Do You Like This Story?
aww birthday cakes How far do you go for a birthday cake?

Bring back some memories?

 

 

 

 

Each year, a month before our birthdays we were allowed to pull a chair up to the pantry. On the fifth shelf, behind some stray party hats and slumping candles was The Book.

To me and my sister the magic of birthdays came straight from the Women’s Weekly Birthday Cake Book.

Once we’d brought the book down we’d start thumbing through the pages.

There was the typewriter and the race track. The swimming pool with green jelly and a ladder made from liquorice rope.  There was the slightly disturbing duckling (with the ruffled potato crisps as its bill) and the pistachio hued shark with its kind eyes and big grin.

I’m not sure we ever really chose a cake for what it represented.  I think we picked them based on how many lollies could be stuck to the icing.  I know that was my rationale for choosing the dump truck with its sticky cargo and mint slices for wheels.

It was only years later in a fit of nostalgia when I was surfing through the rather brilliant facebook group  ‘The Women’s Weekly Birthday Cake book is awesome’ that I realised we hadn’t had the full book.

I don’t remember the sweets shop. Or the train.  I definitely would have chosen the train.

It turns out there were certain pages that were glued together. Our book was censored to protect my mother’s sanity.

My mother is not what you would call a baker. She worked in kid’s hospital. She took care of premature babies. She has a mean backhand on a tennis court. She is patient beyond belief. She is kind.  And every year our birthdays must have been a living nightmare.

I remember the deep breaths and half grimaces when we pointed at certain cakes, excitedly placing our requests. Yet no matter what we asked for, she never said no.

There were some tricks she picked up along the way; cutting a cold cake meant  less crumbling than cutting a warm one. The same thing went with icing- if the cake spent a little in the fridge or freezer then fewer crumbs were dredged through the sweet stuff.  A wet flat knife also helped.

She also maintains that she soon learned we never really ate the cake, so she started buying  sponges from a supermarket.  She says their cakes were straighter too.

When assembling them she rationalised  that skewers worked like surgical pins on broken bones, giving extra support where it might be needed.  A musk stick alone should not be trusted to support the top of a sewing box.  And having toothpicks stick  up out from the icing meant Glad Wrap could swoop over the top like a protective canopy, and not blur it like a burns bandage.

castle cake 214x300 How far do you go for a birthday cake?

.

But it was the candy castle, with upturned ice cream cones, deckled with meringue icing  that finally broke her and left her sobbing in the kitchen.

It was a hot day. The icing wouldn’t stick. It trickled and puddled, helped downwards  by the steep slopes  of the cones. She went through two dozen eggs trying to get it right.  In the photos of my sister’s 6h birthday party, she looks a little more tired than usual.

The next year, I chose a flat pink number five, from the newly censored book . We decorated  it with flowers. The petals were cut from white marshmallows and there were smarties for their centres.

It turns out that Women’s Weekly are reprinting the book. My mother still has her original copy- complete with scabs of icing sugar on the pages that aren’t glued together. She’s offered to hand it down to me when my turn comes.  She’s even offered to help separate the pages out, so there’s the full book to choose from.

Now I’m ok with learning what the symptoms of Meningococcal look like.  I think I’ll be ok helping a little one learn long division and even finding school shoes that will fit.

But birthday party cakes?

I’m just not sure if I’m ready for that kind of responsibility.

I think we might need to open this one up to group therapy.

Best cakes. Worst cakes. Biggest failures. Greatest triumphs. Let it out. And don’t forget to add your photos.

Just how bad is this going to be?

