BY MIA FREEDMAN
It’s a modern story.
Boy meets girl. Boy asks girl to enter into kinky sexual arrangement bound by written contract and occasionally handcuffs. Girl agrees willingly but wants emotional connection too. Boy falls unexpectedly in love with girl. Girl thrilled. Boy and girl have endless conversations about their relationship while going at it like rabbits at every given opportunity. More rabbits etc.
That pretty much sums up Fifty Shades of Grey, the fiction phenomenon that’s infiltrating suburban bedrooms across the western world. This book has millions of female knickers in a happy twist and if you haven’t yet heard about it, it could explain why the women in your life have been peering so intently at their Ereaders.
Fifty Shades is the first book in a trilogy that’s currently only available in Australia as an ebook. The print version is coming as publishers everywhere scramble to catch up with this underground explosion of…..raunch reading. Not since Eat Pray Love have women gone so nuts for a book and it’s particularly resonating with married women in their 30s and 40s, prompting some to call it ‘Mummy Porn’.
I began reading Fifty Shades this week purely so I could tell you what the fuss was about. Yes, I took one for the team. And no, it’s not well written. Still, like most women, I inhaled all three books in 48hrs.
So why should you care? Because if you’re a guy whose partner is reading this book, you’ll notice some delightful knock-on effects. Also because pop culture phenomenons always shine a collective light onto bigger issues and this book has illuminated a couple of doozies.
Firstly, women are reading about sex! All sorts of women! Married, single, divorced, partnered, mothers, caregivers! And it’s making them want to have it! Even though they’re not 20! Who knew!
The idea that women in relationships might want and enjoy sex has been unexpectedly shocking in a culture that has a pretty polarised view of female sexuality. As journalist Erika Christakis writes on Time.com: “Young women are being portrayed [in the media] as louche sluts who need government interventions to control their badly behaving bodies yet, by age 40, turn into spayed harpies with libidos in the dumpster who would happily sacrifice their sex drives for a man who does laundry.”

Fifty Shades author EL James
Unlike porn, erotic fiction (which is usually written by women) is very much a female view of sex, characterised by the relationships and details underpinning it. For example, there are regular discussions between the main characters -Anastasia and Christian – about contraception. Anastasia sees a doctor to choose the best method and has a full gynecological check up. And no, nothing happens with the doctor. It’s just….a doctor’s appointment. Like in real life. At one point, Anastasia panics that she’s pregnant. At another point, she has her period. Can you imagine any of these scenes in a porn flick?
There’s also a condom woven naturally into the action every time they have sex. Women like these details. As one reviewer noted: “You know you’re in Girl Land when the sex scenes are interspersed with pages of angsty email exchanges about where the relationship is headed (oh, and the guy is turned on by watching her eat).” The characters do talk about their feelings a lot. I may even have found myself muttering “oh shut up and get on with it” once or possibly ten times.
The second interesting issue thrown up by this book are its themes of (consensual) submission and dominance. Do women secretly want a bloke who takes control in the bedroom? And out of it? Is this the start of a backlash against feminism and SNAGs? Not so fast. “In our culture, it’s politically incorrect for women to become aroused by something that makes us appear or act submissive” says sexologist Dr Logan Levkoff. “However, we don’t control how and if we’re turned on by something. If [this book] got you hot and bothered, it got you hot and bothered. There’s no underlying psychological issue here. This is not about feminism or the demise of the women’s movement.”

Familiar?
I see it in equally simple terms. Fifty Shades is simply an adults (only) version of all the Disney stories we grew up on – Cinderella and Snow White and Sleeping Beauty and handsome princes sweeping beautiful damsels off their feet. Christian Grey has a helicopter instead of a white stallion but it’s the same; rich, powerful guy plucks sweet innocent girl out of obscurity and they fall madly in love. That’s why it feels so familiar. Most of us have this narrative programmed into our DNA, for better or worse.
Ultimately though, the Fifty Shades phenomenon is about more than sex and ebooks. At its heart it’s about storytelling and friendships. There was no marketing push behind it, no focus-groups or branded sex toys, no seeding in blogs or social media campaigns. It was word-of-mouth in its purest form. Women discovered something they liked and told their friends.
As Dr Levkoff writes at the Huffington Post: “Women have found something that enhances their emotional and sexual lives and want to pass that knowledge onto their friends, family members, and even the world at large.” They’ve found something fulfilling and want others in their lives to find it too. I’m thinking Mothers Day gift. You?
You can get the book here.
