Do You Like This Story?
BookLove 380x380 The 7 types of book lover.

Bliss.

My friends are a metaphorical abyss into which my books tend to fall. They’re like a cosmic black hole just sucking my literature into their unyielding maws. Book grabbers. Thieves. Marauders.

But they do, it must be acknowledged, love books. It’s hard to stay mad at somebody who likes to read. Instead, I’ve decided to categorise and tag them for ease of reference. If you’re a book lover, you’ll relate to these.

1. The Book Thief

You love books so much that you just don’t give them back. It’s all very innocent, of course, but let it be known your bookcase is the product of a sustained pilfering campaign orchestrated by your sheer love of books. I never go around asking for my books back because a.) it would be uncouth and b.) books are such an innate piece of who we are that whenever somebody decides they like a book I’ve loaned them so much they want to keep it, it’s like they’ve decided instead to have that little bit of me stay with them forever. Totally not in a creepy way, I swear.

2. The Dog-Earer

You love your books like you love antiques. Worn. Rustic. Weathered. Sure, the librarians used to mount campaigns against folk of your type in their literary fortresses in days gone by but the reality is: you love books so much you wear them down. There’s no crime in loving a book so passionately that the pages tear and the corners get folded down. Except in Alabama. It’s probably illegal in Alabama.

3. The Serendipity Screamer

If you’re one of these, you read and share. And then tell everyone about how good reading and sharing is. Finished your book? Don’t keep it! Books are meant to be set free you say. So you release a book into the wild. On a park bench. On a train. On a sleeping person’s head in the park. You never know where it will end up but it doesn’t matter because you’ve shared a little knowledge or a little story with the world. And then you tell your friends how avant garde you are.

4. The Self-Conscious Reader

This person isn’t quite comfortable enough with their choice of literature (be it a bodice ripper or a detailed jam-making manifesto) so they pretend to read things like Proust and Hemingway instead. Then they start conversations about the mellifluous nature of prose while secretly hankering to get home and read about heaving chests. The self-conscious reader does not yet understand that we all have our guilty secrets, of course, and would be a lot more easy-going if and when they do.

reading The 7 types of book lover.

.

5. The Did-Not-Finish

This person reads like staccato notes are played in music. Abruptly. Their problem is that they love books too much. They start one book, get distracted by several others, start reading them, get distracted and so on, ad infinitum. This person never quite knows how the books they started reading end, which explains why they think Elizabeth Bennett ends up marrying Ron Weasley in 1984. Or something.

6. The Underliner

Love that sentence? Underline it and save it for a rainy day! The Underliner likes an immersive reading experience and believes the margins were invented for scribbling notes in. These are usually vaguely descriptive affairs like ‘love!’ and multiple asterisks. I have an old study copy of The Great Gatsby which somebody has scrawled throughout. It’s a lovely addition to a great book but whomever took to the margins succeeded more or less in just re-wording what was already there.

7. The Reader-of-Things-You’ve-Never-Heard-Of

It’s not that this person deliberately sets out to be cool and ‘underground’, they really think that people are prone to reading the greater works of revolutionaries from sub-Saharan Africa. Innocent mistake, really. This person reads books you’ve never heard of like ‘The Greater Encyclopedia of Asian Emoticons’ and ‘A Guide to 5th Century Pottery’ written entirely on the inside lip of a clay urn.

But if the goal is simply that people are reading, then who is really complaining?

What kind of book lover are you? What have we missed?

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

305 Comments so far

  1. essessesse

    I’m a Preserver. I like my books to look as thought they’re untouched by human hand. No eating or drinking when reading them, no bending back pages or breaking spines. They are my treasures.

    I’ll loan books but I tell the potential borrower the conditions before they’re allowed to take The Precious, at first people seem incredulous but my close friends know I’m deadly serious. Very often they say they can’t take the pressure and refuse the loan! I’ll happily lend 2nd hand books, this makes me much happier. My most popular loan – and the one which rarely comes back – is Kate Atkinson’s Behind the Scenes at the Museum. I’ve only ever owned one brand new copy, all subsequent copies have been 2nd hand. I’m passionate about people reading it and I console myself that at least it’s giving other people some pleasure. At least I hope so……

    Having said that, I’ve had a Kindle for just over a year now and I adore it. I’m reading ‘Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy’ at the moment. It’s beautifully written, stunning prose. Everyone should read it!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. clairek

    I have had a falling out with a friend who is a book thief! I lent her about 6 books months ago and was adamant that I needed them back. I asked her a couple of times for them and she kept forgetting. I even saw some of them on her book case, as though they’d moved in with her for ever! They were some of my faves and I am very attached to them – I love my books! Plus they are worth about $200.

    Anyhoo we’ve had a falling out and are not speaking (childish I know) and she still has my beloved books. What do I do?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • essessesse

      Kiss them goodbye.

      Write your name in your books in future, that way you can pull the book off the shelf and say, “oh, good, I’ve been looking for this. I’ll take it home with me today.”

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • clarinette

        Or do that now. Fake a coffee visit and leave with your books, dammit. Especially if she’s willing to sacrifice your friendship just so she can keep the books lol….

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  3. ReplyPaid

    Rick, firstly, a huge congratulations on such a beautifully written and entertaining post. You are just getting better and better.

    I definitely fall into categories 2, 3 & 7 and may occasionally be deemed a 1 and 4. Shucks, I recently returned a book to a friend that I have had for five years. So sorry.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. missalyss

    I’m a hoarder and an obsessive re-reader.

    I don’t like lending books to people. My sister took my first Harry Potter book to school, which I’ve owned since I was 5 (ten years) and had bite marks from when my sisters were babies. AND SHE LOST IT. I will never forgive her for that. Even if it turns up.

    I also re-read books heaps. I actually prefer to re-read an old favourite than find a new book. You always know what’s going to happen and you don’t have to worry about the book turning out to be really crap.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. MissT

    The hoarder!!

    Husband has a library. And a study. And our spare room. And the lounge room. We have 24 bookshelves (standard 80cm Billy) full and more boxes in the garage.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • cmx

      Love! So jealous… I have 3 full (read *overflowing*) book cases, and a number of boxes and loose books strewn around the bedroom. As a renter I just a) don’t have the storage space, and b) get a bad back when I move…!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  6. Bex

    I dog ear, I immerse and I don’t like to lend.
    I’ve stopped writing in books and can never re- read and I enjoy receiving but giving recommendations. My mother in law and I trade books and in doing so she has managed to get me to read some types of books I would probably not pick for myself. I started a list long ago for my children regarding what books I would like them to read and it was a lovely moment when my 13 year old read and told me how much he loved To Kill A Mockingbird and would like his own copy. Will NEVER get an e-reader.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Anonymous

    Why buy books when they are freely available at Libraries all over the place. Sure a book might not always be available exactly when you want it, but why spend a whole heap of money on something that will probably be only read once then left of a shelf to gather dust or impress friends with your collection.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • skinnyflatwhite

      Libraries are great, particularly when you just want a short-term relationship with a book…. but sometimes you come across books that you want to have and to hold, so to speak!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Bee

      Because a book is a friend you want to spend time with again.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Freya

      A) To support the author so their sales go up and then their publishers let them write another book
      B) You can’t dog-ear or underline a book you borrow.
      C) Comforting. It’s nice knowing they are there if you want to read them again, or find that quote, or lend it to someone who you think would benefit from it (and by lend, I normally mean give. i don’t believe in asking for books back, so i’ll wind up buying myself a new copy).

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Erica

      I love using my local library if its a book that I’m not sure I’m going to like. But if I end up loving the book, I’ll often go out and buy it to support the author who gave me so much enjoyment.
      if its a book I’m sure i’ll like, then I’ll buy my own copy straight away (eg/ most things by Alexander McCall Smith)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  8. Ronnie

    What about “Compulsive Book-Buyer” as another category??

    I go a little crazy whenever I enter a book store – the urge to buy is overwhelming, almost like an addiction…I guess the problem is me trying to stay away from book stores, because I feel like visiting almost every day!!!

    This would not be so bad if I didn’t mind purchasing second-hand books, but they MUST be absolutely pristine and I only like to shop at independent book stores…which means I frequently end up with an empty wallet and a full bookshelf!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anon.

      Im addticted to buying books too – anywhere, anytime. I love second hand books, new books, but my fave place at the moment is online at the book depository – and its wayyyy to easy to buy from it. I love books, I love the feel, the places that they take me and best of all, I love having them on my shelf to look at – my books are all a part of me and I even write in the front where and when I purchased them. I will loan them out, but only to my sisters and my Mum. I have all my books from my childhood too and cant wait to share them with my daughter when she is older – she loves books already and is only 20 months old.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  9. Skinnyflatwhite

    I’m a comfort re-reader as someone coined below.
    There is also another type of reader, let’s call them the misguided nitpicker reader, who takes it upon themselves to correct grammatical/spelling errors in library books – they roam the western suburbs of Perth marking up books. I’ve had several library books that have had the ‘mom’s changed to ‘mum’s etc.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • coaster

      I think the nitpickers have been on holidays in NSW recently :) The last few books I got from the library had lots of corrections written throughout them and most were incorrect as well!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • skinnyflatwhite

        Yes – they must be the same people!! Perhaps they travel around Australia, correcting one library book at a time?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  10. hannahfromsa

    I live in a family of book thieves. So I hoard books and have no shame in asking for them when I’ve lent them out. You have to be a verrrry good friend for me to even consider it. Every now and again when I’m home and retrieve all the books that my brother has nicked from me.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. Bradley

    I won’t lend my books to anyone ! I treat mine with such utter respect. No writing in the margins, no underlining passages, no dog earring the pages. Books that I’ve had for over 30 years are still in pristine condition. The only things that define the age of the books are yellowing pages and very cheap prices listed on the back.

    I do admit to writing my name and the date of purchase on the inside cover.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • missamoo

      Me too and i generally write where i am, like what city or country. My friends used to make fun of me then one of them started doing it and told me he finally realised why i did it.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  12. KatLizzy

    I am a book thief – only with my mum’s books. I am also a Did-Not-Finisher. It took me 9 years to read Wuthering Heights – finally finished it on a train travelling through the grey, cold Yorkshire moors. A beautiful end to an absolute CHORE OF A BOOK.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. kylie

    What i never understand are the people who read the last page first. What is with that????????????????

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. natalie272

    I’m definitely number 5. The Did-Not-Finish. Started so many books that I did not finish. I’ve only really finished the ones that I’ve made myself finish! I lose interest too quickly!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Gab

    Great post Rick. I’m definitely a Serendipity Screamer and can become almost evangelical when it comes to recommending something I’ve loved…
    The Book Thief is also one of my faves. Other books I’ve loved are at http://www.dudleyday.com/ on the Best Books page.
    Sir Richard Steele said, ‘Reading is to the mind what exercise is to the body.’

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. Acanberramum

    Re #2 I do the double dog ear with books that I especially love or loathe. Top of page for where I am up to, bottom of page gets folded for things that I absolutely must discuss with someone. Usually after I have convinced certain someone to read said book (harder to do if it’s one I loathe!).

    Re #1 I love my books to bits, even the bad ones. They bring up such important memories of my life stages. So, I really hate it when I loan them out to people, only for them to disappear into the universe, never to be heard from again. If anyone out there has my copy of We Need to Ralk About Kevin, I would love to have it back :)

    My husband and I share a love of books such that we gave our favourite book as a gift to the guests at our wedding. We figured that would be longer lasting than sugar coated almonds, and lovely to hear reports back from our friends and family about whether they loved the book as much as we do…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Which book was that?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Gee Jen

      That’s such a cool idea re: the wedding gift!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  17. Loulee

    Definitely love to share books. Nothing better than sharing a book with friends and family. I love reading.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  18. Tatania

    I love all my books.. I can never bring myself to throw old ones out or donate.. they are like family!! They are rough, worn, torn and loved! I always write my name in them and the year I read them.. and I encourage my family and friends to do the same thing under mine..

    AND! I am a re-reader… I can’t help it.. if I love a book or series its like going back to a comfy spot and getting reaquainted.. and I swear I always find lots of things I either dont remember or read over last time!

    I lament the demise of the bookshop.. browsing online is not quite the same feeling as walking into a shop and randomly browsing the shelves and gambling upon a gem.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. Fat Heffalump

    Don’t make me use my librarian voice on you dog ear readers! Wearing them out is one thing, but willfully damaging them… HMPH!!

    It really doesn’t matter what you read, so long as you are reading. Trust me, I am a librarian!

    I am none of the above. I could add lots of different types of readers to this list. I’ll nominate my own type as No.8:

    8. The multi-tasker. Has several books running at any time. One in the handbag, one by the bed, one on the coffee table. Always has a list of books on them so that they can pick up a book on the fly at the nearest bookshop or library. Can remember and separate the characters, settings and plots of every book they are reading, plus the any they’ve read in the past. Great for recommendations and reviews.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Tatania

      oh yes I have more than one on the go always!! usually a fiction and non-fiction!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Rick Morton

      I have 7 on the go at the moment so I feel you on point number 8.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • marmalady

      Yep, definitely a multi-tasker here too. Usually have about 5 books on the go at once..and then a couple on the library waiting list and a couple on their way from bookdepository.co.uk :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • I flirted with the idea of giving up law to become a librarian. Then I changed jobs and realised I do actually like practising law!

      I researched librarianship so much, I am determined to work in a library at some stage – probably when I live overseas!

      What kind of librarian are you? Sorry to be nosey, I’m just interested!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • elli

      Ooh me too! I’ve always got a number of books on the go, sometimes more than one novel at once. There might be the book that’s too heavy to lug to work so remains beside the bed, the smaller one that’s more handbag-sized, and the one/s on my phone’s Kindle app. The only time I’ve got plots confused was when I was reading two similar novels simultaneously – maybe A Modern Witch & A Discovery of Witches LOL.

      My holiday reading is always something I know I’ll like, either a book I’ve read before or a new one by a favourite author.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • anon.

      Im a number 8 too!!!!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • missamoo

      I have a booklist that i email to my family for Christmas and Birthday makes life much easier.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  20. crystalanne83

    I have a friend that will not borrow library or firends books, or buy second hand books. Just in case the person before her has read them in the toilet.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rick Morton

      Now that is certainly interesting!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Haha I always feel bad if I am reading a library book at the hairdressers and they are cutting my hair. I do try to get the bits of red out of the book, but sometimes, I just can’t and I think of the next reader…It definately won’t be your friend!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        my mother worked as a librarian – they called this sort of thing ‘unidentified bodily excretions’… (eewww!)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Emmeline

      I hate it when you are reading a library book or a book from the book exchange and you come across a hair, piece of dried food (heaven forbid it dislodges and falls on MY floor or rug or bed) or splatter of some sort of liquid (all the while i’m thinking – drink, blood, snot??).

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  21. Anonymous

    I hate it when people don’t return books! I always re-read my favs and it sucks when you realise why its not on the shelf – its been 5years but still miss my copy of Life of Pie everday :(

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Jane

      I always put “Stolen from Jane” on my books and funnily enough they come back!!!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  22. frazun

    I am a Book Groper. Walking into Dymocks George street as a special treat makes my heart leap with joy. I love picking up books that look interesting, reading the cover and moving on to the next one. The tactile nature of doing this is just wonderful. I keep a mental tally of which ones to go back to and retrace my steps once I have had a look at everything and make the odd purchase according to my budget…and yes, there is a set routine involved!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Shelleyrae

    I’m A Book Hoarder – Even though I read a book every two days or so I have shelves full of books, triple stacked and spilling out that I haven’t read yet but nevertheless keep adding to (and my e-reader is even worse) I love books so much I can’t bear the idea of missing out on one…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • cmx

      Me too – the number of times I’ve sworn to myself “I will not buy another book until I’ve made a significant dent in the pile of unreads already at home” only to convince myself that “oh, except for THIS one of course”

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  24. Shaezy

    We have issues at our house – hubby is the Anal Retentive Book Freak who has a close of circle of one other person he will lend books to (and it’s not me). His books are pristine, and don’t even have as much as a small crease in the spine.

    I am the Dog Earer, Underliner, Highlighter, Notetaker, Spine Crusher. All done with love and adoration. A bashed up book is a well loved book in my opinion! When I loan my books out, I encourage the borrower to do the same – then when I re-read it I get some fascinating opinions and notes of others and their interpretations.

    Subsequently, I am not allowed to borrow hubby’s books. If I even look at them with intent he gets cranky!

    I am also the One Sitting Reader – it’s rare for me not to finish a book in one sitting (usually between 8pm till whenever it takes except Diana Gabaldon’s bloody Outlander series – those things are tomes. Boring tomes a lot of the time too.) which usually means I am tired and cranky the next day, especially if I have loved the book and didn’t want to finish it! I just have self control issues with the phrase “just one more chapter”!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      The Outlander Series are my favourite ever books and like you I read them in massive chunks, the last few though have been a big struggle. The first 4 were great. My original Cross Stitch went to God last year – it literally fell apart from the rough treatment and rereading.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • kadriyeburggraaff

      I have managed to read Diana Gabaldon’s books in one sitting every time. Except the last one, and that was only because I now have 2 children who just wouldn’t let. By the time the next one comes out, I’ll have 3…. Gonna take even longer. *sigh*

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kirstchick

        I absolutely love reading but I don’t fit into any of your 7 types. I work more on a barter system where I may have “loaned” books on my shelves but my book loving friends have my books on their shelves. I know this becos I have lost count of how many times I have bought The Lovely Bones for my own shelf & it’s always “missing”. Sadly my book reading has been severely lacking due to have two young boys that use up all my time & energy…I read half a page & fall asleep zzzzz

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  25. crystalanne83

    I am a book borrower. I hate chosing my own so I borrow them from friends and family. I promise I return them though!

    PS- I LOVE that first pic – do you have a source?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. g

    haha ” the greater works of revolutionaries from sub-Saharan Africa” love that line

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. Trish

    You’ve missed out those of us who will read anything. Back of packets, instructions, whatever is around.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rick Morton

      I count myself firmly among this troupe.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • 30dollardate

      I’m one of those too!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • feistyangel

      Me too. I find it hard (very very hard) to sit and eat if I’m not able to read anything. If I’m out at a restaurant I will find the special board and read that if I have to, over and over again.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Lisa

      Yep – and nobody likes coming to the Museum or exhibitions with me – You gotta read all the info right??

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • clarinette

      Cereal box reader here, always been, always will be :D

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  28. adychen

    I am…. the Completely immersed Lazy Listener?….lol.
    I waste so much money on buying 2 of every book – one in the normal paperbacks, and one in audio book versions (if available). Somehow the atmosphere of what the book is trying to portray comes to live so much more when listening and reading at the same time….

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • clarinette

      This is how i got the first slap of my life when i was 6: was reading the story as the teacher was reading it to us. She thought i was “not listening” to her….

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  29. SamGW

    My two yr old sleeps with books lined down each side of her body under her quilt. Bless. My 10 year old does the good ol’ torch under the quilt to read (bless Harry Potter books, Rowling is a genius in getting kids’ into books). My eight year old however proclaims reading to be boring. As someone who has no less than 15 books in/on my bedside table at the moment, it breaks my heart! I hope she finds a love for books… and becomes one of these types!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. Oh, another category…I’m like this…it can take me 6 months to read the first half of a book, and 6 hours to read the second half. I guess you could call me the “slow-starter”…

    I have 3 slow-start books in progress at the moment…I’m due for a reading marathon on one of them sometime soon…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • alison

      i have to agree. it takes me AGES these day to get ‘into’ a book, and once i’m ‘into it’ i finish it in a nano-second. i’m onto my second book this year – kate morton’s ‘the distant hours’ – ive been reading it since about march! :(

      I am appalled at how little time i allow myself to read these days. when i was younger i used to do the ol’ torch under the doona trick to keep reading at night! :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  31. girly

    I am the dog-earer – my boyfriend got upset when I did it to one of his books.. woops.

    He is the serendipity screamer. He is trying to get me to read David Eddings. It is good, only a few pages in so far. He is reading it for the 5th time.

    When engrossed in a book, I will tune out the world. Once I missed my train stop going to work! Currently reading “Love is the Best Medicine” by Dr Nick Trout. Huge animal lover. :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • An Idle Dad

      David & Leigh Eddings’ Pawn of Prophecy series of five books was staple multiple readings when I was a teen. Even now, I’ve rebought those books and love ‘em.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • karynainsworth

      I bought the Eddings books so that I could share them.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  32. elli

    I’m a 4, 5 and anti-2.

    If I know someone is a dog-earer (or, goddess forbid, a highlighter!) I’ll invent an excuse not to lend my book to them. I once mostly-convinced my Dad that he’d already read a book I didn’t want him to maul. I don’t let people get away with being book thieves – after 6 months or so I’ll ask for it to be returned as I’d like to lend it to someone else.

    I have 6 or so books beside my bed, all with bookmarks in them. Which I pick up depends on what mood I’m in, what I just finished, and how heavy it is to carry around. That’s the good thing about my phone’s Kindle app: I can buy books for much cheaper than the hard copy price and they don’t weigh anything. Perfect for commuting or at work.

    I’d like to have more elite taste in books. I once bought The God of Small Things but it was so effing boring it’s still unfinished. I then bought Tara Moss’s The Blood Countess and inhaled it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • I’m the same Elli. It took me two weeks to read Jonathan Franzen’s “Freedom”, which has much critical acclaim. I then inhaled a chick lit book in two days over the weekend!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • picardie.girl

      I am also VERY anti-2!! Writing in book margins and dog-earing corners is sacrilegious to me. Although I’m not as anal as my friend who even prefers her books remain with spines uncracked.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  33. kellyexeter

    I am definitely a dog-earer … I have read all the books on my shelf countless times.
    I am an also an escapist reader. I WANT to read intellectual books and non-fiction books and the classics. But limited time and a desire to escape sees me returning to fantasy again and a again.
    Mind you Rick .. thanks to you, I recently made myself get through Bill Bryson’s Short History after one previous failed attemp. Was totally worth the effort :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rick Morton

      Oh my, someone took my advice and agreed! I love that you did. I totally heart that book.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Megan

      Ditto! I have begun Bryson’s Short History twice and given up because I just want to escape my world and visit another fantasy one when I read. Will have to persist!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  34. L.M.Montgomery

    Love the description of Reader type No. 5.’The Did- Not- Finish’ antics, but there could also be a sub-section in this category, of those who technically ‘Do-Not-Finish’ and ‘Skip- to- Last -Pages’ to complete ‘the Not -So- Good -Read.’

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. Holly

    I’m with Kat below, I’m definitely an immersive reader. My Mum used to get quite annoyed by having to ask me something 3 times before she could get my attention when I was reading as a kid. Now it’s my husband and kids getting annoyed when they can’t break through the book barrier!

    I also have books that I re-read for comfort – there’s nothing quite like picking up your favourite book on a cold rainy day and settling in for a good session :) Some of my family members and friends think I’m quite weird for being able to re-read my favourite books. My record for one book is about 5 times!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Arthur C Clarke’s 3001 (yes, that’s not a typo) is my comfort book. 3001 is about Frank Poole, the astronaut who was killed by HAL 9000 in 2001: A Space Odyssey. His body is found in deep space and they bring him back to life. I just love reading what Clarke thinks the year 3001 will be like…I don’t know why, but I can re-read that one over and over again…usually in a day…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • An Idle Dad

        Except that Clarke continously copied vast chapters out of previous books and pasted into all his subsequent 2001 series of books. Didn’t you find that annoying?

        3001 was interesting though.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Yeah…the 2001 series is not my favourite…much preferred Rama…but I just loved 3001 from the get-go!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • XANTHE

      It was Billy Connolly who said that he only needs to own one book because he has forgotten it in 6 months and can read it again. I can relate, but
      I’m also with you, Holly – I think I must have every book I’ve ever owned since I was a baby … AND I keep re-reading them all, because “luckily” I read so much that I can forget what’s in those gone before.
      I do read newer ones too – avidly – everything I can get my mitts on.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Holly

        Me too Xanthe, isn’t it lovely! I feel all happy just thinking about my well-loved collection of books :)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  36. Charlie

    Rick, I confess to being both a book thief, and also a recovering dog earer. My husband hates that I fold the pages down (even though he is not a big reader… ) and will rouse on me if I do this to anyone’s books, so I have become much better. But i do accidentally never give books back to a friend and for this I am often very remorseful and embarrassed when I see it in my book case… but so much so that too much time has passed to give it back without further embarrassment! Also I am terrible at returning books to the library so rarely go there, now… my husband, once again, ends up returning them and paying my fines after I confess to receiving numerous reminders. Oh the shame! but like you said, it’s all very well intentioned, I just forget and too much time passes…. i am glad there are lovely book readers out there like you that forgive us book thieves.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rick Morton

      I not only forgive, there’s something I find quite endearing about it! As much as I love my own library of books, I do think they should be communal…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  37. Kat

    I think there needs to be another category – the immersive reader. When I am reading something great something has to be said at least 3 times to get my attention, and anything not life-or-death waits until I find out what happens.

    That said, I do have a comfort reader tendency – Little Women is my go-to book. Mum is a clear-cut anal retentive reader – she even used to cringe at me highlighting and annotating uni notes!

    As for the e-reader issue, I have made the switch to Kindle. I still buy some book in hard copy, if they are not on Kindle. I am still not convinced it is the same experience as a paper book but at half the price it is tough to say no.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • An Idle Dad

      My wife’s name is Kat and she is exactly like that and has switched to Kindle. Are you my wife?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • An Idle Dad

      I just asked my wife via SMS and no, you aren’t my wife.

      I gots some splainin’ to do.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • anon

      I just cant bring myself to be a kindle reader. I read in the bath and in bed alot and I like the warmth of paper and the smell of a book. I also love that my bookshelf tells a story about my life and me. An electronic device just isnt the same, no matter the cost.
      My daughter will no doubt grow up and find me very old fashioned, but I dont see myself converting unless I have too.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • annajjj

        I really love books but I made the switch to Kindle about 6 months ago and I absolutely love it! It takes a bit of getting used to but the cost of books is about a third of the cost of paper books (I buy two to three books a week) and the best part for me is you can download the first chapter of each book for free to decide if you like it before you buy. Then there is the convenience of taking just one small device on holidays instead of several bulky novels…I’ve actually bought copies of all my long standing faves for my kindle. Yes I love the smell and feel of paper books but I’m totally addicted to my Kindle…

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  38. Appledapple

    Ah if does your English teacher’s heart good Rick to read such a fine piece! You missed the reluctant reader the one who finds, quite suddenly ,after a number years of enforced reading that there is a beauty and a joy in the written word that cannot be compared to anything! I have now also become the elctronic reader as the ebook has opened up the portablity of books! Now I can take tall my faves on holiday with me even on a plane!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. natalieosborne

    Perhaps a subset of the Dog-Earer – the book smeller. The reader who goes into second hand bookstores to…smell.

    I am both a book smeller and an underliner – which is making the whole e-book thing a bit of a difficult transition. Yes, I can still highlight in some formats, but dammit, it isn’t smelly!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rick Morton

      I’m so with you on the smell. They should bottle it. Surely someone’s made a perfume or cologne based on books by now?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • I’m a smeller. Hence my love for lifeline bookfest. They are all second hand. Love it. Kindle will never replace the sheer joy of books!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Zelicat

        Guilty… For some reason old books remind me of school holiday, reading in the sun with my much beloved grandma nambour :-)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Fi

      I used to love the smell of books, but now I’m scared to sniff because I bought one on eBay once, and it smells like… uh… man bits. I don’t know why, I don’t want to know why, but eek!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  40. Anonymous

    I’m none of these. I’m a buy-a-book-but-never-get-chance-to-start-reading-it. I love books but never really get a chance to read them. Between 3 kids and part-time work time is a bit sparse and often I’m too tired to read at night. Also after 2 degrees at uni (I’m now a doctor) reading also feels somewhat of a chore and work. And so while I love the idea of reading, I usually never get around to it. I also will never watch a movie made from a book, which means there are so many movies I haven’t seen because I haven’t read the book yet. I really should open a library – I have so many books in such great condition (read – brand new like at the bookshop) it is a pity they are just sitting there doing nothing!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • missamoo

      May i have them please??
      Books are my crack if i am not reading something i get itchy and quite mean. Ask my family!. Also i am an all kinds of book reader. I went through the 19th Century Literature only to the Biographies only to the “only if i am learning something only” to reading anything i can et my hands on. I will read books in one sitting,take 2 months to finish some and then stay up all night to finish others. OH ! and i love to crack the spine mmmmmm nummy!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  41. Cordeline

    I’m really tired… I just read the No. 2 heading as ‘Dog Eater’ and thought you were going to tell us about people who can’t give back books they have been loaned because they claim the dog ate them.

    I need to sleep!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rick Morton

      That COULD be a valid category, of course…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • XANTHE

      Lent. Lent! Only banks make loans… (sorry) (can you tell I’m an English-language pedant?)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  42. courtneynicholas

    I agree with previous comments you missed anal retentive book lover. This reader adores books of all kinds and abhors anyone who dog ears, bends covers, breaks spines, underlines, highlights or generally causes any harm to a book. These people are often booksellers ( ok in my case anyway) You also forgot book sniffers YES I said sniffers these are rare but very very creepy !

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • therecipebinder

      Sometimes I sniff…… *cue the shame*

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Rick Morton

      I am a repeat-book-sniff-offender and I am not afraid to say so. I find it actually gives me a little rush.

      I’m so cool.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Maggie

        New book smell and old book smell battle it out to be my favorite smell of all time, though I think new book just wins it.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • I’m a sniffer! I love flicking a brand new cookbook in front of me and breathing in the smell.

      I’m wierd.

      I know.

      Sad face.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  43. christabel

    I’m a “Did Not Finish”

    I’ve been working in a bookstore for three years so every day I’m faced with the thousands of books I haven’t read and it’s just so overwhelming. I want to read them all! I want to mainline the goodness through my veins!

    I have 13 books on my bedside table all with bookmarks in various places.

    And on top of that there’s the internet to distract me.

    I need help.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  44. Rick Morton

    I should add that I have more armchair (and some not quite armchair) guides to physics, the cosmos, quantum physics than most non-science majors. Except maybe for Lana’s husband.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • An Idle Dad

      Are we starting a pissing contest here, Rick?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • An Idle Dad

      If I could put a moment that bookstores like Dymocks and Borders died for me, it would be the gradual shrinking of the ‘general science’ section to nothing except books by Dr Karl.
      That was my first point of call in any bookstore. When you lose your first point of call, you stop going in.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  45. LK

    You missed the ‘Anal Retentive Book Freak’ who would never dog ear, underline or mark her book in any way, let alone bend the spine. She loves her books so much they must be kept in pristine condition. The damage of any book is heart breaking and often (ok always) leads to a fresh copy being purchased.

    GUILTY!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Emma in Melbourne-land

      THIS IS ME! I cringe when I see people dog ear a page, or crease the spine, or spill, write or do anything really. I like my books to be in good condition to the point that I won’t lend my books out, even when asked. I’m that anal! Glad to know I’m not alone :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Rick Morton

      Ah yes, a glaring omission!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • therecipebinder

      That’s me too. If I lend people books and don’t get them back, then I get really cross. I get even more cross when I get my books back in a terrible condition. I have also been known to buy new copies of books which have been badly damaged by other people.

      Perhaps I should seek therapy?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Sweet-ness

      This is ME!!!! See comment below.

      I even have a cloth ‘book bag’ (more like an envelope) that I keep my books in when they travel with me, say for work to read on the train (in the past), so they stay new in my bag.

      I will also spend more on a ‘pretty’ copy of a book, and much prefer buying the same books from small independent bookshops-the atmosphere- that chains or places like Target. Even places like Book Depository at times. Even though I pay more for it. I don’t care…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • fee283

      i am definitely an anal retentive book freak – happy to lend books, BUT DON’T YOU DARE CREASE THAT SPINE!!! pretty much for fear of death :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • KT

      Haha this is me too! My books must remain in perfect condition – almost untouched!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  46. Neola

    Love the Zuzak reference, Rick!

    I’m a 1, 2 and 5…sorry to all those who didn’t get their books back, but as Rick says, it’s only because I love you and want to keep a piece of you with me forever!

    Proposed Category #8: The (Sometimes Way Too Dogmatic) Evangelist – You love your books so much and you just know that they’re going to change your friend/boyfriend/relative’s life if only you could just get them to take the time to see the light. You buy them copies, and every subsequent phone conversation includes a not-so-subtle “Have you started reading that book I gave you yet? Really, you’re not getting into it? WHAT? But that main character is SO AMAZING and he’s exactly LIKE YOU!!! Stick with it, honestly, it’ll BLOW YOUR MIND! You gave up? Well, you’re just…infuriating!”

    Um, not that I ever do that…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  47. An Idle Dad

    Guilty: Two, Three, Four (who isn’t occasionally, really), Five and Seven.

    Two: Some of my books are held together by sticky tape. I recently started re-buying my favourite books in e-format simply so the IRL copies won’t be destroyed.

    Three: I lend books to anyone (and the same with DVDs, Rick!) but most people don’t have the same taste as me (see Seven). I’ve bought some books three or four times because people keep not giving back their copies. Basically, if someone mentions on twitter they were interested in a book and I owned it, I immediately DM them and get their address and send it. I am not bullshitting.

    Four: I’ve read books to impress chicks. I’ve listened to music I’ve hated to impress chicks. I’ve seen movies that make me want to kill myself to impress chicks. Sue me.

    Five: I have over one hundred Popular Penguins and about thirty various other books sitting on a shelf I am yet to read (see picture, that’s three layers deep of books).

    Seven: If you haven’t read “Salt: The story of salt” (how can you not want to!) or “Cod: The fish that changed the world” or “The Spice that changed the world” (answer: nutmeg, my favourite spice of all time) you haven’t lived.

    I love oddball historical non-fiction. These books I finish, usually. However, I also love philosophy with never ending titles like “How to Live: A Life of Montaigne in One Question and Twenty Attempts at an Answer” (by Sarah Bakewell) which I sometimes finish (How to Live itself is a finishable book, I will at some point finish it) but I also like oddball science (anything by Jared Diamond, plus books-I-never-finish by Steven Pinker and Douglas Hofstadter). Hence, my unread books grows forevermore.

    Dog eared I can live with. Underlining or highlighting is the devil’s work.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Amanda

      I’ll have to read ‘Salt’ now – I’ve read the other two!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • An Idle Dad

        1) Salt is awesome. Just amazing how it has shaped history.

        2) I think I love you because I’ve never met anyone with remotely the same enthusiasm about nutmeg or it’s historical significance.

        (And if you look closely at the photo, you can see 1491: New Revelations of the Americas Before Columbus). Love my historical oddities.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Amanda

          Ha ha! I will admit to a fluttering of excitement when I saw your comment on type 7. However there is a possibilty that we have not read the same book about nutmeg. I’ve read ‘Nathaniel’s Nutmeg’ by Giles Milton. Is it possible that there are *two* books about the history of nutmeg?!

          Other books you may be interested in are:
          * Courtesans and Fishcakes (The Consuming Passions of Classical Athens)
          * The Map that Changed the World (my favourite book by Simon Winchester, only just pipping ‘Krakatoa’ at the post)
          * Pickled, Potted and Canned (The Story of Food Preserving). A lot more interesting than it sounds!
          * The Miraculous Fever Tree (Malaria, Medicine and the Cure that Changed the World)
          * The Discovery of France (currently reading)

          I’m fascinated with English history, particularly the Tudor period, and have more books about Henry VIII and his wives and offspring than I care to count.

          How great are the Popular Penguins?! I’m making my way through classics that I’ve heard of and seen referenced in other books but never actually got around to reading before.

          Finally: Do you read Terry Pratchett?

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • An Idle Dad

            Thanks for the list! I’ve read Krakatoa (doesn’t he talk about the sea freezing at one point?), I must get the maps one. Yes, the nutmeg was Nathanial’s.

            The story of pickling sounds AWESOMESAUCE! Why wouldn’t someone find that interesting?

            Terry Pratchett rules. The Science of Discworld (Parts 1, 2 and 3) are possibly the BEST EVER GENERAL SCIENCE BOOKS ON THE HISTORY OF EVERYTHING EVER RICK IF YOU ARE READING THIS. (Pissing contest, won).

            Toats recommend. I got a little teary at the end of part 3 where they find Charles Darwin’s statue in the cafeteria of the British museum.

            But, yes, the discworld series are fantastic. Small Gods, anyone?

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Amanda

              I can’t remember anything about the sea freezing… I found the stuff about the Wallace Line and the ‘discovery’ of plate tectonics fascinating though. Yes, do get the maps one!

              I haven’t got the third Science of the Discworld book! Arggh! How did that happen?

              Small Gods… yep.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
        • Lulu

          Idle, another Salt & Cod fan! Did you read his book about the oyster industry in old New York? Called The Big Oyster I think (too lazy to google).

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • Gracie

        An Idle Dad, you’re the coolest!! I love how generous you are with book lending….and now I have a strange desire to read about salt. Hah.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • sloanepeterson

      I spy Twilight!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • An Idle Dad

        I have read Twlight. I gave up on the second because I remember there was 400 pages where she simply pines for Edward. I had enough teen angst when I was a teen.
        I gave up and will never go back.

        I did read Harry Potter in the end though and except for the last couple of books where they just wonder in the wood for fifty chapters, they are pretty good.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • sloanepeterson

          I read the whole series. The only thing that comes to mind is the old Dorothy Parker quote: “This is not a novel to be tossed aside lightly. It should be thrown with great force.”

          I’m very fond of Harry Potter; he was my constant literary companion growing up. In a nice bit of symmetry, the last book came out when I was 18.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Anonymous

            I love your name :)

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
    • acanberramum

      You aren’t my husband are you, An Idle Dad? My husband read Salt on our honeymoon…such a romantic ;) Other faves are The Frozen Water Trade, Wittgenstein’s Poker, Measuring the World, anything about the history of the english language and the History’s Worst series (Decisions, Predicitions, Inventions, Deceptions).

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • An Idle Dad

        I remember playing with my daughter on my honeymoon, but not what books I read. How strange!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  48. Maggie

    I am type 7.
    My Dad’s taste has worn off on me and he always buys these random Sci-Fi and Fantasy novels, that no one I know has heard of. Most are brilliant and I am always stealing them and never giving them back unless he asks. So I guess I am part of Type 1.

    There maybe should be a Type that always re-reads books. Like some sci-fi’s I read once every year.
    Actor Christopher Lee re-reads the Lord of the Rings trilogy once a year and has done so for the last 40 years. — Update I see this has been labeled comfort reader. I like :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • An Idle Dad

      I’m a re-reader. People ask me how I can do this and I ask them if they’ve ever watched a movie twice. They always say yes. I say it’s like that, but much better.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        That would be me. I’m often asked why I keep my books. What a ridiculous question. To re-read, of course! :)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  49. Pingback: Third Quarter Gemini Moon: Book Talk « Astrologer Kelly Surtees' Blog

  50. Oh, what about the category of people who have used their favourite bookmark as the basis of a tattoo they got on their 40th birthday…again, this may or may not be me…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...