My friends are a metaphorical abyss into which my books tend to fall. They’re like a cosmic black hole just sucking my literature into their unyielding maws. Book grabbers. Thieves. Marauders.
But they do, it must be acknowledged, love books. It’s hard to stay mad at somebody who likes to read. Instead, I’ve decided to categorise and tag them for ease of reference. If you’re a book lover, you’ll relate to these.
1. The Book Thief
You love books so much that you just don’t give them back. It’s all very innocent, of course, but let it be known your bookcase is the product of a sustained pilfering campaign orchestrated by your sheer love of books. I never go around asking for my books back because a.) it would be uncouth and b.) books are such an innate piece of who we are that whenever somebody decides they like a book I’ve loaned them so much they want to keep it, it’s like they’ve decided instead to have that little bit of me stay with them forever. Totally not in a creepy way, I swear.
2. The Dog-Earer
You love your books like you love antiques. Worn. Rustic. Weathered. Sure, the librarians used to mount campaigns against folk of your type in their literary fortresses in days gone by but the reality is: you love books so much you wear them down. There’s no crime in loving a book so passionately that the pages tear and the corners get folded down. Except in Alabama. It’s probably illegal in Alabama.
3. The Serendipity Screamer
If you’re one of these, you read and share. And then tell everyone about how good reading and sharing is. Finished your book? Don’t keep it! Books are meant to be set free you say. So you release a book into the wild. On a park bench. On a train. On a sleeping person’s head in the park. You never know where it will end up but it doesn’t matter because you’ve shared a little knowledge or a little story with the world. And then you tell your friends how avant garde you are.
4. The Self-Conscious Reader
This person isn’t quite comfortable enough with their choice of literature (be it a bodice ripper or a detailed jam-making manifesto) so they pretend to read things like Proust and Hemingway instead. Then they start conversations about the mellifluous nature of prose while secretly hankering to get home and read about heaving chests. The self-conscious reader does not yet understand that we all have our guilty secrets, of course, and would be a lot more easy-going if and when they do.
5. The Did-Not-Finish
This person reads like staccato notes are played in music. Abruptly. Their problem is that they love books too much. They start one book, get distracted by several others, start reading them, get distracted and so on, ad infinitum. This person never quite knows how the books they started reading end, which explains why they think Elizabeth Bennett ends up marrying Ron Weasley in 1984. Or something.
6. The Underliner
Love that sentence? Underline it and save it for a rainy day! The Underliner likes an immersive reading experience and believes the margins were invented for scribbling notes in. These are usually vaguely descriptive affairs like ‘love!’ and multiple asterisks. I have an old study copy of The Great Gatsby which somebody has scrawled throughout. It’s a lovely addition to a great book but whomever took to the margins succeeded more or less in just re-wording what was already there.
7. The Reader-of-Things-You’ve-Never-Heard-Of
It’s not that this person deliberately sets out to be cool and ‘underground’, they really think that people are prone to reading the greater works of revolutionaries from sub-Saharan Africa. Innocent mistake, really. This person reads books you’ve never heard of like ‘The Greater Encyclopedia of Asian Emoticons’ and ‘A Guide to 5th Century Pottery’ written entirely on the inside lip of a clay urn.
But if the goal is simply that people are reading, then who is really complaining?
What kind of book lover are you? What have we missed?








Comments
305 Comments so far
The perpetual re-reader
This is me. I mean hey, there are LOADS of great books out there and when someone hits me over the head with something new I’ll read read read. But. I adore reading ‘comfort novels’ like I enjoy roast chicken. I’m not ashamed to have re-read the Harry Potter novels over 30 times each (no joke), Phryne Fisher series by Kerrie Greenwood. Janet Evanovich’s Stephanie Plum series. The novels of Jane Austen. It all started with my re-re-reading of the Baby Sitter Club novels as a young girl….. It just makes me happy. I’m always reading something, its just likely that its something I’ve already read.
loading...
I agree! I love to re-read a good book. And I too have read each Harry Potter many times. One of my favourite things to do is read Harry with a nice glass of red after everyone else has gone to bed. Makes me happy and is like catching up with an old friend.
And I too started my love of re-reading with Babysitters Club!
loading...
i’ve always thought about writing a blog post with book categories:
Books I insist everyone reads.
Books I will read every one to five years for the rest of my life.
Books that have changed me
My S Club Seven of books (i.e. trashy books I will never admit to liking publicly)
Books that I’d like back now thanks very much
Books I want my children to love as much as I do
loading...
Go on then! I am always looking for great book ideas. I love to read but hate to choose…
loading...
I’m a re-reader as well! And like you, I re-read my comfort novels, the ones that make me feel good, calm, happy and content. Bit like watching a good chick-flick for me.
loading...
I’ll put my hand up to that! I’m a re-reader, and like you, have read the Harry Potter books again and again and again. I’d say I’ve read them over 30 times each as well. A great book is enjoyable time and time again…it’s a fantastic feeling. Other books I re-read are anything by Jane Austen, Atonement, After You’d Gone and One Day (off the top of my head!)
loading...
I am a chronic re reader. If I don’t re read a book, it means I didn’t really like it, or like War and Peace, it was too exhausting the first time to bother re reading.
Like idle dad, I demand books back. A friend of my daughter’s is not allowed to leave our house with my books. If he wants to read, he must read them here, he’s that bad. It has led to us having a 25 year old lounging about the house at odd times, reading a book, but the death threats and “I know where you live”s didn’t work.
loading...
Speaking of book thieves, have you read The Book Thief? Brilliant book by an Australian author about Nazi Germany and the war.
http://www.booksattransworld.co.uk/thebookthief/
I always return books I have borrowed, but many are never returned to me and I don’t mind, once I’ve read them.
I would NEVER fold a page or write on a book – I find that disrespectful to the book itself. But I do crease the spine – something I try not to do but happens despite my best efforts.
loading...
Have I ever. It’s one of my favourites of all time.
loading...
Alyssa, The Book Thief is one of my ALL TIME FAVOURITES. It is just brilliant. Such an ambitious idea and Marcus Zusak totally nailed it.
loading...
have either of you read any of his other books? I think I would very much like to!
loading...
I’ve read The Messenger which is fantastic. Definitely recommend it. xxx
loading...
It’s now on the list! Thanks
loading...
The messenger by markus zusak is amazing. Great read!
loading...
I second this recommendation.
What a wonderful book. Totally destroyed me.
loading...
Ooo I could never get into htat book! I have tried to read it twice! Wierd, because a lady at work who I always chat books with, says it is brilliant and I would love it.
loading...
I just didn’t like The Book Thief at all. I thought it was a wonderful premise, but it just didn’t do it for me in the end. Maybe because I read as part of a (rather depressing) trifecta of it, The Reader by Bernard Schlink and Night by Elie Weisel – now they are great books.
loading...
I’m closest to a 7. Never a 1. And as for 2 and 6: The Horror! I will re-read favourites (I like the ‘Comfort Reader’ category mentioned below) but my basic reading style is ‘So Many Books – So Little Time’. I read fast and furious and when I’m on the last pages of one book have already decided which book I’m going to pick up next, if I haven’t started it already. The most books I’ve had on the go at one time recently is 5.
Generally when I’m finished with a book, it’s in the same condition as when I started it – no dog ears or bent covers – the spine doesn’t even get creased. This is not intentional and I only realised once my bookclub pointed it out.
loading...
Rick – I’m beginning to wonder if you have an astrologer helping you time your posts! Very apropos to have a book post on a Gemini Moon day.
loading...
Oh, I don’t even know what that means! But I’m guessing it is a good thing?
loading...
Absolutely! Gemini is the main communication sign and has a lot to do with writing, talking, reading and books. Was a lovely cosmic coincdence to see your post on reader styles, as well as the Guardian’s top 100 book lists coming out under that astro vibe. Many curioius readers about today for sure!
loading...
Back away slowly, Rick.
loading...
Oh IT IS ON.
loading...
Oooo also, that I love reading cartoon? That is the background picture on my phone and on my twitter account!! Love it!
loading...
i am always reading… i am 1 2 and a bit of the 3 as if i read a good book, i want my friends to read them, so i usually make them by just literally here it is read it, its amazing and then i keep asking them, what did you think, did u like it? a bit annoying,i know, but they mostly thank me for the book… yesterday, i was reading my book (i came to say goodbye by caroline overington) and i was about to dog-ear it when my 11 yo yelled at me “you should never do that with a book, get yourself a bookmark!”
loading...
I am the “Library lover”. I love books so much, but I always get them out from the library to read. I scour Good Reading magazine every month for books I might like and put them on hold at the library to read!
Ohhh…I also go to LifeLine’s bookfest every 6 months and pick up anything that looks good, and they fill my shelves and I haven’t read ANY of them, because I always have books out from the library I need to read FIRST because they have to go back! Honestly, I have a minimum of 10 books out from the library at any one time, and 20 on hold!
When I grow up, I want to have a library in my house. My own little reading room. Then I hopefully will be able to afford to buy books instead of going to the library, and I will have a nice reading chair near a big window and I can sit amongst my books and read all day and forget about everything else!
I feel sick at the idea of e-books. I hate them! I’ve decided that when I travel, I will take books with me (probably one that has been gathering dust on my shelves from years gone by Bookfest purchases that I have not read in favour of library books) and leave them on seats at the airport for people to pick up and read, rather than use a kindle or something! Book re-gifting!
Good post Rick. I love reading. We should start an MM book club!
loading...
i love the library too, i am always there,e specially if i have spare time, grab a cup of coffee and read all the latest mags and then take my books home!
loading...
We’re always talking about books at MM so I’m very happy here indeed!
loading...
You should start the MM book club Rick, write a post calling for book nominations and categories, and then majority rules and then do a post a month or so later for the book club meeting! Yes!!
I already nominate Jessica Rudd’s new book, when it eventually comes out.
loading...
I gave the first Ruby book to my sister to read as I loved it, and thought she would enjoy it. This is the only book I have ever lent her that she has finished. If Jessica Rudd can turn my sister into a reader, I’ll be super excited!
loading...
I’m most of those and one more .. I keep a list in my computer of books other people talk about that I think I want to read so next time I want a book, I don’t have to curse about not remembering the name of the one I want to read. The list is getting really long though and I’m starting to wonder if I can even read all of them in my lifetime … yikes!
loading...
I’ve got a list on my phone
loading...
Try goodreads.com and if you have iPad or iPhone there is a free app. Tracks books you have read, want to read, are reading, etc. I find it really helpful for the want to read section mostly.
loading...
Really?? …finally, I have a good reason to get an iphone
loading...
The.Android app is free, too.
loading...
Haha – love this! I am an avid reader and own bookshelves of beautiful fiction and non-fiction books but I have difficulty sharing my personal copies!! Isn’t that totally awful? It stemmed from the trauma of loaning my Baby-Sitters Club books in primary school and receiving them in all states of distress (“sorry, dropped it in the bath” or “my sister ripped out those pages”) or not at all. As an adult I love discussing books with friends – tis one of life’s great pleasures – but I ungenerously hoard my own copies like my own life depends on it or make vague excuses when friends request to borrow it. When friends come around and grab a book from the shelf, requesting ‘Can I borrow this?’ I wince and feign a casual ‘Oh sure’. But inside, it is killing me. I get such pleasure from seeing them lined up in my house – untouched by other people’s pens and dog-earring fingers and absent-minded forgetfulness. I know this utterly shameful but I am getting better as I get older and realising the error of my ways. Wish I could be a ‘Serendipity Screamer’ – I’ll try to be less possessive!!! So yes, maybe a 9th category – The Possessive Hoarder – who loves books not only as stories but as precious objects!
loading...
I’m not ALONE!….err, I mean that person I know…
loading...
I think there might be more of us out there – admiring our precious collections with Golum-like pleasure … we don’t mean to be so …uptight or ungenerous … it’s just that no-one seems to understand that you don’t just throw a book into a bag if you’re reading it on the train – no, you put it in a plastic sleeve or a paper bag and you always, always use a book mark – that’s not too much to ask is it?!
loading...
My boyfriend’s mum came to stay and borrowed a book while she was here. Sure. Borrow a book-that’s fine… Then a few days later she dropped into conversation how she spilt something on it. Milk. Oh but she cleaned it off… No worries…That’s ok… deep breaths, tight smile….
Or books tahtare returned that have lived in the bottom of someone’s bag-creased, dirty, spine bent back…. when it went out in pristine condition.
I TAKE CARE OF MY BOOKS GODDAMMIT! Breathe….
loading...
What an interesting piece. I hate Book Thiefs, they’re kind of light lighter stealers in the days when people smoked. I am definitely a Dog Earer and proud of it, but it’s also why I’m not a Book Thief, because I forget to return them and some people are too precious about their books. I am definitely a Serendipity Reader when a book is that good – The Help springs to mind recently – and can be Self Conscious when I occasionally feel a need to read trash (although rare) but I can say, I am very rarely a Did-not-Finisher – it’s got to be extra crappy to do that – i.e. Men are From Mars, etc…. Therefore I would like to define myself as a Voracious-Messy-Reader-of-Pretty-Much-Anything-That’s-Gets-My-Braincells-Pumping-And-Introduces-Me-To-New-Ways-Of-Thinking-About-Things! Short and sweet no?
loading...
Can I ask why you’re proud of being a Dog-Earer? I’m one of those annoying neat freaks and I just can’t work out what could be good about it…
loading...
Sure darlin, for me it’s part of the devouring process when I love a good book. I don’t want it neat and perfect when I’m done, I want it loved up and battered. As you don’t understand me, I don’t understand neat freaks, but one thing I’ve learnt is to never ever borrow books from anyone who is precious about their books – we just don’t understand each other. For me, mashing it up is definitely part of my enjoyment. I know it doesn’t make sense but it’s my thing you know xxx.
loading...
I fall into a few of the categories, but not predominantly in any of them.
I’m a 3 in the sense that when I’ve read something incredible, I tell everyone who will listen to me how amazing it is – I don’t release it “into the wild” though.
I’m only a 5 on rare occasions, such as with Jane Eyre, Frankenstein and On The Road – just couldn’t finish them.
I am a 7 sometimes – not often.
This is the book reader that I am – the perfectionist book reader. When I loan someone a book, nothing irks me more than getting it back with the previously pristine spine now creased and pages dog-earred. I like my books to look perfect, so am very careful to keep them in perfect condition – for example, I bought all the Harry Potter books in hard cover because I know I will read them quite frequently and don’t want to crease the spine. I also get annoyed when I lend a book and never get it back, while others don’t mind, I do, usually because I lend people books that I adore and I want to share it with them and I like to get the amazing book back. Maybe I’m just being uptight, but I like to receive my books back in the condition in which I lent them out.
loading...
Monique, you and I could never share books – you’d hate me!
loading...
I now scope out the state of people’s books before lending them. I know that sounds crazy, but each to their own. I completely understand that some people like to dog-ear their books and crease the spines, showing that the book is loved etc. it’s just not me.
loading...
Me too!
loading...
I am a dog-earer, I have had so many bookmarks and lose them all.
I am also a comfort reader like Josephine. I have many books that I will re-read many times. I have read all HP books at least 4 times and any books by Jennifer Crusie at least 10times
I am also speed reader. I read fast and also if I love a book and find myself lost in it, it is not uncommon for me to read until I finish. Many books have been read in a night and a couple of the longer ones took me two.
I love books and consider it one of my greatest accomplishments that I got my partner into reading.
loading...
I’ve been an all-night reader since I started reading as a child. Some nights it was unbearable to stop and I spent them under the covers with a torch, my book and the cat. Good times!
loading...
Many times I have woken up at stupid o’clock with the light still on and the bookon the floor after falling asleep while reading
loading...
What about the pristine, “my books look like they’ve never been read” book hoarders? They treat their books like precious gems, never spill things on them, or use-dog-ears, or bend book spines beyond 50 degrees…and NEVER NEVER EVER lend them to ANYONE…I, err, THEY don’t care how good you are at looking after books…
Of course, I’m talking about someone else, not me…really!
loading...
You are my nemesis.
loading...
You mean that person I know…not me…
loading...
This is exactly me! But I do lend books and have been known on occasion to cry when books have been returned to me with creased spines. Glad I’m not the only one
loading...
arghhh!!!….creased spines!!!…it’s like people don’t really care about books…THEY HAVE FEELINGS TOO, PEOPLE….
loading...
Could not agree with you more on that! I like books to look pristine in my book case
loading...
But, but I have a relationship with books! We grow old together, we both get wrinkles with every read, we share meals…
loading...
You must be talking about my sister, her books always look brand new. She once lent a book out and it came back creased so she bought herself another copy of it!
Last year she lent me a book and it arrived with a bookmark in it…not that I would ever dog ear a book!!
Their definitely needs to be a category 8 for this type of reader
loading...
I, err that person I know, may have once done the same…
loading...
I’m a 2! I always dog-ear the pages of my books. Never have bookmarks nearby. Plus a book that is worn and battered has been truly loved! My books have coffee stains and dog-eared pages and sometimes water damage (due to ugly bath incidents) but they tell the story of how much I have loved them.
loading...
I love that you, an author, have validated my reading habits!
loading...
Yes! My books are full of coffee, red wine and chocolate — and signs of being waterlogged. I could never part with them. I still have my copy of ‘Two Weeks with the Queen’ from when I was eight, and Lord, does that one tell many stories…
loading...
I’m a dog earer OCCASIONALLY. I will only dog ear a page if there is NOTHING to use as a book mark,. I start books and then start another, then go back to the one I started in the first place. I don’t write in books, they’re too precious for that. I will lend books out, but hunt them down until the day I die to get them back in my book case, but lend me a book and you may not see it again. Just sayin’.
Oh, and the day libraries and real books are replaced by e-readers, kindles and iPads is going to be a very sad day!
loading...
I agree. I just can’t do the Kindle. It goes against every fibre of my being…
loading...
I also agree. Hate hate hate e-books. Depresses me.
loading...
I shocked my husband by deciding I needed a Kindle – and I love it. Not only do I have heaps of books on hand, I AM going out to buy the ones I really love after I have read them on Kindle. It’s not exactly the money saving exercise I thought it would be!! But I try to view it as a library substitute rather than replacing my love of owning books altogether. The house we are building right now has a wicked library and it was THE most important room in the house. I will never give up books.
loading...
Oooh, I am 2 and 7… I am a reformed 1.
I have very eclectic tastes and will read anything as long as it is well written. I also read multiple books at a time. I am currently reading: collapse, how civilizations survive or fail, the Roberta Williams autobiography ( crap, but I have almost finished it) committed by Elizabeth Gilbert , the dragon keepers by Robin hobb (re reading that one actually) the biography of Valerie plame ( CIA agent outted by bush) and last but not least the 19th wife about historical and modern Mormon sects- really enjoying that one.
loading...
Almost anything by Robin Hobb is on my ‘comfort’ list. Love her writing…
loading...
My ultimate comfort read is the assassins apprentice series, then the the three ships trilogy, followed by the “fool” series. Read one after the other. I probably do this about once a year… Love love love Robin hobb.
loading...
Rick, I’d like to put forward another category, if I may…
The Comfort Reader
This person has a small collection of absolute favourite books that they can return to time and again – when in-between new books, or in times of strife when in need of familiar old friends.
I am most definitely the Comfort Reader
loading...
That is definitely me as well, mum wonders how I can keep reading and re-reading the same books without getting bored.
loading...
Me too! Good call, I like that.
loading...
Me too! I am Comfort Re-Reader type
loading...
I dog-ear. I underline. I note-take. I loan out copies and then buy replacement copies for myself. I sometimes buy second copies if I like the cover more. I always have about five or six to read. I also hate kindles and will get into a fight with anyone who tells me bookstores and books are obsolete.
loading...
I’m 1, 2 and 5. I’ll borrow your book, dog-ear the pages, never finish it and forget to give it back. (Don’t ever lend me a book!)
loading...
I don’t fit into any of those tbh
loading...
You can add your own!
loading...
Well, in that case….
I guess I’m the Subtle/Low Key Reader. My books are all over place, I try to keep them in good shape (even going so far as to cover the corners with sticky tape so that they wouldn’t split. ALWAYS use bookmarks. My days of underlining and highlighting over- haven’t done that in a novel since high school. I rarely lend my books out anymore, mainly because my friends either already have a copy or they’re not interested. But I’m forever trying to get them to read the same things as me because it would be nice for them to know a quote or reference when I use one.
loading...
I am definitely “The Dog-Earer”
loading...
Hemingway – one ‘m’ only please Rick x
loading...
I love the letter ‘M’ SO much…
loading...
I’m a 1, 2 and 5!
loading...
I think I might also be all of them!
loading...