I packed a kindle on my holiday recently. It was a big step for me. I’ve always been a book with pages girl but I REALLY wanted to read How to be a Woman by Caitlin Moran and I couldn’t find it anywhere – well not in the page turning format.
And then I bought a kindle and two minutes later I had the book in front of me. Handy.
Mia had spoken about Caitlin Moran’s book so much, so much that I was using other books to block my ears to drown out the constant praise. You know how when someone raves about something constantly, talks it up and demands that you read it, it can lose its sparkle? I wanted to read it but deep in the recesses of my brain I knew that it could never be as good as Mia said it was.
Turned out I was right.
It was better. Seriously.
To give you a real idea of what the book’s about this is how it is described on her website (which I am also addicted to)
1913 – Suffragette throws herself under the King’s horse.
1969 – Feminists storm Miss World.
NOW – Caitlin Moran rewrites The Female Eunuch from a bar stool and demands to know why pants are getting smaller.
There’s never been a better time to be a woman: we have the vote and the Pill, and we haven’t been burnt as witches since 1727. However, a few nagging questions do remain…
Why are we supposed to get Brazilians? Should you get Botox? Do men secretly hate us? What should you call your vagina? Why does your bra hurt? And why does everyone ask you when you’re going to have a baby?
Part memoir, part rant, Caitlin Moran answers these questions and more in How To Be A Woman – following her from her terrible 13th birthday (‘I am 13 stone, have no friends, and boys throw gravel at me when they see me’) through adolescence, the workplace, strip-clubs, love, fat, abortion, TopShop, motherhood and beyond.
I have never ever read a book with such clarity of language, such humour and so much intelligence all in one. I started to think about things in a completely new light, I felt validated in so many of my beliefs and I felt part of something wonderful. I did begin to worry about the porn that my son is going to have access to. This particular point was rather startling to my husband when I suddenly erupted “We have to make sure there is decent porn for Ethan in our house.” He is only 10. We have a couple of years. I hope
I started to do that annoying thing when you read paragraphs aloud to anyone near you so that they can appreciate how brilliant the book is. I underlined pages at a time, I told friends that unless they read the book I would have to terminate our friendship. I tweeted Caitlin so much about how I loved her every word that I am quite sure she has blocked me on Twitter.
So yes I loved the book. Only one problem. Just after I finished reading it and started reading Ellen DeGeneres new book Seriously I’m Kidding– I dropped the kindle (in horror – I hated that book). It broke. Real books don’t break.
This is what the rest of the Mamamia office (and their families) were reading:

Mia and Lana weren't the only ones who read this book - Nat, Lucy and Bec all read it too.
What did you read over the summer?








Comments
184 Comments so far
a WordPress rating system
Brilliant books that sucked me in over summer:
A Visit from the Goon Squad – Jennifer Egan
With my Body – Nikki Gemmell
Palladio – Jonathan Dee
The Privileges – Jonathan Dee
a WordPress rating system
My girlfriend, who moved to London late last year, had just finished Caitlin Moran’s book when she packaged it up and sent it to me, insisting I had to read it. I’m so glad she did! I’ve never laughed so hard. An extremely frank, hilarious read and something to talk about for the next year as we Skype each other.
a WordPress rating system
i read meltdown by ben elton
matilda is missing by caroline overington and room by emma donoghue, recommend all of them, especially room!
Oh, i also colour coded all the books on our shelf… it looks so much better!
a WordPress rating system
Oh Mamamia! I truly love these posts but I still have two FULL library bags of books to get through from the last two of these!
Between shows to download and watch, blogs to keep up to date with and books to read there is just no time! If only I could cut work out of my day!
Oh well, I’ve now built up another list of books to get through…
And did I mention that I got myself a Kindle for Christmas which is also full of downloaded books to read, I haven’t even gotten near it yet because of the aforementioned bags of library books!
a WordPress rating system
“Foals Bread ” by Gillian Mears was divine!
It is beautifully written, really atmospheric. The characters are believable, and there is a running thread of the imagery of the Jacaranda trees – just beautiful!!
I also loved Marieke Hardy’s “You’ll be sorry when I’m dead”. Might not be everyone’s cup of tea, but I’m a fan and I appreciated her honesty.
I had looked for “How to be a woman” and couldn’t find it, so I just downloaded it and have already read the first chapter.
a WordPress rating system
The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini.
One of the only books I’ve read which deserves the hype it received. I’d been meaning to read it for ages, got around to it last night.
I started reading at 11pm last night, intending to read a chapter or so.
I read it all, finishing at 2:30am.
My tiredness today was definitely worth it! I thought it was an amazing piece of writing, and the most interesting and vivid look at the history of Afghanistan I’ve read.
a WordPress rating system
I’m currently reading “Religion for Atheists: A non-believer’s guide to the uses of religion” by Alain De Botton. Very witty and thoroughly enjoying it so far.
Oh and CoCo, I hope you enjoyed The Magic Faraway tree as much as I did. Great choice.
a WordPress rating system
I love love loved Mrs Kimble by Jennifer Haigh. It’s about a man called Ken Kimble and the three women he marries (and discards). Well written and thought provoking.
For a good gripping thriller I can also recommend Blue Monday by Nicci French.
a WordPress rating system
Oh, I love anything by Nicci French
a WordPress rating system
I read Jessica Bell’s ‘String Bridge’ which was excellent. She is an Australian author who lives in Greece. Not only was there the novel, there was also an accompanying soundtrack.
a WordPress rating system
OMG I love watching Ellen and was v excited to read her new book. About 4 pages in I started skimming and now it’s gathering dust…dreadful
a WordPress rating system
Is that Ellen;s “seriously….Im kidding” ? I just got through reading it, it did not live up to my expectations. At all.
a WordPress rating system
haha “real books don’t break!” i love that Lana- i have avoided the Kindle and co as i don’t want to be partly responsible for the demise of the book and bookstore- i’ll try hard to hold off! i’ll use that quote when asked why i don’t want a kindle!
a WordPress rating system
You Before Me by Jojo Moyes. Loved it.
a WordPress rating system
I really loved ‘The Book Thief’ by Markus Zusak. Such a beautifully written piece of work! I would recommend it to anyone and everyone!
a WordPress rating system
Promises to Keep by Jane Green – a great read. Chick lit-esque, but written really well and with so much heart. Love Jane Green!
a WordPress rating system
Stories I Only Tell My Friends by Rob Lowe…get it NOW!
a WordPress rating system
Thanks for this post. I’ve just ordered a copy of How to be a Woman from Readings online. I’m looking forward to reading it.
a WordPress rating system
Jasper Jones, and I loved it, by Craig Silvey
Matilda is missing
I came to say goodbye
A discovery of witches
The Guernsey Literary and Potato peel pie society
The hypnotist’s love story was ok
Thoroughly enjoing how to be a woman, but in small doses. She can really go on and on when making a point.
a WordPress rating system
I’ve read so many books! I counted last night that, since I got my HTC phone last Easter, I’ve bought about 70 books and have read >50 of them. That’s a lot of shelf space saved.
Memorable books include Tea With Arwa, by Arwa El Masri; The Spider Goddess by Tara Moss; Why Be Happy When You Can Be Normal, the autobiography of Jeanette Winterson; and A Hidden Witch & sequels by Debora Geary (only on Amazon.com for Kindle).
Looking forward to receiving Quiet: The Power Of Introverts by Susan Cain in the mail.
a WordPress rating system
One Day, David Nichols Never cried so much with a book.
Before I go to sleep, SJ Watson
The Help, Kathryn Stockett
Loved them all.
And copious trash mags…my guilty holiday pleasure
a WordPress rating system
I read the latest Matthew Reilly and Stephen King books and devoured them.
Got some good suggestions here and have downloaded some books – thanks everyone. I have both iBooks and Kindle on my iPad. Kindle is consistently cheaper. Has anyone else found that?
a WordPress rating system
According to studies you only have two years left until Ethan looks at porn on the internet.
I read somewhere recently that a university tried to do a study about the effects of porn and tried to find participants that had not consumed it or consumed very little of it and the study had to be changed to something else because they couldn’t find any participants that hadn’t consumed it!
a WordPress rating system
Kind of wishing you posted this *before* my holidays were over… never mind. I have a list to follow up. You guys get a lot of reading time… I seem to have lost mine
I read Howard Jacobsen, Who’s Sorry Now – very good
And Daniel Schacter, Seven Sins of Memory, about how our memories work, and why the way they work means they sometimes trip us up.
Anyone read WildWood, the children’s novel? That’s next on my list.
a WordPress rating system
“This particular point was rather startling to my husband when I suddenly erupted “We have to make sure there is decent porn for Ethan in our house.” ”
Oh to have seen your husband’s face after that! Too funny.
a WordPress rating system
I read quite a few books over the summer break!
– The Happiest Refugee by Anh Do
– The Help by Kathryn Stockett
– Tea with Erwa by Erwa El Masri
– Chaising Daisy by Paige Toon
– Room by Emma Donoghue
– Ruby Blues by Jessica Rudd
At the moment I’m reading Matilda Is Missing by Caroline Overington.
Books on my ‘Want to Read’ list include:
The Freudian Slip by Marion von Alderstein
The Girl In The Steel Cap Boots by Loretta Hill
Baby Be Mine by Paige Toon
The Younger Man by Zoe Foster
a WordPress rating system
I finally succumbed to the bandwagon and read the Millennium Trilogy – great fun. People of the Book by Geraldine Brooks – excellent!!!! I highly recommend it. I am heading out tomorrow to buy Year of Wonders and Caleb’s Crossing.
Read Goodbye Sarajevo by two women who lived through the Bosnian War. Amazing – I learned so much as I was only 10 when it was happening.
The Happiest Refugee by Anh Do – Great! What a lovely book. We are lucky that he chose to call Australia home.
When God was a Rabbit – Good, but it followed me reading One Day and I think I was cranky at WGWAR for not being One Day.
a WordPress rating system
I got my Kindle just last week and I’m a little ashamed to say that the first two books I read were “Something Borrowed” and “Something Blue” by Emily Giffin. And I thoroughly enjoyed them. As in, read late into the night enjoyed.
Sometimes a little chick lit is just what you need to escape from real life. Have a long and varied list of other books to download, mostly thanks to the Mamamia book posts, and I’ve already downloaded heaps of the classics I want to revisit and (shock horror) read for the first time.
a WordPress rating system
Oh I loved the ‘Something Borrowed’ movie! Have you seen it? How would you compare the movie to the book? (I haven’t read the book but wondering if it’s worth my while).
a WordPress rating system
Haven’t seen the movie yet, in my experience books are better than the movie though so I don’t think you’d be disappointed.
a WordPress rating system
The book is way better. I found the movie boring.
a WordPress rating system
I’m a teacher, who is also studying, so summer is my only real reading time a year.
I read The Princess Bride-hilarious-had never seen te movie!, Calab’s Crossing by Geraldine Brooks which I found really interesting(big fan!), reread Cloudstreet, the novel in the Violin, which was beautiful and I stayed up half the night to finish, something else which has gone from my mind at the moment…. Currently struggling through Mansfield Park. Love other Austins, find the witty and funny with strong characters, but I don’t like any of these people! sigh.
I did go a little overboard on my purchasing, and have Room, When God was a rabbit, and a fee de mauriers waiting for me.
Real books all the way!
a WordPress rating system
Room was unputdownable!
a WordPress rating system
That is funny I seem to be shadowing your choices – I just bought the Princess Bride and am planning to read Cloudstreet.
a WordPress rating system
Wuthering Heights, nothing better than a classic
Secret Life of Bees, I found the strength of the women in this book inspiring
The Other Hand, amazing
Lola’s Secret, a real heartwarming story and easy read.
My 7 year old started the holidays with The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe and followed it with Amelia Jane Again (again), she just loves the classics, and has inherited my love of books.
a WordPress rating system
What fantastic books! Loved them all-apart from Lola’s Secretwhich I haven’t read. May have to add it to my list.
a WordPress rating system
I am currently reading ‘Hand me down world by Llyod Jones..taken a bit to get into but quite intriguing..