And er, don’t even try to compare to this one

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)
*

293 Comments so far

  1. cjwebbly

    I LOVE baking! And I love decorating my creations. This is my latest one, for my brother’s girlfriend’s 18th. The frosting took quite a while and she loved it!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. kirstys

    My Dad was the cake decorator in our family. He bought slabs of sponge and then cut and decorated them. I think it took him three attempts to get my swimming pool cake – if you cut too much cake out then the weight of the jelly will make the sides collapse… and only add the people/rafts/balls at the last moment or they’ll sink. I remember him doing the castle for me as well, with him sitting there patiently with a matchbox to cut the bricks into the icing. He did cakes for several neighbours as well – it took quite a few skewers to keep the ducks head on (and the ribbon hides fingerprints in the icing from having to put the head back on several times) and you only do the train cake if you have quite a few people to feed or like eating dry birthday cake for several days afterwards. :) Ahhh, memories!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Kris2040

    I’ve decided that I’m going to give Hoot a go for KDot’s first birthday (it’s 3 months away, but I’m keeping my eyes open now). I have a great ABC Kids cake book, but it doesn’t have Hoot! Lots of people have done Hoot cakes though. There are some amazing and frankly ridiculously OTT parties and cakes on the interwebs!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Jen

    I LOVE making my kids awesome birthday cakes, AWW cookbook rules, can’t go past their fun cakes and easy recipes. Still like to put a bit of imagination into it sometimes…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. JL

    My cakes have and always will be amazing!! My Mum is a cake decorator and a very talented one that enjoys what she does and always has. Our birthday cakes we from the womans weekly book only cos we really wanted them and she always made them better than what the book picture looked like…now, i have my own child, she makes even better cakes for him as she is in love with him and he nearly faints at the site of a Thomas cake. They are so yum and everyone is always very excited to see what she will create! Even dinner at Mum’s we get amazing looking cupcakes and cookies….I am very spoilt when it comes to cakes! It just feels like your birthday when you see that cake that mum has put all that love and energy into!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. Sarah

    I love to bake, but I remember a few years back making my dad a birthday cake. It started off well until I didn’t put greaseproof in the bottom of the two cake tins (it was a two-tiered cake).
    It ended up in pieces, and I had to kind of paste it back together with icing.
    disaster to say the least, and plenty of tears while it was all happening.
    I’ve since stuck to birthday/baby shower/party cupcakes. way safer.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Jess

    ahhh, the reprint. After years of putting up with me saying *can I have my inheritance yet, or do I have to wait until you die* (because i am that charming), mum bought me the reprint!. for my 29th birthday I made myself the log cake, because mum would never make it for me. I ate all the flakes and threw away the cake (guess, i never grew up!). I made a Dolly Varden for my daughter – another cake I had spent years coveting to no avail. Mum made the ghost one year – but turned it into a ghostbusters cake. My daughter now spends her days (months) leading up to birthdays putting in her cake requests. as there are only two of us, and her birthday is in summer, there are limits to how far I am willing to go. Birthday parties are required to make the bigger ones! But, child is like mother. she definitely picks cakes based on their decoration as opposed to anything else…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Megan

    I work at a bowling alley and some mothers bring in the most amazing homemade cakes for their child’s birthday party.
    For my 18th last year we just bought a cake.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. Jess

    Love ALL cakes, just made some divine Red Velvet Cupcakes that could easily be served as b’day cakes at any party – they are bright red and fun, and taste super yummy! Check out the recipe and some pics here:

    http://www.cocoandarchie.blogspot.com

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Trying to bake cakes

    These are 2 cakes i have made in the last year. I must tell you all i am not a baker at all, so am very proud of my efforts

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Trying to bake cakes

      Oppps only could do one at a time.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  11. Anonymous

    My sister and i would do the same, each year pick out a cake from this book. And now my own children are doing the same, i am going to attempt the train in August for my 2yo son.
    When i was 3 I(i think) i requested the Fluffy Duck. Mum was brilliant at cake making, including making and icing her own wedding cake!!!!
    My Mum has always said it was really diffucult and was so tricky trying to find 2 perfect chips for the mouth. And now my soon to be 5yo son has requested this exact cake. I have infomed my Mum that she will be coming for a visit to help me..LOL karma!!!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. just a girl

    my late mother was BRILLIANT at making the cakes from this cookbook! Every year my brother and sisters were allowed to choose a cake for our birthdays for my mum to somehow make!
    this one is from my 5th birthday- she said it was the best one she had ever made.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Stormgirl1960

      My mother made this one recently for my sister. She has just turned 50 and barracks for Richmond. (and yes I know it is a lion and Richmond are the Tigers.) She did a great job and my sister loved it.
      I have this book and my children spent the month (at least) prior to their birthday choosing their cake for that year. Some of the pages have the child’s name written on them. With 4 children, quite a few of them were attempted, sometimes successfully. My grandchildren now do the same to their mums, who do a great job of decorating the cakes the way the kids want. Some cakes are more of a challenge than others. I always did the number 1 cake which was pretty simple; but the robot cake was the most difficult one I did, then after all the effort involved, I forgot to take a photo of it. Damn!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  13. RetroPastiche

    I made the piano cake for my 16th birthday. My birthday was on a Friday and Mum told me on the Thursday night that because I spent Friday night to Sunday afternoon at my father’s house if I wanted a birthday cake for Sunday I would have to make it myself. I spent all night in tears because I really wanted a proper 16th birthday as I was convinced all my friends were having them… poor me *sob*.

    The cake turned out beautifully (I’m the only person in the family who can make proper whipped icing now my Grandmother has passed away). I also made a tiny flute to sit on top of the piano (because I played both instruments). I was still weeping at the thought it would sit in the fridge for the weekend but at least I’d have a cake for my late birthday dinner.

    6am on Friday morning and I get out of the shower, wrap in a towel and walk back into my bedroom to find about 12 of my school friends sitting on my bed shouting ‘happy birthday!!!!’. My mum and my best friend had cooked up a surprise birthday breakfast party, all the girls were dropped at my friend’s house up the road before dawn, and came down the hill to a feast of pancakes, bacon, eggs, sparkling water and OJ and, of course, piano cake! It was such an amazing day, and I still have a massive guilt trip about the angst I put my mum through the night before.

    Amazingly, she repeated the event for my 21st birthday, except that was with champagne ;-)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • sailorgirl

      awesome! I loooooove the piano cake.. makes me wanna buy the book just for that picture

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  14. Jayne

    Ahhh i loved that book too! Huge memories come back just from looking at it! I was fond of the ‘number’ cakes. I have a twin brother too so we had two amazing cakes each year. My poor mum!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Flipfeet

    Ha, ha, the memories. Mum would always do one for us with usually quite good outcomes.

    My eldest son turned 4 last year. Previously, as a FT working mum I outsourced cakes (thank you Donut King) and parties. But 4 saw my mini-me(read: clear in opinion lol)-pirate-obsessed first born INSIST on a pirate ship cake in, wait for it, black.

    Here is the result (whole container of Wilton’s black gel = weird taste). Think the parents hated me (you should have seen the mess and the sugar buzz this made) but son was thrilled. I did it for this reason, but also a bit out of working mummy guilt :S

    My husband says I have screwed myself over by setting the bar too high…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nicky Champ

      That is awesome Flipfeet!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • chellebelle

      W O W

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Holly

      Flipfeet I made this exact same cake recently for my son’s 4th birthday, except with brown chocolate icing! I think I made it for the same reasons as you and yes I agree with your husband, I think I have screwed myself over too – am now dreading birthday number 5!! Great cake though, his little friends loved it :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Kyra

      That’s exactly what my husband said to me when I made that for one of our boys. The other parents at the party looked at me like I was evil for “upping the anty” for cakes, but my son loved it, and now he’s too old to care about birthday cakes!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  16. Cam

    I just love making the kids cakes – they are no where near perfect but I have a ball! My secret? I get a friend over the night before, open a good bottle of wine and start the baking. We’ve been doing it for five years now and we have a blast – certainly helped along by some wine and way too much sugar!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. chellebelle

    I am sooo thankful to be married to an engineer who loves to create things. Last year our then 3-year old asked for a digger cake. Hubby made one up – and boy was it impressive! It’s that time of year again, and this time our soon-to-be 4 yo has asked for a “wrecking ball crane knocking down a building”. Hubby has cheerfully agreed. Love it!! (yes, I know how lucky I am, especially as I am atrocious at baking)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Silverdragon

      That’s awesome!! I love that he makes them up from scratch – good for him (and you)!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Nicky Champ

      Can’t wait to see the wrecking ball cake!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • chellebelle

        Ne either Nicky! He had a practice run this arvo making trusses out of pretzel sticks and melted chocolate. The party is in 3 weeks so I’ll post a pic after that!

