Do You Like This Story?

food police Why Ive had a gut full of the food police

 

 

 

 

My diet is none of your business. There, I said it.

This week alone I have been told to cut down my salt intake, count my calories, cut out corn and potatoes, limit rice and pasta, stop eating sugar (as if), eat anything I want as long as it is organic (organic donut anyone?) and cut out caffeine. None, I repeat none of this advice has come from my doctor.

This advice has come from a friend, a family member, another family member, yet another family member, a writer, another friend and a celebrity….in that order. Some has been to my face and the rest through dramatic articles and ‘news’ stories. I mean, really, the advice is constant and contradictory. It’s endless and confusing. Apple juice contains arsenic (thanks Doctor Oz)…even dieticians and doctors can’t decide what is right.

Every few weeks I have a panic attack about what is in my fridge and pantry. I’m killing myself and my kids. It’s my fault. I have to take control. But which advice do I follow? If my kids and I are mostly healthy and at a reasonable weight do I really need to do anything at all?

There’s something to be said about society when we can critique each other’s eating habits. Eating is very personal. When did we become so comfortable with commenting about what we are eating? At least fifty per cent of the advice I’ve received in recent week has been from people who could frankly stand to lose a few kilos themselves.

I’m not innocent. I give diet and exercise advice. But only if asked. And then I feel guilty for preaching. If asked how I maintain my weight I describe what I do but I always make sure to explain that this is what works for me, it won’t work for everyone and we all have different habits, cravings and lifestyles. It’s really about eating what we like but not too much, exercising when we can and shaking off all the terrifying food advice we’re bombarded with. Do your best. There’s no need for extremes. I might decide to reduce my salt intake if I’m feeling unwell, count my calories if I want to lose a couple of kilos for an event, cut out corn and potatoes if they becomes too expensive, limit rice and pasta but not cut it out completely, reduce my sugar intake (sugar is my drug of choice but I am only a recreational user), eat organic if I can find affordable quality produce and reduce my caffeine intake if my children ever decide to let me have a proper night’s sleep.

This week I spent four hours avoiding sugar and caffeine thanks to a Facebook link to a horrific lecture about how it was poison. Okay, sugar may not be the healthiest substance in the world but do I really have to run screaming from it and so abruptly? I lasted until 2pm. I might just reduce it I think. I’ll do my best but Easter is coming. I can’t promise anything. Is life really worth living without experiencing the crackle of a quality hollow chocolate Easter egg as you bite into it? Isn’t a cheese and tomato sandwich spectacular with a sprinkle of salt on it? My mum grows her own corn. It is sweet, fresh and bursting with flavour. My dad’s potato salad recipe is spectacular (boiled potatoes, tomatoes, onions, extra virgin olive oil, salt and oregano).  I love steamed rice that clumps together and can’t eat chicken without it. Pasta is my life, just not every day. Coffee – I love you. Once or twice a day. You are my friend, my comfort, my five minutes of quiet time each day.

Come on dieticians…pick this apart. Tell me about my addictions, about the damage I am doing to myself and my family. Ignore the fact that we are all healthy and at a reasonable weight. Tell me about elimination diets, about breaking bad habits. Write some more sensationalised articles and books to scare me to death.

Obesity is a serious issue but I’m not obese. I’m no expert but I’m doing okay. Don’t gasp when I grab a biscuit (a work colleague) or raise an eyebrow when I scramble two eggs with yolks in the smallest amount of real butter (my sister). You look at your plate and I’ll look at mine. And for goodness sake, stay out of my children’s lunch boxes. I maintain that good quality potato chips with three ingredients (potatoes, oil and salt) are much better than your ‘healthy’ choice with fifty ingredients, most of which I can’t even pronounce. What is emulsifier? I rest my case.

Jo Abi is the author of the book How to Date a Dad: a dating guide released by Hachette Livre Australia. Her first love is being a mum closely followed by writing about being a mum. You can read more about her many and various exploits here.

What’s your diet like? How do you handle people talking about it?

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

153 Comments so far

  1. My

    Great post – and I can’t wait to try your dad’s potato salad recipe. I’ve never had potato salad with tomatoes but it sounds AMAZING so I’m going to try and make it – I hope I do it justice!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. Georgie

    I cut out sugar and it really has made a difference to my life. The taste of chocolate doesn’t appeal to me like it once did, it’s so sweet! Also, I no longer have those intense cravings at around 3-4pm for cake/lollies/biscuits. That’s the best part, I’m much more in control of my appetite. I definitely recommend Sarah Wilson’s e-book to anyone thinking about quitting sugar. Give it a go, you’ll be really surprised by the results. Even if you don’t stick to it, I think it’s good to be aware of how much sugar we consume without even knowing it (i.e. low fat dairy, bbq sauce, mayo, salad dressings etc)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Isa

    Love it.
    One of my favourite things is how fashionable it is now to eat gluten free. Gluten free foods are for people with Coeliac Disease. It is also true that some people are ‘gluten intolerant’ and they don’t have the genes for coeliac disease but they feel a lot better when they avoid it. However, those are the only two classes of people who need to be avoiding gluten…which is a protein (I think) found in wheat, rye, oats and barley. There’s that thing in the Sunday life magazine where minor celebrities write about what they eat and it’s very hip to say things like ‘I eat organic, sugar free and gluten free wherever possible’. Classic. My mum is both a doctor and a coeliac and finds it hilarious. The only possible benefits that I suppose you would get from eating gluten free is that if you were replacing simple carbs with higher protein stuff it would be like an Atkins diet type thing but I’m pretty sure that’s actually not all that good for you in the long run because glucose from carbohyrdates is SUPPOSED to be the body’s primary fuel source. And if you were substituting stuff like pasta and bread for stuff like rice cakes and rice pasta then you would be eating things that are higher GI and probably aren’t gonna be that useful. Haha listen to me lecturing about nutriton just like the people I hate. I’m like Mia, a self proclaimed hypocrite :D

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • tara

      The “I-eat-gluten-free-because-I-choose-to” people WOULD be hilarious, if they didn’t make actual sufferers of coeliac disease look like hysterical maniacs.

      If you choose to eat gluten free, that’s your choice. But if you’re a coeliac and you ingest so much as one non-GF toast crumb from a contaminated toaster, or a 50th of a piece of pasta which was stuck to the spoon when they served the non-GF fettucine before you, or a couple of mls of soy sauce because no-one rinsed the spoon, then you can become really, *really* ill. But because the by-choice-non-GF “weekend warriors” can have a slice of cake when they feel like it then return to their trendy diet on a whim, diagnosed coeliacs get the eye-roll if they mention the toast/pasta/soy sauce thing.

      Gluten-free is not cute. It’s not a choice. It’s not overkill to eliminate microscopic gluten. it’s not cheap to follow a ‘proper’ fully GF diet. It’s not a minor illness if you’re a coeliac. Therefore, it’s not funny.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • You’re totally right tara – my boyfriend’s aunt was diagnosed with coeliac’s disease later in life (in her 50s).

        She was so ill, they thought she had cancer and was weeks away from dying. Some clever doctor thought to test for coeliac’s disease and bingo. She gets so ill from eating gluten now, it’s unbelievable, I feel so sorry for her.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • SusieQ

        Exactly, Tara! The number of times I’ve heard, “But surely a little bit won’t hurt?” Oh, yes, it will! And for the next six weeks or so. Sigh.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Relish

        Hi Tara, I am GF by choice, not coeliac. My choice is based on a whole load of reasons but my family (both Mum & Dad’s sides) have a number of coeliacs as well as wheat intolerance). Because I choose this lifestyle, I hope that I don’t make actual coeliacs seem hysterical but perhaps with such a strong family history I am more aware than some. While those of us who are not coeliacs choose to be GF for health benefits, I hope that the increased demand for GF products helps those who really depend on them. I take your point about the weekend warriors though, and I understand that it can be frustrating for those of you who can’t choose. I just ask that you don’t tar all non coeliac GF eaters with the same brush as like me, some may actually get huge health benefits from eating that way.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • wondering

      “I’m pretty sure that’s actually not all that good for you in the long run because glucose from carbohyrdates is SUPPOSED to be the body’s primary fuel source.”
      Citation please…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Isa

        I’ll look it up when I get home but I learnt that at Uni in biomed and in high school in biology and health.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • wondering

          Be good to look it up then. Look up what they based their ‘supposed to be’ assumption on.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Anon

            Yeah, all those cavemen ate so much bread and pasta and potato for all those years before we invented agriculture… oh wait…

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
    • Gluten free

      I would think your mum would like people saying they eat gluten free. If more people decide to eat that way, surely it would make the gluten free foods more readily available, and thus easier for coeliacs to find food they can eat (at restaurants, etc)??
      Just a thought…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  4. Anonymous

    Personally, I prefer to live in a world where people are making educated food choices, not ignorant ones.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Essie

      Snce when can you choose what ‘world’ you live in?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        I wrote “prefer” not “choose”

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  5. Ads

    I LOVE I mean LOVE pasta. Pasta, carbs, they are my drug of choice. I would eat it every night if I could but no one else in my family are big pasta eaters so I do ration pasta dishes. In fact my husband fills up so quickly on pasta that he has the tiniest amount, out of guilt I reduced my pasta quantity (small bowl now not the big massive bowl filled to the brim).

    If you watch and read enough about diets and what is good and bad for you you wouldn’t be able to eat anything at all. Everything in moderation I say and if something doesn’t agree with you don’t eat it. I agree that food is a personal thing, its going into your body and frankly your body is your own business.

    I can’t read magazines etc about healthy eating because they always put me into a panic. I just prefer to be happy and carbs make me happy :) In moderation of course!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Stella

      Not to throw the cat amongst the pigeons but it tends to be the foods I “love” and crave that I am able to overeat that are the worst for me. I discovered I was gluten intolerant a few years ago and stopped eating that, then gave up eating sugar, potatoes and other grains (eg corn, rice etc) a month ago. I now eat LOTS more vegetables, meat, eggs, nuts, avocados, some full fat dairy… and I honestly have never felt better. The things that I told myself I loved were the things I ate uncontrollably or mindlessly, or my “comfort” foods. I could easily have half a packet of corn chips before dinner, or eat a burger then stuff myself with fries despite feeling full, or eat a whole family sized block of chocolate in one sitting. Now I don’t crave these things and find that my diet is far more nutritionally sound. I am able to stop eating when I feel full, because my body recognises what I am eating as food! I am not one to preach and will only offer dietary recommendations if someone expresses dissatisfaction with their own eating habits or the way they are feeling. And then I will say “Well this is what really works for me, maybe you should try it?” I never in a million years thought I could live without sugar, and thought my life would be less fun without the little pleasures, but now I feel better without it than I ever did with it. It’s funny how things have changed, because I still LOVE my food and find eating to be a pleasurable experience – but now I feel like it loves me back!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • wondering

        I have had the same experience Stella, thank you for sharing it so eloquently.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  6. Rebecca

    Oooh! I just want to know which potato chips are the ones with just 3 ingredients!! Please?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Shan

      Most ‘original’ or ‘plain’ chips have just 3 ingredients, and as long as the oil isn’t hydrogenated, they’re actually not a bad food choice at all.
      Plain corn chips are just corn, oil and salt.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jo

        Red Rock Deli but just the sea salt ones.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Kettles’ and Red Rock Deli are both three ingredients only for their “sea salt” flavour (in other words, “original” or “plain”)! They are the pricier chips and bigger portion sizes, but they do taste the best. :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Katie

      Smiths potato crisps :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  7. Sammie

    After eating a cupcake and feeling like I was going to vomit for the rest of the day I looked into giving up sugar. Faaaaaark that research was an eye opener!
    I don’t eat packet/processed food very often, we buy fresh food and make meals ourselves.
    What scared me the most was a packet of pre-marinated steak in the freezer. It has more sugar per 100g than a packet of jelly beans. I would NEVER give my 8m old lollies, but last week she had marinated steak… Oops.

    I’ll see how I go with this!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. M

    Scoff all you want, but some of those choices that people are calling “fad diets” aren’t about losing weight, but about feeling great. And your cutting down sugar isn’t going to work, sorry!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. Noelle

    And when did gluten and dairy become our worst enemies?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Rainie

    Yes please to the organic donut. As long as it’s sugar free – of course!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. Helen

    Although I agree with this article to an extent and that all the advice given is constant and often contradictory… regardless there are people out there that are constantly looking for this advice and are constantly looking for different perspectives regardless. So, because the market is out there.. you can’t really blame these people, writers, bloggers or whoever who are putting the info out there when their are so many people asking for it.

    Also, of course not everything works for everyone… but what’s the harm in seeing what other people are doing, trying it for yourself and well, if it works for you sticking to it… and if it doesn’t canning the idea? There is no harm in people receiving this information and figuring out what’s rubbish and what’s best for them. People have a choice.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. An Idle Dad

    Potatoes and tomatoes are an awesome combination. Michael Pollan’s (famous for his discetion and rejection of nutrient-based eating advice) is to “eat food, not too much, mostly plants”.

    Your comment about chips instead of low carb chip-like ‘thing’ is why I love butter and avoid margarine.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Sandi

      I make a great Italian potato salad that is: potatoes, chopped tomatoes, red onion, a huge amount of basil (I estimate how much by how the colours look together!) and seasoned with salt, pepper and olive oil. That’s it. It’s ALWAYS a hit and when I take it to a BBQ or party, no one believes me when I say that is all I put in it!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  13. Loz

    I try to eat foods that aren’t so processed, but ultimately I eat what I feel like.

    I only arrived at this ‘peace with food’ after many years of treatment for Anorexia. I will admit that when diets come up at work I discourage them – but I’m not sure this is a bad thing…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. Kristy

    Each to their own – love it!

    Although in my head I silently judge ‘healthy choice’/'lean cuisine’ eaters. That stuff freaks me out.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions