked.’
I love Jamie, but I sometimes want to smack him. I don’t care whether the trout is so fresh it’s still gasping for air as he pan fries it, it’s still a trout and its troutness is what I don’t like. So f*ck off, Jamie, and cook me a chop why don’t you?
Still, I realize the fault lies with me. Not the fish or the people who catch and cook them. It’s a failing; a flaw. It’s something I wish I could overcome, but at my age it’s unlikely.
I know it’s sad I get my Omega 3 from a capsule (odorless).
It’s a shame I’ll never be friends with the local fishmonger (as recommended by every food writer ever). But on that – the suffix ‘monger’ is rarely positive is it? … ‘Fear-monger’, ‘rumor-monger’. The fish marketing people should address this.
Not that it would help me.
All I’m asking for is understanding.
If I politely decline your offer of a grilled sardine, please don’t try to sell me on it.
If we eat at a sushi bar, it would be tops if you didn’t announce to the whole place that I’m sticking to the egg nigiri.
Not liking fish is a burden, yes, but I try to carry it with dignity.
Is there something you just can’t eat that most people love? How do you explain it?









Comments
211 Comments so far
I can not eat spicy food. Most of my family and friends know this yet they still try and make me eat it. There is nothing worse than when we get invited to an Indian restaurant for dinner, I eat a lot of rice! People just don’t seem to understand I don’t like it, I don’t even taste anything I just get this burning sensation in my mouth and throat.
loading...
Your lack of sophistication shocks me! I had no idea….
Having said that, I feel the same way about tofu, but unlike you I’m not brave enough to tell any of my friends and so I suffer in silence.
loading...
But Renee, no one ever says, “i’ve got a glorious piece of Tofu for tonight’s dinner party!’
loading...
I like most things, and will always try stuff. If you at least try stuff, I don’t mind if you don’t like it.
My things are:
Mango (UNAUSTRAYAN!!!!)
Cucumber – tastes like yuck nothing, waste of space.
Tropical fruits in general – hate melon of any kind, rambutans, jackfruit, kiwifruit. I do like starfruit and bananas though. Cold climate fruits for me, please!
Aniseed flavours – fennel (in friggen everything at the moment. WHY???), dill (friggen same as fennel), um, aniseed, sambucca, All revolting.
I think that’s it.
loading...
With the exception of cucumber, which I’m a bit meh about, you’ve picked pretty much a lot of food I love.
loading...
Yeah, it’s strange – Mum loves (apart from cucumber) all the stuff I listed there (well, not fennel, but she likes aniseed, like licorice and stuff).
I love a lot of stuff she hates, too – mushrooms, rare meat, seafood, parsley, lemon (like strong lemon – she doesn’t like it much). I think Dad also dislikes similar stuff to me.
loading...
I’m glad I’m not the only one who is made to feel this way
loading...
Hooray!!! Someone who gets me. I dont like fish either. Never have. The smell and the taste – yuk! People always ‘try’ to convince me that I just havent had it cooked properly or their fish will convince me that it is really nice.
I would never try and convince someone to eat brains or kidneys or liver, so why do people think its ok to try and convince me to eat fish???
So when we have group dinners organised and someone, who I have usually known for years, books the seafood restaurant I always just go along with it because I can always get steak or chicken at a seafood place. And then when they want to order a massive platter for the whole table to share, I then have to say count me out, I’m ordering a steak. And then end up being the brunt of the jokes about being the freak who orders steak at a seafood restaurant!
I wouldnt do that to a vegetarian so why do they pick on the non fish eater?
loading...
And yes!! Tuna is cat food. I used to work with a woman who had a tuna sandwiches for lunch every day and the smell made me heave.
loading...
I love fish and seafood, but I don’t really like tuna and salmon. It’s too heavy and rich. I would order pretty much everything else before getting either of those two.
loading...