        Yep Silverdragon, it’s amazing to me how he just has an idea in his head and produces something so realistic. I’m soooo grateful he’s up for it!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  18. Anonymous

    Thought I’d just quickly post a pic of the Castle Cake! Wasn’t easy, but came out looking okay, I think. :) Miss 5 certainly loved it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • whatahooha

      and just to drop the bar a little… another 5 year old’s cacstle cake

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  19. Helen

    ahhh..memories of me making the dolly vardin birthday cake for my daughter’s 6th birthday. I remember my delight in sawing in half a barbie doll…she had such sly eyes so it was case of good riddance from the toy box!
    And yes I did the train for my son …even baked the cakes…it requires lots of cakes! I wonder if they remember and I hope they cared!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. Ivorybub

    I get so stressed over the expectations of the birthday cake! My daughter is now 2 and doesn’t even eat cake but yet I spend weeks researching, deliberating, planning and then changing my mind at the very last minute. Thank you Nigella Lawson and Maggie Beer for the last two years of yummy cake, good for eating but not so entertaining to look at. I thought about Maisy Mouse for this year but was convinced Miss 2 would cry at the sight of a knife going into her favourite character.
    I’m sure my baking will evolve when the parties are for the children and not for the adults.
    I take my hat off to you talented bug/castle/mermaid cake making parents.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. Bookworm

    This was my latest one for my son’s 6th bday. Even though I bought the expensive red gel colouring from the cake shop it still didn’t turn the icing red. So at midnight, faced with pink colouring, I used all the blue colouring I had to turn it purple instead. I think it still turned out ok. :-)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  22. Bookworm

    I’ve got the WW cake book, and even through it’s ridiculously stressful, I soldier on with them. I think in a way its me trying to say “even though I’m a single parent I can still make something good” (as long as my parents are around to mind the kids most of the day and leave me in the kitchen!).
    I do feel a bit proud of my efforts though. :-)

    This was the first one I tried:

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Ann

    I had such a nightmare with my son’s last cake… so bad in fact that I wrote about it as therapy! (http://myvillalife.blogspot.com/2011/02/diary-of-crazed-cake-decorator.html).

    But I will never learn… I have just bought the reprinted Women’s Weekly Cake book and I’m sure next year I’ll think, ‘oh sure, easy, I’ll make that one!’

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. Faybian

    1. I. hate. this. dad……. (the angry birds cake)
    2. I never showed my kids an AWW cake recipe book when they were young, they were happy with what they got.
    3. I didn’t have the money, time, or more importantly, the inclination for the effort that goes into one of these cakes.
    4. Everyone else’s photos look lovely.
    5. I give up, I fail at birthday cakes

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Trina

      I don’t even try! I have 2 cake makers in the family that do them for my little girls. Saves me the time and effort!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  25. TF

    I love te AWW Kids Birthday Cake Cook Book. I brought one a couple of years ago and I knew it wasn’t the real thing – just an abridged version of the original. But I had to. Miss 4 was about to celebrate her first birthday and Mum couldn’t find her much loved and well used 40 year old copy. I’m so excited the original is coming back. Can’t wait to get my copy. So far I’ve made:
    Flutterby
    Hickory Dickory Dock (Mum made it from memory as this one isn’t in the new book)
    Dorothy the Dinosaur (using the net for help on this one)
    Cinderella (Dolly Varden with blue icing and Cinderella instead of Barbie)
    Lady Bug
    Dora (helped by the net again)

    The best thing – staying up til late the night before and snacking on icing, leftover lollies and cake offcuts!!! Oh, and seeing the joy on my Kid’s faces!

    But… can someone please tell me where to buy black food colouring in Bris? I’ve tried all the Supermarkets and a few speciality stores. I’ve resort to using dark choc but it’s not the same.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Is there a Your Habitat shop is Brisbane? If so they sell gel colours that are expensive, but the black is pretty good if a little disturbing.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • anonymous

      YOu need to use gel or powder colourings to get black, and to get these you need to go to a cake decorating shop. Supermarkets only sell the liquid stuff. Most cake decorating places also sell pre-made, ready to roll black icing. Same with red. If you use the liquid, it will be more a dark pink colour, unless you use the whole bottle which seems to change the consistency of the icing.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Silverdragon

      TF – try online for the black icing – there are lots of good cake decoration suppliers around now.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  26. paul

    my mother made me so many of these cakes!!!!
    the typewriter
    the piano
    the ghost with eggshell eyes
    one year i wanted the train but she got sick and couldnt do it :(
    but i love this book

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. ellajean

    Well it is official i am a BAD mother…My cakes may taste nice,,but they never ever look good…I refuse to show my girls that book,,,cause it would be a major fail if i attempted any of them…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. cleo

    LOVE the WW cake book! A big hit in our house and inspirational for other versions of cake as well. Mini cleo had this mermaid one for her 4th birthday. Love all the photos on this post as well. xoxo

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. Tilly

    The candy castle cake was recently recreated by my awesome mum for my 30th birthday. It was every bit as awesome as I remember 26 years before. Thanks mum!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. Melissa J

    Holy moly the photos of cakes here are amazing!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  31. traibe

    we make the kids cakes every year from this book and we all LOVE IT. so many childhood memories of my own – and now for our kids too. Check out my sons 1st bday cake (Our version of the pool cake). It was a huge hit with kids and adults alike!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • traibe

      and the WW helicopter (in pink) for our daughters 2nd bday – she was obsessed with helicopters at the time!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  32. Flutterby

    I have all boys and they tend to get over cute cakes really fast.

    I made a golf cake once, complete with bunkers, parsley trees, green, rough and bunkers.

    Birthdays are usually cupcakes which taste delicious and the kids decorate with dinosaurs or other hard decorations.

    Other times, it’s been a beautiful chocolate cake or sponge from the local bakery. The best gift I’ve ever given myself is to be gentle on myself and not compete with other mums or what I think a mum should do.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  33. kateb

    I must have had the wrong idea!!! I thought it was more fun to make and who cared how perfect it was afterwards. My sons are now in their 30′s but cake making was a family event. They would spend days choosing what they wanted and working out what they could use that was easier than the picture, yes cold cakes were easier to cut. We had no air conditioner, I worked full time, and my husband would join in, in fact he was the best at keeping things straight. Keeping the cake over night from cockroaches and mice was the hardest bit( we were on a farm). I must get the new book to start doing things with grandchildren , I lost the first book to the first family of grandkids.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. jo

    I also grew up with the WW books, but with no kids or nieces/nephews I had forgotten how wonderful these birthday cakes are. Thanks to everyone who shared their photos below – this has really put a smile into my weekend!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. ClaireC

    I was feeling pretty smug about my cake making abilities until I saw the photos below!

    I too grew up on the WW cake book. I saw a poster for it in the newsagent’s window last week, I think it has reached perhaps it’s 25th anniversary and has been rereleased. I love how the cakes are not Donna Hay perfect in it; the icing is a bit dodgy in some places, the lollies a bit skew, it makes them seem more achievable.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. Ellie

    My mum made us spectacular cakes until my 4th birthday when she realised we never actually ate the cake and that a bunch of 3 and 4 year olds won’t look at a cake first before they smear it on one anothers faces. The magnificent barbie skirt was my last cake!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. Ella

    We grew up with this book as well, I have great memories of the pig and the duck and to many numbers to count. I recently recieved a copy from my mother in law as a gift, I love the fact that she took the time to add a photo of my husband on each of his birthdays with the cakes she had made. The poor man was never allowed to have the train … This might explain why I was in tears making the front cover train for his 30th this year and yes a picture was taken and added to the book.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  38. Kimbo

    The cake making is the highlight of my daughter’s birthday for me cause it brings her so much joy:)
    I did the toadstool for her 1st birthday, the ladybird for her 2nd and a dora princess castle for her 3rd.
    May have to go more simple this year as I will be due to give birth very close to her 4th birthday.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kimbo

      the ladybird

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kimbo

        the castle that nearly killed:)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  39. Tammylyn

    I never had that book or got fancy cakes as a kid but have discovered a love of decorating (only a few times a year though)!! This was my first ever fondant cake for my son’s 1st Birthday, helped along by a LOT of internet research on the how to’s and where for’s!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Tammylyn

      This one I did for my Niece’s 10th Birthday, colours were her choice.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Tammylyn

        Last one I did for my nephew’s 6th birthday. This I had to repeat for another nephew a few months later and for some reason the second one caused me no end of grief!!! I think the heat had something to do with it but by the end there were tufts of my hair scattered all over the floor!!!!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • LittleMissSunshine

          Tammylyn, your cakes are freaking amazing!! So awesome!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Tammylyn

            Thank you LittleMissSunshine!! They took a lot of time but were absolutely worth the effort! Admittedly I’ve lost some of the enthusiasm I had when I first started doing cakes but it’s such a joy to see the kids faces light up when they see them that I will continue to put myself through the ordeal of it until they are much older!!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
    • Faybian

      Gorgeous! Well done

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Silverdragon

      Fondant gives you such a professional finish and is really much easier to work with than you think. Your cakes look great and your family is very lucky you make for them. I think I’ll use fondant next year – buttercream icing can be such a pain in the provervial and so much harder to get to take colour!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Emily

      Hello
      Im a year 12 food and hospitality student and as part of an assignment we are to make a cake. I was thinking of doing a cake similar to this one. um i was just wondering though what recipe you used to make the cake? and how big are each of the circles? If you understand what i am trying to say. I have to order my ingredients but im not sure how big the cake is and how much mixture i am going to need :/

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  40. lazzarooch

    This post is timely. I spent ALL day yesterday making a Batman cake for my son’s 4th birthday tomorrow. It was supposed to be the easiest cake I have made but the icing kept sticking or cracking after I rolled it out. It also isn’t easy when you have little helpers!

    I decided yesterday that I hate cake decorating but I have a year to get over it until the next birthday I have to make a cake for.

    I have my childhood version of the original WW cake book but bought the new version when my son was born. I have since made:

    Son’s 1st – teddy cake out of new WW book
    Son’s 2nd – dragon cake out of new WW book
    Son’s 3rd – Big Red Car using the Wilton 3D tin
    Son’s 4th – Batman symbol from Internet pic

    Daugher’s 1st – Matryoshka Doll from Internet pic

    Mum’s 60th – Bunch of flower cupcakes from new WW book.

    For someone who hates cake decorating so much I continue to put myself up to the challenge.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • lazzarooch

      And the “simple” cake that broke me……

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • melissacarter

        Well done, the cake looks awesome! My kids are into the butter icing cakes (or maybe I just encourage them to choose those types), but I’m not looking forward to having to use fondant (is that what you used) icing and doing all the tinting and rolling.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Silverdragon

          Melissa – it’s actually not that hard to work with the fondant and it takes colour much more easily (more true to colour and less required) than buttercream. If you’re using black (or even truly dark red) though, I’d buy it pre-coloured, as it’s hard to get the intensity of colour without changing the texture of the icing and potentially making it soft and floppy/easily broken.