Next on the shelf are:
_The elegance of the hedgehog
_Sarahs key
I am off to France in months so drawn towards anything set in Paris… Just finished ‘A moveable feast’ by Ernst Hemingway and LOVED it!
a WordPress rating system
The Elegance of the Hedgehog is a wonderful read, one that i have gifted to so many others. I hope you enjoy it as much as i did! Before my own explorations to Paris i also read ‘Almost French’ by Sarah Turnbull. Worth a look!
a WordPress rating system
Sparkle, I’ve heard great things about The Paris Wife by Paula McLain – it’s set in 1920s Paris and is about the Hemingways. Bon voyage!
a WordPress rating system
Franklin and Eleanor – wonderful
The Submission – fascinating and sad for anyone with links to 9-11
The Help- a great summer read
The Obamas – I love Michelle, I don’t care what anyone says
The latest Anne Brasheares installment of the Sisterhood of the Travelling Pants (can’t remember the name) – took me back to my earlier younger days and I still loved it…
How to teach your child Maths – no patience
The Panic Virus – for anyone interested in immunisation and the scare mongering of the antivaccine brigade. Fascinating
Various backdated New Yorker and Vanity Fair magazines – vale Christopher Hitchens
And not a single email – my greatest achievement!
a WordPress rating system
I HATE THESE POSTS.
THEY SEND ME BROKE.
Please STOP.
!
a WordPress rating system
Oh and PS I am reading Kylie Ladd’s ‘Last Summer’ AGAIN!
Absolutely love it!
This is not a sponsored comment, if you want to talk about the IDEA of sponsored comments please call 0404…..

a WordPress rating system
It may not be, but I’ll pay you to keep making them
(Thanks!! xxx)
a WordPress rating system
Lana, I completely understand – I can’t find Caitlin Moran’s book anywhere! Might try online. I haven’t succumbed to the kindle yet… probably will soon though books are getting expensive!
And as I mentioned on Twitter – I hated Ellen’s book. It was just POINTLESS! If I read someone’s memoir, or whatever you call it, I want to read about their life and finish the book knowing more about them. I learnt nothing. I felt ripped off to be honest. I’m taking the book to vinnies… I don’t want it on my bookshelf.
It really annoyed me how she kept saying throughout the book for you to buy the book for others! I mean CONSTANTLY… once – funny, twice – desperate, three times very annoying!
a WordPress rating system
The link to t in the post has it in paperback from booktopia.
a WordPress rating system
well i was after a book i could read without much effort as i am pregnant and in lots of yukky pain so i cant concentrate that much sometimes and i read the Hunger games and holy crap does it suck u in! Its written for young adult or teenagers, but i ready all three in 4 days! it was the best pain relief ever!
I wanted to read we need to talk about Kevin but tbh with a 4yr old and a human on the way i dont think its good for my brain! I need a new easy book to get addicted to, i didnt realise how good a book can be when u are in lots of pain, it can really take your mind of it!
a WordPress rating system
If you haven’t read it already I HIGHLY recommend One Day by David Nicholls or The women he loved before by Dorothy Koomson. They both suck you right in and you wont want to put them down.
a WordPress rating system
OOOooo thanks Kell, i will totally check them out!
a WordPress rating system
I am such a dag, but I just got a total thrill because I read ‘Consuming Innocence’. I’m cool! Trendy! Ahead of the game! I’m just like Mia!
Yep. I’m a dag.
a WordPress rating system
We need to talk about Kevin – didn’t realise how much I enjoyed it until I finished it – really well written. Mammamia – read in a few days (which is quick for me!) & got mia culpa for xmas…can’t wait to read it but first have to finish Dave Grohl biography.
a WordPress rating system
The Colour Purple, by Alice Walker

Odd Girl Out, by Rachel Simmons
Bloodlines, by Richelle Mead
a WordPress rating system
As well as Major Pettigrew’s Last Stand (which is a delight) I also read Rob Lowe’s autobiography, ‘Stories I Only Tell My Friends’. Other than the front cover pic, it’s a shocker. Hate to know what Rob tells his enemies. On another note, Lana’s son has excellent taste in fiction x
a WordPress rating system
I read Major Pettigrew a few years ago and it was an endearing and sweet little novel …
a WordPress rating system
I am a bit like a born again Christian with Caitlin Moran’s book and wander around Sydney extolling its virtues to everyone – we need this discussion about all the work still to do, brazilians (worries me for my daughter who’s 11 – what the hell is wrong with pubic hair???), and the constant worry of ‘I’m not a feminist but …”. And she’s a seriously funny woman. Go on everyone, read it or I’ll come round to your house and harrass you.
a WordPress rating system
I remember my Mum listening to some pretty unguarded girl talk from the brideschicks and assorted other girlies the night before my wedding, and everyone was talking about Brazilians and she just said in this genuinely perplexed way, “When did everyone take against pubic hair?” Will definitely read this book.
a WordPress rating system
Read and loved:
A Visit From The Goon Squad
Middlesex
The Help
Last Summer
All mamamia reader recommendations. Thank you so much xxx
a WordPress rating system
And thank you!! xxx
a WordPress rating system
This is not so much what I read over Summer but what a fourteen year old boy sitting next to me on a plane was reading … The Help. I couldn’t resist asking him what he thought of it and he looked at me very seriously and said it was way better than the Qantas magazine and television. Not the answer I was expecting but what else would a fourteen year old boy have said I had to ask myself…
I read everything already mentioned plus Matilda is Missing. Had a great time with all these books.
a WordPress rating system
Hi Lana
I finished Ellen’s book last week and I agree with you, it seemed to be just one sarcastic joke after another with no real stories or insight to her life which I think might have been funny said out loud but, on paper, just made me speed read most of the book to finish it.
I am currently half way through How to be a Woman and absolutely love it (am also reading paragraphs out loud to my partner) and plan on reading again and buying copies for a few of the women in my life for their birthdays this year. A definite must-read for women AND men!
a WordPress rating system
Try as I might, I just cannot get into Caitlin Moran’s book. I like its message, but just want to write ‘Don’t use 22 words when 12 will do’ all over it. And I am quite over the whole self-deprecating humor that’s become the new sarcasm.
In a similar vain, but less wordy, I highly recommend ‘The Great Feminist Denial’ by Monica Dux and Zora Simic. And one targeted at young adults is, ‘Your Skirt’s Too Short’, by Emily Maguire. (This was a YA take on the grown-up version, ‘Princesses and Pornstars’.)
Less political, but much loved, recent reads which I’d recommend far and wide:
‘The Help’, Kathryn Stockett (oops, I retract previous claim about less political)
‘What Alice Forgot’, Liane Moriarty
‘I Came to Say Goodbye’, Caroline Overington
and the beautifully written, ‘Guilt About the Past’, Bernhard Schlink
a WordPress rating system
The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and The Hunger Games series.
a WordPress rating system
What ever happened to the MM book club where a group of people all read the same book and reported back on it?
and also the MM testers where they tested products and reported back on them.
Sometimes this site seems to be very schizophrenic and jumps from one idea to another and never sticks to anything.
a WordPress rating system
I read Wild Swans by Jung Chang, which is about three generations of women in China. Then read ‘Waiting’ by Ha Jin which is fiction but picks up fairly close to where Wild Swans ends.
I also read Mawson by Peter Fitzsimmons, all the Walsh books by Marian Keyes (and there’s going to be another one!!!), and dipped into How to Make Gravy by Paul Kelly again. His words are beautiful.
Not sure about Caitlin Moran though – whenever I read that kind of thing I always come away feeling like I should be more feminist-like. Which seems to totally miss the point of being a feminist. Just me?
a WordPress rating system
Hey Lana, Mum’s friend had her Kindle break a couple of weeks ago – she called the Kindle hotline and they took her through trying to fix it herself, when that didn’t work, they replaced it. The beauty is that everything’s in your Amazon account so you don’t lose the books you’ve bought!
a WordPress rating system
yep, mine broke and had a new one on my doorstep two days later.
a WordPress rating system
me too – my kindle screen cracked and they just sent me a new one – awesome customer service
a WordPress rating system
I am trying to figure out a book for my book club (it will be my turn to pick in the next couple of months), and I am sort of interested in the Caitlin Moran book but this is what I am worried it will be like…
“It could be argued that this book has some utility if it introduces WAG-obsessed young female readers of celebrity gossip magazines to a semblance of feminist ideas, in a language they’ll readily identify with. But as a commentary on modern feminism for the mature, intelligent woman, it’s a dead loss.: – this is one of the Amazon reviews.
I am worried if I pick this book (which I haven’t read myself and would only be able to order online rather than pick it up and flick through it at the shops) that the girls will hate me for it!
A few times I have come up with reviews like this one, and the bits of Moran that I have seen scattered around the place only seem to reinforce my idea that this is what this book will be like. As I am in a place with (what I believe!) are intelligent, mature women, can someone please tell me why this view is unfounded? It sounds like it is a whole lot of coarseness for no reason, lots of unwarranted CAPITALS, and not a whole lot of substance. Obviously the MM office wholeheartedly disagrees with my perception and I would love to hear it refuted? Please tell me why this is wrong, and why I should pick it for my book club (we happen to all be women)? If it is as great as you have said, I think it would be a good talking point!
a WordPress rating system
I just reckon you can’t please everyone all the time, and you’ll only know if you read it! Do you hate anyone else for the books they’ve suggested?
a WordPress rating system
Well actually one of the girls made us read this atrocious book and I haven’t spoken to her since…!

No, they wouldn’t hate me I’m sure, but we kind of have limited reading time, and I know that, for myself, I would prefer to use that time on a good book rather than one I really wasn’t enjoying if you know what I mean? I just really would like to hear why my perception is wrong? i would like someone to tell me ‘no that is rubbish, it is actually really good because…’ so that I am more prepared to give it a chance. Does it only appeal to a certain market? What is that market?
a WordPress rating system
I’ve been a member of the same bookclub for more than ten years and without a doubt, the BEST sessions have been when there’s a good ‘discussion’. Ok, let’s call it for what it is: a stoush of epic proportions.
We’re all used to each other by now, and nobody’s feelings or intellectual ego get too dented by the conversation. Everyone goes away with a new perspective on a book they mightn’t otherwise have picked up. So we all win.
Go on, DO it! you might be pleasantly surprised at what comes out of it.
a WordPress rating system
It’s a good light read, and I enjoyed it as that, but as anything more than that it was a failure for me. Moran doesn’t back up her very black and white thoughts (strip-clubs=evil, pole dancing classes=awesome) with any real arguments, so I can’t take it seriously as a feminist tract. I thought it had much more in common with Tina Fey’s Bossypants than say, Simone de Beauvoir’s The Second Sex.
And I do tire of the idea that to make something ‘accessible’ you have to constantly reference celebrities and generally just dumb down your arguments. People are smarter than that. My grandmother, who was taken out of school at 12 years old, was perfectly capable of reading The Feminine Mystique and The Female Eunuch, so surely today’s more educated women can handle something with a little more substance.
a WordPress rating system
I just can’t do kindles! I have a theory that they must be good for books that aren’t too complicated. I often need to flick back a few chapters of a book to remind me of a character’s back story or just to read over a good paragraph, it must be so hard to find a place electronically!
I also can’t stand not being able to share my book finds – one of the greatest parts of a good book is sharing it around with everyone as soon as you can and sharing opinions!
I love books, so I’m open to getting one, no one has convinced me yet though.
a WordPress rating system
My one (I don’t know about the touch ones) has forward and back buttons to turn the pages. You can also search for and bookmark stuff too.
You can share but it’s only for 14 days or something and you can only share twice.
Otherwise for sharing, have you heard of http://www.goodreads.com?
a WordPress rating system
Most recently finished Marley and Me. Loved it – I laughed and cringed and cried – very well written and a lovely story.
Water For Elephants (after waiting for it for almost a year at the library) – beautiful story, a little hard to get into – but once I did – I read it in one (long) night. It’s confronting, but I’m so glad I persevered! Was well worth the wait.
The Sound Of One Hand Clapping, by Tasmanian Author Richard Flannagan – I’d been meaning to read it for years.. But had never gotten around to it and hadn’t heard the most positive reviews – but bought the book and really enjoyed it – It gave me a more thorough understanding of what my father’s family (migrants to Tasmania) must have gone through -the environment, the community, the hard times, the confusion between cultures and language… I could go on, but it was good.
Currently reading Memoirs Of A Geisha – it took a while to get into it – but now i’m getting pretty hooked !
a WordPress rating system
I haven’t read Marley and Me but I noticed at Big W the other day that they have a released a book called something like ‘Marley – the Puppy Years’! I was in too much of a rush to have a good look, but I bet my kids would love that one! It had a gorgeous puppy Marley pic on the front!
a WordPress rating system
I happened to look up the movie trailer online and found another called marley and me – the Puppy years (or something like it) looks like its only being released to DVD – but the puppy seems to talk? I think your kids would love it!
a WordPress rating system
Oh Kaybee, maybe that was what I was looking at! (the books and DVDs were right near each other). My girls loved some of the snowbuddies etc movies, so I’m sure they’d love another talking dog movie! Thanks for the tip – I will have to go back and have a closer look!