Have you read 50 Shades? If so, who do you think should play Anastasia and Christian in the movie?
Mia chats about the book on the Today Show here:







Comments
75 Comments so far
Dont know what books you where reading but I think it just got better and better….maybe you need a new profession
cant wait for the movie and we need more to the set
loading...
This book (the first one) does not portray a healthy BDSM relationship.
Christian is unwilling to compromise for her. He controls her every move. She is portrayed as powerless, weak, and clumsy.
I believe this book is the biggest setback to the feminist movement in decades. To me, it suggests that to find a man that is wealthy and well-endowed, you must be willing to accept that he will also be mentally ill and violent. Further, it shows her changing her standards and morals for a man who justifies his violence and control problems by saying “it’s just the way I am.” He showed no compassion towards her, only lust, and she was AFRAID of him. How is this healthy?
I feel sorry for people in healthy BDSM relationships that RESPECT each other. Christian does not respect Ana. I feel sorry for the women in violent domestic situations that have now had their pain documented and mass-produced and have to watch thousands of women lap it up as mummy porn. And I am disappointed Mamamia, which I read religiously, would appear to endorse it.
loading...
Alexander Skarsgard is my pick
loading...
Change that ~ Chris Hemsworth (Thor) ~ and….. me
loading...
Easy… Matthew McConaughey and ….. me
loading...
I want to start reading these books, I’m interested to know what the hype is about, but your post seems to be geared more towards women in their 30-40s. I’m 18. Would it be inappropriate for me to read this trilogy?
loading...
I finished the first book last night (in print from the airport!).
I have to say by the middle I was yawning – it felt a little ‘flowers in the attic’ to me…..I will say – Christian Beale (he’s got the mean streak) and Mila Kunis (sweet but hot)…….
loading...
Oh gawd. The most unerotic book I’ve ever read. Couldn’t stop laughing at the bad writing, poorly imagined characters and completely unimaginative sex scenes long enough to be turned on! Life is too short for me to bother reading the 2nd and 3rd books.
loading...
In the middle of the first book- enjoying it very much….. I think definitely Ryan Gosling for Christian and possibly Keira Knightly as Ana!!!!
loading...
The whole way through it I just couldn’t help but think how stuck in the late ’90s the author was.
Like how Christian always wears jeans with white linen shirts and pinstripe blazers (vomit), and when they go to the ball and Anastasia wears the silver satin gown with matching wrap. It just conjured up images of high school formals.
And yes, all the ‘Oh my’s were awful. And… the sex scenes didn’t turn me on at all! She was always coming after two thrusts and I found that totally unrelatable. Anyway.
loading...
The sex scenes are incredible, but other than that is is awfully written. The inner goddess crap drove me nuts. I still bought the other two, and they were both out of stock at Booktopia. Coming Monday.
loading...
I bought this tonight (what did we do before kindles) and I cringed when I read the first line. But I’m settling myself into bed for the night because I have a feeling I won’t be able to stop reading!
loading...
For some reason all that comes to mind when I read this is Patrick Bateman!!!!! So I am trying to wipe the image of CHRISTIAN Bale out of my head!!
loading...
Peter Kable // November 27, 2009 at 1:00 pm | Reply (edit) I have had a copy of “Damned Rascals” since it first became liavaable – it is well thumbed and has been used to assist in the preparation of a talk I have given about the two ‘rascals”. The book is a most valuable resource and I refer to it often. The maternal side of my family is descended from Frederick Meredith a working sailor of the First Fleet and a free settler who came back on the Second Fleet.
loading...
So Mia… and Lana… I get where you are coming from. I rumaged around online and found legal free e-books for all 3 titles. I finished book 1 in an all nighter. I am now halfway through book 2. I love it all so far… does this reveal that I am a single, repressed middle aged mother?
reeking of sad desperation?… LOL
Despite the naysayers (all entitled to there opinion) I will say I am not a literary purist nor am I a feminist per se, so am not up in arms about the content (well yet anyway), the writing style (lip biting or otherwise) and I like a bit of escapism now and then. Not territory I could go to myself (whether an accurate portrayal of true BDSM or not as noted by another MM guest here) but have had it offered several times by potential dates. I think there is more of an undercurrent out there then perhaps we realise!
Anyway, thanks for the tip!
loading...
When I read the title of the article the other day….I wondered what sex smelled like.
So I went bought a bottle of Bulgari Blue Notte. When I wear it, I turn myself on…..and nobody knows.
And you all thought that it was Justin Timberlake who was bringing sexy back !!!!!!
loading...
i don’t care if it’s not a literary great, or compared to this or that, etc. I have been married for 20+ years, (very happily) we are in our mid 40′s, and for the first time in a long time asked my husband to drive home for lunch (night time’s different). So as I’m basking in the afterglow, and about to try and work and not keep reading the 2nd book, I give it a 5 out of 5, if only to keep the loving alive. Thanks Mia for sharing, oh & my husband, he thanks you too!
loading...
I had never heard of this book,but now i just read some ‘scenes’ on Jezebel….and ‘oh my god’ (as the chick says as the dude’s ‘erection is springing free’ from his pants),this has got to be yhe most hilariously terrible book EVER!!
I’m sorry for everyone who thinks this is erotic fiction,and i’m sorry for the author too…
This might be a little mean,but i knew the minute i saw that author photo that there was no way this lady would have written anything i would find remotely ‘erotic’… Brrrrrrr!
loading...
This is a woeful book that even the better-than-average-and-very-frequent sex scenes could not save, in my opinion.
Never have I been so disappointed in a novel I was sure I’d love. Loved Twilight, loved Hunger Games, but this one…. It’s just Bad with a capital B. And I went and bought all 3 e-books at once! Stupid!
loading...
What Mamamia should be writing about is the power of women in story telling in Hollywood right now. Suzanne Collins, JK Rowling, Stephanie Meyers and now EL James.
Three of Hollywood most important franchises (Harry Potter, Twilight and now The Hunger Games) are based on books written by women. Together the films account for more than $10 billion in box office revenue and millions more in merchandise revenue. Franchises are what Hollywood studios desperately need and right now they are being provided by female authors.
loading...
Has Mia been paid to send 5 tweets a day for the last 2 weeks about this book?? A bit tired of my twitter feed full of this book
loading...
I am so confused. What’s everyone talking about twilight for?
There’s this MASSIVE fanfic with a HUGE following that’s with an S&M Bella and Edward – is that what you’re talking about? It’s not called Master of the Universe (o.O) though. Is this that? Confused =/
loading...
I think you’re missing the important questions this books brings up. (fan fiction, copyright etc) This post says it well:
http://letterstotwilight.com/2012/03/02/the-new-york-post-focuses-on-the-important-things-in-their-articles-about-twilight-fan-fiction/
& who would play them in a movie? Hello, it came from a movie!
loading...
A+ comment!!!!
Read it for free years ago when it was called Master of the Universe – why would I pay to read it again??
loading...
I just finished the first one. OMG. I haven’t masturbated that much in a long time!! TMI?!
I didn’t realise the next 2 had been released already until I read this article. Have bought them this afternoon and can’t wait to start reading!!
loading...
Crap books, but the sex is hot.
Question for those who have read the WHOLE series, if you haven’t then this is a spoiler
S
P
O
I
L
E
R
A
L
E
R
T
I had no problem with the S&M at all. I found Christain annoying in the way that he controlled her whole life but could deal with it.
However,
In the epilogue, she’s describing their ‘kinky fuckery’ whilst she is pregnant and the flogger swept across her swollen belly. Did he hit her belly whilst pregnant? If so, then I have a problem with that. I’m not a medico so I don’t know if it would harm the baby, but even so it seems so wrong.
Anyone have any thoughts?
*
*
*
*
*
loading...
I too read this as fan fiction when it was Master of the Universe.Ther is a story behind the sex with Christian’s background
I can’t see Kristen Stewart in the role. that was pretty much written for her Twilight Bella.
loading...
Pingback: Fifty Shades of Grey | Website of Megan Burke
There’s a lot of really well crafted erotic fiction out there, most of it dealing with the same ‘Disney’ tropes and much of it containing. BDSM
loading...
As soon as I saw the words ‘Twilight’ and ‘fanfiction’ I was out.
loading...
I’ve read the first two books. I thought the first was ok, the second really quite bad, I skipped over a lot. Two phrases that turn me off “my inner goddess” and “don’t bite your lip”… Repetitive and boring, even the sex stuff. I’m really unsure why it’s so popular. I usually like to read a bit of trash (which this is), but just couldn’t get into it. From reading the other comments though I am the odd one out here!
loading...
If I have to read “oh my” one more time my kindle might end up in the bin!!
loading...
Does anyone actually say “oh my!” in real life? Just can’t imagine. In my head I had to replace all those occurrences with OMG and *then* it made sense.
loading...
Yes!!!! Oh my goodness I am so happy to read this. Those two statements are driving me mad. I don’t understand why an author continuously would say the same thing over and over – so monotonous and repetitive and dull. I’m onto the second book, trying to like it but it’s beginning to bore me.
loading...
Just started reading last night -wanted to know what the hype was about….well Im not convinced she so naive which irritates me to no end….I don’t understand how she peeks at him through her lashes.
Not sure I’ll bother with 2 & 3 or rest of 1 but I’ll see
loading...
I tried to do it, but my eyes almost roll into the back of my head
loading...
These books were so frustrating – yet I also ‘inhaled’ them all in record time.
Have to agree with the lip biting, Oh My, and looking through lashes irritations and add that if I read how she ‘exploded around him’ one more time, I was likely to throw my iPad against the wall. A thesaurus is so easy to access, damnit.
loading...
Erotic fiction is nothing new. For those who have read it: What makes this one so special? I’m curious.
loading...
Out of interest, why do you seem so pro this book, yet so anti anything that might depict bondage that a man might see, like porn, those t-shirts etc.
Do you feel that women can cope with the fantasy of it all but men cant.
Lets face it, erotic fiction is just a preferred form of porn for many women. Why the different view based on who the target adience is.
loading...
Yeah but wounded bull, there’s a big difference between dominance contained within an erotic novel (which, by definition, an adult is choosing to read) compared with a child or sex assault survivor having bondage shoved in their face (whether they want to see it or not) by some douchebag in an offensive tshirt.
Like in bondage itself, the acceptability of bondage in culture comes down to the control that people have of involving it in their lives.
loading...
…or some douche bag reading this book on a train maybe, or when it gets made into a movie, seeing the posters etc that will surely follow
I dont get the difference sorry. You just assume that women are mature enough to cope with the idea of this fantasy, but because a tiny tiny proportion of men rape, that all other men have to be assumed not capable of dealing with this as a fantasy topic and are banned?? Smacks of double standards to me.
loading...
I don’t have a problem with men looking at this stuff. Particularly as I’m in this kind of relationship (for the record this book is a rubbish account of a BDSM relationship, it’s written by someone whose only exposure to BDSM seems to be other people’s erotic fiction. Nothing wrong with fantasy over how it really works, but with such rich source material it’s shame the fantasy came out so poorly).
I see a difference though between t-shirts and porn. Porn is typically watched in private. As I see nothing wrong with these desires, men can watch all the bondage they want. I don’t want to see it on t-shirts. Not because there is something wrong with bondage, or because men can’t ‘handle it’ but because it furthers the pornification of society. I don’t need to see it when walking down the street. I’m sure men can handle the themes and desires it may raise. But keep it private.
Just like I think girls need to put their breasts away men can put away their porn t-shirts, whatever kind of image is on it.
loading...
Are they really making a movie? Do they have to make a movie of what seems like EVERYTHING!?
loading...
Definitely Joe Manganiello for Christian!!! Maybe Anne Hathaway as Ana
loading...
Oh God. Reading this right now with Joe in my head. Yes please.
loading...
It’s fan fiction from the Twilight series which is currently being questioned for copyright infringements of Stephanie Meyers work.
I felt sorry for Ana and Christian was a dick with a dick.
By the way, a 27 year old billionaire? So, he’s like Mark Zuckerberg? Nothing sexy about Mark Zuckerberg. Just sayin’.
loading...
Lizzie – in the books Ana is just graduating and Christian is in his late 20′s … casting older actors for the roles wouldn’t make sense!
loading...
Ha love it! When I read the intro to the article I thought man that sounds like fan fiction!! I think I’ve actually read it!!
loading...
Why does booktopia say it isn’t published yet, but everyone has read it?!
loading...
It was released as an e book not in paperback form hence the ‘not published’. I’m assuming everyone who has read it, read it as an ebook. It’s being released in paperback on April 3rd.
loading...
Being ‘published’ is not confined to hard copy printing in hard-back or paper-back format. Even in electronic format it is considered published.
However, it was certainly available OS is paper-back form, so it has been published in paper-back. Just not in Australia. Yet.
loading...
Confession: I read the books…finished the third one…then started from the beginning again….I think the book is fascinating…I would never seek to know so much about a Dom/sub relationship, but for me, the ultimate fantasy lies within the fact that he organizes everything! As a stay at home mum, this is the ultimate for me…now excuse me while I go book the restaurant for dinner tonight, it’s my first wedding anniversary (yes, my husband dosnt even do that…love him) AND I gasped out loud at the Ryan gosling suggestion…heaven….I would like an unknown for Ana…but Anne Hathaway esq…
loading...
Have almost finished 50 Shades Freed and I have to say, the quality definitely goes downhill after the first book, it just turns into a Mills and Boon novel with kinkier sex! Having said that though I just couldn’t stop reading. Mia I totally agree with you, it is a sexier version of the Disney princess story. As far as casting a movie can we please stay away from Kristen Stewart, in every Twilight movie she has the same, pained, I need to fart expression! Probably Rooney Mara or Anna Kendrick for Ana and for Christian, Ryan Gosling. Or they just need to cast complete unknowns! I did read somewhere though that a bit of Christian’s physical appearance was based on Eric Stoltz……
loading...
God how I HATE “that” Bella expression……. Why, Why, Why?!?!!?
loading...
As a fan of the Twilight books (not the films), I am so annoyed at the casting choices for the films. Worst acting ever! Ever. Has had a knock-on effect thus ruining the books a little for me. Shame. Can’t wait to read Fifty Shades of Grey though!
loading...
@vetty29 – why do you say that a Mills & Boon is of ‘lower quality’? Have you read many?
loading...
I love that it’s a no brainer read, but I wish she’d find another substitute for the word ‘mercurial’… First time I read it I thought it was a great descriptive word, now I think she’s lost her thesaurus.
loading...
It was a an interesting read! For those who would like more of the same, and a with a belly laugh thrown in, I have also just read Arrabella Candellarbra & The Questy Thing to End All Questy Things by A. K. Wrox. What great talent we have coming out from the females of Oz!
loading...
Book Depository is offering pre-order for all 3 titles (available next month) and only AUS $9.11 each (free postage worldwide) – which is cheaper than e-reader format… looks like I had better get my to-do list sort before they arrive!!!
loading...
This book is excellent and I think the way in which important topics such as boundaries and contraception and such are discussed is excellent.
I think it is interesting to explore the roles of dominant and submissive in this context because as you read you realise that really the submissive holds ALOT of the power in the relationship….an interesting concept for women to think about.
The book is different there is no doubt about that but it certainly is intriguing and leaves you thinking about the sexual roles that we play…
loading...
I’ve never heard of this book before,and i must say this article doesn’t make rush out to purchase it either.It’s Anaïs Nin who does it for me in the erotic literature genre.
loading...
Big fan of Anais Nin also!!! Beautiful intense reading!!!
Still, heard so much through Mamamia about these books and it’s made me curious and wanting to find out what all the fuss is about!!
loading...
Anais Nin is my recommendation too
loading...
Saw The Hunger Games this afternoon and good God! I hadn’t noticed him before but that Liam Hemsworth is a beautiful boy, complete with panty melting smile. Ana is harder, her character gives me the shits at times so I guess Kristen Stewart would suit
or maybe someone like Anna Kendrick – pretty and sassy. Totally pictured someone like Kellan Lutz or Channing Tatum for Elliot though!
loading...
I’m reading the first book and it’s soo addictive! I will pick it up and read it even if I only have 2 minutes to spare! For some reason I have a Jude Law lookalike in my head… It’s strange as I’ve never been a huge Jude Law fan but that’s what I have in mind.. Although he might be a bit old!
I don’t want Kristen Stewart for this part!! Like her but we need to separate it from Twilight! I think it needs an unknown for Anastasia
loading...
I have just finished book two and I’m loving it.
Love the comparison to the “Princesses” didn’t actually click til you said it, but I can see the fairy tale aspect!
My picks for the movie……..Roony Mara, and Kellan Lutz ( he has the glare down pat!)
loading...
Master Of The Universe yes?…
loading...
I can’t wait to see the comments on this one because I have become totally reliant on movies and I want to see what Ana “should look like”.
I want Christian to be Rob Lowe (but many years ago) and I am imagining Ana as Michelle Pfeiffer (a younger version too).
I think I am showing my age
loading...
Lana, I haven’t read the book(s) yet, but have been reading the MM columns and it all sounds so titillating… but I have to say that IF Rob Lowe was cast and there is any sex involved (even totally simulated over-produced Hollywood style) and that man’s flesh is exposed?… I’m IN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
LOL.. (insert Sad, repressed single Mother here)…
and did you see him on the cover of Vanity Fair????… OMGawd.. still so freakin’ hot… OK, back to reality, gotta go get the kid ready for school
loading...