          Maybe have a go sometime when it doesn’t really matter – you might be surprised by the results you can create. :)

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  41. hannahfromsa

    Such Happy Memories! I had all my cakes out of that book! I even threw a birthday party for my cake and demanded a cake (three blind mice cake). My mom only put her foot down about the barbie cakes- she disapproved on principle.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  42. becnherboys

    We had the book when I was a kid but my Mum wasn’t at all domesticated – not sure why she bought it really… We used to spend hours looking through it. One year I really wanted the swimming pool so Mum got our local bakery to make it. It was fabulous!
    I have made my boys quite a few of them over the years. The best I ever made was the Pirate Ship. This year I made the train for my youngest boy’s 2nd birthday. It was a disaster!!!! Took me all night and my husband was in fits of laughter at me! At one point he said to me “the problem is you’re going by what you think a train looks like and it is actually nothing like that…” When I served up this lopsided shocker, loaded with lollies to disguise how bad it was, my kids loved it and ate every bit of it!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  43. GK

    My Mum made me the train for my 5th birthday party. My brother and I are exactly 5 years and 4 days apart.

    What a woman!

    I *heart* her big time. I will definitely tackle them with/for my future kids.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  44. Elena

    Yes we had the book too. My poor mother! I’ve been tossing up whether or not to continue on with “the book” with my own children, who so far have been happy with their number 1 smartie cakes and then subsequent icecream cakes from wendys…. When i think back with nostalgia on all our birthday cake triumphs and (near) disasters, how excited we were and how proud our mother, its seems cruel not to carry on the tradition.. :-)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  45. Virabelle

    I grew up with that cook book too….and I recently liberated it from my mum’s cook book stash! My mum was and still is an amazing baker and it is one skill that I am so happy to have inherited from her.

    I do not yet have my own children but that hasn’t stopped me from baking birthday cakes. I am known amongst friends and work friends as the ‘cake maker’. People discretely put in their requests, hoping that word gets back to me on flavour and appearance. I might be 26 but I love the look of walking into a friends place for their birthday dinner or to staff drinks at work with a personalised cake for the birthday person and seeing how easily the child n them reawakens.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  46. Melanie

    My husband is the cake maker in our family too. So far, he’s made the following for our daughter: number one, butterfly, bedroom setting (dolls in a big bed with side lamps) and the fairy castle pictured below (with the steps and ivy growing up the sides). Entering into the spirit of it, I made him a Transformers cake last year :-)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  47. Joey

    I grew up with the WW Birthday Cake book! That was awesome. My mum would always make INCREDIBLE cakes. IT was sooooooo exciting to choose which one I’d have. If I ever have kids I will (try) to do the same. Or maybe just enlist the help of their grandma ;-)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  48. mc

    After looking at all the caked below I must be a bad mother i must admit i have looked at the book and think how the f***k am i going to make that.
    But i must admit I do then go to the shop and get them to make my kids awesome cakes – - so really i am a good mother i just don’t make them i buy them!!
    Please is there anyone out there who is with me?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Petal

      Oh yeah, MC, I’m definitely with you. Everytime the kids used to see that book (or similar) in shops I would always steer them away with “Look there’s Tic Tacs over here!” Can’t ever go past making the number by sticking a packet of chocolate biscuits together with cream!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • mc

        i feel so much better now, thanks petal!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  49. KAtherine

    My mother swore off birthday cakes after my 1st birthday after she created a rainbow with coloured sponge and smarties and after all that effort, at the end of the day, only the smarties were eaten!
    I have become the resident dessert baker in our house. Everyone gets to choose what they want and I get to make them… Not quite as amazing as the others but it certainly tasted amazing!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Cordeline

      that’s a classy looking cake!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • KAtherine

        Merci, Thank you! I have made all sorts of pavlovas and lemon meringue pies even a very decadent bailey tiramisu! I don’t have any kids yet but I will certainly be trying these amazing cakes when I do!! They look like good fun!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  50. missneriss

    I grew up with this book! I’ve had the dressing table and the doll and endless numbers. There’s also a rabbit in there, right? My brother has had the train for sure (although that might have been a thomas the tank engine). It was always such a treat to pick which cake we could have although I always wanted the swimming pool, but my mum never agreed to that one!

    I’d most definitely buy the book, but I would guess my mum still has hers that she would gladly pass on.

    Thanks for the nostalgia, great post.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions